Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MarshaBradyo · 10/04/2023 08:32

pointythings · 10/04/2023 08:26

@MarshaBradyo and @Jonei as an immigrant who has been on the receiving end of the post 2016 referendum British 'welcome' I think your views are heavily rose tinted.

No rose tint required. Net migration is up post 2016.

I haven’t noticed any change and I am dual citizen but many would think I’ve moved here

Your experience may be different but there’s no point assuming you are the only one who knows what it’s like.

Jonei · 10/04/2023 08:32

pointythings · 10/04/2023 08:26

@MarshaBradyo and @Jonei as an immigrant who has been on the receiving end of the post 2016 referendum British 'welcome' I think your views are heavily rose tinted.

Rose tinted?
Why?
These things are already happening. People are here already working in these jobs.
People already have to pay unless they are under the threshold.
I'll add to that, that the majority are actually quite grateful for this help.
What exactly is rose tinted about these facts?

Cheesedoffandgrumpy · 10/04/2023 08:30

Euthanasia needs to be a legal option.

MyopicBunny · 10/04/2023 08:28

@Thebestwaytoscareatory - I really think that your belief that euthanasia is the remedy to 13 years of Tory rule is completely abhorrent.

There are plenty of people who think like you and also think the same thing about disabled people. I did not say you mentioned disabled people, but rest assured there are plenty of people with your mindset and I think its utterly objectionable.

'Difficult conversations' - what rubbish. The answer to some of these questions is to have a government who doesn't shit on the vulnerable from a great height whilst making the rich infinity richer.

pointythings · 10/04/2023 08:26

@MarshaBradyo and @Jonei as an immigrant who has been on the receiving end of the post 2016 referendum British 'welcome' I think your views are heavily rose tinted.

Anewuser · 10/04/2023 08:26

I’m scared of euthanasia.

I watched my dad die and it was awful. But whilst we had to watched him slowly disappear from the man he was, at least at the end he was made comfortable. For him, he made that decision to stop treatment so it was only a matter of time.

However, having a severely disabled adult child has shown me too many times where the medical team feel his quality of life is not high enough. He has been refused treatment and access to ICU. We have been told by professionals it’s only us keeping him alive. Who are they to decide he should be put down.

Euthanasia will always be a topic of contention. I’ve been on both sides of the argument but at least when it’s not legal means we won’t have hundreds/thousands of people being put to sleep before their time.

Jonei · 10/04/2023 08:24

MarshaBradyo · 10/04/2023 08:16

There are Care Worker visas, re immigration, it’s not the case that the majority of public say no to this.

Absolutely they don't say no to this. Particularly those recieving the care. Why on earth would they.

Limetart · 10/04/2023 08:24

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/04/2023 08:11

I never said anything about the disabled thank you.

I am of course being deliberately provocative by framing things so bluntly but it is often the only way to get people to stop burying their heads in the sand over the issues mentioned.

We're already seeing a crisis in elderly care that will only get worse and, if things continue as they are, we'll find ourselves in a position where it is a choice between caring for the elderly or caring for those with additional needs / long term conditions as we simply won't have the facilities or personnel to do both.

As I said the British public, including a higher proportion of elderly, have made their views on immigration or financing their own care very clear. There's also very little support for shifting the finical/physical responsibility of care towards families.

13 years of tory rule and austerity have not only massively impacted the care sector but have also reduced the overall health of the population to the point that life expectancy is decreasing (for the poor, which I suppose is one way of solving the care crisis).

All the reports I've read suggest that the demand for elderly care will increase by anywhere between 15-30% in the next few decades, and that 80+% of elderly in care are their due to severe memory related illnesses, which means they are not going to get better and are essentially being kept alive for the benefit of their families.

We can either continue to bury our heads in the sand and pretend things will somehow magically improve or we can start to have difficult discussions on how to address these issues.

Your views are actually terrifying.
My df is 90. He’s lonely and scared. Definitely has the beginnings of dementia. He’s also remarkably physically fit. I doubt he’ll die for a few years.
Someone like you describes not bumping him off as burying our heads in the sand.

Your ageism is frankly disturbing.

Jonei · 10/04/2023 08:23

As I said the British public, including a higher proportion of elderly, have made their views on immigration or financing their own care very clear. There's also very little support for shifting the finical/physical responsibility of care towards families.

Immigration is already happening and supporting these care roles. I can't see this stopping any time soon.
People already do pay for their care if they are over the financial threshold. Regardless of appetite.
Many families do already support their older people as much as they can.
Often, however, you do get families that try to reduce cafe packages, get by on minimum care, because they are protecting their inheritance.
Imagine how much worse that would start to look if euthanasia in this country became a thing.

MarshaBradyo · 10/04/2023 08:16

There are Care Worker visas, re immigration, it’s not the case that the majority of public say no to this.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/04/2023 08:11

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 21:30

Comments like those made by @Thebestwaytoscareatory are the reason I am opposed to Euthanasia being legalised.

There are a lot of people who think it's ok to bump off old, sick and disabled people.

I never said anything about the disabled thank you.

I am of course being deliberately provocative by framing things so bluntly but it is often the only way to get people to stop burying their heads in the sand over the issues mentioned.

We're already seeing a crisis in elderly care that will only get worse and, if things continue as they are, we'll find ourselves in a position where it is a choice between caring for the elderly or caring for those with additional needs / long term conditions as we simply won't have the facilities or personnel to do both.

As I said the British public, including a higher proportion of elderly, have made their views on immigration or financing their own care very clear. There's also very little support for shifting the finical/physical responsibility of care towards families.

13 years of tory rule and austerity have not only massively impacted the care sector but have also reduced the overall health of the population to the point that life expectancy is decreasing (for the poor, which I suppose is one way of solving the care crisis).

All the reports I've read suggest that the demand for elderly care will increase by anywhere between 15-30% in the next few decades, and that 80+% of elderly in care are their due to severe memory related illnesses, which means they are not going to get better and are essentially being kept alive for the benefit of their families.

We can either continue to bury our heads in the sand and pretend things will somehow magically improve or we can start to have difficult discussions on how to address these issues.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/04/2023 07:20

@Teenangels , I don’t understand why you couldn’t even wet your poor mother’s lips. During her last days I sat a lot with an aunt who had advanced dementia - we were given little sponges with which to keep her mouth moist, but not enough for her to need to swallow - this was in her very good care home.
She was consistently refusing food and drink, would close her mouth and turn her head away, and thankfully did not seem to be in any discomfort or distress.

JackiePlace · 10/04/2023 06:10

You would have to be some sort of sociopath to believe that people should be euthanised just because there aren’t enough workers to look after older people.

... so the alternative is to leave these people stittng there hungry, unwashed and with no human contact? And that's better somehow?
"Not enough carers" is not a trivial problem.

GretaGood · 10/04/2023 05:40

Suzi888 · 09/04/2023 19:43

@GretaGood What do you mean about declining antibiotics? My dad had a syringe driver, he was unconscious after it was fitted. It haunts me. He took a few weeks to pass.

If people can’t swallow properly then food and water can run into the lungs and cause infection / pneumonia from which I assume patient might die . Giving them antibiotics stops the infection, but they can’t swallow so food and water is stopped and die over time from that.
i feel it would be better to die quicker of infection.
But someone would need to stop medics giving the anti-bs - and a family member would need to say No ABs - let them die. And no family member would be able to say that so the patient themself needs to have that written clearly in their end of life care.
This my view. Haven’t tried to write my end of life wishes yet.

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/04/2023 00:11

I understand people's reticence. I also understand that some doctors and other HCPs are uneasy with it and just as with abortion, none of them should forced to provide the service.

However, in the case of my family, euthanasia would decrease life by days or weeks, but decrease the pain and trauma suffered, massively.

Euthanasia would enable us to die with dignity and peace. It needs to be made law. Even if just for last stage terminal illnesses.

Felixss · 09/04/2023 23:32

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 21:30

Comments like those made by @Thebestwaytoscareatory are the reason I am opposed to Euthanasia being legalised.

There are a lot of people who think it's ok to bump off old, sick and disabled people.

I think it should be a choice, I've seen a lot of death. I want a quicker release the thing is we keep people alive at all costs especially if you have no advanced directive. Relatives will often want to carry on, if you have a progressive terminal illness no amount of antibiotics or special nutrition is going to cure that the body is failing. It's definitely become more about quantity Vs quality we have got very good at the body alive but not the previous functioning.

Jonei · 09/04/2023 21:48

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 21:30

Comments like those made by @Thebestwaytoscareatory are the reason I am opposed to Euthanasia being legalised.

There are a lot of people who think it's ok to bump off old, sick and disabled people.

Yes exactly. We only need to look to Canada to see how badly it can be done. And there is a lot of people that would like to bump off older people once they perceive them as an expense / taking up housing etc.

ElleMD80 · 09/04/2023 21:48

Let people choose a humane way to die. What business is it of yours? Does it sit better with you to have someone in unspeakable pain, reduces to a physical wreck or living with an unbearable mind? Is that more acceptable to you? Or is them jumping off a building or suffocating on a lonely bed at home more palatable to you?

AveragePerson5 · 09/04/2023 21:46

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/04/2023 19:31

Yabu, putting aside the personal wishes of individuals for a second, we've an aging population and a shrinking workforce, which is leading to an acute elderly care crisis.

The British public have made it quite clear that immigration, asking families to care for their elderly relatives, or increasing taxes to fund investment in the sector are absolute no-no's, so we're running out of options really.

None of that is a reason to support euthanasia.

You would have to be some sort of sociopath to believe that people should be euthanised just because there aren’t enough workers to look after older people. Or as a cost cutting exercise. This type of thing is posted to stir up anti-euthanasia sentiments.

The only reason to legalise assisted dying it is to relieve suffering in the face of death; to give someone a good death instead of a horrific one.

pointythings · 09/04/2023 21:44

@MyopicBunny you are entitled to your opinion, but there is plenty of evidence showing that it can be done well (not perfectly, but well). I am deeply thankful that my grandmother had the choice. And no, there wasn't an inheritance.

AveragePerson5 · 09/04/2023 21:34

oakleaffy · 09/04/2023 16:11

Re Diamorphine overdoses being “ Irreversible “
Absolutely not true!

Prenoxad nasal spray or injection can reverse an opioid overdose.

Get from a drugs project or GP.

Saves lives.

Yes I’m aware of naloxone. That’s why I carefully said:

Deaths from overdoses of diamorphine are also irreversible

Death is irreversible. As far as I know.

MyopicBunny · 09/04/2023 21:30

pointythings · 09/04/2023 21:25

@Jonei it isn't about 'older people with care needs'. In countries where euthanasia is legal, the vast majory of cases concern people with cancer first, cardiovascular disease second. We're talking terminal physical illness here, not just 'granny is a bit frail, let's get rid'. With the caveat of not trusting the current government and in the light of the existence of places where euthanasia has been legalised well (not perfectly, no such thing is possible), why should people not have the choice? There's no single best option for all, there are only options which are best for an individual.

Comments like those made by @Thebestwaytoscareatory are the reason I am opposed to Euthanasia being legalised.

There are a lot of people who think it's ok to bump off old, sick and disabled people.

pointythings · 09/04/2023 21:25

@Jonei it isn't about 'older people with care needs'. In countries where euthanasia is legal, the vast majory of cases concern people with cancer first, cardiovascular disease second. We're talking terminal physical illness here, not just 'granny is a bit frail, let's get rid'. With the caveat of not trusting the current government and in the light of the existence of places where euthanasia has been legalised well (not perfectly, no such thing is possible), why should people not have the choice? There's no single best option for all, there are only options which are best for an individual.

Alaimo · 09/04/2023 20:45

I'm ain favour of legalising the euthanasia, but people should realise it's not a silver bullet that can prevent any and all forms of painful death or 'undesirable' ways of living out one's final years.

I have two family members in the Netherlands whose requests for euthanasia were denied. One ended up with severe dementia and had a natural, but slow and painful death. The other ended up starving himself, not a very pleasant way to go either.

But that's the other side of the coin of having safeguards in place. It means that some, especially those suffering from cognitive impairments like dementia, will have their requests turned down because it cannot be ascertained that they truly wish to die.

Jonei · 09/04/2023 20:21

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 09/04/2023 19:31

Yabu, putting aside the personal wishes of individuals for a second, we've an aging population and a shrinking workforce, which is leading to an acute elderly care crisis.

The British public have made it quite clear that immigration, asking families to care for their elderly relatives, or increasing taxes to fund investment in the sector are absolute no-no's, so we're running out of options really.

Immigration is already happening. And many people from different places are working in the care sector. The native population might be shrinking. But the population is increasing. Because. Immigration.
A lot of tax is already poured into the sector to fund it.
Plenty of families do care for their older family members.

But despite all this, you think the best option is for older people who have care needs is euthanasia. Why?