Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Family Court Scandal and Abuse

264 replies

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 19:37

Wasn't sure what to post this under:

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by authorities to leave their abusers or risk losing their children.

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by the family courts to coparent with their abusers or risk losing their children.

The family court system is not fit for purpose. Women are re traumatised during proceedings whereby they are forced to face their abuser, are further gaslit by Cafcass and magistrates and forced to push their children into unsafe contact arrangements.

The court want to handle cases as quickly as possible and women are criticised for raising allegations of abuse as this prolongs the court process.

The abuser uses the court to further their abuse through the children and is not held accountable for their harmful and abusive behaviour.

If you can relate to this then I am sorry. The trauma experienced can trigger ptsd, anxiety and depression to name a few. I don’t know how to change the system but in raising awareness and talking about it I hope it’s a move in the right direction for real change.

OP posts:
JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 11:05

If it's all about the children and their "rights" then how come only children get forced to see parents, but a parent can't be forced into any form of contact? Or at least paying for those children.

Soopermum1 · 09/04/2023 10:58

I found court and Cafcass reasonably sympathetic and he was made to jump hoops for two years to get access. But it moved towards its inevitable conclusion, and there did seem to be a constant thread running through proceedings that contact with the father should be re established at all cost and that was the only end goal to be considered. There was a large amount of evidence that he had abused me and DS but there was no evidence he had abused DD, that was because he hadn't seen her (his own choice) for 4 years. Her case was viewed very much in isolation. He got contact, she started to hate it after the novelty wore off then he assaulted her. So we're back at square one. I hope he decides not to go back to court, perhaps having to explain the massive decline in her mental health and the cctv footage of the assault will put him off. I hope Cafcass and the court decide they're flogging a dead horse, despite all the courses he was made to go on, he's a deeply damaged man who has damaged his children.

Alicehatter · 09/04/2023 10:54

The question is, how do things get changed?
The authorities want "what's best for the children", I get that, but they just assume having both parents involved is what's best!
But what happens when parents don't want involvement?

I'm so sorry to read about the abuse many of you have suffered and are still suffering. My personal opinion is that even if the kids weren't abused, mum shouldn't be forced to send them.

No physical abuse here and a wonderful dad at home..
He left and now has minimal contact with the kids - turns up when he should but never on time, never contacts them outside of his day and never gets involved with anything. I see the kids saddened by his attitude towards them and it breaks my heart, but I can't force him to do any more for them!! How can it be right that so many of you guys HAVE to send your kids to abusers, yet on the flip side, deadbeats aren't forced to do more?!
It's a massively fucked up, contradictory system but I honestly don't know what the answer is 😔

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 09/04/2023 10:41

Stomacharmeleon · 09/04/2023 09:36

I think @Polik is getting a hard time and it's unwarranted. She is being forthcoming about a difficult subject. DSL is a very difficult job and I take my hat off to you.

I respectfully disagree, yes, DSL is a difficult job but using their role to demonise parents who disclose abuse and saying that they see many many cases of false allegations as the children do not back the abuse is not okay.

Lots of people on this thread prove how difficult it is to be believed and thinking you know better because you allegedly can spot patterns/behaviour when traumatised children do not disclose abuse readily is dangerous.

SweetSakura · 09/04/2023 10:14

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/04/2023 10:10

Its the polar opposite in my experience.

I find your view rather concerning. Much like rape and sexual assault statistics....abusers are far more likely to get away with abuse and false allegations, whilst perfectly possible, will be a tiny percentage.

Agreed.

And my understanding is that the academic research supports this. Women actually very rarely make false accusations of abuse.

Most "high conflict" divorces aren't parents using children as "pawns" but rather the outcome of an abuser dominating and the abused trying to keep themselves and their children safe.

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/04/2023 10:10

Polik · 08/04/2023 20:16

I (school safeguarding) deal with more cases of parents trying to restrict their ex access to their children by falsely claiming abuse, than families facing actual ongoing risk of abuse.

When I say more, it's trebel, quadruple type amounts. Not just a few more.

Herein is the problem.

Its the polar opposite in my experience.

I find your view rather concerning. Much like rape and sexual assault statistics....abusers are far more likely to get away with abuse and false allegations, whilst perfectly possible, will be a tiny percentage.

maddening · 09/04/2023 10:00

Stomacharmeleon · 09/04/2023 09:36

I think @Polik is getting a hard time and it's unwarranted. She is being forthcoming about a difficult subject. DSL is a very difficult job and I take my hat off to you.

I think it is as she is unlikely to be sufficiently skilled to be stating what she is as fact and using her role to qualify her opinions.

And based on people's experience there are many people in the system which seem to be easily duped by manipulative abusers and not sufficiently skilled to unpick damaged, abused children's cases to the point that they will accuse the abused parent of lying.l and actively support the abuser.

Yes there are some cases where a parent lies and fabricates abuse - just as there are rape cases that are fabricated - but I suspect that these are fewer than actual abuse cases.

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 09:57

Busybody2022 · 09/04/2023 09:50

I found it worked well for our family.

Ex was highly abusive. We split. I enforced SS to withhold contact and await him taking me to court.

He did take me to court. My view was always ensuring the safety of the children as priority.

Court ordered him to complete a couple of programmes. He refused to do these programmes. Court ordered no direct or indirect contact as a result.

It's difficult when there is no evidence and it's one word against another.

It is also difficult to accept that what is a highly dangerous environment for a child when the parents are living together can be managed to be safe. This might just be supervised contact, it might be unsupervised there's no real one size fits all.

I can see things a lot clearer now it has been 5 years than when I was in the thick of it.

The problem is women are also encouraged to allow contact to avoid court. This was my experience with Womens aid. They were supportive but advised me to try to come to an agreement with ex. I did this and he still took me to court. It was then used against me. "If is was that bad why did you allow contact". Well I was advised unless there was severe abuse contact would be awarded anyway and to avoid court at all costs. My ex also started accusing me of parental alienation by limiting contact so it's a very difficult position to be in

OP posts:
cato40 · 09/04/2023 09:57

@Polik you think you saw that because you can't see the abuse and fall for the charms of the abusers. I live with one and no one would believe me because they are so charming and cool, all the ladies love him

Busybody2022 · 09/04/2023 09:50

I found it worked well for our family.

Ex was highly abusive. We split. I enforced SS to withhold contact and await him taking me to court.

He did take me to court. My view was always ensuring the safety of the children as priority.

Court ordered him to complete a couple of programmes. He refused to do these programmes. Court ordered no direct or indirect contact as a result.

It's difficult when there is no evidence and it's one word against another.

It is also difficult to accept that what is a highly dangerous environment for a child when the parents are living together can be managed to be safe. This might just be supervised contact, it might be unsupervised there's no real one size fits all.

I can see things a lot clearer now it has been 5 years than when I was in the thick of it.

Stomacharmeleon · 09/04/2023 09:36

I think @Polik is getting a hard time and it's unwarranted. She is being forthcoming about a difficult subject. DSL is a very difficult job and I take my hat off to you.

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 06:33

LifeLoatheItOrIgnoreItYouCantLikeIt · 09/04/2023 02:12

That would be nice. The prevailing view in the courts is that parental contact is vital no matter how shit the parent. But why? What evidence is there for this?

Exactly I would like to know too

OP posts:
BeatrizViter · 09/04/2023 05:01

I have worked in this field professionally previously for 10+ years and it doesn't matter what your level of expertise is, to some extent, as there is no clinically reliable way to tell if someone is lying. A famous project studying the body language of parents interviewed about missing children, who were later found to have murdered their children, found no consistencies in the way they behaved when telling the most atrocious lies. The case law noted in most fact findings will lay out people lie about many things for many reasons, including fear and shame, and this does not mean they are lying about the factual matters of the case. Credibility, as determined by the professionals involved, is notoriously subjective, and often there is no evidence as to what either parent is saying other than the voice or behaviour of the child, which is rightly noted here to be hugely subjective in its interpretation and influenced by parents anyway. This is why social workers often detest working private law cases, even more that public law, because they have to make a decision and recommendation based on what is likely to be very flawed evidence with two plausible parents.

LifeLoatheItOrIgnoreItYouCantLikeIt · 09/04/2023 02:17

I made a formal complaint against CAFCASS. Their investigation of the complaint consisted of asking the children's guardian (who I'd complained about) if he'd done anything wrong. Shock result - he said no, and they closed the complaint. You can't re open closed complaint. So I made a new complaint. About the way they'd investigated the first complaint. So they sent it for 'internal review' and the head of practice said their was 'learning to be done' for the children's guardian. But no complaint of mine was upheld in any way shape or form. Frankly that tells you all you need to know about the honesty and integrity of CAFCASS

LifeLoatheItOrIgnoreItYouCantLikeIt · 09/04/2023 02:13

snitzelvoncrumb · 09/04/2023 01:24

I am waiting for people who were forced to see abusive fathers as children start a class action lawsuit against the courts.

Sorry, meant to quote this

LifeLoatheItOrIgnoreItYouCantLikeIt · 09/04/2023 02:12

That would be nice. The prevailing view in the courts is that parental contact is vital no matter how shit the parent. But why? What evidence is there for this?

snitzelvoncrumb · 09/04/2023 01:24

I am waiting for people who were forced to see abusive fathers as children start a class action lawsuit against the courts.

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 01:19

AutisticLegoLover · 09/04/2023 00:02

My dc just used to say what's the point of talking to someone else, they never do anything to help

My daughter has said this too and it's sad

OP posts:
SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 01:18

SunUp · 09/04/2023 00:38

I think one of the biggest problems that people who have suffered dv face when it comes to family courts is the attitude towards it.
As in.......
' well why didn't you leave? '
' it can't have been that bad because you stayed '
' why didn't you report him to the police? '
Etc.
Because clearly it's so easy to do the above things when you're emotionally broken and skint!!!
These attitudes need addressing and changing, because until they do them I can't see how the issues are ever going to be resolved in favour of the children.
I can guarantee that most, if not all of these judges and magistrates have never been in the position of the petitioner to have any understanding of the situations that they're passing judgement on.
If they have then they wouldn't make half of the ridiculous and often dangerous orders.

Yep. They also said why did you allow any contact if you had concerns, when equally I was told by withholding contact I was emotionally manipulative and accused of parental alienation. We cannot win in these circumstances

OP posts:
SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 01:14

TheVanguardSix · 08/04/2023 23:53

How do i know the most claims against ex's are false? Because I speak to the child.

To an abused child, you’re just some strange official wearing a lanyard, sitting in a white room covered with industrial carpet tile flooring. You’re another adult not to trust. Why would they tell you the truth? You’re not gonna save them. They know this. You’re just the person writing notes, putting together a file on them, observing them, studying them. They’re your project among too many others. You’re not taking them to the sunlit uplands, away from the abuse. If they can’t tell people they love and trust about their suffering, what makes you think they’d tell you about their suffering? Why should they trust you?

When a child is abused, they too are trained. Trained to shut up.

My daughter’s abuser was a DSL. Very well trained. Trained to speak to the child. Excellent at deceiving everybody. My advice to you is, hear us mothers. Listen to us. Don’t laugh at us and turn away. Our intuition so fucking strong, our own breasts can leak milk when even a stranger’s baby cries. That’s how fucking in tune with shit we are. There’s no training manual to tell you that.

Thank you 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 we grew those babies, gave birth to them and raised them. Yet a stranger who has known them for 5 minutes apparently knows best. Insanity!

OP posts:
maddening · 09/04/2023 01:03

Bepis · 09/04/2023 01:01

@maddening Sadly, even a clinical psychologist could not see through the manipulation in my husbands case and painted him to be the abuser even though the evidence showed otherwise.

Exactly- therefore a safe guarding lead at a school really should understand their own limitations before stating facts with such confidence in their own ability.

Bepis · 09/04/2023 01:01

@maddening Sadly, even a clinical psychologist could not see through the manipulation in my husbands case and painted him to be the abuser even though the evidence showed otherwise.

maddening · 09/04/2023 01:00

TheVanguardSix · 08/04/2023 23:53

How do i know the most claims against ex's are false? Because I speak to the child.

To an abused child, you’re just some strange official wearing a lanyard, sitting in a white room covered with industrial carpet tile flooring. You’re another adult not to trust. Why would they tell you the truth? You’re not gonna save them. They know this. You’re just the person writing notes, putting together a file on them, observing them, studying them. They’re your project among too many others. You’re not taking them to the sunlit uplands, away from the abuse. If they can’t tell people they love and trust about their suffering, what makes you think they’d tell you about their suffering? Why should they trust you?

When a child is abused, they too are trained. Trained to shut up.

My daughter’s abuser was a DSL. Very well trained. Trained to speak to the child. Excellent at deceiving everybody. My advice to you is, hear us mothers. Listen to us. Don’t laugh at us and turn away. Our intuition so fucking strong, our own breasts can leak milk when even a stranger’s baby cries. That’s how fucking in tune with shit we are. There’s no training manual to tell you that.

I agree, and a safeguarding lead at a school is hardly a clinical or forensic psychologist - they may have some training but it is unlikely to be to a level to really determine the truth.

SunUp · 09/04/2023 00:38

I think one of the biggest problems that people who have suffered dv face when it comes to family courts is the attitude towards it.
As in.......
' well why didn't you leave? '
' it can't have been that bad because you stayed '
' why didn't you report him to the police? '
Etc.
Because clearly it's so easy to do the above things when you're emotionally broken and skint!!!
These attitudes need addressing and changing, because until they do them I can't see how the issues are ever going to be resolved in favour of the children.
I can guarantee that most, if not all of these judges and magistrates have never been in the position of the petitioner to have any understanding of the situations that they're passing judgement on.
If they have then they wouldn't make half of the ridiculous and often dangerous orders.

AutisticLegoLover · 09/04/2023 00:19

My dc have spoken to many social workers, and 2 cafcass people. Early help, primary jigsaw, clinical psychologist. Not one of those people advocated for their safety. Only for the rights of their father to continue to have contact t with them. The latest incident where he physically abused dd1 and this was reported to the police and the LADO was involved and whatever, was later listed by the assigned social worker as a "challenge." A fucking challenge. No one had the presence of mind to wonder why Dd changed her story about that incident and most of the other ones. They just decided it wasn't that bad and she was behaving in a challenging way so it was reasonable for him to assault her. DD's attendance is 60% in year 11. She is going to fail most of her GCSEs when she is capable of mainly Bs. I'm powerless. She lives with him and they do nothing to help. Why is he not held to account for her attendance? Her uniform is filthy, it smells, she smells. Obvious neglect but they do nothing. Dd is now fully aligned with her abuser and has been alienated from me. I can only hope once she's at college or leaves home that she will come out of the fog that he's enveloped her in, enabled by cafcass, social services and the courts. I hope they all burn in hell.