Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Family Court Scandal and Abuse

264 replies

SpringMum30 · 08/04/2023 19:37

Wasn't sure what to post this under:

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by authorities to leave their abusers or risk losing their children.

Women who are victims of domestic abuse are made by the family courts to coparent with their abusers or risk losing their children.

The family court system is not fit for purpose. Women are re traumatised during proceedings whereby they are forced to face their abuser, are further gaslit by Cafcass and magistrates and forced to push their children into unsafe contact arrangements.

The court want to handle cases as quickly as possible and women are criticised for raising allegations of abuse as this prolongs the court process.

The abuser uses the court to further their abuse through the children and is not held accountable for their harmful and abusive behaviour.

If you can relate to this then I am sorry. The trauma experienced can trigger ptsd, anxiety and depression to name a few. I don’t know how to change the system but in raising awareness and talking about it I hope it’s a move in the right direction for real change.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
coodawoodashooda · 29/11/2023 19:29

You are right op.

cato40 · 04/09/2023 23:11

That BBC documentary makes for some sad watching. Isn't there a charity or international organisation like Unicef that could intervene to protect children and vulnerable people?

SweetSakura · 04/09/2023 22:52

You're right @MyHomeIsMyHome , it's a horribly lonely place to be.

MyHomeIsMyHome · 04/09/2023 19:55

What an absolutely brilliant idea to do therapy to take the place of water parent should be able to say, but cannot because of her into alienation accusations. I wish I thought of that! I think we need a website to help innocent residential parents who are in awful situation is being falsely accused of parental alienation to be able to help the children without adding to the force accusation that could be levied against them.

SweetSakura · 04/09/2023 19:33

MyHomeIsMyHome · 04/09/2023 19:16

We really need it to. The way it has been used is nothing short of criminal and made me lose faith in the justice system.

Same. As a lawyer as well as a parent in the system I have been shocked to the core by its failings.

I remember my blood ran cold when my son made a shocking disclosure to me, first because of the shock that his dad was even worse than I imagined but second because I knew that when I did what I had to do and brought it to the courts attention I ran the risk of losing my son if the parental alienation line succeeded. I also hated that I felt tongue tied and unable to properly support him in his shock at his dad's actions because I was so afraid of those accusations

What I would say, the thing I did that at least helped was sort decent therapy for him. Initially because I felt helpless to support him because I knew I needed to tread such a careful path and not be seen as alienating, but it also meant there was a neutral expert involved.

MyHomeIsMyHome · 04/09/2023 19:16

We really need it to. The way it has been used is nothing short of criminal and made me lose faith in the justice system.

SpringMum30 · 04/09/2023 18:11

Yes someone posted about it this morning! Really hard watch it's been on mind a lot of the day,?very triggering. I'm glad about the exposure! They even mentioned Cafcass having to change some of their approach to parental alienation too. I hope it's going somewhere in the right direction!

OP posts:
MyHomeIsMyHome · 04/09/2023 16:19

Just seen this OP...

Family courts: Mothers dying after 'abusers' claim access to children www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-66531409

frazzledasarock · 04/09/2023 12:20

ElsieMc · 12/04/2023 08:01

I have experience of Cafcass complaints. After final hearing, I received a registered letter stating that my case was one of 6 to be reinvestigated for issues I had raised. I was assigned a senior worker. I thought the guardian may receive some kind of disciplinary until I received an email which was not intended for me.

My email began with the same initials as one of the most senior cafcass workers at the time and was sent in error. It made interesting reading. They discussed how they would refer to criticism of me by the first Judge but not a more supportive second judge who amended the order. They felt the second Judge had no right to overturn an order made by a more senior Circuit Judge indicating the opposite of what Cafcass had told me. They also discussed their fear of how far I would take matters. They simply cannot be trusted.

As for the age when a child can made their own decision, during his last two years of contact my gs simply hated going. I did not want to end up back in family court, so persuaded him to suck it up for the remaining amount of time rather than causing stress during his gcses. Tbh, he never spent the full weekend there anymore as there was conflict between them.

BUT when he got to 16 that was that as far as gs was concerned. He refused to go or see them ever again. That was four years ago. He tells me that he felt his childhood was blighted by miserable enforced contact. He said it was like he was forced to spend a weekend with randoms. Those are the words of a child who has been through the system.

This was my experience as well.

