Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Felixss · 09/04/2023 16:05

Ponoka7 · 09/04/2023 15:47

My concerns have happened since people who had LD's, often in their 20's were left to die, while we gave 80+ year olds intervention, during Covid. The old attitudes towards disabled people are very much there. Also we have a lot of people who use the fact that women could have opted for abortion to not care about child poverty and social housing conditions. Those people will no doubt not care the state social care and residential settings are allowed to drop down to. Under a Tory government, I don't want it. I'm surprised at so many people experiencing harrowing deaths. Doctors can sedate people, so they are out of pain, even if that could contribute to death. But the person has to have a DNR, wishes made clear when reasonably well and most importantly, the family has to be onboard. I'm in Liverpool, my DH was helped along by the Liverpool pathway. I don't agree with starving people to death, but there could easily be an in-between. I have two very disabled friends. Both housebound, relying on carers. One wouldn't want to live in the state she is in. The other desperately wants to live. He does get low mood and recently was hospitalised. He was very confused during that time and it would have been easy to convince him into euthanasia. It's actually a fear of his. He won't have visitors because he knows he won't get treatment for Covid, that the none disabled take for granted.

Yes I agree about LDs and diagnostic over shadowing still we shouldn't deny people a pain free death and bodily autonomy over risk. There's a lot of work to do but within LD with the LeDer and Oliver McGowan training we are making inroads. LD life expectancy is increasing.

In this situation we are talking about people with progressive terminal illnesses they can give medication but since shipman there's a lot more reluctance to prescribe the large amounts in case they get into trouble. I think if you have capacity and have specifically asked for it in advanced care planning you should be able to request it for when your health deteriorates.

Ponoka7 · 09/04/2023 15:47

My concerns have happened since people who had LD's, often in their 20's were left to die, while we gave 80+ year olds intervention, during Covid. The old attitudes towards disabled people are very much there. Also we have a lot of people who use the fact that women could have opted for abortion to not care about child poverty and social housing conditions. Those people will no doubt not care the state social care and residential settings are allowed to drop down to. Under a Tory government, I don't want it. I'm surprised at so many people experiencing harrowing deaths. Doctors can sedate people, so they are out of pain, even if that could contribute to death. But the person has to have a DNR, wishes made clear when reasonably well and most importantly, the family has to be onboard. I'm in Liverpool, my DH was helped along by the Liverpool pathway. I don't agree with starving people to death, but there could easily be an in-between. I have two very disabled friends. Both housebound, relying on carers. One wouldn't want to live in the state she is in. The other desperately wants to live. He does get low mood and recently was hospitalised. He was very confused during that time and it would have been easy to convince him into euthanasia. It's actually a fear of his. He won't have visitors because he knows he won't get treatment for Covid, that the none disabled take for granted.

TrueScrumptious · 09/04/2023 15:29

We absolutely urgently need assisted dying in the U.K. It cannot come quickly enough for those with a terminal diagnosis, facing a horrible death, at least.

IrisAtwood · 09/04/2023 15:24

Having spent an utterly horrible 24 hours in hospital recently watching an elderly woman with dementia being neglected and ignored I have made sure that my advanced directive is in place. I also made a complaint and have tried to highlight cases like this with the media.
I am afraid of ending up needing care that the NHS/social care (in my experience) does not provide.
I also campaign for assisted dying.

AveragePerson5 · 09/04/2023 15:06

I understand where you're coming from, I really do. But death is irreversible. There are also situations where someone is told they have weeks or days to live but in the end they live a lot longer.

Deaths from overdoses of diamorphine are also irreversible and happen on the streets every day through misuse but that doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be used legitimately. Women are still prescribed diamorphine every day during childbirth.

Most of us are not advocating for it to be legalised for the moment you get a diagnosis. That’s not how it’s used. Most people have some sort of long or short decline over time. They are in hospital and go past the point of no return. It certainly should be available for the last 3 months and few weeks of life. The other group are people who have degenerative incurable illnesses which get to a point of existing in a state of living torture with a horrible death.

Jonei · 09/04/2023 14:36

During the covid pandemic there was a great deal of reporting on disabled people having DNRs without their own or their family's knowledge in the event that they became very ill with covid.

Yes this was the case for older people and people with disabilities. It absolutely does not inspire trust.

pointythings · 09/04/2023 14:34

Im assuming they would then plan to die early before they were in any pain?

Your assumption is very wrong. If you look at the data from Oregon, where assisted dying is legal, a substantial % of the people who register for it upon diagnosis never make use of it. What they want is the choice to have a dignified way out if they need it.

If your assumption were correct then you would see a large majority of the people diagnosed with painful cancers taking the assisted way out long before they are in any pain in countries where this is legal. Again, the data does not support this.

On the other hand, people in the UK DO die earlier than they would have needed to had assisted dying been legal, because they have to be physically able to travel to Switerland independently. So you have it completely upside down.

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 14:25

I don’t think you understand at all. If someone has a terminal diagnosis and wants to end their life then that is their own choice. So what if they could have lived one more week or month in terror and pain? Why do people like you get to take that choice of a peaceful and dignified death away from them.

I'm not talking about people who are already in pain - I'm talking about people who are given a prognosis that turns out not to accurate. Im assuming they would then plan to die early before they were in any pain?

People like me? I live in this country too and I don't want my rights to be eroded. Why should people like you assume you're right in every situation?

During the covid pandemic there was a great deal of reporting on disabled people having DNRs without their own or their family's knowledge in the event that they became very ill with covid. Why should I trust the government not to abuse legislation around euthanasia or not to implement proper 'safeguarding' which people on the thread are so sure would happen.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 09/04/2023 14:19

I sincerely hope it is legalised In my lifetime, I work in nursing and so see the way some people are kept alive with no quality of life, In pain etc every day and I do not want that for myself, I do not want to forget who my children are. There are definitely fates worse than death in some cases. I can make an advance directive stating I do not want antibiotics for every infection or any admits to hospital but someone pointed out on another similar thread that these are not always upheld

PinkiOcelot · 09/04/2023 14:03

Teenangels · 09/04/2023 12:33

Thank you, I am sending you all my thoughts and love (very unmumsnet).

If you ever need to offload people just message me.

Thank you ❤️

Luckydip1 · 09/04/2023 13:18

I would rather I decide when and how I die not the government which is the current position.

AnotherSaturdayNight · 09/04/2023 13:08

GoldenAye · 09/04/2023 12:25

@AnotherSaturdayNight

I don’t agree that people tend to put animals down because they can’t afford treatment. Sure some might, but the majority don’t. There are loads of threads on the Doghouse asking how will I know when it’s time to PTS. Most people are worried about prolonging the suffering of the animal because they can’t bear to part with them.

So that's a few different reasons you've listed - of course, it's always difficult to part with a pet. But to deny that the cost of treatment isn't a major reason is disingenuous. Vet costs are bonkers.

We don't treat animals more kindly, and they aren't humans.

I don’t agree with the first part of what you said. They don’t have to suffer like humans do. I have witnessed this suffering. Owners have to make difficult decisions when it comes to the cost of treatment. It is kinder to PTS than leave the animal to suffer.

Jonei · 09/04/2023 13:01

Alargeoneplease89 · 09/04/2023 12:49

No I don't want it, like everything else an inch turns into a mile. Look at the equalities act and how levelling up for women are has now turned into a trans shambles. Something starts off with good intentions and turns into chaos.

Indeed. Who would trust any government to deal with this responsibly. And even if one happened to deal with it responsibly, it doesn't mean the next one will. Humans are too corrupt it would seem.

Alargeoneplease89 · 09/04/2023 12:49

No I don't want it, like everything else an inch turns into a mile. Look at the equalities act and how levelling up for women are has now turned into a trans shambles. Something starts off with good intentions and turns into chaos.

Teenangels · 09/04/2023 12:33

PinkiOcelot · 09/04/2023 12:04

@Teenangels

I’m so sorry. I’m going through the same and it’s horrendous. I think this will live with me the rest of my life. Flowersx

Thank you, I am sending you all my thoughts and love (very unmumsnet).

If you ever need to offload people just message me.

GoldenAye · 09/04/2023 12:28

pointythings · 09/04/2023 12:25

Why should any creature whether human or animal be forced to live in unbearable pain?

Who are you directing that at?

pointythings · 09/04/2023 12:25

Why should any creature whether human or animal be forced to live in unbearable pain?

