Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Family Court Scandal and Abuse

264 replies

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 19:37

Wasn't sure what to post this under:

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by authorities to leave their abusers or risk losing their children.

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by the family courts to coparent with their abusers or risk losing their children.

The family court system is not fit for purpose. Women are re traumatised during proceedings whereby they are forced to face their abuser, are further gaslit by Cafcass and magistrates and forced to push their children into unsafe contact arrangements.

The court want to handle cases as quickly as possible and women are criticised for raising allegations of abuse as this prolongs the court process.

The abuser uses the court to further their abuse through the children and is not held accountable for their harmful and abusive behaviour.

If you can relate to this then I am sorry. The trauma experienced can trigger ptsd, anxiety and depression to name a few. I don’t know how to change the system but in raising awareness and talking about it I hope it’s a move in the right direction for real change.

OP posts:
TitaniumTess · 12/04/2023 05:56

What a sad thread. I feel.for everyone. 💐💐💐

CAFCASS did a shocking job with a report recently - factual mistakes everywhere and overall, a light touch. They ignored so much evidence that I showed them.

I replied straightaway to the CAFCASS advisor who didn't amend the report, so I logged a formal complaint. That acknowledged that she had made lots of mistakes around the years of events and other facts but it largely lifted up a carpet, swept the issues underneath it and said 'sort it out in court.' It also said if I wasn't happy to go to a local MP or Obdsuman (spelling?)

Has anyone got any advice about complaining to these people? Thanks

KTSl1964 · 11/04/2023 20:21

Absolutely harrowing isn’t it? Social services who are meant to protect and safeguard children forcing parents to send the child back to the abuser - something is very very wrong with the system. Someone up thread mentioned class action? Also I wonder if a child could sue social services for not protecting them as a child? The damage these abusers cause children is life long. This would make them think.

SweetSakura · 11/04/2023 20:04

That's really interesting @cato40 I would genuinely love to hear more about how they do it better.

cato40 · 11/04/2023 19:52

Coming from an EU country and going through divorce in England I had the opportunity to compare legal systems and can say English law is 50 years behind in regards to women welfare and children rights. Stories you read on papers and threads like this really show how backward it is and many people don't realise. DV happens everywhere in the world but here it hardly makes the news, no wonder other EU countries get the bad rep just for exposing it. And the poor children forced to live through the 50/50 arrangements like nomads to please their parents? If that is their best interest!!

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 17:53

I believe that once they're into their teens they have a huge say. You just have to be careful not to give the impression you've swayed his thinking - they're so quick to accuse of parental alienation for so much as sneezing in the wrong direction.

Lightpatterns · 11/04/2023 17:33

I'm so sorry and horrified to hear of people's experiences and my heart goes out to you and your children for your trauma and suffering. It's heartbreaking how children's needs are ignored and how the courts sanction and perpetuate abuse.
At what age do the kids need to be for courts to stop forcing them to have damaging contact with abusive parents again their wishes? I'm about to taken to court by my abusive (but utterly charming) ex over contact with DS aged 14. Having read this thread and others, I'm now scared. Do kids gets to escape the court sanctioned abuse once they become teens?

MeliaLane · 11/04/2023 16:09

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 11/04/2023 12:56

Sorry, I'm a little confused - you said they were your GC and from your posts it suggests the mother isn't your child? Are you a step GP? Where is the father in this scenario?

MeliaLane · 09/04/2023 15:59
I said ‘step son’. I am not his mum.

As far as DGC’s, these LO’s do not make the distinction between DGP and a step DGP.

I met my step son whilst he was an adult. I can be much more objective about him and his relationship.

PP’s asked about him. He has been denied access to his DC. As written about above, his EXW, lots of delaying, lots of last minute new claims, lots of new reporting needed, at one point she was told by the court that she was in danger of having residency awarded fully to DGC’s dad if she didn't sort herself out.

However, due to the delays, eventually it was found that the status quo should remain, that DGC had spent nearly three years without access to DF and it was too disruptive for this to be changed.
DGC has lost his DF and all associated family.

Iwasafool · 11/04/2023 16:07

@JustDudeIt I am so sorry for your poor brother and his kids.

I think what we need is children's rights to be prioritised over parents rights.

IneptDestructive · 11/04/2023 15:24

JustDudeIt · 11/04/2023 13:15

This thread is such a hard read. So many harrowing stories.

I don’t want to be the NAMALT apologist, but my brother really wasn’t an abuser, yet virtually lost access to his children. His ex-wife converted to a fundamentalist religion and the marriage broke down as a result. She then told him he would never see his children again and accused him of a catalogue of different sorts of abuse - filing police reports, calling social care, even getting a place in a womens refuge despite my brother packing up his stuff to move out and leave their apartment for her and the children

She would literally make an allegation, there would be no evidence / social care and police NFA / kids didn’t corroborate stories etc. So she would then suddenly pull up a new (formerly not mentioned) type of abuse. And on and on it went. No professionals ever challenged her madness. Meanwhile DB had phone contact only with two of his children, and a few hours a week supervised contact with one child, for almost 3 years.

At the point he was in an hospice with terminal cancer, the children’s school reported his ex to social care for suspected fabricating childhood illness (Munchausen’s in old money). The children were put on a CP plan and suddenly all the professionals were concerned that she had been abusing the children, was mentally ill, the children were traumatised etc. no shit Sherlock. But too late for the children to say goodbye to their father, who had fought tooth and nail to see them (was on the phone to his solicitor three days before he died l from his hospice bed).

I think the issue with the courts and CAFCASS seems to be that they don’t deal with manipulative, abusive people well. More of those people are men, so women are disproportionately affected. Psycho abusers, rapists, violent men are given the benefit of the doubt around vulnerable children, and that shouldn’t happen.

However, there are dangerous women out there - in smaller numbers, I’m sure - and the children ultimately suffer in ALL of these scenarios.

I will never forget the CAFCASS social worker calling my brother in hospital two days before he died apologising for the previous CAFCASS’s shoddy reporting to the courts and essentially saying sue believed him now.

Too late. Thanks for noticing.

This is exactly what we're dealing with (aside from the terminal cancer thankfully, my condolences).

She has a diagnosed personality disorder, there have been repeated concerns of prolonged periods of emotional abuse, neglect, FII, but keep hitting a constant wall of "she's mum" claims from her off abuse towards my husband that have repeatedly been found to fabricated (not just lack of evidence) and we are completely unable to provide any of our evidence (of the concerns from professionals, medical issues, school issues, evidence of her personality disorder) as funnily enough, her and her solicitor won't agree to it because it looks bad for them and the court won't order anything they disagree on!

Can you imagine if criminal cases worked that way? No mr prosecutor, you can't provide dna evidence because the accused think it will make them look guilty...

It's an absolute sham.

SpringMum30 · 11/04/2023 13:23

Igmum · 11/04/2023 13:15

Thank you for this thread OP. Absolutely agree. We spent over 7 years going through the Courts. We had what I thought was a spectacular amount of evidence of abuse including witnesses to attacks, witnesses to bruises and (large) bite marks, repeated statements from child, Police reports etc etc. X admitted to drug and alcohol dependency in Court. The Courts didn't care. They really didn't care. They moved mountains to discount the (witness) evidence of independent sources, choosing instead to rely on ex's mum who was caught lying on the stand. I am beyond appalled. DD is now 16. Has refused to see her dad for years but still bears the scars of the many physical and mental assaults she has endured. We need child safeguarding to be prioritised over fathers' rights.

I'm sorry for you and your DD's experiences 😔 you summed it up in a nutshell: 'We need child safeguarding to be prioritised over fathers' rights.' 👏🏽

OP posts:
JustDudeIt · 11/04/2023 13:16

That should have read Thanks for NOTHING

Igmum · 11/04/2023 13:15

Thank you for this thread OP. Absolutely agree. We spent over 7 years going through the Courts. We had what I thought was a spectacular amount of evidence of abuse including witnesses to attacks, witnesses to bruises and (large) bite marks, repeated statements from child, Police reports etc etc. X admitted to drug and alcohol dependency in Court. The Courts didn't care. They really didn't care. They moved mountains to discount the (witness) evidence of independent sources, choosing instead to rely on ex's mum who was caught lying on the stand. I am beyond appalled. DD is now 16. Has refused to see her dad for years but still bears the scars of the many physical and mental assaults she has endured. We need child safeguarding to be prioritised over fathers' rights.

JustDudeIt · 11/04/2023 13:15

This thread is such a hard read. So many harrowing stories.

I don’t want to be the NAMALT apologist, but my brother really wasn’t an abuser, yet virtually lost access to his children. His ex-wife converted to a fundamentalist religion and the marriage broke down as a result. She then told him he would never see his children again and accused him of a catalogue of different sorts of abuse - filing police reports, calling social care, even getting a place in a womens refuge despite my brother packing up his stuff to move out and leave their apartment for her and the children

She would literally make an allegation, there would be no evidence / social care and police NFA / kids didn’t corroborate stories etc. So she would then suddenly pull up a new (formerly not mentioned) type of abuse. And on and on it went. No professionals ever challenged her madness. Meanwhile DB had phone contact only with two of his children, and a few hours a week supervised contact with one child, for almost 3 years.

At the point he was in an hospice with terminal cancer, the children’s school reported his ex to social care for suspected fabricating childhood illness (Munchausen’s in old money). The children were put on a CP plan and suddenly all the professionals were concerned that she had been abusing the children, was mentally ill, the children were traumatised etc. no shit Sherlock. But too late for the children to say goodbye to their father, who had fought tooth and nail to see them (was on the phone to his solicitor three days before he died l from his hospice bed).

I think the issue with the courts and CAFCASS seems to be that they don’t deal with manipulative, abusive people well. More of those people are men, so women are disproportionately affected. Psycho abusers, rapists, violent men are given the benefit of the doubt around vulnerable children, and that shouldn’t happen.

However, there are dangerous women out there - in smaller numbers, I’m sure - and the children ultimately suffer in ALL of these scenarios.

I will never forget the CAFCASS social worker calling my brother in hospital two days before he died apologising for the previous CAFCASS’s shoddy reporting to the courts and essentially saying sue believed him now.

Too late. Thanks for noticing.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 11/04/2023 12:56

MeliaLane · 11/04/2023 12:51

Except I am not the mother of this boy.

Sorry, I'm a little confused - you said they were your GC and from your posts it suggests the mother isn't your child? Are you a step GP? Where is the father in this scenario?

MeliaLane · 11/04/2023 12:51

Thatbloomindog · 11/04/2023 08:46

@SweetSakura yep. Mothers of boys and all that. No one’s sons is ever a rapist or abuser or a rubbish dad. It’s all these evil women making stuff up about their darling sons who are victims of these awful women.
I get it. It’s the preferable narrative to sell yourself as the parent of a grown man accused of these things.

I saw a meme the other day and it said

‘instead of asking why a father doesn’t see his child, ask the mother why he had to fight so hard’

this was posted by a grandparent. And I thought ‘yeah let’s ask’ because they’ll be a damn good reason.

Except I am not the mother of this boy.

TheVanguardSix · 11/04/2023 11:00

Ah the angry mother! Yep. We’re not allowed to be angry and emotional, AKA ‘unhinged’. You show anger to the police running your case, they’ll punish you and crucially, the victim by doing the bare minimum for your case. The abuser stays calm and cool, even when facing jail. It’s the mother who is learning, on the go mind, how terrifyingly bad the other parent is. The mother is in shock (or father, if the mother is the abuser). And at a time where anger is the best thing to lean into, we’re advised by police, lawyers, judges, DSLs, all of the adults in safeguarding, to suppress it. Behave.

My ex claims that it is in fact my anger that has encouraged our daughter to hate him. My anger has destroyed their bond, according to him. Oh it’s got nothing to do with him violating her body for 5 fucking years.

Reugny · 11/04/2023 10:56

SunUp · 11/04/2023 09:41

I agree. I've seen it first hand on more than one occasion.
Yet, those mothers are made out to be saints and the father's the devil's incarnate.

Of the cases I know that have gone to family court an equal number of men and women have made allegations against each other.

In most cases the allegations have no other evidence e.g. he said/she said. Some of the allegations made were laughable as if the person was doing as they claimed they would have caused a disturbance and it would have been acted on at the time. With others then the claimed evidence would have been easy to prove.

SpringMum30 · 11/04/2023 10:55

TheVanguardSix · 11/04/2023 10:36

I just want to add, regarding our children opening up (as if the person with the lanyard and a few letters after their name holds the Almighty Key To Healing- pardon me while I stick an LMFAO here), it took my daughter months, months, not days, not weeks, months to open her mouth and speak with the therapist she’d been seeing on a weekly basis. She was mute.
Silence says and reveals so much. Maybe these experts need to listen to the silence. Often there is more power and truth in the unspoken word.

Well said 👏🏽 the expectation that a child will pour their entire heart out to a stranger because it's a 'safe and neutral environment' is absolutely ridiculous

OP posts:
SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:46

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 09/04/2023 11:05

If it's all about the children and their "rights" then how come only children get forced to see parents, but a parent can't be forced into any form of contact? Or at least paying for those children.

Because they decide the father's right to contact trumps the outside chance a child's reluctance could be heavily influenced by an angry mother.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:38

AutisticLegoLover · 09/04/2023 00:02

My dc just used to say what's the point of talking to someone else, they never do anything to help

Oh my life. My DC repeatedly say this EXACT same thing.

They tell me they have no faith in the police, social services or justice system because when they did speak up nothing happened. So now Dad knows what they've said which places them in far greater danger.

They've learned to stay quiet to protect Dad which will serve to better protect themselves.

TheVanguardSix · 11/04/2023 10:36

I just want to add, regarding our children opening up (as if the person with the lanyard and a few letters after their name holds the Almighty Key To Healing- pardon me while I stick an LMFAO here), it took my daughter months, months, not days, not weeks, months to open her mouth and speak with the therapist she’d been seeing on a weekly basis. She was mute.
Silence says and reveals so much. Maybe these experts need to listen to the silence. Often there is more power and truth in the unspoken word.

TheVanguardSix · 11/04/2023 10:29

I think the real issue is not men vs women/fathers vs mothers, but more importantly, how manipulative, abusive, coercive people, regardless of sex, are so skilled at deceiving. The idea that this person/parent is violent/dangerous/abusive is unbelievable to so many. Street angels/house devils fool all the people all the time.

But above all, judges, CAFCASS, lawyers, DSLs, teachers, police, SS don’t care about people’s trauma and mental health. The system perpetuates trauma simply because those running it are automatons. Cogs in the great wheel to nowhere. They’re, as my dad used to say, glorified pencil pushers: Pencil pushers with the frightening capacity to further destroy a traumatised family. They just don’t even bother to care about the families they’re dealing with.
It’s a godawful system.

There’s a laziness and complacency underpinning the safeguarding of children in this country. My ex is in prison for sexually abusing our child and viewing underage porn. Yet! The police did not check the PCs in his work place (he was a family GP and NHS DSL and the GP who carried out all of the newborn checks), did not inform families working with him that they had a right to know about his charges, never removed our home PC that he predominantly, exclusively actually, used in the home office (in fact the lead detective on my daughter’s case asked me several times if I could give my ex the home PC because he was bored at his flat where he was living while out on bail for 8 fucking months). My ex’s lawyers continue writing to me, asking for the home PC (apparently my ex would like to store it while he’s in prison). I mean, there’s total laziness and no fucks given in action! Safeguarding? What safeguarding? Red flags everywhere.
My eldest son and I will one day have the PC looked at. I can’t face it right now.

So… the fact that my daughter got a sliver of justice served cold from such a lazy police force and complacent judicial system is miraculous. Even the police could not be bothered. The police are misogynistic AF. There’s no love lost there. On the day my ex was sentenced, I sat in the courtroom in utter silence. The detective turned to me and said, “Well done for your behaviour. Well done for keeping it cool and not showing anger.”

What a good girl am I. There’s so much to unpack in what he said.

SpringMum30 · 11/04/2023 10:27

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:23

*"Reasonable point.

"In all fairness though, it's not my role to interpret what the child says or why. That's the role of social care (and sometimes police). All a school does is offer opportunities to disclose and then report any disclosures to disclosure care to assess."*

And to make assumptions that most cases are false because children are often too traumatised to verbalise their experiences.

Yep that's what the Cafcass officer did too. My eldest was adamant she would not be speaking to them again but obviously has no choice and just out on a brave face. She therefore implied that I was lying and this definitely unfairly impacted her report and recommendations.

OP posts:
SpringHasSprungAtLast · 11/04/2023 10:27

Bepis · 08/04/2023 21:17

@Sugarplumfairy65 So they both lied to the court and nothing happened to them? Goodness me!

DHs ex lied to the court on a statement which we could prove but the judge wasn't interested. Essentially giving a green light to lie in court.

My ex lied in court and that was ignored. As were his multiple breaches. It beggars belief.

JustDudeIt · 11/04/2023 10:26

I saw my brother and his wife and their children going through the family courts and it was an huge, shocking eye opener. I had no idea things were so awful, Especially CAFCASS. The whole thing dragged on for so long and was utterly traumatic for everyone involved, especially the children.

I’ve held off posting about it, as I’m a staunch feminist and I know that many women and children suffer at the hands of the courts. I don’t ever want to come across as an apologist for abusive men. But my experience was that the courts were just as horrific towards my DB as women have described here.

An extremely unstable, unwell person (ex-SIL) was able to fabricate a narrative of ‘emotional abuse’ that CAFCASS bought into and my DBro’s contact with his children was severely limited.

It all came out in the wash, after 3 hellish years, and the children were placed on a CP plan for emotional abuse by their mother. Unfortunately, my brother had a terminal cancer diagnosis by then and died without contact with his children.

I still haven’t processed the damage done. It was one of the worst things I have ever witnessed. Failures and dreadful practice at every turn.