I had to persuade my dc to put up with contact. My eldest wanted to speak to the judge herself. My solicitor advised that would be catastrophic as it would be taken as me coaching her.

ex was horrifically abusive, I knocked on every door I could think of. CAHMS wouldn’t offer any help as my dc weren’t considered damaged enough, CAF wouldn’t get involved as the reason for the mental health issues my dc were experiencing was present ie contact with their father.

SS wouldn’t step in as it was a court matter.

CAFCASS I had three officers the first was beyond shit, and kept yawning and falling asleep during interview with me! Second one wanted an easy ride told me as there was no current Physical abuse and the mental abuse was my word against his there was no problem. I ended up telling him I would spend the rest of my life bringing him down when ex killed fatally injured my children as a result of his recommendations to court. And only then did he refer us for a finding of facts and ex to a dvp course.

it was truly horrific for my children and I and we played the waiting game till they were old enough to be included in the recommendations.

id frankly take my dc and leave the country if I had an abusive ex who posed a really danger to my dc. As the courts will not protect the dc.

SpringMum30 · 04/09/2023 11:36

Whiskeypowers · 04/09/2023 10:57

If anyone has read an can summarise key points I would be most grateful!

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 04/09/2023 11:01

Thanks for sharing @Whiskeypowers

SpringMum30 · 04/09/2023 08:05

@AutisticLegoLover wow I would like to check this out although I imagine it would be triggering for me too. On a positive note, to have the issue exposed is a great move in the right direction!

OP posts:
AutisticLegoLover · 04/09/2023 08:03

There was something on the BBC news website this morning about this. It was hard reading and rather triggering to read over s morning cup of tea so I'll read again later. It really brought back the horror of court. It was saying how abusive men use parental alienation as a tactic against DV accusations.

SpringMum30 · 14/08/2023 21:04

So sorry you've had such a horrible
experience. I still find it hard to comprehend how the Family Courts come to such harmful and irresponsible conclusions.

I just wanted to share some things that have worked for me. Firstly I've started counselling with a charity for women who have been victims of DV. It's been very validating as the counsellors are well trained and informed.

We can't control their behaviour unfortunately but we can control how we treat ourselves. Journaling, self care, mindfulness, cultivating good friendships etc have all been really beneficial for me.

Regarding communication there are lots of videos on YouTube about 'coparenting with a Narcissist'. Just a few highlights, taking time to respond to messages so they are not reactive, being to the point and not over explaining yourself, having a neutral tone and not being drawn in to arguments.

My ex is still always up to no good behind the scenes but learning to communicate this way means our conversations are no longer confrontational and there is a lot less stress as a result.

Focus on you and the new life you can have away from him. I hope some of this helps and wish you well. 🙏🏽

OP posts:
cracklingfireinthewind · 14/08/2023 13:49

Hello @SpringMum30

thank you for making this post. I hope your family are doing much better now. I've been reading through all the replies.

My husband moved in with me and my baby when she was 1.5. I had just escaped an attempt on my life by my daughter's father.
He later told me how he would look at pictures of us on social media (we knew one another and were facebook friends) and that he wanted to have me and my daughter instead of my ex, who he could tell was a wrongun (not much argument there)

So he actively pursued us both but I only found that out later. My daughter and I got socially housed, and were settling in when he came over to my house for a gatherind and we kissed.

We began seeing one another, my baby was there, and he was so so overly amazing with her, and I thought it was a good thing.

He spend hundreds and hundreds of pounds on my daughter from day one. I could never dream of spending that much, and it's also not really my way to shower children with material gifts.

His parents actually brought all his things to my home and I felt pressured to let him live there. Then he and his parents told me I should sign a will giving them care of my baby in case something happened to me, and they all said I should call them grandparents and him dad. I was uncomfortable, but his parents' investment also made me feel silly for thinking it was too much.

It wasn't long before my own parents took offense at his parents putting their 'grandchild' all over social media. My ex began giving my child to his parents and spending the day forcing me to perform sex acts and making me feel really stupid for not wanting to do certain things.

Cut a long story short I eventually chucked him out when he suddenly converted to Islam and began saying he would be taking my daughter to Dubai with him where she would live in luxury, instead of in poverty with me, and told me Allah did not recognise our marriage anymore and we were no longer married, this made me incredibly fearful for my life as he seemed to detest me anyway, and the only thing keeping me safe was his promise of how much he loved me, now he was saying that wasn't even the case anymore. It was so bizarre, I locked the doors. His parents took him in and stonewalled me as to his weird behaviour.

