Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is teaching 6 Yr old about crucixation out of order?

386 replies

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 20:30

I might be over reacting but after multiple nights on the trot sleeping no more than 45-60 mins at a time I'm at the end of my tether. 6 year old goes to a non dom school and we are agnostic/atheist at home. School have been teaching them about Jesus and Easter etc including how Jesus was crucified. I now have a sobbing child every night who can't get the pictures out if her mind (and I'm not surprised!!)and subsequently cant sleep from about midnight, crying. Aibu to complain to school that 6 is way too young to be taught this?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheWelshposter · 09/04/2023 18:40

OldFan · 09/04/2023 17:49

I was so scared of ending up in hell as a child.

@TheWelshposter Did it possibly make you try and behave better than you otherwise might've done?

' The Beginning of Wisdom is the Fear of God. '

Yes it probably did but I don't think that's a good thing....a child changing their behaviour for fear of ending up in hell while their family is in heaven.
I'd rather have my children misbehave slightly than live with the fear of being burnt in a fire.

Luckily I try to be a good person now as an adult just to be a decent person, not so that I get my reward at the pearly gates.

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 18:40

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 17:51

Mostly bad

Actually that’s not really true, there’s been good bad and indifferent. But every society has an ideology that governs its views on the world. Sometimes it’s for the benefit and sometimes to the detriment of that society as an whole, sometimes some benefit, sometimes people suffer.. but, nevertheless, to understand a society we need to understand the ideologies that shape its development

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 18:37

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 18:06

This . We had a y3 girl get very upset about the story of the Khalsa sikhs . The were no gory pictures , or movies or demonstrations. She still got upset because the story can be upsetting, even if no one actually dies in that one.

Should that be taken out of the curriculum too? Maybe Sikhism altogether?

Nope, it just shouldn't be taught to 6 yr olds same as most violent episodes in history like crucifixion and serial killers

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 18:06

CottonSock · 09/04/2023 17:52

I take back my response. My 6yo is being taught this at school, but couldn't recall many details.
Her school language is not English so that doesn't help her explain complicated things.
Sometimes kids react how you don't expect. I remember age 6 in school there was a girl who had to be taken out of the tv show we watched (1980s) in lesson. She'd been having awful nightmares about it.

This . We had a y3 girl get very upset about the story of the Khalsa sikhs . The were no gory pictures , or movies or demonstrations. She still got upset because the story can be upsetting, even if no one actually dies in that one.

Should that be taken out of the curriculum too? Maybe Sikhism altogether?

RampantIvy · 09/04/2023 17:54

Everydayshouldbe · 09/04/2023 17:52

Oh good. A thread were we can bash Christians on the most important day of their year.
Looking forward to the similar one for Eid ul Fitr.
Hmm

Unfortunately, many mumsnetters are pretty religiously intolerant, and love to sneer at anyone who believes in God.

CottonSock · 09/04/2023 17:52

I take back my response. My 6yo is being taught this at school, but couldn't recall many details.
Her school language is not English so that doesn't help her explain complicated things.
Sometimes kids react how you don't expect. I remember age 6 in school there was a girl who had to be taken out of the tv show we watched (1980s) in lesson. She'd been having awful nightmares about it.

Everydayshouldbe · 09/04/2023 17:52

Oh good. A thread were we can bash Christians on the most important day of their year.
Looking forward to the similar one for Eid ul Fitr.
Hmm

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 17:51

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 17:20

Yep that is certainly an important facet. The development of the west over the past 2000 years has been so interwoven with Christianity it’s vital to understand the perspective of Christianity to understand every aspect of the development of Europe during that time. From Wars, to art, to persecution to the formation of borders to the position of women, the calendar, the law etc etc. even many parts of language have seen its influence.

almost every aspect of it has been shaped by religion for both good and bad. It doesn’t have to be taught as fact but it is so so important for understanding the western way of life that christianity is well understood.

Mostly bad

OldFan · 09/04/2023 17:49

I was so scared of ending up in hell as a child.

@TheWelshposter Did it possibly make you try and behave better than you otherwise might've done?

' The Beginning of Wisdom is the Fear of God. '

QueenSmartypants · 09/04/2023 17:47

@TeaForMeandThee the crucifixion of Jesus of Nazareth isn't in doubt. Historians agree he existed, was a religious leader/teacher and was crucified. So, no, not all made up stories. What is contested is whether he was the Son of God or not.

TheWelshposter · 09/04/2023 17:45

I completely agree, I'm still angry that schools and churches are allowed to teach children this stuff. And that parents are happy that their children learn it. I was so scared of ending up in hell as a child.

TheWelshposter · 09/04/2023 17:40

TeaForMeandThee · 08/04/2023 21:32

I went to a Catholic school and they made us sit through the film made I assume in the 70s/80s about Jesus which included the whole crucifixion/torture etc it was very graphic, I was 5 and can still remember it 34 years on! Absolutely 0 need to make young children watch it or even be taught about it, even in a Catholic school. I'd simply tell your daughter it's a made up story like fairytales. Easter is about spring time, bunnies, chick's and chocolate, not nailing bearded men to crosses. My children go to a Catholic school, I absolutely would not tolerate any graphic depiction of the crucifixion to them!

Was it Jesus of Nazareth? I had the exact same situation in primary school. Some kids in my class were very upset. I had already seen it at home so wasn't as shocked but remember how graphic it was, especially the nail bit.

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 17:20

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 14:34

Knowing Christianity and the larger abrahamic religions does explain the reasoning behind most atrocities and wars at least. Oh and it's a good starting point for explaining the flawed reasoning behind most bigotry.

Yep that is certainly an important facet. The development of the west over the past 2000 years has been so interwoven with Christianity it’s vital to understand the perspective of Christianity to understand every aspect of the development of Europe during that time. From Wars, to art, to persecution to the formation of borders to the position of women, the calendar, the law etc etc. even many parts of language have seen its influence.

almost every aspect of it has been shaped by religion for both good and bad. It doesn’t have to be taught as fact but it is so so important for understanding the western way of life that christianity is well understood.

ferntwist · 09/04/2023 17:18

It’s a huge and inescapable part of our culture and history, seen in artwork, public buildings and more. My two year old and four year old have been learning about it all weekend and throughout Lent and they’re fine

OMG12 · 09/04/2023 17:12

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:41

my 5 year old reopening the question about whether his granny who died is coming back
And yet for whole generations of us there was no confusion at all. Isn't it strange?

I mean this is a valid point. I have never heard anyone having issues like this. Surely in the sort of environment that teaches a redirection as fact would also be teaching about the nature of Jesus and point of him doing the whole dying/resurrection thing to the extent even a 5year old would grasp Jesus (as explained by mainstream Christianity) in this situation is different from Granny.

If not, the failure of the parental explanation of death here is probably the main issue.

ConcordeOoter · 09/04/2023 17:10

Tandora · 09/04/2023 14:33

Just because it’s fact doesn’t mean it’s appropriate for a 6 year old?! There are a lot of “facts” about the world that we don’t share with 6 year olds.

“kids tend to love all that gory stuff”. Clearly you have no experience of sensitive children. Not all children are psychopaths.

As a result of your comments, I think you're in your early twenties and don't have children.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 17:08

OldFan · 09/04/2023 15:58

Your child has never seen a church or a historical building with a crucifix statue? Or even a crucifix necklace?!

I was thinking this myself as PP said, in Church today @Whostoblame . Babies and toddlers are there and there's a giant crucified Jesus above the altar. So they see it virtually from birth.

And should they? Or is it horrific imagery?

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 17:08

OldFan · 09/04/2023 16:02

I think you'll find you were indoctrinated. As was I. My children aren't, they get to ask questions.

@Forgooodnesssakenow Ideally instruction should include the possibility to ask questions too (though maybe that's harder if they have a large class.)

I converted recently and I had to have a lot of instruction in the Faith from the Priest before I was baptised. I definitely asked a lot of questions.

And answers were based on what? A single 2000 year old text?

OldFan · 09/04/2023 16:02

I think you'll find you were indoctrinated. As was I. My children aren't, they get to ask questions.

@Forgooodnesssakenow Ideally instruction should include the possibility to ask questions too (though maybe that's harder if they have a large class.)

I converted recently and I had to have a lot of instruction in the Faith from the Priest before I was baptised. I definitely asked a lot of questions.

OldFan · 09/04/2023 15:58

Your child has never seen a church or a historical building with a crucifix statue? Or even a crucifix necklace?!

I was thinking this myself as PP said, in Church today @Whostoblame . Babies and toddlers are there and there's a giant crucified Jesus above the altar. So they see it virtually from birth.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 15:11

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:56

I'm not sure it's that simple.

Please explain how you think it is?

borntobequiet · 09/04/2023 15:04

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:56

I'm not sure it's that simple.

Much of the time, it really was. It certainly was in my case. And that was mainstream Catholicism.

Our lessons, as I’ve said, were literally called “Doctrine”.

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:56

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 14:54

I think you'll find you were indoctrinated. As was I. My children aren't, they get to ask questions.

I'm not sure it's that simple.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 14:54

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:41

my 5 year old reopening the question about whether his granny who died is coming back
And yet for whole generations of us there was no confusion at all. Isn't it strange?

I think you'll find you were indoctrinated. As was I. My children aren't, they get to ask questions.

ReadersD1gest · 09/04/2023 14:41

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/04/2023 14:38

Being taught at 6 that there is a religious festival marked by some religions perfectly fine.

Being told as if it was fact that Jesus died for our sins, rose again and that he was brutally tortured and murdered probably not so much.

Opens kids up to wondering what the hell they've done that was so bad it travelled back in time and murdered a mild mannered Jewish man. It sure as shit would have my 5 year old reopening the question about whether his granny who died is coming back. And the boy asks questions very literally and needs all the details of everything and won't be fobbed off so it'd be a nightmare.

There is absolutely no reason to traumatise children with religious rhetoric, none at all.

my 5 year old reopening the question about whether his granny who died is coming back
And yet for whole generations of us there was no confusion at all. Isn't it strange?

Swipe left for the next trending thread