Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To smoke around newborn/baby/child?

215 replies

newmummie · 08/04/2023 09:08

Just want to know AIBU. I'm due me and dp first child in 3 months time, we are so so excited. Dp smokes (I don't, and never will) and when I say smokes, I mean around the clock. Since becoming pregnant I've made him very aware that he isn't allowed to smoke near me and I don't want to inhale any of it, he's agreed with this and does try his best to keep me away from it all. Although he does smoke when he's beside me in outdoors, this still makes me uncomfortable as it hits me up the face so I just walk infront of him until he's finished. I've recently told him that under no circumstances is anyone allowed to smoke near our child, he said he's not silly and he wouldn't do so but he can't help if someone in his family does. (All of his family smoke, none of mine do) This has made me quite uncomfortable, that he would say he can't help it if they decide to smoke around our child? I made it quite clear to him that if I ever see his family or anyone else light a cigarette near our baby/child I will simply get up and leave and ask them not to do it in future. He then said he won't let them smoke BESIDE baby but nothing wrong with a few distance away. But he's not asking them to go outside in their own house, which I understand. This has just made me very wary as they always talk about babysitting and how excited they are to have a new baby in the house. I just don't trust that when I'm not there they'll follow what I'm saying surrounding smoking near baby. They already have a child in the house and they've been smoking near her since newborn days, was never an issue to them. So I'm scared. Been talking more to DP about this past few days and it's causing countless arguments. He's agreed he won't smoke around baby however he CAN smoke when taking baby walks in the pram as it's outdoor in the fresh air. I still disagreed to this and said absolutely not. He's now very angry and said if he can't smoke he's not taking the baby on pram walks. AIBU? As you can tell I'm severely anxious around smoking around a newborn/child, I just don't want my child inhaling it. I've read to much negatives around it, although I am aware the chances of something happening to my baby is low but it's not a chance I want to take. I've also said to DH I'd rather my child not know that he smokes until he's much older, so to hide that he does it for the first few years, he's also said no to this. I just don't want to teach my child NO to smoking but he sees his dad and family do it all the time? What would be the point? Ranting at this point, sorry. Just frustrated. Should I be more easy on DP? Am I over reacting? Be kind, I'm really anxious around the whole thing. Thanks so much. xxx

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
UndercoverCop · 08/04/2023 12:13

My mum smoked for more than 30 years, in similar circumstances to how your partner is suggesting. I hated it as a child but it was a lot more common back in the eighties.
As soon as she found out her first grandchild was in the way she quit, she knew more about the risks, feels terrible for what we were exposed to and went from twenty a day to nothing in six weeks.
He needs to prioritise the baby

GoldenCagedBird · 08/04/2023 12:12

WandaWonder · 08/04/2023 12:04

I am not sure what is worse a person who only smokes outside then goes near a baby or all the air freshener perfume, cleaning chemicals inside around a baby?

I mean smokers will have all of those cleaning products in their house too, so I don’t really see what point your making

unless the smokers don’t clean their house?

I can’t say I’ve met any smokers who use only eco friendly, non toxin creating home cleaning projects either…it doesn’t really link up with what they are willingly putting in their lungs

but to answer your question: secondhand and third hand smoke

Jemandthehologramsunite · 08/04/2023 12:12

Don't let anyone smoke around the baby or even hold the baby if they have been smoking. It is really dangerous, as the smell/nicotine/whatever it is actually will make it difficult for your baby to breathe.

PippaF2 · 08/04/2023 12:09

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/04/2023 11:53

GrandmaWins · Today 11:37
Smokers need nicotine like they need air

Disagree, it’s a choice.
I was a heavy smoker for years, full fat Marlboro, ashamed to say now upwards of 40 a day in stressful job.
Met my husband, a non-smoker. I cut down drastically, smoked on nights out with friends etc. but not at home because I respected his wishes. He tolerated it because he loved me but he told me in no uncertain terms would he bring a child into our relationship unless I gave up completely. So I did, because I wanted a child more than I wanted a cigarette.
It really isn’t that difficult when something else is your priority. I believe that most smokers perpetuate that myth because in reality they don’t really want to stop.

My stepdad has recently stopped after over 60 years. Told me he decided and just did. Said “no idea why I didn’t just do it years ago. I think I imagined it would be too difficult but honestly, it was pretty easy once I’d decided”.

