Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
pointythings · 10/04/2023 20:46

I think that when it comes to dementia we need to be extremely cautious, and I think that means in the event that consent is withdrawn in the moment, that withdrawal must be taken at face value and must then not be reversed. Where there is a clear lack of capacity, we need to err on the side of not allowing the death to take place, end of story.

And that probably means people will end up dying at an earlier stage of their illness, when they have capacity, but erring on the side of caution is the ethical thing to do.

My late father had dementia and was offered an advance directive in the Netherlands at an early stage when he absolutely did have capacity. He turned it down. Later on he changed his mind, but at that stage he had deteriorated so badly that he was deemed no longer able to consent. It was heartbreaking because in his lucid moments he knew very well what he had missed out on. It was a relief for all of us when the dementia progressed to the point that he no longer remembered at all. His care team followed the path of caution and rightly so.

LangClegsInSpace · 10/04/2023 20:44

Suzi888 · 10/04/2023 20:08

“At the time of death she did not want to die” But had dementia at the point she no longer wanted to die. She had no capacity. Her original wish stood (which had she been sound of mind she would probably have stood by). Imagine the ability to see what dementia had reduced you to. Dementia isn’t just not recognising family or remembering.

You forget how to chew, you forget how to swallow.

I've spent about 10 years caring for people with various kinds of dementia including attending deaths. I know what it's like.

50% of mentally sound terminally ill patients said they wanted assisted dying and then change their minds. Why do you think this would be different for dementia patients?

How do you know that 'had she been sound of mind she would probably have stood by' her original decision when 50% of people change their minds?

And when the human right to life is engaged, why do you think 'probably' is good enough?

Jonei · 10/04/2023 20:40

I agree LangClegsInSpace

LangClegsInSpace · 10/04/2023 20:20

Badbudgeter · 10/04/2023 19:35

Ethics committee in NL felt this was the right decision. The woman concerned had been very clear in her wishes that she didn’t want to live with dementia past a certain stage.

I have dementia in my family and I would also be very clear about my wishes not to live beyond a certain stage. I’m sorry it was distressing at the end. Her family obviously thought she’d made the right decision for her. It is unspeakably awful to watch an intelligent, proud, vivacious person slowly become a shell as dementia robs everything from them. I can completely understand someone making a decision that they don’t want to suffer that indignity.

Yes I know that's what the ethics committee in NL decided and I don't blame the individual medic who was acting within NL law.

Nevertheless, a woman was held down and killed when she did not want to die.

Did you miss this bit? - It doesn't matter what anyone else would or would not want for themselves in that situation, or what they now think they would want, or what this woman thought she would want when she signed.

'Sorry it was distressing at the end' is a wholely inadequate response to state sanctioned murder, even if her family approved (as if that would make things better). Sorry for the strong words but you can't even call it manslaughter because the intention was for her to die.

84% of the UK may be in favour (strongly or somewhat) of some form of assisted dying but I don't believe anywhere near that % would be in favour of a law that allowed this to happen. I hope I'm not wrong about that.

Suzi888 · 10/04/2023 20:08

“At the time of death she did not want to die” But had dementia at the point she no longer wanted to die. She had no capacity. Her original wish stood (which had she been sound of mind she would probably have stood by). Imagine the ability to see what dementia had reduced you to. Dementia isn’t just not recognising family or remembering.

You forget how to chew, you forget how to swallow.

Burgoo · 10/04/2023 20:04

Screw it, if I get dementia or end-stage cancer just knock me off! Don't let me wither away and die (esp with dementia where my whole personality is stripped away and I am pissing myself). We would see keeping a dog alive disgusting if it was suffering. Why should we torture people just cos we can spea?

LangClegsInSpace · 10/04/2023 19:58

The other thing to note about the Dignity in Dying survey is that there is not a huge difference between the attitudes of religious people and those with no religion.

82% Christians (44% strongly, 38% somewhat) supported the proposal compared with 84% of the overall sample (49% strongly, 35% somewhat). 90% with no religion supported the proposal (57% strongly, 32% somewhat).

The results for other religions were interesting - Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and 'Other' more in favour than the overall sample, Muslims significantly less so. But the numbers were tiny, e.g. 13 Sikhs surveyed compared with 2636 Christians and 2606 people with no religion.

So the idea that concerns are only being raised by religious people with 'sanctity of life' arguments is false.

MarshaBradyo · 10/04/2023 19:40

The dementia part of it is very difficult to deal with. The story below is very distressing.

