Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is teaching 6 Yr old about crucixation out of order?

386 replies

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 20:30

I might be over reacting but after multiple nights on the trot sleeping no more than 45-60 mins at a time I'm at the end of my tether. 6 year old goes to a non dom school and we are agnostic/atheist at home. School have been teaching them about Jesus and Easter etc including how Jesus was crucified. I now have a sobbing child every night who can't get the pictures out if her mind (and I'm not surprised!!)and subsequently cant sleep from about midnight, crying. Aibu to complain to school that 6 is way too young to be taught this?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TeaForMeandThee · 08/04/2023 22:11

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/04/2023 21:53

If it was The Passion of The Christ (directed I think, by Mel Gibson), it is an absolute gorefest and totally inappropriate for children (or adults, for that matter. It glories in unnecessary brutality IMO - and I am a Christian)

A little googling, it'll have been Jesus (1979), will have been around 1987 when we watched it. From the images doesnt look like something I'll be sticking on for my 5 year old!

ReadersD1gest · 08/04/2023 22:11

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 08/04/2023 22:09

I used to go to a Catholic school and some of the hymns we sang in assembly were so fucked up.

'were you there when they crucified our lord? Were you there when they crucified our lord, woooah, Sometimes it causes me to tremble'

All sang to a joyful merry tune.

Fucking weird.

That is not sung to a joyful, merry tune, op. Stop playacting.

nondenom · 08/04/2023 22:10

Crucifixion was a punishment by an occupying power (Romans Empire). Presumably at least some children at the school will come from military or refugee families, or have parents who work in jails or family who've been to jail? It's helpful to think through the human face of all this, in an educational setting?

Christ on the Cross is meant to show that even someone who is being bullied to death can be viewed as valuable, loving, innocent, even powerful.

Possibly some children or parents/carers at school are in abuse situations. Empathy, complicity, responsibility, and hope can be taught through images like Crucifixion and maybe give children an emotional language that will help them articulate what's going on in their world.

FWIW, I went to a non-denominational school & don't remember being taught about the crucifixion, but someone must have taught it non-traumatically as we certainly knew about it by the age of 6.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 08/04/2023 22:09

I used to go to a Catholic school and some of the hymns we sang in assembly were so fucked up.

'were you there when they crucified our lord? Were you there when they crucified our lord, woooah, Sometimes it causes me to tremble'

All sang to a joyful merry tune.

Fucking weird.

Hazymaze · 08/04/2023 22:07

anerki10 · 08/04/2023 20:48

My 4yo goes to a CofE school. He keeps banging on about Jesus being crucified. The other day he said, "Mum, did you know, they beat and spat on Jesus before they put him on the cross." 😳

Well that's exactly what it says in the Gospel accounts, so it's not surprising that that's what they were taught.

Then the people there spat in Jesus' face and beat him with their fists. Others slapped him. They said, “Prove to us that you are a prophet, you Christ! Tell us who hit you!” Matthew 26.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 22:04

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 21:59

Thanks to those that were helpful, giving an insight that it is in fact normal to be taught at this age (my girl is my oldest so haven't been through this before) and happy Easter to all who celebrate it.

Try and find out after Easter what she was told exactly. If it wasn't that bad(and I really don't think it was but I could be wrong) try and explore where her strong reaction came from. Sometimes it can be the lack of detail that causes upset as kids fill in the blanks with their own imagination or worse, ask other more "knowledgeable " peers and it all goes downhill from there.

TeaForMeandThee · 08/04/2023 22:03

Sortyourlifeout · 08/04/2023 21:46

Why did you send your child to a Catholic school if you are going to tell her that what she is being taught is a big lie?

It's the best school where we live, my husband and I both went to Catholic school (the same one actually) we might not believe in God, but we believe in a good education. I don't tell my kids it isn't real, i just smile and nod when they tell me Jesus "facts" or come home singing songs like they've been to a bible camp. I am partial to a classic banger anyway "Sing Hosanna", "shine Jesus shine" love it 😆

SparkyBlue · 08/04/2023 22:01

I went to a catholic school and my children go to a catholic school and I've never heard of any child being upset or traumatised over this. Usually it's the opposite I've found young children can really enjoy the gorey stuff

ReadersD1gest · 08/04/2023 22:00

Sortyourlifeout · 08/04/2023 21:53

You're the nicest atheist I've ever come across. I wish everyone could be like you!!

You certainly sound like a very discerning person @RumpleDumple
You put the nitwits squealing It's bad for our children's mental health! It shouldn't be allowed! to shame.

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 21:59

Thanks to those that were helpful, giving an insight that it is in fact normal to be taught at this age (my girl is my oldest so haven't been through this before) and happy Easter to all who celebrate it.

OP posts:
AngryBirdsNoMore · 08/04/2023 21:59

Lovely post @RumpleDumple 👏👏👏

bittersweetmemory · 08/04/2023 21:58

I'm a Year 1 TA and can confirm that the Easter story is on the R.E syllabus. The children are aware that it is a story that Christians believe in and the resurrection isn't presented as fact.

In my experience, although the crucifixion is touched upon, we keep it factual and spare the children the gory details.

Have never known a child to be upset by it and we address any questions there and then.

AlexandriasWindmill · 08/04/2023 21:58

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/04/2023 21:53

If it was The Passion of The Christ (directed I think, by Mel Gibson), it is an absolute gorefest and totally inappropriate for children (or adults, for that matter. It glories in unnecessary brutality IMO - and I am a Christian)

The Mel Gibson film is an 18. There's no way they're showing it in schools.

PuttingOnTheKitsch · 08/04/2023 21:57

JudgeJ · 08/04/2023 21:38

Because anyone taking a pop at other religions gets put on the MN naughty step.

Things must have changed round these parts. There used to always be an annual thread on how stupid Ramadan was for starters.

I will never forget someone on here saying that it was fine to be rude to Muslims on here because we'd (Muslim posters on Mumsnet) would throw acid in her face.

Anyway, I hope all those who celebrate have a lovely Easter.

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 21:56

RumpleDumple · 08/04/2023 21:47

YABU. The world's major religions have both major historical, cultural and faith based significance (not that they always concur or have much overlap). Crucifixion is a fact. A man called Jesus, who inspired a 'new' religion is a historical fact. You don't have to be Christian to accept that these 2 things did happen.

I would expect a well rounded education to include a discussion on the significance of Easter (how it came about, why some people find it important etc). Knowing about this does.not for a second force people into a belief, does not force a faith upon them. It's a mention (at your DD's age) of something that did happen and which led to the Christian dominance in the western world that exists today. This dominance has shaped our lives, our world, ever since and is so important.

As a disclaimer, i am an athiest. I don't believe in God. But I believe that a knowledge of religion (different from believing and following in a religion) is as worthwhile as knowledge of any other aspect of history.

You can preface it with "some people believe" without denying the validity of their belief. And as an atheist, I'm aware that my non belief is God is just a belief, no more and no less valid as the beliefs in Catholicism or Hinduism etc.

I do detest the atheist idea that somehow they (we) have the automatic right to be dismissive of all other religious beliefs. And that we are somehow superior in our intellect by profession our non beliefs. I suspect you are feeding her hysteria by being vocal about how such things should it be taught in schools. I

I didn't even know she had been learning about crucifixion until she was up screaming and sobbing about it so unsure how my "hysteria" (of which there is none btw) has fed into this and caused it?

OP posts:
Sortyourlifeout · 08/04/2023 21:55

Newname221 · 08/04/2023 21:50

I’m not Christian but was brought up going to (Protestant) church.

My parents explained the reason is because Protestants focus more on the miracle that he was resurrected rather than the crucifixion itself. Not sure if that was a fact or just their interpretation. It kind of makes sense since the Catholic faith seems to focus more on sins than anything I was brought up with (confessions and such)

Yes, that's one reason why my church doesn't display a crucifix.

We celebrate the resurrection, not the event leading up to it.

Plus nobody wants to look at a person on a cross, even if it is made of wood.

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 21:54

And I'm not saying these things shouldn't be taught, just I think 6 is a little young is all!

