Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 20:10

The British public have made it quite clear that immigration, asking families to care for their elderly relatives, or increasing taxes to fund investment in the sector are absolute no-no's, so we're running out of options really.

What does this have to do with euthanasia??

Suzi888 · 09/04/2023 19:43

@GretaGood What do you mean about declining antibiotics? My dad had a syringe driver, he was unconscious after it was fitted. It haunts me. He took a few weeks to pass.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 09/04/2023 19:39

@Thebestwaytoscareatory I spend a lot of time thinking about this, and it is a worry, particularly where I am it’s rural and the elderly population really outstrip the younger people they leave to go to cities as there is nothing here so I really don’t know what this generation and the next expect to happen, the vast majority are retirees from England coming for the free personal care which is fine but there are no carers to provide it or massive waits for them and I’m talking a year to 18 months for care packages currently.

I posted on the AI thread that robots may be an answer they could help with personal care, meals and meds and the current carers could provide some human contact

Suzi888 · 09/04/2023 19:39

WhyCantYourPartnerDoIt · 08/04/2023 01:14

You’re being unreasonable by not citing your sources.

^ I agree.

I also support it, if you want to die in agony OP feel free ~I don’t.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 09/04/2023 19:36

@Puzzledandpissedoff people coming to the end of their natural life span and being kept comfortable is not a bad thing but unfortunately the vast majority of the people I work with with dementia for example are in care homes in various horrible states of life, not knowing where they are or why, agitated, lying in bed unable to move incontinent etc not what I want for myself

then there are those dying of cancer or other terminal illnesses who we just can’t seem to get it right for them pain relief wise or secretions wise sometimes because things just happen to fast for us to really deal with them particularly those who choose to die at home, i work in rural community nursing one of the areas we cover takes nearly 30 minutes to get to so if called out they could have quite the wait especially if we are with other people

families are a big obstacle as you say they want everything done regardless of whether it’s in the best interest of the their relative or not and can be very unrealistic. We as health professionals need to start being more frank

the nhs really is a victim of its own success In that it’s good at keeping people alive but not in good health a lot of the time

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/04/2023 19:31

Yabu, putting aside the personal wishes of individuals for a second, we've an aging population and a shrinking workforce, which is leading to an acute elderly care crisis.

The British public have made it quite clear that immigration, asking families to care for their elderly relatives, or increasing taxes to fund investment in the sector are absolute no-no's, so we're running out of options really.

Pythonesque · 09/04/2023 19:07

I have always felt deeply sympathetic to people who find themselves in a position to wish euthanasia; or whose loved ones end up in a state where they know that would have been their wish if they could express it. However, I also believe that it is not possible to safely legalise this and at the same time retain adequate safeguards for those who do not wish euthanasia but are in some way vulnerable.

One of several groups I worry about, is older people who "feel they are a burden" and could decide it is their "responsibility" to ask for euthanasia.

Hotpinkangel19 · 09/04/2023 18:23

GretaGood · 08/04/2023 05:13

write VERY clearly that you do not want antibiotics after a certain deterioration in your situation otherwise each time your condition deteriorates they (the docs/nurses) will pump you full so you lurch on in a deteriorated state until you eventually die of starvation and lack of fluids.
Hopefully the morphine syringe driver means You are oblivious of the hunger/ thirst pangs, the aching body and parched and shrivelled mouth but who knows.

This must have been what happened to my Mum. Heartbreaking to watch. Could talk to her until that syringe driver went in. I wasn't told that she wouldn't be awake after that happened. She passed peacefully thank goodness.

NeonBoomerang · 09/04/2023 17:59

In my job I see people who are suffering and have no quality of life for years. Their care is expensive and they and their families are miserable. I absolutely do want euthanasia here.

TrueScrumptious · 09/04/2023 17:55

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 14:25

I don’t think you understand at all. If someone has a terminal diagnosis and wants to end their life then that is their own choice. So what if they could have lived one more week or month in terror and pain? Why do people like you get to take that choice of a peaceful and dignified death away from them.

I'm not talking about people who are already in pain - I'm talking about people who are given a prognosis that turns out not to accurate. Im assuming they would then plan to die early before they were in any pain?

People like me? I live in this country too and I don't want my rights to be eroded. Why should people like you assume you're right in every situation?

During the covid pandemic there was a great deal of reporting on disabled people having DNRs without their own or their family's knowledge in the event that they became very ill with covid. Why should I trust the government not to abuse legislation around euthanasia or not to implement proper 'safeguarding' which people on the thread are so sure would happen.

And in the Covid pandemic, due to travel restrictions, there were people who had been accepted at Dignitas due to their illness who were then unable to travel, and who then killed themselves in the most horrendous ways.

Snowythecatbitch · 09/04/2023 17:46

If you have seen BOTH your parents die in absolute agony and you don't have any advocates ie kids sorry but I'm gunning for euthanasia all the way

pointythings · 09/04/2023 17:37

@Puzzledandpissedoff I agree with you that no system can be 100% safe from being abused. But that's no different from anything else in medicine and it irks me that people don't see that. They expect everything to be 100% safe and if it isn't, we mustn't do it at all. Then when you point out that not even their paracetamol and Ibuprofen are 100% safe, they're either annoyed or they refuse to believe you. It's about managing risk. And if someone has capacity, they should be allowed to take that decision and take that risk.