I went to police who shared all my concerns but told me 'you got out just in time' and assured me all was well as he was gone and I had done the right thing. I disclosed the things my daugther began to tell me about what he had done, hurt her, laid down on her and refused to get off, she said she cried, she even said he held our cat under water. Nothing could be done as there were definitive timings or dates available. but again they shared my concern.

A family court judge overturned all these concerns and have basically told me I should look to sit down with my ex and become friends again.

they've ordered my daughter to go with him every weekend on Sundays unsupervised.

Now she has an overnight too. And I've been told he will get equal access as is his right, and that he must be devastated not seeing my daughter like he used to, even though he was increasingly isolated in our bedroom masturbating to porn all day long by the time I eventually chucked him out. The conversion to Islam was even more scary as he began burning himself with a lighter and saying he had been sinful and wished to wash away his sins. He began saying homophobic things and more things about women's place in the home.

This is an extremely shortened version of what is going on.

The court is right about one thing though; that he is the only father my child has known, and to have him removed from her life may have not been the best thing long term. This is the very reason I never left him before. It's not like I don't realise this.

Despite what she told me, she enjoys the contact with him at his parents', she's young, and they buy her new things every second of every day, it used to suffocate me.

Unfortunately each time I have to interact with him I have a panic attack, so I'm looking into ways to cope with this, but I feel like it's taking a huge toll on my body physically, and mentally the only thing I can think to do is use medications.

cracklingfireinthewind · 14/08/2023 13:36

IlIlI · 09/04/2023 13:40

I've never understood in these situations, it looks to be that if she stays with her abuser then the children can possibly be removed for "failure to protect" but if she decides to leave her abuser, then suddenly the children no longer need protection and must go to his home alone.
I don't know what the best solution would be, but when I see these things I do understand why so many stay with abusers, in their minds it's probably better for her to be around when it happens instead of them being alone with him when it happens.
I know some will be doing things like making excuses for the children to divert his rage away from them and onto herself, trying to keep the children quiet so he doesn't get angry, tiptoeing round him so he isn't wound up etc and they see that as protecting them rather than leaving him and sending them off to be alone with him every weekend.

And yes, false allegations happen. That's the same excuse they give for abysmal stats on rape convictions too though. And that's before we get to the sentencing, so it's really not a shock that we see similar in family court cases.

The message there is worse than you think. It's basically that once the relationship is finished the father will cease his behaviour, which was a symptom of (in my case) a troubled marriage.

They're saying it's us making the men abusive and once they're away from us that will stop.

SpringMum30 · 14/08/2023 12:57

I'm still here x

OP posts:
cracklingfireinthewind · 14/08/2023 12:18

Hello. Is anyone still responding on here? I have a story but don't want to out myself here unless it's going to be read by people who have engaged in the thread.

Whiskeypowers · 12/04/2023 10:58

I quote from their defensive 2020 press release on the fact they were not in fact consulted on the MoJ report “Harm in the Family Courts”

“ CAFCASS was not invited to be a member of the Panel and we do not agree that the criticisms in the report reflect our current practice. But our task now is to learn from this feedback and to work collaboratively with families and specialist organisations to provide support that is considered more effective and which clearly promotes the safety and welfare of children at all times.”

https://www.cafcass.gov.uk/2020/06/25/cafcass-responds-to-the-publication-of-the-report-from-the-ministry-of-justice-expert-panel-on-harm-in-the-family-courts/

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2020/jul/28/twisted-priorities-mean-cafcass-has-failed-to-protect-children-from-abusive-parents

Cafcass responds to the publication of the Report from the Ministry of Justice Expert Panel on Harm in the Family Courts - Cafcass - Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service

The publication of the report from the Ministry of Justice Expert Panel on Harm in the Family Courts makes a significant contribution to the necessary […]

https://www.cafcass.gov.uk/2020/06/25/cafcass-responds-to-the-publication-of-the-report-from-the-ministry-of-justice-expert-panel-on-harm-in-the-family-courts/

Whiskeypowers · 12/04/2023 10:50

There is a very good reason CAFCASS - as I am sure was the case based on historical reasons - was not one of the official stakeholders consulted in the first tranche of the new DA Bill legislation.

they are an absolute fiasco form start to finish.
still they’ve published another of their redundant toolkits as you do.
https://www.cafcass.gov.uk/2021/06/17/cafcass-publishes-new-domestic-abuse-learning-and-improvement-plan/