OP posts:
PuddlesPityParty · 08/04/2023 21:54

HopefulElle · 08/04/2023 21:53

My niece got very upset, but after some digging we realised that she misheard it as “Jesus was nailed to a fox” and felt bad for the fox 🤣

Bless her 😂 this made me giggle

Minierme · 08/04/2023 21:53

I think it’s a very normal thing to learn about and having taught from reception to year 6 (including RE) I haven’t known any children upset by it. So I think either the school are places very very heavy emphasis on all the details (very unlikely) or your panic is making her more frightened or she is particularly sensitive.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 21:53

It seems that a lot of the people upset about this , have has unpleasant childhood experiences around it. Have you considered that maybe,just maybe things might have changed slightly?

Sortyourlifeout · 08/04/2023 21:53

RumpleDumple · 08/04/2023 21:47

YABU. The world's major religions have both major historical, cultural and faith based significance (not that they always concur or have much overlap). Crucifixion is a fact. A man called Jesus, who inspired a 'new' religion is a historical fact. You don't have to be Christian to accept that these 2 things did happen.

I would expect a well rounded education to include a discussion on the significance of Easter (how it came about, why some people find it important etc). Knowing about this does.not for a second force people into a belief, does not force a faith upon them. It's a mention (at your DD's age) of something that did happen and which led to the Christian dominance in the western world that exists today. This dominance has shaped our lives, our world, ever since and is so important.

As a disclaimer, i am an athiest. I don't believe in God. But I believe that a knowledge of religion (different from believing and following in a religion) is as worthwhile as knowledge of any other aspect of history.

You can preface it with "some people believe" without denying the validity of their belief. And as an atheist, I'm aware that my non belief is God is just a belief, no more and no less valid as the beliefs in Catholicism or Hinduism etc.

I do detest the atheist idea that somehow they (we) have the automatic right to be dismissive of all other religious beliefs. And that we are somehow superior in our intellect by profession our non beliefs. I suspect you are feeding her hysteria by being vocal about how such things should it be taught in schools. I

You're the nicest atheist I've ever come across. I wish everyone could be like you!!

Rosebel · 08/04/2023 21:53

It wouldn't bother me but I'm RC and have older siblings so had already learned about this by age 6.
Am pretty sure my DDs were a bit older when they learned about it though. Do you think that it's been exaggerated by other children so made your DD more anxious.
On the plus side I'm assuming they will move away from this subject after the holidays anyway

HopefulElle · 08/04/2023 21:53

My niece got very upset, but after some digging we realised that she misheard it as “Jesus was nailed to a fox” and felt bad for the fox 🤣

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/04/2023 21:53

TeaForMeandThee · 08/04/2023 21:32

I went to a Catholic school and they made us sit through the film made I assume in the 70s/80s about Jesus which included the whole crucifixion/torture etc it was very graphic, I was 5 and can still remember it 34 years on! Absolutely 0 need to make young children watch it or even be taught about it, even in a Catholic school. I'd simply tell your daughter it's a made up story like fairytales. Easter is about spring time, bunnies, chick's and chocolate, not nailing bearded men to crosses. My children go to a Catholic school, I absolutely would not tolerate any graphic depiction of the crucifixion to them!

If it was The Passion of The Christ (directed I think, by Mel Gibson), it is an absolute gorefest and totally inappropriate for children (or adults, for that matter. It glories in unnecessary brutality IMO - and I am a Christian)

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 21:52

I'm not sure how some can say I'm over reacting and influencing her behaviour when I haven't said how ive been dealing with this with her.....I have of course been telling her it's just a story. She can be very empathetic and she's quite soft hearted, although very matter of fact about death overall. doesn't speak about it like it's a bad thing. No she's never seen a cross/crucifix before, were not a religious family, she's never set foot in a church. we don't talk about stuff like that coz we don't believe in it, I'm not sure how they'd a bad thing
She's on school holidays at the moment but unfortunately it's been this week that she's been having these nightmares. When she goes back I'll ask to see what it was she was taught and what pictures etc were used. Fingers crossed for a better night tonight. Thanks

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread