Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Family Court Scandal and Abuse

264 replies

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 19:37

Wasn't sure what to post this under:

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by authorities to leave their abusers or risk losing their children.

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by the family courts to coparent with their abusers or risk losing their children.

The family court system is not fit for purpose. Women are re traumatised during proceedings whereby they are forced to face their abuser, are further gaslit by Cafcass and magistrates and forced to push their children into unsafe contact arrangements.

The court want to handle cases as quickly as possible and women are criticised for raising allegations of abuse as this prolongs the court process.

The abuser uses the court to further their abuse through the children and is not held accountable for their harmful and abusive behaviour.

If you can relate to this then I am sorry. The trauma experienced can trigger ptsd, anxiety and depression to name a few. I don’t know how to change the system but in raising awareness and talking about it I hope it’s a move in the right direction for real change.

OP posts:
Dhama · 09/04/2023 17:27

I wrote my dissertation on this 😔

Thriwit · 09/04/2023 17:27

I think the issue of money isn’t talked about enough.

Child maintenance reductions for contact, or nil child maintenance for 50/50 care, mean it’s often in people’s best financial interests to have shared care, even if they don’t actually want to/can’t parent.
Legal aid is only available in cases of domestic abuse.
With divorce, the primary concern is housing the children, therefore whoever has primary residency of the children usually ends up with more than 50% of assets/a house (I know that’s a simplification, but it’s generally true).
The benefits system favours the resident parent - child benefit, UC, housing etc

None of this can be brought up in contact/residency disputes, but it’s naive to think finances don’t come into this for a good chunk of people.

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 17:23

MeliaLane · 09/04/2023 15:59

Bias works both ways. It is interesting on here that posts about mothers ‘playing the system’ to keep their children to themselves are just about ignored. My stepson has had his life near ruined by his ExW. Our family have lost a family member and more importantly a LO has lost his grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins.
This is a female with many issues, is charming and giving but very controlling. Watching from a more objective stance as a step parent, I could have predicted this is what she would do. I didn't forsee that she would get away with it though.

A fair system would produce the right outcome for the child not for whichever is the most manipulative parent.

This is a valid point but I think the overall argument is that mothers are presumed to be lying about allegations of abuse in the first instance. Likely because of previous cases in the past. So when there are real accusations it's very difficult to prove and even with evidence often the abuser, Cafcass and the magistrates will justify the behaviour. This is I have now learned is referred to as a different 'parenting style'. They are desperate to close the case and focus on the damage to the children by being 'within the court system' whilst ignoring the abuse from the abuser themselves. This was my experience and I left utterly traumatised. I sat in a court room for two full days where my ex lied, the Cafcass officer supported him and the magistrates increased contact as a result. Now I have to hand over the children to an abusive person or risk being in breach of a court order.

OP posts:
ASimpleLampoon · 09/04/2023 17:11

I hope the children affected Will speak out when they are adults. I hope they recover from their trauma.

coodawoodashooda · 09/04/2023 16:57

SweetSakura · 09/04/2023 15:34

I think it will, but it will take time. Like with the CSA scandals of the 70s and 80s it wil be when the children hit adulthood and get therapy and the enormity of the harm done hits them that some may start to (quite rightly) seek recompense.

I agree. My kids will be those kids.

pickledandpuzzled · 09/04/2023 16:55

Some I know has been told by police to report her ex, asked her to detail the abuse, which was traumatic. SS then blamed her for not leaving earlier.
She's afraid to say what went on and afraid not to say.

Next step is court, ex still manipulating the DC against her whenever there is contact. If you ask the DC, they love their daddy and want to see him. Meanwhile the police are investigating his behaviour to their mum.

MeliaLane · 09/04/2023 15:59

Bias works both ways. It is interesting on here that posts about mothers ‘playing the system’ to keep their children to themselves are just about ignored. My stepson has had his life near ruined by his ExW. Our family have lost a family member and more importantly a LO has lost his grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins.
This is a female with many issues, is charming and giving but very controlling. Watching from a more objective stance as a step parent, I could have predicted this is what she would do. I didn't forsee that she would get away with it though.

A fair system would produce the right outcome for the child not for whichever is the most manipulative parent.

SweetSakura · 09/04/2023 15:34

coodawoodashooda · 09/04/2023 14:33

I would bloody love for this to start happening. A bit of accountability for the do-gooders that get to walk away once they've made their 'expert' decision.

I think it will, but it will take time. Like with the CSA scandals of the 70s and 80s it wil be when the children hit adulthood and get therapy and the enormity of the harm done hits them that some may start to (quite rightly) seek recompense.

poormanspombears · 09/04/2023 15:32

@Iwasafool

I think the system is breaking parents, children and good social workers alike.

I definitely think there are 'professionals' with bias and the system is pro 'keeping the family together' (hence why kids who are being abused are left with a caregiver who ends up killing them rather than being taken into care and possibly surviving) which in cases as shown here, is dangerous and will inevitably cause more concerns down the line. I think there are professionals who think they know better and there are professionals who base new cases on old case evidence and push an agenda they've assumed rightly or wrongly.

I personally feel contact centres are not used correctly enough and from my own experience of working in one, I saw too many cases where the parent was using as a control tactic towards the other parent.

The social care system needs a complete overhaul and restart to do any good. As it stands, they are training social workers who have good intentions but then overwork them with rigorous and almost impossible duty schedules and uncapped case loads.

The whole thing is fucked basically and I think a lot of it is down to luck. My local authority for example is in special measures and I would genuinely fear for my family if I had to use the court system or social care system right now.

Bepis · 09/04/2023 15:10

From my experience, I feel the system is mired in misandry. Men can do no right and they have to jump through hoops to see their child every other weekend. Whereas the mum is automatically granted residence.

An example - DH and his ex were said to both be manipulating their son and not able to put his needs first. They concluded that DSS was a victim of emotional harm and abuse from both parents (which I don't agree with).

The result of that was DH fighting to not have his contact supervised yet mum (who had done the same) would have been awarded more time unsupervised with their son.

Makes no sense. I feel the system is sexist but that's just based on my own experience. I have experienced the system as a mother and I was treated hugely differently to my DH.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/04/2023 15:02

I agree. It's mired in misogyny from the bottom up.

One CAFCASS worker on a home visit sat on my bed and he told me my ex still loved me, so I could make 'all of this go away' if I stopped being silly and took him back and the judge ignored the next one who utterly believed me to declare that I'd 'very sadly but understandably, been tempted to gild the lily' despite said gilding being DD making a statement that she had been assaulted.

Another a few years later informed me quite seriously that the reason we didn't get on was because the ex was a Pisces whilst I was a Capricorn. And then when this was brought up in Court, said it was just jokey banter and I was making it out to be more than it was. I mean, I could have sworn that we didn't get on because he was an alcoholic rapist and abuser who pinned me to the wall by my throat until I nearly passed out (or died), but no, it's because my mother had an induction rather than waiting for me to die in utero, apparently.

Thriwit · 09/04/2023 14:46

Theunamedcat · 09/04/2023 14:32

And people wonder why I dont let my ex drag me through court why I agreed to him seeing them rather than fighting I stay put and wait him out rather than going through court the social worker I spoke to was pleased im playing the long game and agreed court would give my ex way too much power over me im currently promoting contact but giving my sons wishes and feelings credit which means they haven't seen him for months and he doesn't care because I agreed to his demands its bizarre I offered him more contact he cut it down to virtually nothing an inconvenient hour twice a week he spends longer travelling than seeing them by choice

I will never understand the system

Unfortunately some of us have no choice over whether we go to court or not. If your ex starts court proceedings, you don’t have much choice. If your ex takes your children and won’t give them back, and won’t let you see or contact them, you don’t have much choice. If your ex is abusive towards the children, you don’t have much choice (and if you withhold contact, ex will often then start proceedings, and again you have no choice - but are often even worse off).

MeliaLane · 09/04/2023 14:34

Yes, I have a very low opinion of family courts.

We have almost no contact with our DGC due to the claims made by our ex DiL.
Believing malicious adults, who are unwilling to share their children with the other parent, brings about so much damage, including attachment disorders. Children are not the priority.

coodawoodashooda · 09/04/2023 14:33

Tortelemon · 09/04/2023 14:29

Has a child who has been forced to see an abusive parent ever taken legal action against cafcass and the family court once they reach 18?

Money talks and asking for financial compensation at the age of 18 plus may be a way to get the system changed.

I would bloody love for this to start happening. A bit of accountability for the do-gooders that get to walk away once they've made their 'expert' decision.

Theunamedcat · 09/04/2023 14:32

And people wonder why I dont let my ex drag me through court why I agreed to him seeing them rather than fighting I stay put and wait him out rather than going through court the social worker I spoke to was pleased im playing the long game and agreed court would give my ex way too much power over me im currently promoting contact but giving my sons wishes and feelings credit which means they haven't seen him for months and he doesn't care because I agreed to his demands its bizarre I offered him more contact he cut it down to virtually nothing an inconvenient hour twice a week he spends longer travelling than seeing them by choice

I will never understand the system

Tortelemon · 09/04/2023 14:29

Has a child who has been forced to see an abusive parent ever taken legal action against cafcass and the family court once they reach 18?

Money talks and asking for financial compensation at the age of 18 plus may be a way to get the system changed.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 14:25

The thing is, it could possibly be understandable in a strict he said she said situation. However there are thousands of cases where the are police reports, proof of injuries, doctor reports, plenty of evidence and statements , hell even arrests and convictions and they all get ignored and dismissed, ironically citing "the rights of the child". You can't gamble that way with children's lives, and pretend it's for their own good.

Iwasafool · 09/04/2023 13:56

maddening · 09/04/2023 10:00

I think it is as she is unlikely to be sufficiently skilled to be stating what she is as fact and using her role to qualify her opinions.

And based on people's experience there are many people in the system which seem to be easily duped by manipulative abusers and not sufficiently skilled to unpick damaged, abused children's cases to the point that they will accuse the abused parent of lying.l and actively support the abuser.

Yes there are some cases where a parent lies and fabricates abuse - just as there are rape cases that are fabricated - but I suspect that these are fewer than actual abuse cases.

As an employer I was asked to meet with CAFCAS as my employee's ex had included allegations about his employment (disciplinaries and poor behaviour) I had to say her claims were false. I have no idea if her other allegations were true and if they were it is a shame she included the made up stuff about his work as I think she lost credibility. He got supervised access and after a few months unsupervised and eventually he got overnight contact, this was for a very young child.

I wonder if what she said about other things were true, did my statement mean an unsuitable man got unsupervised access to his child? It does cross my mind from time to time. He moved on and I have no idea how it worked out in the end.

I'd hate to be the one making judgements in these cases, that one example was hard enough and all I had to do was tell the truth.

Iwasafool · 09/04/2023 13:44

poormanspombears · 08/04/2023 20:54

@SpringMum30

Wow, the really sad thing is that that should shock me but nothing does when it comes to the courts anymore. It goes to show that everyone is having equally poor experiences with the courts regardless which party you are.

It's absolutely devastating that people out there are having these experiences and as unfortunately research shows that abused people tend to either stay for kids/money/fear or if they do leave, then likely get in another abusive relationship, it just won't get better because they become stuck in a cycle of being abused by partners then the system that should protect them.

Do you think there are people with their own prejudices and it depends if you get a pro mother or pro father prejudice? Not sure that is very clear but it seems like there are people on both sides getting a bad experience so is it down to who is allocated to their case?

IlIlI · 09/04/2023 13:40

I've never understood in these situations, it looks to be that if she stays with her abuser then the children can possibly be removed for "failure to protect" but if she decides to leave her abuser, then suddenly the children no longer need protection and must go to his home alone.
I don't know what the best solution would be, but when I see these things I do understand why so many stay with abusers, in their minds it's probably better for her to be around when it happens instead of them being alone with him when it happens.
I know some will be doing things like making excuses for the children to divert his rage away from them and onto herself, trying to keep the children quiet so he doesn't get angry, tiptoeing round him so he isn't wound up etc and they see that as protecting them rather than leaving him and sending them off to be alone with him every weekend.

And yes, false allegations happen. That's the same excuse they give for abysmal stats on rape convictions too though. And that's before we get to the sentencing, so it's really not a shock that we see similar in family court cases.

frazzledasarock · 09/04/2023 13:21

My eldest DD always said nice things about her father. She was terrified of telling the truth about his abuse as he’d then mentally torture her during contact.

contact was supported, basically in a church hall where the supervisors would sit at the front observing all the other dead best abusive dads having contact.

ex would strategically sit at the back behind a pillar partly obscured from view.

my younger dd ended up sitting under the table and would not engage my eldest was taking the brunt of the abuse.

in the end I had to tell her if she was telling people she loved him and wanted contact I could not help her or stop contact. And she would have unsupervised contact as the courts would listen to her feelings and wishes.

so she told the truth and god it was bad for a long time till we got a judge who specialised in dv cases.

both my dc still suffer from the remnants of trauma despite the fact I spent thousands in counselling and therapy for them.

I also had police reports and gp and paed reports and. And a lot of other witness statements.

they still put ex’s ‘right’ to contact above my poor children’s well-being. It’s me CAFCASS officer even had the audacity to tell me it was fine as I wasn’t abusive and they had a stable home so ex should have contact.

ElsieMc · 09/04/2023 11:58

It is 15 years since I went through the family court process as a grandparent carer. I have never got over it and my treatment by the Judge and Cafcass. I was forced to hand my gs over to a violent abusive thug and his vile parents eow.

I lost the fact finding when a barrister had said he had no doubt findings would be made against him. The solicitors for the Local Authority told me they believed my treatment by the Judge was Dickensian. I was taken to court relentlessly over a three year period probably around 30 plus times. Yet the same Judge who poured scorn upon me felt I was the only party suitable to care for the children. The abuse towards me continued for over ten long years.

We ended back in another series of court hearings after gs's father began offending again - abh and finally gbh when he nearly killed someone. I was taken back to court because I would not hand him over for contact unless I had an undertaking from his parents they would supervise contact. Judge ordered supervised contact - but a different judge.

I cannot think of a way forward and can only urge people to try and work things out although I know this is often impossible. The process is so adversarial and parties become so entrenched.

The best advice I got from an earlier judge was that a fact finding would not make any difference to the eventual outcome. An honest appraisal of our case. They will get contact and supervised is the slippery slope to unsupervised.

Soopermum1 · 09/04/2023 11:34

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 11:05

If it's all about the children and their "rights" then how come only children get forced to see parents, but a parent can't be forced into any form of contact? Or at least paying for those children.

Absolutely. This should be the ethos.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 09/04/2023 11:29

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 11:05

If it's all about the children and their "rights" then how come only children get forced to see parents, but a parent can't be forced into any form of contact? Or at least paying for those children.

Excellent question but again it's the woman's fault for choosing a deadbeat dad.

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 11:12

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 11:05

If it's all about the children and their "rights" then how come only children get forced to see parents, but a parent can't be forced into any form of contact? Or at least paying for those children.

Good question!!

OP posts: