Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Family Court Scandal and Abuse

264 replies

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 19:37

Wasn't sure what to post this under:

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by authorities to leave their abusers or risk losing their children.

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by the family courts to coparent with their abusers or risk losing their children.

The family court system is not fit for purpose. Women are re traumatised during proceedings whereby they are forced to face their abuser, are further gaslit by Cafcass and magistrates and forced to push their children into unsafe contact arrangements.

The court want to handle cases as quickly as possible and women are criticised for raising allegations of abuse as this prolongs the court process.

The abuser uses the court to further their abuse through the children and is not held accountable for their harmful and abusive behaviour.

If you can relate to this then I am sorry. The trauma experienced can trigger ptsd, anxiety and depression to name a few. I don’t know how to change the system but in raising awareness and talking about it I hope it’s a move in the right direction for real change.

OP posts:
SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:26

AutisticLegoLover · 08/04/2023 21:13

Emotional abuse can be very subtle. If adults can't see that they are being abused until they have had extensive therapy then how are kids going to articulate abuse? Abusers make everything out to be normal to those they are abusing. Sounds like you need better training.

👏👏👏

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:25

"We've been back to Social Services as my sons behaviour has spiralled at school since unsupervised contact commenced. He was interviewed, made all the right noises and case was closed."

@WankBadger5000 this is so distressing to read. Your poor son. Poor you. What damage to this innocent child just because assumptions have been made and his cry for help ignored.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:23

*"Reasonable point.

"In all fairness though, it's not my role to interpret what the child says or why. That's the role of social care (and sometimes police). All a school does is offer opportunities to disclose and then report any disclosures to disclosure care to assess."*

And to make assumptions that most cases are false because children are often too traumatised to verbalise their experiences.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:20

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 08/04/2023 21:08

Also I am shocked by people claiming to be school staff who are demonstrating horrific bias on here

I hope posters remember that people can claim anything and have their own bias and it doesn't stop them from asking support from schools/DSP's for themselves of their children.

We had kids that would swear till the cows come home nothing ever happened, even we knew it happened because the dad admitted it.

I guess sometimes people see what they want to see (especially when it goes against research and statistics) and two of those (allegedly) work in schools.

Yes this is exactly it. It's terrible people can't see beyond the surface. I don't know if it will ever change because elderly, disabled and children have very few rights.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:14

SweetSakura · 08/04/2023 20:57

My understanding, from reading academic research, is that the level of false claims of abuse in the family courts is actually very low .

And I have to say I wouldn't stay in a relationship with a man whose ex accused him of abuse. Because I actually don't think the research backs up the assumptions on here that women are making it up.

Also I am shocked by people claiming to be school staff who are demonstrating horrific bias on here. I hope they are falsely claiming to be work in safeguarding, otherwise they are in the wrong job. It took months of skilled therapy for my son to find the courage to open up about what his dad had been doing. A few chats with someone who assumes all mums alleging abuse are using their children as "pawns" would never have got to the bottom of it

This is EXACTLY it. Absolutely hit the nail on the head.

My experience completely and the school view shared by Polik was an added burden to an already horrendous situation.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:09

DeeCeeCherry · 08/04/2023 20:44

Polik
I (school safeguarding) deal with more cases of parents trying to restrict their ex access to their children by falsely claiming abuse, than families facing actual ongoing risk of abuse

How do you know the claims are false? How can you know? You do know abuse isn't just physical, don't you?

Part of the issue is society's fawning over good looks, charm, a well modulated voice on tap, and a sob story. Both men and women are susceptible to the fallacy.

Years ago after abuse from an ex which resulted in a police matter, a policewoman actually asked me if I was SURE things were as bad as I said. She'd spoken to him - a handsome man who was charming when he wanted his own way - & she felt sorry for him! Ridiculous. I eventually discovered he'd hit his ex too.

People are stupid and gullible over good looking men - if they're ugly and well built its a different story. I feel sorry for any woman going through the family court process i have some friends who've been through it and it looks to me as if they're being punished for being abused...

Exactly this.

Or... they're smooth talking and do a very-important-job so couldn't possibly be they kind of a person.

The fact police officers, judges, nurses have been in the news for various horrendous crimes escapes them.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:07

"Which goes back to my point. The vast, vast majority of claims are not backed by the voice of the child or any other outward indications of abuse to the child. Which is likely where the assumption comes from."

@Polik you have to be very careful here. My DC didn't back up their abuse because of Stockholm syndrome. They blamed themselves and would do anything to protect the perpetrator, partly because nobody would protect them from him so they had to keep on side for their own sanity.

It's a real thing. In my experiences schools made terrible judgments and listens to his voice, but when it went against him in court they changed their views. But it's been a punishingly difficult journey and it disheartens me to hear people like you say these kind of things without looking beneath the surface.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 11/04/2023 10:04

@MMeliaLane where is the GC father in all this?

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 09:56

Bizzieizz · 08/04/2023 19:53

Agreed. I am in the middle of this nightmare now.
Refused a fact finding against Cafcass advice, childrens wishes ignored, abuse of me now an annoyance, abuse of the children now something I’ve “made them believe happened” ditto the witnessed abuse of me.
Forced to do what the court says to attempt to force one of the children into a relationship with him.
Made to prove my mental health whilst his abuse of us all is referred to as “alleged” and the court laps up any old shit about me he comes out with, no proof of that required.

It’s a joke.

"Made to prove my mental health whilst his abuse of us all is referred to as “alleged” and the court laps up any old shit about me he comes out with, no proof of that required."

Even if you have proof, it can be explained away as your fault for viewing it in such a way.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 09:55

worried4698643 · 08/04/2023 19:42

Agreed.

Abuse claims are not usually taken seriously. Even if they are it seems to be the view 'well he never hit the children, so it's fine'

I don't know what the answer is, but the family court system I absolutely broken.

In my case he hit the children and that was deemed fine too.

They report being scared of him but that was Mum's fault. Apparently her experience of DV affected the children even without her bad-mouthing their Dad.

Women can't win. But sometimes, it can happen though is not the norm anymore. Frightening for the children.

SunUp · 11/04/2023 09:41

Iwasafool · 11/04/2023 09:16

Women can be violent. My exDIL punched my son in the face as he had a toddler on his lap and new baby in his arms.

For anyone who doubted the truth she proved it years later when the toddler was a teenager and she punched him in the face as well.

I agree. I've seen it first hand on more than one occasion.
Yet, those mothers are made out to be saints and the father's the devil's incarnate.

Iwasafool · 11/04/2023 09:16

Thatbloomindog · 11/04/2023 08:46

@SweetSakura yep. Mothers of boys and all that. No one’s sons is ever a rapist or abuser or a rubbish dad. It’s all these evil women making stuff up about their darling sons who are victims of these awful women.
I get it. It’s the preferable narrative to sell yourself as the parent of a grown man accused of these things.

I saw a meme the other day and it said

‘instead of asking why a father doesn’t see his child, ask the mother why he had to fight so hard’

this was posted by a grandparent. And I thought ‘yeah let’s ask’ because they’ll be a damn good reason.

Women can be violent. My exDIL punched my son in the face as he had a toddler on his lap and new baby in his arms.

For anyone who doubted the truth she proved it years later when the toddler was a teenager and she punched him in the face as well.

Gondala · 11/04/2023 09:15

MeliaLane · 10/04/2023 22:04

No, not sinister at all.
She portrays as a really lovely woman. No mental health issues, more learnt poor behaviour. The counselling was relationship counselling for them both. The financial was due to a ‘I need it now’ attitude. We often made up their mortgage shortfall to keep a home for DGC ( whilst she bought private plates for her car).

It is difficult to maintain being someone different to who you rreally are though.

For instance, what does she tell others ( her own family, her new extended family) about why we don't see our DGC? Do they think we have abandoned DGC?
We are reasonable, decent people, in education and higher levels of public service ( DBS in place, trusted to work with children)
Surely, if we were part of our DGC’s life, through our normal behaviours, it would be apparent that we are fit to have contact with our DGC, that this LO is not at risk.
How does she truthfully justify the lack of contact to her family and friends?

Time will tell if she repeats her behaviours, including financial.

Sorry, to clarify has your son passed away?

Surely if not he should be arranging contact between you and DGC?

ElsieMc · 11/04/2023 08:49

Sad posts from both perspectives. I was alleging abuse against the father of one of my gc's which the Judge chose not to believe. I did not know when I made the allegation (he tried to attack me in front of gs) that he already had a substantial criminal record of violent offending. He went on to be convicted of gbh after the final hearing and was even convicted of drink driving home from court during ongoing proceedings!

Cafcass described it as "youthful indiscretion" but I contacted Police headquarters and asked the legal team to disclose to the court any offence that was of concern. I was self representing so could not apply. I was right. One of the attacks was on a child.

Their applications took up years of court time, even three day hearings. After a certain point, why do Judges not consider a 91 (14) order blocking applications for a certain length of time?

Another ludicruous application during which the Judge ordered what we asked for (reinstatement of supervised contact) - but the application was theirs, because they felt we would refuse contact! They were effectively taking themselves to court using the public pot of legal aid. They even had a barrister for a directions hearing.

Thatbloomindog · 11/04/2023 08:46

@SweetSakura yep. Mothers of boys and all that. No one’s sons is ever a rapist or abuser or a rubbish dad. It’s all these evil women making stuff up about their darling sons who are victims of these awful women.
I get it. It’s the preferable narrative to sell yourself as the parent of a grown man accused of these things.

I saw a meme the other day and it said

‘instead of asking why a father doesn’t see his child, ask the mother why he had to fight so hard’

this was posted by a grandparent. And I thought ‘yeah let’s ask’ because they’ll be a damn good reason.

SweetSakura · 11/04/2023 08:36

Forgive me for being very wary of grandparents claiming their sons ex was manipulative and that he is a picture of innocence... But every abused woman I speak to has an ex with parents who are sure their darling boy couldn't possibly be abusive behind closed doors.

My ex was a model dad and husband whenever his parents were there. Quite prepared to put my son and I in danger of our lives over and over again when they weren't there.

MeliaLane · 10/04/2023 22:04

TheVanguardSix · 10/04/2023 21:26

There is a fear on her part, that her past might catch up with her, we know too much as we supported, paying for counselling, bailing them out financially.

Hmm. It almost sounds like you’d use mental health and financial issues against her. But surely you wouldn’t do that. Or would you?

I understand you’re hurting. I get that. But there’s a slightly sinister tone to your sentence.

No, not sinister at all.
She portrays as a really lovely woman. No mental health issues, more learnt poor behaviour. The counselling was relationship counselling for them both. The financial was due to a ‘I need it now’ attitude. We often made up their mortgage shortfall to keep a home for DGC ( whilst she bought private plates for her car).

It is difficult to maintain being someone different to who you rreally are though.

For instance, what does she tell others ( her own family, her new extended family) about why we don't see our DGC? Do they think we have abandoned DGC?
We are reasonable, decent people, in education and higher levels of public service ( DBS in place, trusted to work with children)
Surely, if we were part of our DGC’s life, through our normal behaviours, it would be apparent that we are fit to have contact with our DGC, that this LO is not at risk.
How does she truthfully justify the lack of contact to her family and friends?

Time will tell if she repeats her behaviours, including financial.

Teder · 10/04/2023 21:51

SpringMum30 · 10/04/2023 19:41

True but we're talking about a majority here. This screams "all lives matter" to be honest with you

Couldn’t agree more OP.

TheVanguardSix · 10/04/2023 21:26

There is a fear on her part, that her past might catch up with her, we know too much as we supported, paying for counselling, bailing them out financially.

Hmm. It almost sounds like you’d use mental health and financial issues against her. But surely you wouldn’t do that. Or would you?

I understand you’re hurting. I get that. But there’s a slightly sinister tone to your sentence.

MeliaLane · 10/04/2023 21:19

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 19:42

@MeliaLane that sounds awful and not too dissimilar to our experience.

DH has created a box from court that he can pass on to the children should the need ever arise. It shows categorically the lengths he went to and the levels she stooped to. Who knows whether it'll ever be needed but it gives DH comfort to know he has plenty of evidence to disprove her lies.

Yes, we do similar. Take photos and clips of presents bought, copies of letters etc.
I very occasionally come across a SM photo and save this so that we still know what our DGC looks like. Sad eh?

Maybe when our 18 year old DGC gets in touch, in the distant future, we can share our efforts made to keep in touch or even why we felt that it would be better to be out of touch rather than ‘in and out’ at the whim of our ExDiL....or perhaps not - does this just screw up a young adult even more, when they realise their own DM has mislead them all along?

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 19:42

@MeliaLane that sounds awful and not too dissimilar to our experience.

DH has created a box from court that he can pass on to the children should the need ever arise. It shows categorically the lengths he went to and the levels she stooped to. Who knows whether it'll ever be needed but it gives DH comfort to know he has plenty of evidence to disprove her lies.

SpringMum30 · 10/04/2023 19:41

MeliaLane · 10/04/2023 19:38

I think back to the OP @SpringMum30 - it isn't just women who are traumatised, it is men too, it is dad, grandad, uncles too.

True but we're talking about a majority here. This screams "all lives matter" to be honest with you

OP posts:
MeliaLane · 10/04/2023 19:38

I think back to the OP @SpringMum30 - it isn't just women who are traumatised, it is men too, it is dad, grandad, uncles too.

MeliaLane · 10/04/2023 19:35

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 18:59

@MeliaLane I could have written that myself. It's an awful system. We lost count of the number of times she broke the order and absolutely nothing happens. She was just told "let's try not to do that again".

Awful for you.
Manipulative adults who, because of their own damaged background, convince themselves they are doing the best for their child. In our case, this is not the best for the child and this adult should know better.

We have not seen our DGC for four years. We played as full a part as we could prior, though always felt DiL didn't really want us around, even then. Full of charm ( both of them) hasty marriage, urgency to have a baby, controlling and emotionally abusive.

Losing our DGC, feels like the break up of any relationship, gut wrenching. Sadness, upset, grief, we miss our DGC immensely. We have had to learn to move on and live without, but this is my DH’s blood relative ( and always will be). It is awful to have someone take this away.

I can only imagine how our DGC feels about our unexplained disappearance. Working with children, I see the damage caused, the alienation, the lack of trust, the abandonment.

We did have some very limited contact planned but we were told by EXDiL, prior, what we could and couldn't talk about. This included no mention of DGC’s father.
There is a fear on her part, that her past might catch up with her, we know too much as we supported, paying for counselling, bailing them out financially. We are a relic from the past and there is no way ExDiL will want any of that to be part of her new life. Her charm needs to be maintained.

This contact was to be a ‘one-off’. DiL would not commit to any follow up. It seems very cruel for our DGC to meet us once in four years and it to appear we have walked away again. I'm not sure I can put this LO through this. Perhaps no relationship is the best, we are trying to work that out.

We send presents and cards ( to a false address provided) . We never get a response, not even a thank you. We are not sent anything on behalf of our DGC - ( no Christmas card, no annual school photo). Nothing.

Feels this part of our family has died.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 10/04/2023 18:59

@MeliaLane I could have written that myself. It's an awful system. We lost count of the number of times she broke the order and absolutely nothing happens. She was just told "let's try not to do that again".

Swipe left for the next trending thread