GoldenAye · 09/04/2023 12:25

@AnotherSaturdayNight

I don’t agree that people tend to put animals down because they can’t afford treatment. Sure some might, but the majority don’t. There are loads of threads on the Doghouse asking how will I know when it’s time to PTS. Most people are worried about prolonging the suffering of the animal because they can’t bear to part with them.

So that's a few different reasons you've listed - of course, it's always difficult to part with a pet. But to deny that the cost of treatment isn't a major reason is disingenuous. Vet costs are bonkers.

GoldenAye · 09/04/2023 12:20

pointythings · 09/04/2023 09:29

@GoldenAye actually your example of 'the animal is near the end of its life' bears a great deal of resemblance to the situation for humans, so you've shot yourself down in flames right there. When one is dying of cancer and in agony, 'near the end of life' captures the situation perfectly.

I should have clearer there. My meaning was 'lifespan'. If an animal is reaching the end of its natural lifespan, then an owner might be more likely to euthanise rather spend a great deal on treatment. This might be the same for humans, but slightly different if someone had a terminal illness but not old.

gelatogina · 09/04/2023 12:06

And for all those saying yes, of which there are many…please make your voices heard.

lobby your MP
join campaign groups

nothing will change unless we force it to

712oohahh · 09/04/2023 12:05

Yes.

I'm only speaking for myself but YES I want this in the UK. If I'm ever in a situation where there is no prospect of recovery, where I am in pain and suffering for a large proportion of my daily existence then I would definitely definitely want the CHOICE to end my life. I may not choose to, but I want that choice available to me.

PinkiOcelot · 09/04/2023 12:04

@Teenangels

I’m so sorry. I’m going through the same and it’s horrendous. I think this will live with me the rest of my life. Flowersx

gelatogina · 09/04/2023 12:04

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 11:24

I understand where you're coming from, I really do. But death is irreversible. There are also situations where someone is told they have weeks or days to live but in the end they live a lot longer.

I don’t think you understand at all. If someone has a terminal diagnosis and wants to end their life then that is their own choice. So what if they could have lived one more week or month in terror and pain? Why do people like you get to take that choice of a peaceful and dignified death away from them.

at the moment if you want to go to Switzerland to end your life, people are going far too early when they will have some quality of life left because they are scared of leaving it too late and being too ill to travel. And of course this is only an option for those who can afford it. The poor have to roll the dice and take their chance.

better a week too early than a day too late is the saying for animals. Why can’t we apply the same compassion to ourselves?

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 11:24

AveragePerson5 · 09/04/2023 10:14

There are many women who are forced into abortions they don't want by their partners.

There doesn't seem to be adequate safeguarding to stop that.

There are women who are forced into marriage but that doesn’t mean we never allow marriage.

There will always be abusive people. Safeguards can never be 100%. That isn’t a reason not to have laws and processes that are largely beneficial to people.

As people are living longer more of us have seen what often happens in the last months and weeks, when you can’t have the hoped for morphine induced pain free sleep. It is becoming more acceptable to talk about it. We are extremely shocked and angry by what we have seen our relatives go through. We are terrified the same fate lies ahead for us and others.

I understand where you're coming from, I really do. But death is irreversible. There are also situations where someone is told they have weeks or days to live but in the end they live a lot longer.

Teenangels · 09/04/2023 11:15

magicthree · 08/04/2023 23:51

I feel that TV is to blame to a point. Death is not someone lucid, talking to relatives, then passing away with a smile on their face moments later. Active dying can take days, and then it is things like terminal agitation, secretions (the death rattle), all odd patterns of breathing, things like suddenly sitting up etc.

While that is unpleasant for the person sitting with the dying relative/friend, the person who is dying is unaware of those things happening, it is peaceful enough for them. I recently sat with my DF for several days as he was dying and I didn't find it so terrible, although admittedly I wasn't there when he actually died, but I found the whole thing far less stressful than I had imagined it to be. It was in fact a lot easier than what happened before, when he was delirious and thought everyone was his mother.

I can assure you that my Mum was very aware of what was happening to her, she was choking 5 days before she died and had to be turned into her side.

My mum was saying help me, she was trying to sit up, cried out in pain.

How can you be certain that the person has no idea, you can't.

Swipe left for the next trending thread