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 09/04/2023 17:16

@EuphemiaLives

I'm so sorry for you and your poor dad, and everyone else affected by such a terrible situation 💐

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/04/2023 17:10

True enough, pointythings, but even in the Netherlands it appears they've had cases off "due care not met": https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/7/10/e017628

The most honest response for me was from AveragePerson5 who said "There will always be abusive people. Safeguards can never be 100%. That isn’t a reason not to have laws and processes that are largely beneficial to people"
To my mind that works, just so long as there was a way of making absolutely sure that financial imperatives for the NHS weren't allowed to come into it - though how this could be prevented is anyone's guess

https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/7/10/e017628

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/04/2023 17:01

I work in nursing and so see the way some people are kept alive with no quality of life, In pain etc every day ...

Definitely with you on that, AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii; however to my layperson's mind there seems a difference between allowing nature to take its course and active killing - and when someone's coming naturally to the end of their lifespan I'm not sure that allowing the inevitable to happen (with symptom management of course) is any bad thing

I've also experienced very aged relatives being treated for such as pneumonia when it's clearly not in their best interests, and been told that if something's deemed to be treatable then in the absence of any advance directive it has to be treated. I don't know if this still applies (?) and I realise that relatives who expect everything to be cured are another issue, but again it hardly seems helpful

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 16:58

Yes that's my concern as well.

pointythings · 09/04/2023 16:50

@MyopicBunny the Netherlands has a pretty right wing government and nobody over there is bumping off hordes of oldies. However, I would not trust our current government to legislate for this simply because they have shown themselves to be so spectacularly incompetent about absolutely everything.

gelatogina · 09/04/2023 16:43

I highly doubt anyone is going to take a taxi home from the hospital after their diagnosis and end their life that night.

but when the time comes, and life isn’t worth living, we need the power to make that choice before it becomes utterly hellish. And it does. Trust me I’ve seen it.

gelatogina · 09/04/2023 16:41

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 14:25

I don’t think you understand at all. If someone has a terminal diagnosis and wants to end their life then that is their own choice. So what if they could have lived one more week or month in terror and pain? Why do people like you get to take that choice of a peaceful and dignified death away from them.

I'm not talking about people who are already in pain - I'm talking about people who are given a prognosis that turns out not to accurate. Im assuming they would then plan to die early before they were in any pain?

People like me? I live in this country too and I don't want my rights to be eroded. Why should people like you assume you're right in every situation?

During the covid pandemic there was a great deal of reporting on disabled people having DNRs without their own or their family's knowledge in the event that they became very ill with covid. Why should I trust the government not to abuse legislation around euthanasia or not to implement proper 'safeguarding' which people on the thread are so sure would happen.

Your rights wouldn’t be eroded. You would still have the right to die as you wish. Nothing would change for you.

as previous posters have said, people die early right now because they currently have to travel to Switzerland BEFORE they feel they are ready because they fear they won’t be able to make it if they wait too long. You have this back to front.
if you can choose when the time is right, you would.

pointythings · 09/04/2023 16:30

@Nursejackie1 seconded.

People bought into the LCP hysteria so easily, and people are so naive about what is possible with palliative care.

Qhaecciarr · 09/04/2023 16:17

I'd like to have the choice personally, plus as others have already said, we wouldn't allow animals to go through what we force people to go through. I believe I would like to see euthanasia with appropriate guidelines and qualifiying criteria legalised.

Nursejackie1 · 09/04/2023 16:17

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:44

The Liverpool care pathway was subject to hysteria by the media they now follow the gold standards framework which is similar. If someone is requesting food drink and they can process and swallow it of course they should have it. They should also be given regular mouth care to prevent a dry mouth.

Relatives quite often will try to feed because we associate feeding with love and helping them get better even if they are in the last days of life . They also can misunderstand the process of cachexia which is wasting so assume that the staff must be starving them. It's common to have wasting in terminal illness and being unable to swallow. It's also common to start withdrawing from the world , a syringe driver is a kindness for the person.

The media and misunderstanding was why it got a bad reputation. I'm sure some staff didn't use correctly but the LCP was designed to minimise pain and suffering.

One of the most sensible things I’ve heard so far about the LCP. Spot on.

TrueScrumptious · 09/04/2023 16:16

I'm surprised at so many people experiencing harrowing deaths. Doctors can sedate people, so they are out of pain, even if that could contribute to death.

That is so completely untrue. Loads of people die in intractable pain, pain that cannot be relieved by even the very best palliative care. Sedation does not mean pain-free, it does not mean like general anaesthesia, which is never used in palliative care. And even the best pain-relieving medication available under the most expert care may have no effect on some people.

oakleaffy · 09/04/2023 16:11

Re Diamorphine overdoses being “ Irreversible “
Absolutely not true!

Prenoxad nasal spray or injection can reverse an opioid overdose.

Get from a drugs project or GP.

Saves lives.

Felixss · 09/04/2023 16:07

pointythings · 09/04/2023 14:34

Im assuming they would then plan to die early before they were in any pain?

Your assumption is very wrong. If you look at the data from Oregon, where assisted dying is legal, a substantial % of the people who register for it upon diagnosis never make use of it. What they want is the choice to have a dignified way out if they need it.

If your assumption were correct then you would see a large majority of the people diagnosed with painful cancers taking the assisted way out long before they are in any pain in countries where this is legal. Again, the data does not support this.

On the other hand, people in the UK DO die earlier than they would have needed to had assisted dying been legal, because they have to be physically able to travel to Switerland independently. So you have it completely upside down.

It's so sad when people do go to dignitas as they will have to be relatively well, have capacity to make the journey. So they will have to end it far before they are ready which is so cruel .