Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Family Court Scandal and Abuse

264 replies

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 19:37

Wasn't sure what to post this under:

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by authorities to leave their abusers or risk losing their children.

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by the family courts to coparent with their abusers or risk losing their children.

The family court system is not fit for purpose. Women are re traumatised during proceedings whereby they are forced to face their abuser, are further gaslit by Cafcass and magistrates and forced to push their children into unsafe contact arrangements.

The court want to handle cases as quickly as possible and women are criticised for raising allegations of abuse as this prolongs the court process.

The abuser uses the court to further their abuse through the children and is not held accountable for their harmful and abusive behaviour.

If you can relate to this then I am sorry. The trauma experienced can trigger ptsd, anxiety and depression to name a few. I don’t know how to change the system but in raising awareness and talking about it I hope it’s a move in the right direction for real change.

OP posts:
MeliaLane · 10/04/2023 18:07

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 11:23

DH's exW is one of the many people blocking family court. Her accusations have increased in severity as the years have gone on, every time a new court date approaches she lodged a new allegation, simply so the judge would then have to request further information at the next hearing, therefore not being able to end proceedings.
Didn't help that every hearing was heard by a different judge, however all 6 involved were very scathing of her and her solicitor's methods.

Yep! And in our experience, in all that waiting time, mother prevented child and father having any contact.
Each delay prolonged the estrangement.

Court felt that status quo should continue.
Father denied access.

Child has lost a father, grandparents and extended family.
No wonder children feel abandoned.

SpringMum30 · 10/04/2023 12:00

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 11:36

@SpringMum30 if it wasn't so serious it would have been laughable.

Her solicitor arrived at the first hearing with a massive jumbled mess of "issues" and she was sent away with the instruction to come to the next hearing properly prepared and with her 3 "most serious" allegations, which she did. They were all ridiculous and not one of them related to anything that could be remotely considered abusive - though incidentally, were all based on actual events that had happened.

That second judge was very scathing of her taking up time in family court with the issues she had brought.

Over 2 years later and the week before a hearing she would file a new allegation with her solicitor and as the time went on the allegations were getting more and more serious. It was a horrible time.

At the final hearing the judge went to town on her behaviour, making a point of saying about her initial 3 "concerns" being so petty and how it was noticeable that the severity of her allegations had increased over the course of the time it was in family court.

She ended up sending 2 solicitors off with stress, causing the owner of the firm to have to pay costs because of one of the solicitors work prior to going off with stress, and a cafcass officer took early retirement because of her. To this day, she still maintains they are HER children, and she will make all decisions regarding them, and no court will convincer her otherwise.

I appreciate your experience. I know this does happen and is equally wrong and problematic. It is a less common occurrence though and shouldn't be presumed the reality for every case. Often it is. I imagine for magistrates that have sat through cases similar to the one you described naturally are sceptical based on their personal experience.

OP posts:
Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 11:36

@SpringMum30 if it wasn't so serious it would have been laughable.

Her solicitor arrived at the first hearing with a massive jumbled mess of "issues" and she was sent away with the instruction to come to the next hearing properly prepared and with her 3 "most serious" allegations, which she did. They were all ridiculous and not one of them related to anything that could be remotely considered abusive - though incidentally, were all based on actual events that had happened.

That second judge was very scathing of her taking up time in family court with the issues she had brought.

Over 2 years later and the week before a hearing she would file a new allegation with her solicitor and as the time went on the allegations were getting more and more serious. It was a horrible time.

At the final hearing the judge went to town on her behaviour, making a point of saying about her initial 3 "concerns" being so petty and how it was noticeable that the severity of her allegations had increased over the course of the time it was in family court.

She ended up sending 2 solicitors off with stress, causing the owner of the firm to have to pay costs because of one of the solicitors work prior to going off with stress, and a cafcass officer took early retirement because of her. To this day, she still maintains they are HER children, and she will make all decisions regarding them, and no court will convincer her otherwise.

SpringMum30 · 10/04/2023 11:25

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 11:23

DH's exW is one of the many people blocking family court. Her accusations have increased in severity as the years have gone on, every time a new court date approaches she lodged a new allegation, simply so the judge would then have to request further information at the next hearing, therefore not being able to end proceedings.
Didn't help that every hearing was heard by a different judge, however all 6 involved were very scathing of her and her solicitor's methods.