Cafcass publishes new Domestic Abuse Learning and Improvement Plan - Cafcass - Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service

Cafcass’ Domestic Abuse Learning and Improvement Plan has been developed in response to the serious findings of the Ministry of Justice’s Expert Panel on Harm […]

https://www.cafcass.gov.uk/2021/06/17/cafcass-publishes-new-domestic-abuse-learning-and-improvement-plan/

SpringMum30 · 12/04/2023 08:08

ElsieMc · 12/04/2023 08:01

I have experience of Cafcass complaints. After final hearing, I received a registered letter stating that my case was one of 6 to be reinvestigated for issues I had raised. I was assigned a senior worker. I thought the guardian may receive some kind of disciplinary until I received an email which was not intended for me.

My email began with the same initials as one of the most senior cafcass workers at the time and was sent in error. It made interesting reading. They discussed how they would refer to criticism of me by the first Judge but not a more supportive second judge who amended the order. They felt the second Judge had no right to overturn an order made by a more senior Circuit Judge indicating the opposite of what Cafcass had told me. They also discussed their fear of how far I would take matters. They simply cannot be trusted.

As for the age when a child can made their own decision, during his last two years of contact my gs simply hated going. I did not want to end up back in family court, so persuaded him to suck it up for the remaining amount of time rather than causing stress during his gcses. Tbh, he never spent the full weekend there anymore as there was conflict between them.

BUT when he got to 16 that was that as far as gs was concerned. He refused to go or see them ever again. That was four years ago. He tells me that he felt his childhood was blighted by miserable enforced contact. He said it was like he was forced to spend a weekend with randoms. Those are the words of a child who has been through the system.

I'm actually not surprised with your findings because there has been story after story of Cafcass failings and this makes complete sense. That just motivates me to make sure I take it as far as it will go. They have to be held accountable. I'm sorry for your gs it's children like him that we are fighting for x

OP posts:
ElsieMc · 12/04/2023 08:01

I have experience of Cafcass complaints. After final hearing, I received a registered letter stating that my case was one of 6 to be reinvestigated for issues I had raised. I was assigned a senior worker. I thought the guardian may receive some kind of disciplinary until I received an email which was not intended for me.

My email began with the same initials as one of the most senior cafcass workers at the time and was sent in error. It made interesting reading. They discussed how they would refer to criticism of me by the first Judge but not a more supportive second judge who amended the order. They felt the second Judge had no right to overturn an order made by a more senior Circuit Judge indicating the opposite of what Cafcass had told me. They also discussed their fear of how far I would take matters. They simply cannot be trusted.

As for the age when a child can made their own decision, during his last two years of contact my gs simply hated going. I did not want to end up back in family court, so persuaded him to suck it up for the remaining amount of time rather than causing stress during his gcses. Tbh, he never spent the full weekend there anymore as there was conflict between them.

BUT when he got to 16 that was that as far as gs was concerned. He refused to go or see them ever again. That was four years ago. He tells me that he felt his childhood was blighted by miserable enforced contact. He said it was like he was forced to spend a weekend with randoms. Those are the words of a child who has been through the system.

Tandora · 12/04/2023 07:56

Polik · 08/04/2023 20:16

I (school safeguarding) deal with more cases of parents trying to restrict their ex access to their children by falsely claiming abuse, than families facing actual ongoing risk of abuse.

When I say more, it's trebel, quadruple type amounts. Not just a few more.

Herein is the problem.

And how exactly do you know that?

SpringMum30 · 12/04/2023 07:46

TitaniumTess · 12/04/2023 05:56

What a sad thread. I feel.for everyone. 💐💐💐

CAFCASS did a shocking job with a report recently - factual mistakes everywhere and overall, a light touch. They ignored so much evidence that I showed them.

I replied straightaway to the CAFCASS advisor who didn't amend the report, so I logged a formal complaint. That acknowledged that she had made lots of mistakes around the years of events and other facts but it largely lifted up a carpet, swept the issues underneath it and said 'sort it out in court.' It also said if I wasn't happy to go to a local MP or Obdsuman (spelling?)

Has anyone got any advice about complaining to these people? Thanks

I also saw the option to go to an MP if unhappy with the outcome. I know the local MP personally, in the borough I live, so will definitely be going down this route if I need to

OP posts: