Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Family Court Scandal and Abuse

264 replies

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 19:37

Wasn't sure what to post this under:

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by authorities to leave their abusers or risk losing their children.

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by the family courts to coparent with their abusers or risk losing their children.

The family court system is not fit for purpose. Women are re traumatised during proceedings whereby they are forced to face their abuser, are further gaslit by Cafcass and magistrates and forced to push their children into unsafe contact arrangements.

The court want to handle cases as quickly as possible and women are criticised for raising allegations of abuse as this prolongs the court process.

The abuser uses the court to further their abuse through the children and is not held accountable for their harmful and abusive behaviour.

If you can relate to this then I am sorry. The trauma experienced can trigger ptsd, anxiety and depression to name a few. I don’t know how to change the system but in raising awareness and talking about it I hope it’s a move in the right direction for real change.

OP posts:
Bizzieizz · 08/04/2023 21:06

I am a victim of domestic abuse, my children have been victims of domestic abuse.
I have stood in court for two years and not swayed from this once.
We spent years with me being gaslit, coercively controlled and financially abused.
Now I am divorced I am financially controlled via child maintenance and abused through the family courts.
I am frustrated to fuck by the Courts and Cafcass.

The last thing I would have needed was a member of staff at the kids school deciding that with no real experience of DV and only minor training on it, that I must be lying because the kids don’t quite back up what I say.

As an aside, I was raped one night by my exh. The children were in bed. Does the fact they didn’t see it and couldn’t have verified it mean it didn’t happen??? 🤔

Polik · 08/04/2023 21:06

How do you know the claims are false? How can you know? You do know abuse isn't just physical, don't you?

I'm a DSL, my full time job is knowing and spotting types of abuse and harm.

How do i know the most claims against ex's are false? Because I speak to the child.

One in the week before we broke up involved Mum escalating from school to MASH to police, in a desperate attempt to move 15yo away from resident father. Mum started pushing school to make a MASH referral, claiming emotional abuse in Dads home. I spoke repeatedly to the child who gave zero indication of this in discussions. Mum then made a MASH referral herself. Social care spoke to child and closed. She then went to police. They spoke to child and took no action. Then MASH again, this time claiming threats of violence and alcohol use ftom Dad, as well as emotional abuse. Again no disclosure from child - but in this case I (school DSL) pushed social care for an assessment with concerns of mum's emotional abuse. They assessed, talked at length to child, as did I - still no signs, suggestions or disclosure from the child of harm from Dad - so social care closed. This child is telling me eloquently and directly that her relationship with Dad is just normal teen-parent relationship. But mum continually insists that Dad occasionally telling her off, Dad insisting she washes the pots, or Dad having a couple pints on a weekend (child is 15) is emotional abuse. Like anything other than Perfect Parent (which doesnt exist) is labelled abuse and Ex considers that de-facto that they should have custody.

This is just one of dozens I deal with week in - week out.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 08/04/2023 21:05

@TheTheVanguardSix I'm so sorry that you and your daughter went through that hell, what on earth do you have to do to have PR removed by a judge? More and more I think this country is full of and judged by women hating, paedophile enabling bastards.

samqueens · 08/04/2023 21:05

Polik · 08/04/2023 20:37

The child.

Claims of abuse are taken very seriously by schools.

The vast, vast majority of "Mum claims abuse" are not backed up by the voice of the children. Threshold of risk of harm is very rarely met I these cases.

I take your point, but I seriously think it’s almost impossible for a child to be able to voice their experience of, say, emotional abuse unless it’s unbelievably heavy handed.

there are plenty of plausible, professional and charming abusers who do deeply damage their children (and the other parent). But if it takes an adult many years to understand what’s happening to them I don’t think there’s much chance a six year old will see it.

Plus using the children to further abuse of their mother is a real thing and the ultimate negative effect of that on the children is also real.

I understand if the bar is “will this child die at their abuser’s hands? Are they in imminent physical danger?” and I understand schools can’t be responsible for everything - a line has to be drawn somewhere. But it seems to me that characterizing accusations of abuse as fantasies/completely unfounded on the basis of a young child’s word is quite unfair and naive in itself.

It also underlines one of the failings inherent in the system as it currently stands, which is that the definition of criminal abuse has widened, but the resources and expertise needed to understand and appropriately handle anything beyond physical violence is severely lacking.

As a result many women are thrown back on their own internal resources to navigate these situations and relationships as best they can, at the very point maven those resources are at their lowest ebb. This can mean staying when they don’t want to just to avoid impossible choices in the legal system. It’s sad to know that in this scenario reaching out to schools might well just result in safeguarding assuming you’re a liar, partly because there just isn’t anything they can do to help.

Nat6999 · 08/04/2023 21:04

I was made by Caffcass to sit in a room next to the man who raped me, I also had to hand ds over to him for contact. This was the man who had tried to burn down the house with me & ds in it, if ds hadn't learned to ring 999 in school I don't know what would have happened.

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 21:04

poormanspombears · 08/04/2023 20:54

@SpringMum30

Wow, the really sad thing is that that should shock me but nothing does when it comes to the courts anymore. It goes to show that everyone is having equally poor experiences with the courts regardless which party you are.

It's absolutely devastating that people out there are having these experiences and as unfortunately research shows that abused people tend to either stay for kids/money/fear or if they do leave, then likely get in another abusive relationship, it just won't get better because they become stuck in a cycle of being abused by partners then the system that should protect them.

Right! And the abusers now have another tool to further that abuse and control with even more intensity. The gaslighting becomes even worse because you are being told by 'professionals' that you are wrong too. Thankfully there are a lot of resources out there with people who have had similar experiences that really help ground and validate the truth. I spent a lot of time listening to YouTube videos of women with similar experiences, and it was interesting to see how similar the tactics of the abusers are within the court room

OP posts:
Bepis · 08/04/2023 21:04

@TheVanguardSix I am so so sorry this is the treatment you got via the court system. Was an arrogant, awful judge. Why did he want to give you a PSO? Was that to stop you leaving the country? It's appalling you were treated like that.

TheVanguardSix · 08/04/2023 21:01

OP… hear fucking hear! 👏I lived out your perfect description of family court 18 years ago with DC1 and now again, these past 18 months with DCs 2 and 3 (ex number 2…stopping with the whole marriage experience after this shitshow).

Let me tell you what happened one year ago when I went to remove PR from my ex (who is serving a prison sentence for sexually abusing my daughter starting when she was 3 years old): Not only did the judge mock me, he wanted to slap a PSO on me, confiscate my passport, and referred to me as a ‘flight risk’. The removal of PR was absolutely not going to happen. Never mind that I’ve lived in the UK for 25 years, own my home, and have children in school and uni here. I’m just going to ‘flee’. I’d have every right to, if I’m honest. But I was never going to abscond with my children.
I said to the judge, ‘If I were planning on fleeing with my kids, I wouldn’t be here in front of you. I wouldn’t bother appealing to the court for help. I wouldn’t pay a fine fee applying to the court for permission to remove PR from a sexual abuser.’

It took me one year and a female judge to remove PR from my daughter’s abuser. I’m left traumatised by the whole experience. I still have the divorce to finish, which has been awful.

Having dealt with police, judges, lawyers all I can say is, this is no country for women and children. The investigating officer on our child abuse case was absolutely misogynistic to the core. I’m not sure what’s worse, the abuse my daughter suffered or the quest for ‘justice’. Justice… it’s a loose term. You lose so much of yourself, it costs you so much spiritually and emotionally, just to fucking claw to your children’s rights and your protection of them.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 08/04/2023 21:00

Polik · 08/04/2023 20:37

The child.

Claims of abuse are taken very seriously by schools.

The vast, vast majority of "Mum claims abuse" are not backed up by the voice of the children. Threshold of risk of harm is very rarely met I these cases.

A now adult friend of mine who lived in an abusive household said to me that when she went to see counsellors or when the school spoke to her about her behaviour (trauma related) she wouldn't tell them what was happening as she feared they would take her and her sibling away from their mum, which was likely to be honest.

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 20:59

AutisticLegoLover · 08/04/2023 20:49

This has been my experience too. 20+ times I had to go to court with my abusive exH. I'd add court appointed psychologists to the gaslighting bastards list too. My abuser now abuses my Dd who the courts says could live with him. Utter fuckwits the lot of them.

😔😔

OP posts:
Tinybrother · 08/04/2023 20:58

IME many women go to great lengths to protect the children from the abuse. Good to know that those natural protective instincts work against you when it comes to being believed by school safeguarding.

Bepis · 08/04/2023 20:57

I think it may just depend who is better at 'charming' the social workers and psychologists. It seems that sometimes the man is favoured and sometimes the woman. In my experience, a lot of social workers are very easily manipulated by the abuser. Then when the one who has been abused comes across as angry and traumatised, they are accused of being the abusive one.

SweetSakura · 08/04/2023 20:57

My understanding, from reading academic research, is that the level of false claims of abuse in the family courts is actually very low .

And I have to say I wouldn't stay in a relationship with a man whose ex accused him of abuse. Because I actually don't think the research backs up the assumptions on here that women are making it up.

Also I am shocked by people claiming to be school staff who are demonstrating horrific bias on here. I hope they are falsely claiming to be work in safeguarding, otherwise they are in the wrong job. It took months of skilled therapy for my son to find the courage to open up about what his dad had been doing. A few chats with someone who assumes all mums alleging abuse are using their children as "pawns" would never have got to the bottom of it

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 20:56

Polik · 08/04/2023 20:16

I (school safeguarding) deal with more cases of parents trying to restrict their ex access to their children by falsely claiming abuse, than families facing actual ongoing risk of abuse.

When I say more, it's trebel, quadruple type amounts. Not just a few more.

Herein is the problem.

Forgive me, I don't know how to quote your most recent comment but children don't always speak up because they are victims themselves and may not be aware of the abuse. Particularly where there is coercive control it takes a long time for a woman to identify that abuse even exists. What more for a child! The mother (in most cases) however has experienced the abuse and can now identify the abuse of the children. I was deeply offended by my ex's claims that I was using the children to further my case. They are genuinely my priority and I would have rather 'lost' the case then use them as a pawn.

OP posts:
poormanspombears · 08/04/2023 20:54

@SpringMum30

Wow, the really sad thing is that that should shock me but nothing does when it comes to the courts anymore. It goes to show that everyone is having equally poor experiences with the courts regardless which party you are.

It's absolutely devastating that people out there are having these experiences and as unfortunately research shows that abused people tend to either stay for kids/money/fear or if they do leave, then likely get in another abusive relationship, it just won't get better because they become stuck in a cycle of being abused by partners then the system that should protect them.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/04/2023 20:54

Polik · 08/04/2023 20:37

The child.

Claims of abuse are taken very seriously by schools.

The vast, vast majority of "Mum claims abuse" are not backed up by the voice of the children. Threshold of risk of harm is very rarely met I these cases.

So men can’t abuse women while the children are in bed?

FFS women can’t win. Now they are being blamed for not being abused in front of their children. When in practice they’re probably just trying to shield the kids from what is happening.

And you work in a school. Disgraceful. Do loads of children make false claims too?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/04/2023 20:51

MsInsomniac · 08/04/2023 20:26

No one believed me or my kids either. The whole family court process was utterly abusive and traumatic. CAFCASS only worried about his right to see the kids. My ex had physically assaulted my small child. My son told them. I told them. His little sibling told them they had heard it. They still forced me to take the kids to him 3 nights a week where he failed to parent them, failed to protect them, and continued his volatile abusive behaviour. The kids would cry and beg not to go. He actually told them there was a court order that said they had to come to him and make them believe I or they would be put in court if they didn’t go. My eldest is now 14. Hasn’t seen him for 2 years. Hates him. Said to me the other day he feels his childhood was shit, ruined by all of this.

I’m so sorry you went through this. Your last sentences are so powerful - why don’t courts consider the effects on children? Why are they pushing children to have shit traumatic childhoods?!

Bepis · 08/04/2023 20:51

Gondala · 08/04/2023 20:23

I believe there should be more accountability for judges and cafcass decisions. If a decision means a child is subjected to further abuse when there is clear evidence that this was likely to happen, a judge or cafcaff should be criminally responsible for their part in this.

Absolutely agree with this 100%. They can make life changing decisions and yet are not held to account. A recent local story involved a judge ordering a child to go back home to his parents (social had removed him). After returning home upon the order of the court, the child was then murdered. Nothing will happen to the judge though.

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 20:50

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/04/2023 20:45

Well said OP - I wish more people knew what it was like.

If my DH ever becomes violent towards I wouldn’t say a word to anyone, I’d just leave. I’m thankfully in a position to do so. It no way in hell would I invite the family court system into my life as a DV victim. It’s distressing, insensitive and the system SO misogynistic. Women have to protect their children but also facilitate access to their abuser. They are held to a scarily higher standard than men. And absolutely nobody in power cares

You've summed it up in a nutshell. The trauma of the family court system is almost as horrific as fleeing domestic abuse in the first instance.

OP posts:
TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/04/2023 20:49

Polik · 08/04/2023 20:16

I (school safeguarding) deal with more cases of parents trying to restrict their ex access to their children by falsely claiming abuse, than families facing actual ongoing risk of abuse.

When I say more, it's trebel, quadruple type amounts. Not just a few more.

Herein is the problem.

How do you know it’s a false claim? Were you there?

AutisticLegoLover · 08/04/2023 20:49

This has been my experience too. 20+ times I had to go to court with my abusive exH. I'd add court appointed psychologists to the gaslighting bastards list too. My abuser now abuses my Dd who the courts says could live with him. Utter fuckwits the lot of them.

Bepis · 08/04/2023 20:47

poormanspombears · 08/04/2023 20:40

@Bepis I'm so sorry that you and your DH went through that.

Men get bashed for not caring enough and for caring too much.
Women are encouraged to 'embellish' and men can't even tell the truth.

The system makes me sick to be honest.

It makes me sick too if I am honest.

So for a year and a half, DSS told lies to SS saying his dad grabbed his arm and bent it behind him, hurting him. Another time he said his dad went to hit him but my own daughter stopped him. All of this is untrue as I am always at home when DH is there and my adult children were too. So DSS spent a year saying this stuff about his dad (which we are under no illusions came from the mum) and SS believed him.

Then, DH had enough of his son telling lies so told him to tell the truth otherwise it may affect his contact with us all. DSS was then more truthful with the psychologist but then this got turned round that DH was alienating his son from mum. Everything bad DSS was saying about his dad over the 18 months was disregarded.

So essentially, DSS says bad about his dad, it must be true but if he says bad against his mum, then it's down to my husbands manipulation 🙄

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 20:45

poormanspombears · 08/04/2023 20:40

@Bepis I'm so sorry that you and your DH went through that.

Men get bashed for not caring enough and for caring too much.
Women are encouraged to 'embellish' and men can't even tell the truth.

The system makes me sick to be honest.

My experience is actually that women are discouraged from speaking about abuse as they are automatically assumed to be lying. There are certain procedures in place when abuse is alleged that make the court process more prolonged and so women are penalised for raising valid concerns

OP posts:
TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 08/04/2023 20:45

Well said OP - I wish more people knew what it was like.

If my DH ever becomes violent towards I wouldn’t say a word to anyone, I’d just leave. I’m thankfully in a position to do so. It no way in hell would I invite the family court system into my life as a DV victim. It’s distressing, insensitive and the system SO misogynistic. Women have to protect their children but also facilitate access to their abuser. They are held to a scarily higher standard than men. And absolutely nobody in power cares

DeeCeeCherry · 08/04/2023 20:44

Polik
I (school safeguarding) deal with more cases of parents trying to restrict their ex access to their children by falsely claiming abuse, than families facing actual ongoing risk of abuse

How do you know the claims are false? How can you know? You do know abuse isn't just physical, don't you?

Part of the issue is society's fawning over good looks, charm, a well modulated voice on tap, and a sob story. Both men and women are susceptible to the fallacy.

Years ago after abuse from an ex which resulted in a police matter, a policewoman actually asked me if I was SURE things were as bad as I said. She'd spoken to him - a handsome man who was charming when he wanted his own way - & she felt sorry for him! Ridiculous. I eventually discovered he'd hit his ex too.

People are stupid and gullible over good looking men - if they're ugly and well built its a different story. I feel sorry for any woman going through the family court process i have some friends who've been through it and it looks to me as if they're being punished for being abused...

Swipe left for the next trending thread