At the same time I can see why any of us might say now we want the choice.

Badbudgeter · 10/04/2023 19:35

LangClegsInSpace · 10/04/2023 19:23

The Dignity in Dying survey that showed 84% in favour of assisted dying can be found here:

https://yonderconsulting.com/poll/dignity-in-dying/

It's worth digging down into both the question people were asked and the results.

A proposed new law would allow terminally ill adults the option of assisted dying. This would mean being provided with life-ending medication, to take themselves, if two doctors were satisfied they met all of the safeguards. They would need to be of sound mind, be terminally ill and have 6 months or less to live, and a High Court judge would have to be satisfied that they had made a voluntary, clear and settled decision to end their life, with time to consider all other options. Whether or not you would want the choice for yourself, do you support or oppose this proposal for assisted dying becoming law?

49% strongly supported this proposal and 35% somewhat supported it.

If I had been asked I would have said I 'somewhat' supported the proposal. I think the safeguards outlined in this proposal would be strong enough if health and social care, including EoL care, was not in such a dreadful mess.

I know palliative care is not a magic guarantee of a pain-free peaceful death but it's what most people still choose even in states where assisted dying is legal. It needs to be good enough so that people are not choosing AD out of fear of inadequate EoL care, or inadequate health and social care. In order to make assisted dying as safe as possible we need to make health, social and EoL care as good as possible. Some of the responses here terrify me.

A lot of people have talked about dementia. The proposal in this survey would not help them.

Advance directives are not safe because people change their minds.

In this survey, a small proportion of terminally ill patients seriously considered euthanasia or PAS for themselves. Over a few months, half the patients changed their minds.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/193281

There was a dreadful case in the NL a few years ago where a woman had signed an advance directive to be euthanased if she reached a certain stage of dementia. When the time came, the medic had to surreptitiously sedate her and then her family had to hold her down while she struggled against the lethal injection.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/26/doctor-on-trial-landmark-euthanasia-case-netherlands-dementia

It doesn't matter what anyone else would or would not want for themselves in that situation, or what they now think they would want, or what this woman thought she would want when she signed. At the time of death she did not want to die, she fought against it and she was deliberately killed by a medic.

I don't want any kind of law in the UK that would allow this. Unless someone can show a 'voluntary, clear and settled decision to end their life' at the time of their death then it's too dangerous.

Ethics committee in NL felt this was the right decision. The woman concerned had been very clear in her wishes that she didn’t want to live with dementia past a certain stage.

I have dementia in my family and I would also be very clear about my wishes not to live beyond a certain stage. I’m sorry it was distressing at the end. Her family obviously thought she’d made the right decision for her. It is unspeakably awful to watch an intelligent, proud, vivacious person slowly become a shell as dementia robs everything from them. I can completely understand someone making a decision that they don’t want to suffer that indignity.

LangClegsInSpace · 10/04/2023 19:23

The Dignity in Dying survey that showed 84% in favour of assisted dying can be found here:

https://yonderconsulting.com/poll/dignity-in-dying/

It's worth digging down into both the question people were asked and the results.

A proposed new law would allow terminally ill adults the option of assisted dying. This would mean being provided with life-ending medication, to take themselves, if two doctors were satisfied they met all of the safeguards. They would need to be of sound mind, be terminally ill and have 6 months or less to live, and a High Court judge would have to be satisfied that they had made a voluntary, clear and settled decision to end their life, with time to consider all other options. Whether or not you would want the choice for yourself, do you support or oppose this proposal for assisted dying becoming law?

49% strongly supported this proposal and 35% somewhat supported it.

If I had been asked I would have said I 'somewhat' supported the proposal. I think the safeguards outlined in this proposal would be strong enough if health and social care, including EoL care, was not in such a dreadful mess.

I know palliative care is not a magic guarantee of a pain-free peaceful death but it's what most people still choose even in states where assisted dying is legal. It needs to be good enough so that people are not choosing AD out of fear of inadequate EoL care, or inadequate health and social care. In order to make assisted dying as safe as possible we need to make health, social and EoL care as good as possible. Some of the responses here terrify me.

A lot of people have talked about dementia. The proposal in this survey would not help them.

Advance directives are not safe because people change their minds.

In this survey, a small proportion of terminally ill patients seriously considered euthanasia or PAS for themselves. Over a few months, half the patients changed their minds.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/193281

There was a dreadful case in the NL a few years ago where a woman had signed an advance directive to be euthanased if she reached a certain stage of dementia. When the time came, the medic had to surreptitiously sedate her and then her family had to hold her down while she struggled against the lethal injection.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/26/doctor-on-trial-landmark-euthanasia-case-netherlands-dementia

It doesn't matter what anyone else would or would not want for themselves in that situation, or what they now think they would want, or what this woman thought she would want when she signed. At the time of death she did not want to die, she fought against it and she was deliberately killed by a medic.

I don't want any kind of law in the UK that would allow this. Unless someone can show a 'voluntary, clear and settled decision to end their life' at the time of their death then it's too dangerous.

https://yonderconsulting.com/poll/dignity-in-dying

LangClegsInSpace · 10/04/2023 18:07

There is an current UK public inquiry on assisted dying/assisted suicide:

https://committees.parliament.uk/work/6906/assisted-dyingassisted-suicide/news/174845/mps-launch-new-inquiry-on-assisted-dyingassisted-suicide/

Public submissions closed on 20 Jan but they've had one live evidence session since then. I don't know if more are planned or if we're just waiting for their report now.

The terms of reference were:

  • To what extent do people in England and Wales have access to good palliative care?
  • How can palliative care be improved, and would such improvements negate some of the arguments for assisted dying/assisted suicide?
  • What can be learnt from the evidence in countries where assisted dying/assisted suicide is legal?
  • What are the professional and ethical considerations involved in allowing physicians to assist someone to end their life?
  • What, if any, are the physical and mental health criteria which would make an individual eligible to access assisted dying/assisted suicide services?
  • What protections could be put in place to protect people from coercion and how effective would these be?
  • What information, advice and guidance would people need in order to be able to make an informed decision about whether to access assisted dying/assisted suicide services?
  • What capabilities would a person need to be able to consent to assisted dying/assisted suicide?
  • What should the Government’s role be in relation to the debate?

These are the things we need to be thinking about.

Unfortunately these ToR were only really highlighted in the call for written submissions from professionals and organisations. Ordinary members of the public got sent to an anonymous survey asking simplified questions (IMO simplistic in parts) which I imagine will have mostly garnered the kind of simplistic responses that make up the bulk of this thread.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/04/2023 16:55

@Charley50, since I can’t (yet) request euthanasia in certain circumstances in my Health and Welfare Power of Attorney, I have requested firmly that in certain specific circumstances, i.e. if I can no longer care for myself and speak - with full mental capacity - for myself - then I emphatically do not want any life-saving or life-prolonging treatment. Palliative care only, please.,
In other words, no ‘striving to keep alive’.

This is something that everyone can do.

Of course you need to know that whoever will have P of A will do their best to abide by your wishes - I am pretty sure mine will.

From all I’ve ever read or heard, it’s often the family, rather than the medics, who ‘can’t bear to let him/her go’, and insist that everything possible must be done to keep someone going, when the kindest thing would be to give palliative care and let Nature take its course.

Charley50 · 10/04/2023 13:42

@GretaGood - no, i don't think we should ask care workers to murder patients with dementia.

I do think that now we know the horrors of long-term, severe dementia (the one where you can't speak, can't move aa you have forgotten how, can't eat independently, don't recognise anyone, are basically just existing, we should be able to add that into any euthanasia bill that is introduced. So that we can give consent for euthanasia before we lose capacity, in that situation.

I already have an advanced directive, to refuse antibiotics or other treatment if I am at that stage, but the option of euthanasia (if it becomes law generally) should be open for people who in future don't want to 'live' with severe dementia.

Wombatbum · 10/04/2023 13:34

It’s such a difficult subject.

It took my grandma 3 days to die from sepsis when they knew there was nothing more they could do. In that case surely the kindest thing would have been to put her out of her misery. They were still turning her up until she died and she was screaming in pain. That’s absolutely bonkers. Bedsores the least of her worries.

Having worked with severely disabled children I’d be worried about what would happen there.

Teenangels · 10/04/2023 13:28

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/04/2023 07:20

@Teenangels , I don’t understand why you couldn’t even wet your poor mother’s lips. During her last days I sat a lot with an aunt who had advanced dementia - we were given little sponges with which to keep her mouth moist, but not enough for her to need to swallow - this was in her very good care home.
She was consistently refusing food and drink, would close her mouth and turn her head away, and thankfully did not seem to be in any discomfort or distress.

We were told that the sponges were seen as a choke hazard, as she had started to bite down on things!

We were also told that even a small amount of liquid would choke my Mum, at this point they had stopped all oral medication and she was put on patches.

This was in her very good care home.

GretaGood · 10/04/2023 13:16

Charley50 · 10/04/2023 10:31

I think it's incredibly cruel to keep people with severe dementia (who are just shells really) alive for years, as I've seen happen.

But someone else deciding to kill someone is murder.
Or do you think someone else should kill them for you.

JackiePlace · 10/04/2023 12:06

My df is 90. He’s lonely and scared. Definitely has the beginnings of dementia. He’s also remarkably physically fit. I doubt he’ll die for a few years.

@Limetart what kind of a life do you think your father will have for those few years?
If he decided in a lucid moment that his life was no longer tolerable to him would you really deny him a peaceful ending with medical assistance?

Charley50 · 10/04/2023 10:31

NeonBoomerang · 09/04/2023 17:59

In my job I see people who are suffering and have no quality of life for years. Their care is expensive and they and their families are miserable. I absolutely do want euthanasia here.

I think it's incredibly cruel to keep people with severe dementia (who are just shells really) alive for years, as I've seen happen.

Luckydip1 · 10/04/2023 10:18

This is really about moving the decision/ choice from the government to the individual. As for the argument that you can't ask a doctor to kill someone, why should we ask them to keep someone alive if they are in terrible pain and want to die, as we do now?

Felixss · 10/04/2023 09:45

Anewuser · 10/04/2023 08:26

I’m scared of euthanasia.

I watched my dad die and it was awful. But whilst we had to watched him slowly disappear from the man he was, at least at the end he was made comfortable. For him, he made that decision to stop treatment so it was only a matter of time.

However, having a severely disabled adult child has shown me too many times where the medical team feel his quality of life is not high enough. He has been refused treatment and access to ICU. We have been told by professionals it’s only us keeping him alive. Who are they to decide he should be put down.

Euthanasia will always be a topic of contention. I’ve been on both sides of the argument but at least when it’s not legal means we won’t have hundreds/thousands of people being put to sleep before their time.

I'm sorry you are going through this to offer another view from HCP. ICU mechanical ventilation is very invasive and stressful for the person even if they are very fit. There's a high chance even a fit person won't come out the same let alone someone with underlying illnesses. None of the medical team I know want to deny people life we want them to go better but I do get annoyed when people do insist on treatment that isn't going to make the underlying illnesses go away. It is painful and invasive the end result will still be decline. I do sometimes wonder are relatives doing it for the person or for themselves because they cannot bare to let go.

Being asked to do treatment when it isn't in the person's best interests is also painful for the team.

MyopicBunny · 10/04/2023 09:29

You may have one government that would deliver this well, it doesn't mean the next one would continue to do so.

Yes, this is also how I feel about it.

pointythings · 10/04/2023 09:23

@Jonei because we know that it can be done well. Not perfectly, but well. My grandmother's experience is testament to that. Since 2002 when assisted dying was legalised in the Netherlands, there have largely been right wing governments. They have tweaked the legislation - tightening in some places, loosening in others. That's the reality of it - you bring in the law, you see some unintended consequences, you deal with them.

Sitting there going on about slippery slopes achieves nothing for the people who are suffering.

Jonei · 10/04/2023 09:19

And as I've said, it shouldn't be about getting rid of older people and this is why I wouldn't want to see legalisation under the current government because yes, they'd do it badly.

If you wouldn't want it under this government, then why would you want it under any government? You may have one government that would deliver this well, it doesn't mean the next one would continue to do so.

pointythings · 10/04/2023 08:50

I know immigration is up. That was always going to happen. But are worker shortages in care homes easing? From what I've seen, it's the opposite.

And as I've said, it shouldn't be about getting rid of older people and this is why I wouldn't want to see legalisation under the current government because yes, they'd do it badly.

But for people with a terminal diagnosis who want it, I completely fail to see why it can't be done. As it stands, I'm just counting myself lucky that I have the funds to do a Switzerland trip - as a Dutch person resident in the UK, I can't nip back home for it so it'll have to be that route.

SeeWhatYouGetWhenYouAskAStupidQuestion · 10/04/2023 08:34

herlightmaterials · 08/04/2023 00:53

But we really do need a way of making it possible for people to not die in agony. We wouldn't put a beloved pet through the suffering we subject ourselves and our family to. It's obscene.

Exactly this. As a care worker of many years, I saw so many people just existing in pain and discomfort