What's your point? Are you trying to say that nicotine isn't addictive and all smokers could just choose to stop?

Or are you arguing that all the OP's in-laws will choose to stop because of the baby?

Or are you saying all people are actually like you and will just stop smoking based on an ultimatium?

like where are you going with your point?

BusterGonad · 08/04/2023 12:07

ActDottie · 08/04/2023 09:37

You knew he was a big smoker so I’m confused why this is an issue now? And not when you were planning to get pregnant? His smoking habit sounds disgusting tbh and I’d not let him or anyone smoke around the baby inside or outside. I’m surprised he hasn’t tried to give up the smoking since he found out you were pregnant?

I completely agree with this. Doesn't anyone actually discuss having kids anymore? The amount of threads on about things going wrong after the baby is born due to not actually talking about such a life changing thing. Madness. I'm sorry Op but you're having a baby with a man who can't be fucked to change his ways, and to be fair he never thought he'd have to. His family sound delightful too. It looks like you thought you coukd change him. I wouldn't be surprised about anything else that may come out the woodwork once the baby is here.

Stardustkid · 08/04/2023 12:06

I remember when I had DS the midwife told the whole ward that should a smoker hold the baby they should shower and change before handling baby after smoking. But everyone I know who has been brought up around smokers has lung problems myself included

PippaF2 · 08/04/2023 12:05

GrandmaWins · 08/04/2023 11:37

Smokers need nicotine like they need air, so they will either leave the baby unattended to go outside

I don't see the issue with leaving the baby unattended (not a smoker). But as long as baby is asleep in a cot or in a rocking chair thing and you have a baby monitor to hear them then being in your back garden for 5 mins is hardly unsafe surely? I'd happily take a cup of tea out the back in nice weather while baby was having a short nap.

To a degree, yeah. But again, depending on how heavy a smoker - some people want a cigarette every 20 - 30 minutes - that's fairly average for a pack a day type smoker.

Each cigarette takes roughly 10 minutes. So they're going to be constantly 'stepping away', whether the baby is sleeping or not.

I doubt you drink 20 cups of tea in the garden everyday come rain, snow or high winds, from morning till night?

WandaWonder · 08/04/2023 12:04

I am not sure what is worse a person who only smokes outside then goes near a baby or all the air freshener perfume, cleaning chemicals inside around a baby?

Carouselfish · 08/04/2023 12:01

DP stopped unless at work when dc1 born. He changed out of smokey clothes and washed when he got home too.
Tell him his addiction isnt as important as his child's increased risk of death.

PinkiOcelot · 08/04/2023 11:55

AlwaysGinPlease · 08/04/2023 09:20

I wouldn't have a baby with a smoker.

I couldn’t have actually dated anyone who smoked. It was a dealbreaker for me. Hate it.

YADNBU OP. Your DP is a selfish dick. Smoking means more to him than your child.

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/04/2023 11:53

GrandmaWins · Today 11:37
Smokers need nicotine like they need air

Disagree, it’s a choice.
I was a heavy smoker for years, full fat Marlboro, ashamed to say now upwards of 40 a day in stressful job.
Met my husband, a non-smoker. I cut down drastically, smoked on nights out with friends etc. but not at home because I respected his wishes. He tolerated it because he loved me but he told me in no uncertain terms would he bring a child into our relationship unless I gave up completely. So I did, because I wanted a child more than I wanted a cigarette.
It really isn’t that difficult when something else is your priority. I believe that most smokers perpetuate that myth because in reality they don’t really want to stop.

My stepdad has recently stopped after over 60 years. Told me he decided and just did. Said “no idea why I didn’t just do it years ago. I think I imagined it would be too difficult but honestly, it was pretty easy once I’d decided”.

B0g · 08/04/2023 11:50

exatkynwhat @5128gap said. It’s a barest of minimum, basic thing, yet your boyfriend has failed to educate himself and is actually doubling down on wanting to risk his child. What do you plan to do?

whynotwhatknot · 08/04/2023 11:41

im a smoker and even i think yanbu

i dont have dc btw-your child will inhale it off of his clothes and skin-i dont knwo what to suggest because of you split up he will take the baby round his inlaws i presume

GrandmaWins · 08/04/2023 11:37

Smokers need nicotine like they need air, so they will either leave the baby unattended to go outside

I don't see the issue with leaving the baby unattended (not a smoker). But as long as baby is asleep in a cot or in a rocking chair thing and you have a baby monitor to hear them then being in your back garden for 5 mins is hardly unsafe surely? I'd happily take a cup of tea out the back in nice weather while baby was having a short nap.

PippaF2 · 08/04/2023 11:30

Yeah - the thing with smoking is, it's an addiction. Smokers need nicotine like they need air, so they will either leave the baby unattended to go outside, or stand in a doorway where the smoke will blow straight in anyway. Either way - unsafe.

You're right to say - no you're a smoker you can't babysit.

When my brother had his first kid, I was at University and smoked....quite rightly I was told the same and this was - about 20yrs ago now.

If smokers could just not smoke for several hours - it wouldn't be so hard to quit.....I say this as an ex-smoker!

Could you convince your DP to switch to vaping? Not as good as quitting altogether but far better than continuing to smoke.

Kendodd · 08/04/2023 11:27

Frankly I'm shocked he hasn't even tried to stop smoking because of the baby due. Shows where his priorities are.

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 08/04/2023 11:26

sugarspices · 08/04/2023 10:32

@KateFeather no I'm not a smoker but I was before I got pregnant - currently 32 weeks. My fiancé is still a smoker who has always smoked outside, although I am supporting him to quit, as was our agreement before conceiving. However, if he failed to quit for whatever reason, I wouldn't leave him and conspire to have him alienated from our child's life!

The NHS guidelines on SIDS state:

"do not share a bed with your baby if you or your partner smoke or take recreational drugs, have had 2 or more units of alcohol or have taken medicine that causes drowsiness"

There isn't anything on there to say you shouldn't share a bedroom with someone who has smoked. I wonder if PPs are so extreme about letting their partners (or indeed themselves) in the bedroom with the baby after they've had more than 2 units of alcohol 🙃

In terms of the other issues - I clearly said she shouldn't be taking the baby to homes where people are smoking inside. She has the choice the remove her child in any situation where someone starts smoking around her, as she should!

You are completely negating the 3rd hand smoke issue if you only concentrate on second hand smoke.

I promise you the NHS advice will change as the 3rd hand smoke research is ‘relatively’ new and takes a while to filter down into policy. (We’ve only just got over the ambulance service “it’s better to cut and tie the cord with blunt scissors and an old shoelace” even though we’ve had research for over a decade it’s best to leave it intact and wait for professional or at least clean equipment.)

Yes, we don’t sleep with baby if had lots of alcohol, wouldn’t sleep in same room unless baby was in cot. But alcohol as far as we know doesn’t poison baby from across the room - where as breathing out and emitting smoking particles does (there is research on this).
The biggest problem with alcohol is sleeping too heavily or rolling onto baby.

TBH we don’t drink that much anymore anyway - not worth the cost or hangover 🙃

lv884 · 08/04/2023 11:23

BreviloquentBastard · 08/04/2023 11:16

My gran and grandpa smoked like chimneys and babysat us when we were kids. I'm sure they smoked around us because it just wasn't seen as unusual. Their house always smelled and I'm sure we did when we left. My dad smoked in the house too, so we were always in a smoking environment.

Both my brother and I had asthma growing up, he still suffers it, I get chest infections constantly. I don't know if they're linked, but people I know who were brought up in smoke free environments tend not to have these issues.

I don't think I'd have a child with a smoker.

It sounds a little extreme arguably but I agree about not settling down with a smoker. It’d be a dealbreaker for me too. Yep, I remember spending the night at grandparents who were the same (actually just the one of them!) and having a rattling, chesty cough the next day. Really disgusting. Also asthmatic since childhood… I get so irritated now when stuck behind a smoker when walking down a busy street and realising after getting a nice deep breath of their smoke. I was especially irritated when pregnant or had my baby in their carrier.

girlfriend44 · 08/04/2023 11:23

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 08/04/2023 10:56

The bottom line is he smokes and so does his family, its an addiction you can't dictate to adults what they can and can't do however you can try to come up with a compromise such as only smoking outside

You shouldn't need to dictate. Their common sense should tell the, obvs they haven't got any.

Perfect time to give up.

Nalupa · 08/04/2023 11:20

smokers always stink, no matter how often they shower. That shit LINGERS. I say that as an ex smoker. I can’t believe what I was walking around like.

I probably have such a shit sense of smell. I hate the smell of cigarette smoke but I never notice it on people unless they are actively having a fag.

Pahpahpotato · 08/04/2023 11:19

Oh dear, I’m sorry your partner seems to be behaving in such a selfish way. I can’t believe he would breathe smoke all over you and allow you to walk ahead of him rather than adjusting his behaviour even slightly to prevent harm to both you and your unborn baby.
I am not as hardline as some of the pps. My husband smokes, and we have an 18 month old. He doesn’t smoke in the house, never has, or the cars (whether DS is in them at the time or not!), he changes his clothes and washes his hands when he comes in before touching DS. He doesn’t smoke near DS and I at all even if we are outdoors, he takes himself away altogether. He used to wash his face and brush his teeth when he got home too when DS was very young but I said he needn’t continue with that quite a while ago now. We all slept in the same room (never co slept) between 0-8 months.
I think the issue for me with your partner is that he seems to unwilling to adjust his behaviour and recognise the risks that smoking poses to your child. That’s concerning to me.

5128gap · 08/04/2023 11:18

Honestly OP? Adhering to smoking guidance is the bare minimum, one of the lowest bars for decent child rearing. If he and his family can't even comply with that, it's a safe bet that it's not the only way they will fall short in the card they offer your baby. It might sound OTT, but I'd be starting to question the wisdom of coparenting with someone who either lacks the intelligence to understand the importance of this, or lacks the care for his child to inconvenience himself. Its a very bad indicator of the type of parent he will be and I think you will become more anxious, and with good cause.

Nalupa · 08/04/2023 11:16

You also need to think about how this will affect your child growing up. I went to a kids party once. The parents started smoking in the garden. Everyone left early. Noone from a non smoking family is going to want their kid going round your house.

I don't smoke and I'm single, grew up in a no-smoke house... But I wouldn't make my kids leave a party early because the parents were smoking in the garden. Its outside. I would only leave if it were indoors.

BreviloquentBastard · 08/04/2023 11:16

My gran and grandpa smoked like chimneys and babysat us when we were kids. I'm sure they smoked around us because it just wasn't seen as unusual. Their house always smelled and I'm sure we did when we left. My dad smoked in the house too, so we were always in a smoking environment.

Both my brother and I had asthma growing up, he still suffers it, I get chest infections constantly. I don't know if they're linked, but people I know who were brought up in smoke free environments tend not to have these issues.

I don't think I'd have a child with a smoker.

GoldenCagedBird · 08/04/2023 11:15

sugarspices · 08/04/2023 10:32

@KateFeather no I'm not a smoker but I was before I got pregnant - currently 32 weeks. My fiancé is still a smoker who has always smoked outside, although I am supporting him to quit, as was our agreement before conceiving. However, if he failed to quit for whatever reason, I wouldn't leave him and conspire to have him alienated from our child's life!

The NHS guidelines on SIDS state:

"do not share a bed with your baby if you or your partner smoke or take recreational drugs, have had 2 or more units of alcohol or have taken medicine that causes drowsiness"

There isn't anything on there to say you shouldn't share a bedroom with someone who has smoked. I wonder if PPs are so extreme about letting their partners (or indeed themselves) in the bedroom with the baby after they've had more than 2 units of alcohol 🙃

In terms of the other issues - I clearly said she shouldn't be taking the baby to homes where people are smoking inside. She has the choice the remove her child in any situation where someone starts smoking around her, as she should!

someone’s dh sleeping off a few pints in a bed away from the baby’s cot is in no way comparable to your fiancé - who will absolutely reek of secondhand smoke (if you think he doesn’t, you are used to it), on his hair and skin - being around your child as they sleep

I get you are supporting him stopping and understand that smoke is bad for a baby, but the two situations cannot be compared

the alcohol guidance is to stop an inebriated parent rolling on a baby. The smoking guidance refers to your child constantly being poisoned by secondhand smoke

smokers always stink, no matter how often they shower. That shit LINGERS. I say that as an ex smoker. I can’t believe what I was walking around like.