People like her also contribute to the problem. I raised genuine concerns and was worried I would be accused of this and I was. This meant genuine allegations were dismissed. Despite the physical, mental and emotional stress of the process all whilst raising young children alone it was still presumed I was intentionally drawing the process out when in reality I wanted nothing more than for it to be over as soon as possible.

OP posts:
Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 11:23

DH's exW is one of the many people blocking family court. Her accusations have increased in severity as the years have gone on, every time a new court date approaches she lodged a new allegation, simply so the judge would then have to request further information at the next hearing, therefore not being able to end proceedings.
Didn't help that every hearing was heard by a different judge, however all 6 involved were very scathing of her and her solicitor's methods.

SpringMum30 · 10/04/2023 09:22

ElsieMc · 10/04/2023 09:07

You are right about the Magistrates. As I posted upthread, I went through the system when my gc's were placed with me. My issue came about when the father of one (or in reality his parents) wanted substantial contact when I did not even know who they were until gc1 was 2.5 years old!

My neighbour was a Magistrate often sitting on such cases. Whilst a nice enough lady, she expressed her shock about the boys becoming subject to court proceedings when no-one had been near for over two years. She told me she found the cases incredibly boring and hated sitting on them. What??

I was also told by CPS when we were involved in criminal proceedings against the parent that they were very relieved when a District Judge sat because he got to the point, dealt with it unlike Magistrates who, as I witnessed, sat looking shocked on occasion. Surely they have training of some sort. It might be better if they pulled Magistrates from a larger more diverse pool of those from different backgrounds, cultures and life experience of such matters.

Yes! The magistrates need looking into too. My ex played the card of poor young black man pushed aside and made to be an absent father. The lead magistrate was an older black man and bought into this. Even mentioned it was important for he children to embrace their culture.
The implication of this was that it was ok for some abusive behaviour as it came under different 'parenting styles' particularly cultural differences. I saw him smiling wi to my ex whilst he laughed when I was giving evidence

OP posts:
ElsieMc · 10/04/2023 09:07

You are right about the Magistrates. As I posted upthread, I went through the system when my gc's were placed with me. My issue came about when the father of one (or in reality his parents) wanted substantial contact when I did not even know who they were until gc1 was 2.5 years old!

My neighbour was a Magistrate often sitting on such cases. Whilst a nice enough lady, she expressed her shock about the boys becoming subject to court proceedings when no-one had been near for over two years. She told me she found the cases incredibly boring and hated sitting on them. What??

I was also told by CPS when we were involved in criminal proceedings against the parent that they were very relieved when a District Judge sat because he got to the point, dealt with it unlike Magistrates who, as I witnessed, sat looking shocked on occasion. Surely they have training of some sort. It might be better if they pulled Magistrates from a larger more diverse pool of those from different backgrounds, cultures and life experience of such matters.

SpringMum30 · 10/04/2023 00:18

pinkstinks · 09/04/2023 22:13

I think the magistracy needs to be overhauled and there should be a scheme to support IDVAs to apply to become
magistrates.
unfortunately the roles are voluntary and need a lot of time to be given - then it means most people who do it are older and retired. I don’t know what the training is like
but I can imagine not great.

This was a surprise to me. I Tim's my barrister I presumed they were ex solicitors/barristers and that a magistrate was a progressive position. Didn't hear of an IDVA until after my court ordeal either.

OP posts:
SpringMum30 · 10/04/2023 00:15

SweetSakura · 09/04/2023 22:16

I think i'd want to prioritise vigorously overhauling and retraining cafcass first. How can officers question children without making any effort to build rapport first? How can possibly think it is ok to ask leading questions? How can they ever think it is appropriate to meet one parent in person but not the other?

So true. I still think it's insanity that a stranger can meet a child for 15 minutes and expect them to pour their hearts out. They are trusted to decide how that children will spend their entire childhood based on that 15 minutes. I carried my children for 9 months, birthed them, raised them and spend majority of time with them. But sure the Cafcass officer knows best 🤔

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 09/04/2023 22:16

I think i'd want to prioritise vigorously overhauling and retraining cafcass first. How can officers question children without making any effort to build rapport first? How can possibly think it is ok to ask leading questions? How can they ever think it is appropriate to meet one parent in person but not the other?

pinkstinks · 09/04/2023 22:13

I think the magistracy needs to be overhauled and there should be a scheme to support IDVAs to apply to become
magistrates.
unfortunately the roles are voluntary and need a lot of time to be given - then it means most people who do it are older and retired. I don’t know what the training is like
but I can imagine not great.

Soopermum1 · 09/04/2023 21:45

Don't get me started on solicitors. I represented myself and my ex had a gaslighting lawyer. She tried to convince everyone that my child had every chance of getting into the local, oversubscribed Catholic secondary school where all her friends were going, if she didn't go to Mass every week. The ex refused to take her to Mass despite being (formerly it seems) Catholic. The Cafcass officer and the judge put her and him straight in court, but it didn't make any difference, was like water off a duck's back. She downplayed everything. I wonder how she can sleep at night.

coodawoodashooda · 09/04/2023 21:15

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 20:59

I'd like to know too. I think they actually convince themselves and do everything to justify their actions. There's no emotional attachment for them just another days work 🙄

And also, you generally need a solicitor to be heard in court. The solicitor is after money. Not justice

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 20:59

I'd like to know too. I think they actually convince themselves and do everything to justify their actions. There's no emotional attachment for them just another days work 🙄

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 09/04/2023 20:03

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 19:26

@coodawoodashooda I'm sorry you can relate too x

It's soul destroying. Why are the courts not worried about the repercussions of their decisions?

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 19:26

@coodawoodashooda I'm sorry you can relate too x

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 09/04/2023 19:05

SweetSakura · 09/04/2023 15:34

I think it will, but it will take time. Like with the CSA scandals of the 70s and 80s it wil be when the children hit adulthood and get therapy and the enormity of the harm done hits them that some may start to (quite rightly) seek recompense.

How would the adult child in this situation prove the abuse and trauma?

CheesecakeAddict · 09/04/2023 19:03

The money is a big thing. When the courts put a PSO to stay in SW London, ExH took a demotion to pay less but had loads of money in bonds, high interest rates in off shore accounts etc. He was paying 400 per month, but our childcare bill alone was 1800 and my rent for the shelter was 800. I couldn't afford to move out of my shelter because of the PSO and the cost of rent. I was on 2200 per month and exH refused to pay towards transport costs, uniform, clothes, childcare etc. I even tried to get the PSO lifter citing I couldn't afford to pay my rent and afford food and heating and I had defaulted so many times they were in the process of evicting me. The judge actually told me if I quit my job and went on benefits I would be better off. I had colleagues noticing I was losing a lot of weight and were bringing me in ready meals because I literally couldn't afford to eat as I was saving any food I could afford for DD. ExH just kept claiming I could move back in with him and it would no longer be a problem.

coodawoodashooda · 09/04/2023 19:03

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 17:23

This is a valid point but I think the overall argument is that mothers are presumed to be lying about allegations of abuse in the first instance. Likely because of previous cases in the past. So when there are real accusations it's very difficult to prove and even with evidence often the abuser, Cafcass and the magistrates will justify the behaviour. This is I have now learned is referred to as a different 'parenting style'. They are desperate to close the case and focus on the damage to the children by being 'within the court system' whilst ignoring the abuse from the abuser themselves. This was my experience and I left utterly traumatised. I sat in a court room for two full days where my ex lied, the Cafcass officer supported him and the magistrates increased contact as a result. Now I have to hand over the children to an abusive person or risk being in breach of a court order.

I am so sorry. I'm in a similar situation. It is heartbreaking.

Thriwit · 09/04/2023 18:20

@SpringMum30
I completely agree with you! And it doesn’t help that child maintenance is not a guaranteed payment and could just not be paid.
I just think that money is a motivating factor for some people to fight for more contact or equal residency, and that’s not recognised enough. And I think that ultimately this could be lessened significantly if everyone wasn’t so skint all the time - it would allow some parents to think what’s actually best for the children, as opposed to what’s best for them. It’s just another consequence of such high cost of living.
It wouldn’t stop everyone, you’d still get some parents not wanting to give their ex a penny, but they are also more likely to be abusive in other ways too.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 18:12

Bepis · 09/04/2023 15:10

From my experience, I feel the system is mired in misandry. Men can do no right and they have to jump through hoops to see their child every other weekend. Whereas the mum is automatically granted residence.

An example - DH and his ex were said to both be manipulating their son and not able to put his needs first. They concluded that DSS was a victim of emotional harm and abuse from both parents (which I don't agree with).

The result of that was DH fighting to not have his contact supervised yet mum (who had done the same) would have been awarded more time unsupervised with their son.

Makes no sense. I feel the system is sexist but that's just based on my own experience. I have experienced the system as a mother and I was treated hugely differently to my DH.

I think rather than misandry, it's based on numbers and circumstances. There are more mothers that are the primary carer, more mothers that are forced to run for their safety, more mothers that are left with the children etc. In the vast majority of cases the children already are with the mother for whatever reason, and she is their primary carer so it's a maintaining the status quo situation.

If a mother left her kids behind with their father, especially for a long period in time, no court would say "oh, you're the mother ,here have the kids back immediately ".

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 18:05

These are all valid points but the resident parent (normally the mother) needs more financial support especially with young children as they are likely juggling work and childcare. They are likely to have been off work the most for maternity and may not even be working full time. The non resident parent who has less time with the kids has more capacity to work because they don't have to sort childcare, do the school runs etc.

This has been my experience I work part time and have to work out the school/preschool drop offs, take time off work when the kids are sick etc. My ex can work whenever he likes and so doesn't have to worry about these things

OP posts:
Thriwit · 09/04/2023 17:54

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 17:37

Also child maintenance is used as a tool to maintain post separation abuse. My ex is self employed apparently owns his own company and yet 'pays a low salary and takes dividends' this means he pays zero child maintenance whilst living a lavish lifestyle, trips abroad, fancy meals etc. I actually raised it in court as I was confused about his employment status since he didn't have to pay maintenance at all. The courts do not care

Oh absolutely! We could have a whole other thread about child maintenance issues 😅

A lot of this is a symptom of the wider cost of living problem though. A single person on say £28k will be calculated to pay around £300/month for 2 children if they see them EOW. They likely won’t be entitled to any benefits, but will be expected to provide somewhere for their children to stay over (I.e. bedsit/house share not acceptable), and with the cost of living that’s all going to be a huge struggle.
Note, I’m not saying the resident parent doesn’t need the £300, I’m sure they do (& more!). But it’s a huge motivation to get more contact in order to drop that £300, and if they become resident parent, suddenly other benefits open up for them too.

A lot of this could be stopped if the cost of living was addressed and people weren’t left scraping by.

SpringMum30 · 09/04/2023 17:37

Thriwit · 09/04/2023 17:27

I think the issue of money isn’t talked about enough.

Child maintenance reductions for contact, or nil child maintenance for 50/50 care, mean it’s often in people’s best financial interests to have shared care, even if they don’t actually want to/can’t parent.
Legal aid is only available in cases of domestic abuse.
With divorce, the primary concern is housing the children, therefore whoever has primary residency of the children usually ends up with more than 50% of assets/a house (I know that’s a simplification, but it’s generally true).
The benefits system favours the resident parent - child benefit, UC, housing etc

None of this can be brought up in contact/residency disputes, but it’s naive to think finances don’t come into this for a good chunk of people.

Also child maintenance is used as a tool to maintain post separation abuse. My ex is self employed apparently owns his own company and yet 'pays a low salary and takes dividends' this means he pays zero child maintenance whilst living a lavish lifestyle, trips abroad, fancy meals etc. I actually raised it in court as I was confused about his employment status since he didn't have to pay maintenance at all. The courts do not care

OP posts:
Thriwit · 09/04/2023 17:35

Bepis · 09/04/2023 15:10

From my experience, I feel the system is mired in misandry. Men can do no right and they have to jump through hoops to see their child every other weekend. Whereas the mum is automatically granted residence.

An example - DH and his ex were said to both be manipulating their son and not able to put his needs first. They concluded that DSS was a victim of emotional harm and abuse from both parents (which I don't agree with).

The result of that was DH fighting to not have his contact supervised yet mum (who had done the same) would have been awarded more time unsupervised with their son.

Makes no sense. I feel the system is sexist but that's just based on my own experience. I have experienced the system as a mother and I was treated hugely differently to my DH.

My experience is that the mum is not automatically granted anything - the presumption is continuation of the status quo. I think it can look like the mum is often favoured, simply because in the majority of cases the dad moves out, so the mum is automatically the resident parent (especially if she already works part-time/has done the majority of care until that point).
In cases I know where the opposite has happened (usually women fleeing abuse or separating whilst under medical care), it seems like the dad is favoured and the woman often struggles to get contact, nevermind primary residency.
The courts just want to keep things as they are, unless there are incredibly compelling reasons not to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread