Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is teaching 6 Yr old about crucixation out of order?

386 replies

Whostoblame · 08/04/2023 20:30

I might be over reacting but after multiple nights on the trot sleeping no more than 45-60 mins at a time I'm at the end of my tether. 6 year old goes to a non dom school and we are agnostic/atheist at home. School have been teaching them about Jesus and Easter etc including how Jesus was crucified. I now have a sobbing child every night who can't get the pictures out if her mind (and I'm not surprised!!)and subsequently cant sleep from about midnight, crying. Aibu to complain to school that 6 is way too young to be taught this?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
literalviolence · 03/05/2023 20:48

In the story he was tortured. We don't need to tell 6 year old about torture. Christians will make their own decisions but too much detail is massively inappropriate to atheists.

Jux · 03/05/2023 20:46

I was born and bred Catholic and grew up with Easter Story. The point of it was much more that Jesus died for our sins not that he was killed in an awful, horrfying way. Because he died for us, taking all our sins upon him, he ascended into heaven ("and sits at the right hand of the Father" as Catholics profess every week at Mass). I vaguely remember a teacher saying they nailed him to the cross, explaining about stigmata, the spear in the side - but it was all in a good cause, obviously.

I think mum must have explained it more gently when I was much younger, say 3ish, so I wasn't particularly upset by our teacher; I think I was probably about 7 then and believed fervently that our sins, my sins, were washed away by Jesus' sacrifice.

PS, I'm no longer Catholic.

Sortyourlifeout · 03/05/2023 10:51

Sceptre86 · 03/05/2023 06:55

We are Muslim and my child was taught about Jesus being crucified and rising at Easter. She's the same age and was fine about it. I'm not sure if they used pictures or went into it graphically for which I agree there is no need. All kids are different mine is on the sensitive side and has lots of questions. She did ask me about it as school whilst non dom presented it as fact. I just told her that was the Christian view that we believe a different version and told her that. She can believe whatever she wants or not at all. I also reminded her that attaching someone to a crucifix isn't something that happens nowadays.

Maybe talk to school to find out what level of detail they went to and explain the upset it has caused her. If the details were graphic it could be that other kids were upset too. It could be a learning point for them? Then work with your child to discuss things when she finds them upsetting and help her as much as you can at that age to put them into context. I'd want to work on this now because it's quite a strong reaction to have.

"I also reminded her that attaching someone to a crucifix isn't something that happens nowadays"

Unfortunately that is incorrect information.

But I agree with the other poster, your post was one of the best I have read on here.

FeeFiFoFumble · 03/05/2023 09:47

I'm Jewish and wouldn't have a problem with my kids learning about Jesus and crucifixion as it's fact that they used to crucify people, and Easter is about celebrating Jesus. I would want them to be careful with how they word it though and keep it as non-graphic as possible. My 6 year old learned about the Pesach story and was told that one of the plagues was the death of the first born (he's a first born himself!) but it didn't seem to bother him as I guess they had explained it in an age-appropriate way.

OMG12 · 03/05/2023 09:40

Sceptre86 · 03/05/2023 06:55

We are Muslim and my child was taught about Jesus being crucified and rising at Easter. She's the same age and was fine about it. I'm not sure if they used pictures or went into it graphically for which I agree there is no need. All kids are different mine is on the sensitive side and has lots of questions. She did ask me about it as school whilst non dom presented it as fact. I just told her that was the Christian view that we believe a different version and told her that. She can believe whatever she wants or not at all. I also reminded her that attaching someone to a crucifix isn't something that happens nowadays.

Maybe talk to school to find out what level of detail they went to and explain the upset it has caused her. If the details were graphic it could be that other kids were upset too. It could be a learning point for them? Then work with your child to discuss things when she finds them upsetting and help her as much as you can at that age to put them into context. I'd want to work on this now because it's quite a strong reaction to have.

This is probably the best and most balanced post on the thread

Sceptre86 · 03/05/2023 06:55

We are Muslim and my child was taught about Jesus being crucified and rising at Easter. She's the same age and was fine about it. I'm not sure if they used pictures or went into it graphically for which I agree there is no need. All kids are different mine is on the sensitive side and has lots of questions. She did ask me about it as school whilst non dom presented it as fact. I just told her that was the Christian view that we believe a different version and told her that. She can believe whatever she wants or not at all. I also reminded her that attaching someone to a crucifix isn't something that happens nowadays.

Maybe talk to school to find out what level of detail they went to and explain the upset it has caused her. If the details were graphic it could be that other kids were upset too. It could be a learning point for them? Then work with your child to discuss things when she finds them upsetting and help her as much as you can at that age to put them into context. I'd want to work on this now because it's quite a strong reaction to have.

OMG12 · 02/05/2023 18:42

OldFan · 02/05/2023 00:18

However sweet, where does it say in the Bible God won’t judge you more harshly than you judge yourself?

I know, I was surprised too. But I'm Catholic, we have Priests, if they're going to tell me something then unless it's utterly awful I'll roll with it.

The New Testament depiction of God isn't as violent in his depiction as the Old Testament one.

He gives us Jesus who gives us an out from most of the judgement if we follow Him. But even in the OT, most of the time repentance makes things ok sooner or later (if they get the chance.)

How do you decide which parts to take literally and which parts metaphorically and which parts to totally ignore?

I try and do most of it really except the cutting off my arm bit, because I seem to be one of the few people that ever thought of that as what should be part of the Christian rules. Smile

The only other bit I'll never do is give any husband I might have in future sex when I'm not in the mood. I'd rather be single for life. I explained to a Priest that I would find it very psychologically unpleasant and he said a husband is supposed to care for his wife, so shouldn't expect that of me.

Catholicism is surprisingly laid back in some respects or at least can be. Though I did come across someone on Youtube who said not shagging your husband on demand is a mortal sin. Envy

I was educated by catholic nuns, whilst I appreciate the ritual, symbolism and magic within the catholic faith I’m afraid I can’t subscribe to the hierarchy and indeed the idea that what priest say goes. I think we’re all priests of our own spiritual lives, we don’t need professionals.

what rules do you follow though deciding which parts of the Bible to take literally or not though, why not cut off your arm etc if you follow the other rules

OldFan · 02/05/2023 00:18

However sweet, where does it say in the Bible God won’t judge you more harshly than you judge yourself?

I know, I was surprised too. But I'm Catholic, we have Priests, if they're going to tell me something then unless it's utterly awful I'll roll with it.

The New Testament depiction of God isn't as violent in his depiction as the Old Testament one.

He gives us Jesus who gives us an out from most of the judgement if we follow Him. But even in the OT, most of the time repentance makes things ok sooner or later (if they get the chance.)

How do you decide which parts to take literally and which parts metaphorically and which parts to totally ignore?

I try and do most of it really except the cutting off my arm bit, because I seem to be one of the few people that ever thought of that as what should be part of the Christian rules. Smile

The only other bit I'll never do is give any husband I might have in future sex when I'm not in the mood. I'd rather be single for life. I explained to a Priest that I would find it very psychologically unpleasant and he said a husband is supposed to care for his wife, so shouldn't expect that of me.

Catholicism is surprisingly laid back in some respects or at least can be. Though I did come across someone on Youtube who said not shagging your husband on demand is a mortal sin. Envy

OMG12 · 01/05/2023 09:33

OldFan · 01/05/2023 00:57

IDK I did some Greek at uni, I'll have to look stuff up when I haven't had wine. Smile

I suppose Jesus did arguably speak in metaphor sometimes. Only a few cults expect us to literally shun our family if they're not Christian.

Maybe I take things too literally and adversarially, but before I was a Christian, I used to think 'well, he tells them to cut out their eyes or cut off their arms if they cause them to sin, but I don't see many of them doing it' (except maybe one or two extreme cults or mentally ill individuals.)

A Priest said to me the other day 'God is never going to judge us harder than we judge ourselves' which I think is quite sweet.

Of course I don't like the idea of people being cast into the pit; it's extreme-sounding and surprising esp coming from Jesus with all we culturally assume about him, that's why it sticks in the mind.

He did say that believing in Him as the Messiah/God and following Him is the only way to Heaven; being nice is not enough.

People picking and choosing what to follow out of the Bible has always annoyed me, even before I was a Christian. But I suppose most/all denominations (or people) do in one way or another.

I try not to do it much but I haven't cut off my eyes or hand. Grin Even though baptism seems to have made me more gay.

However sweet, where does it say in the Bible God won’t judge you more harshly than you judge yourself? He literally wiped out the planet apart from a handful of humans and 2 of every species of animal for not worshipping him. He cast out the first humans for eating an apple a serpent (which by definition God must have made£ and punished every one of their descendants. He destroyed cities, he left a whole face wondering round a with little food or water for 40 years on a journey google maps says takes 6 days to walk, and these were his chosen people!!! He drowned millions of Egyptians, killed thousands of Egyptian children. He really is very judgey.. He did a trial run on How it feels to kill your own child )well stopping in the Nick of time) I. The OT then went through with it in the NT. if you believe in the literal interpretation of the Bible then you believe in quite an evil God.

How do you decide which parts to take literally and which parts metaphorically and which parts to totally ignore?

OMG12 · 01/05/2023 09:10

Cel77 · 01/05/2023 07:18

My daughter is 3 and in preschool, and learnt about the crucification of Jesus. I was shocked to be honest . They don't need at all to learn about it until they're much much older. She retold me the story by saying "naughty people put him on a cross and then he died". That's just awful. I covered a RE lesson for a colleague years ago with a Year 2 class (your child's age). They had to listen to the story, then cut pictures of the whole story out and put them in the correct order. One boy asked me if they could colour the pictures in once they were done. There was so much red everywhere! Just a gory unnecessary scary story for such young brains...

Sorry, but which part of it do you find “awful”. I can’t see anything bad about it. Do you object to a 3 year old being told about death? You say much older, what age? Many kids will lose grandparents at this age, what should they be told? What do you say to kids about Easter up to that point? Or do you not want anyone mentioning a religious festival? Utterly bizarre!!!

so kids, 6-7 were drawing lots of red when someone dies, not really surprising, many teachers seem to think kids this age are mature enough to decide what gender they are so a bit of red felt tip is prob not the end of the world.

Do you object to kids learning about the world wars? About slavery etc? About Victorian schools, work houses, the plague? The great fire of London? Anything apart from fluffy bunnies and rainbows?? No wonder kids are growing up so mentally unprepared for adversity if this is the prevailing attitude

Cel77 · 01/05/2023 07:18

My daughter is 3 and in preschool, and learnt about the crucification of Jesus. I was shocked to be honest . They don't need at all to learn about it until they're much much older. She retold me the story by saying "naughty people put him on a cross and then he died". That's just awful. I covered a RE lesson for a colleague years ago with a Year 2 class (your child's age). They had to listen to the story, then cut pictures of the whole story out and put them in the correct order. One boy asked me if they could colour the pictures in once they were done. There was so much red everywhere! Just a gory unnecessary scary story for such young brains...

OMG12 · 01/05/2023 05:43

CelestiaNoctis · 01/05/2023 02:03

It's definitely insanity but good luck fighting it. Maybe contact the humanist society for advice. I felt the same with my daughter but we bought a book on many different religions and how beliefs are cultural and it calmed her down to see that its just a gross story to enslave the masses.

Ah the humanist society, a great balance!!!

So what did your DD say when you explained a peaceful teacher called Yeshua ben Joseph was crucified as this was a common practice and happened to thousands of others for trying to adapt the Jewish religion but this time without the jhappy ending? Was she upset that a potentially mentally ill man was tortured to death? Interested in how you explained this to keep it in line with circumstances widely agreed by historians. How did you explain all the other religions?

Also, it’s not “just a gross story to enslave the masses” it might have been subsequently used that way, but you’re ignoring the historical position as well as the deep symbolism within the story. Sounds like you have done your DD a bit of a disservice here.that’s the danger of parents teaching their kids based on their own ideologies

HoppingPavlova · 01/05/2023 05:06

A man called Joshua bar Joseph was crucified on the orders of Pontius Pilate. Crucifixion was a common Roman method of execution

Exactly. Not sure why this should be kept as a mystery from children? Obviously, the next question will be ‘what is crucifixion’ and you answer that. Hardly child abuse and the problem these days is that children have been raised to be over sensitive. I recall some parent complaining g when one of mine was in early years that a picture of an Egyptian mummy had been shown and their precious petal was disturbed. Complete batshit.

Also rules out teaching kids about British history really and the rolling headcount of kings and wives done away with by siblings eager to climb the ladder, kings who wanted new wives etc. Centuries worth of stuff to keep from kids if you bring them up to find this stuff disturbing.

OMG12 · 01/05/2023 04:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

CoffeeDino · 01/05/2023 04:33

Yanbu.

I wouldn't be fussed about them learning the Easter story. I would be very unhappy about them being taught the mechanics of crucifixion at 6. Even as an adult, the methods of torture used in the past (and present) make me very uncomfortable.

It's unnecessarily bloodthirsty in primary school. Let them learn about it in secondary school.

OldFan · 01/05/2023 03:39

Is it grosser than Mohammed having sex with a child?

And being crucified isn't a story, it's a real thing that happened to a fair few people. Usually the outcome was purely grim. Thankfully with Jesus it had a redemptive arc.

CelestiaNoctis · 01/05/2023 02:03

It's definitely insanity but good luck fighting it. Maybe contact the humanist society for advice. I felt the same with my daughter but we bought a book on many different religions and how beliefs are cultural and it calmed her down to see that its just a gross story to enslave the masses.

OldFan · 01/05/2023 00:57

IDK I did some Greek at uni, I'll have to look stuff up when I haven't had wine. Smile

I suppose Jesus did arguably speak in metaphor sometimes. Only a few cults expect us to literally shun our family if they're not Christian.

Maybe I take things too literally and adversarially, but before I was a Christian, I used to think 'well, he tells them to cut out their eyes or cut off their arms if they cause them to sin, but I don't see many of them doing it' (except maybe one or two extreme cults or mentally ill individuals.)

A Priest said to me the other day 'God is never going to judge us harder than we judge ourselves' which I think is quite sweet.

Of course I don't like the idea of people being cast into the pit; it's extreme-sounding and surprising esp coming from Jesus with all we culturally assume about him, that's why it sticks in the mind.

He did say that believing in Him as the Messiah/God and following Him is the only way to Heaven; being nice is not enough.

People picking and choosing what to follow out of the Bible has always annoyed me, even before I was a Christian. But I suppose most/all denominations (or people) do in one way or another.

I try not to do it much but I haven't cut off my eyes or hand. Grin Even though baptism seems to have made me more gay.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/04/2023 19:12

<blush>

Sortyourlifeout · 19/04/2023 22:10

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/04/2023 20:33

Again - it comes down to the gradual shift of language and translations etc (and although I have a little knowledge of NT Greek, I don't have any Hebrew, so can't go directly to OT sources). The term "hate"didn't have a single meaning the way we think of it. Nor did it mean a dislike so intense that you loathed everything about someone and would do them a bad turn if you got the chance (as some people do).

It signified a strong dislike that causes us to avoid people who behaved badly. SO - God "hates" ie avoids, people who behave sinfully - who kill, steal, cheat, etc

When Jesus said “If anyone comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters—yes, even their own life—such a person cannot be my disciple." (Luke 14:26) he did not literally mean "hate" in the way we think of it - he was saying to think about what was most important. Being a follower of Jesus should be the most important thing in a Christian's life.

With regard to "loving sinners, hating sin" (yes - you're right, it is trite) the NT is very clear that true repentance (emphasis on "TRUE") and belief will lead to forgiveness and welcome in to heaven. Jesus on the cross forgave one of the robbers who recognised his divinity and repented.

I knew you wouldn't let me down! Wish I was able to explain things like this!

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/04/2023 20:33

OldFan · 10/04/2023 13:38

No - God hates the behaviourof loads of people - not the people themselves.

@Emotionalsupportviper This is a popular way of explaining it and I used to subscribe to it myself. But it's not scriptural.

God hates all manner of people who don't follow his law. We're told this again and again in the Bible.

That's why they'll be thrown into the fire where there is wailing and gnashing of teeth, unless they change their ways.

Again - it comes down to the gradual shift of language and translations etc (and although I have a little knowledge of NT Greek, I don't have any Hebrew, so can't go directly to OT sources). The term "hate"didn't have a single meaning the way we think of it. Nor did it mean a dislike so intense that you loathed everything about someone and would do them a bad turn if you got the chance (as some people do).

It signified a strong dislike that causes us to avoid people who behaved badly. SO - God "hates" ie avoids, people who behave sinfully - who kill, steal, cheat, etc

When Jesus said “If anyone comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters—yes, even their own life—such a person cannot be my disciple." (Luke 14:26) he did not literally mean "hate" in the way we think of it - he was saying to think about what was most important. Being a follower of Jesus should be the most important thing in a Christian's life.

With regard to "loving sinners, hating sin" (yes - you're right, it is trite) the NT is very clear that true repentance (emphasis on "TRUE") and belief will lead to forgiveness and welcome in to heaven. Jesus on the cross forgave one of the robbers who recognised his divinity and repented.

QueenSmartypants · 12/04/2023 12:50

Forgooodnesssakenow · 11/04/2023 21:18

Quite the opposite, as far as any evidence shows, death is final. It's not unrealistic to think that doenst need to be flowered up with afterlife nonsense.

Did you feel the wooosh as my point sailed past you? 😄

OMG12 · 11/04/2023 21:43

Forgooodnesssakenow · 11/04/2023 21:18

Quite the opposite, as far as any evidence shows, death is final. It's not unrealistic to think that doenst need to be flowered up with afterlife nonsense.

Actually there is no evidence to show death is final, nor is it likely that science will ever be able to prove that. It is not a falsifiable hypothesis what happens after death, if there is an after life it is most likely beyond observation through scientific means. There might or might not be an afterlife- but scientific methodology will likely not be the arbiter of that

Forgooodnesssakenow · 11/04/2023 21:18

QueenSmartypants · 11/04/2023 07:38

So yeah, they do declare that death is infact not final

This is a rather fundamental tenet of Christianity...

But it wasn't, it was prompted by that on the day of the funeral of her granny who she dearly loved.
I don't understand why it's shocking to you that the death of her grandmother would prompt a realisation that we all die.

You seem to have very unrealistic expectations in believing that your children should continue innocently unaware and ignorance of things that are happening all around them.

Quite the opposite, as far as any evidence shows, death is final. It's not unrealistic to think that doenst need to be flowered up with afterlife nonsense.

Sortyourlifeout · 11/04/2023 20:46

@Forgooodnesssakenow

Come on, now. Surely you can see where people are coming from?