Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 12/04/2023 08:11

GoldenAye · 12/04/2023 02:17

@ChardonnaysBeastlyCat

And it was all fine GoldenAye, no one held you down, no one fed you benzos. You are still here to tell your tale.

Suzy’s statement is about someone’s clearly stated wishes. You had no such wishes, you did not express them, no one made you. And no one will.

No one makes you ask for assisted dying. Don’t do it if you don’t want it. Simple.

You are talking about a completely different scenario and you are unable to see past your own situation.

That's incredibly rude. I was discussing a situation I experienced when I couldn't communicate in any way for months in a medical environment and you think it's a completely different scenario? I was not able to state wishes. I could not advocate for myself. I wasn't dying, but I was extremely vulnerable. I was attempting to draw parallels for you as to how a dementia patient might feel - or someone who cannot find their voice to withdraw consent. I can see you didn't understand it.

Of course it's different.

You had no Advance Decision. You had not expressed any wishes in advance,

And I don't know, or want to know what your condition was, but it does not appear to have been terminal. You are highjacking a situation that was different to yours to make it all about your opinion.

So, yes, you were unwell, but why you felt someone might decide to finish your days on Earth is quite unclear.

AnneWeber · 12/04/2023 03:27

Felixss · 08/04/2023 01:47

Worked as a HCP for years watching people slowly decline they become immobile lose weight in pain, doubly incontinent, and dysphagia. It can take years as well. I'm not actually scared of dying anymore I'm scared to be in pain and have a really slow decline. I want bodily autonomy and I want mercy , l want a quick death for which we have the ability to do.

If I'm already dying a slow painful death why draw it out ?

I agree. I think we should have bodily autonomy

GoldenAye · 12/04/2023 02:20

@LangClegsInSpace

Advance decisions are valid when you lack capacity but you can only use them to refuse consent for medical treatments that you don't want. You can't use them to insist on any active treatment.

There is a huge difference between refusing consent for treatment that might prolong your life and demanding treatment that will actively end your life.

Surely you can see that? The two are not equivalent, legally or ethically.

Thank you - this is exactly what I've been trying to say.

GoldenAye · 12/04/2023 02:17

@ChardonnaysBeastlyCat

And it was all fine GoldenAye, no one held you down, no one fed you benzos. You are still here to tell your tale.

Suzy’s statement is about someone’s clearly stated wishes. You had no such wishes, you did not express them, no one made you. And no one will.

No one makes you ask for assisted dying. Don’t do it if you don’t want it. Simple.

You are talking about a completely different scenario and you are unable to see past your own situation.

That's incredibly rude. I was discussing a situation I experienced when I couldn't communicate in any way for months in a medical environment and you think it's a completely different scenario? I was not able to state wishes. I could not advocate for myself. I wasn't dying, but I was extremely vulnerable. I was attempting to draw parallels for you as to how a dementia patient might feel - or someone who cannot find their voice to withdraw consent. I can see you didn't understand it.

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 23:19

TrueScrumptious · 11/04/2023 19:08

www.ohe.org/publications/unrelieved-pain-palliative-care-england

In summary:

378,427 people receive palliative care a year in England.

125,971 end-of-life patients receiving, or in need of, palliative care suffer from unrelieved pain.

16,130 patients experience no relief from their pain at all in the last three months of life.

Some suffer unnecessarily because of variations in the quality of care.

Even if unrelieved pain rates were the same as they are in hospices, there would still be 50,709 dying in some level of pain.

5,298 would still experience no pain relief at all in the last three months of life.

These stats are quite encouraging.

378,427 people receive palliative care a year in England.

The study itself says '378,427 people died in 2017 with palliative care needs' which is a useful clarification and allows this figure to be directly compared with the others given.

125,971 end-of-life patients receiving, or in need of, palliative care suffer from unrelieved pain.

This is around 33%.

16,130 patients experience no relief from their pain at all in the last three months of life.

This is around 4%

Even if unrelieved pain rates were the same as they are in hospices, there would still be 50,709 dying in some level of pain.

This is around 13%

5,298 would still experience no pain relief at all in the last three months of life.

This is around 1%

So the majority of patients experience effective palliative pain relief. With the best care, we could reduce the number of patients experiencing only partial pain relief from 33% to 13% and the number of patients experiencing no pain relief from 4% to 1%.

Regardless of what we do about assisted dying, we should do this.

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 22:43

pointythings · 11/04/2023 19:33

@LangClegsInSpace I would argue passionately for the withdrawal of consent to be accepted and taken as the end point of the process in patients where capacity is impaired at the stage where euthanasia is to be carried out. I don't think anything else would be ethical.

I agree.

I just don't think it's safe to allow assisted dying by advance decision. Unless you have clear, valid consent at the point of death then you might be killing someone who does not want to die.

If you are evaluating whether someone consents or not to you deliberately and actively ending their life then you'd better be bloody well sure they consent before you proceed.

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 22:32

Felixss · 11/04/2023 19:51

If advanced decisions aren't valid when you lack capacity what's the point in making one ? I'm horrified that something you have written down when sound of mind could be discarded. In late stage dementia I would not be the person I was because of the damage to the brain. She didn't know what was going to happen nor could she retain the information.

When she started to resist the doctor should have stopped , then come back another time and sedated properly instead of carrying on they should have been disciplined for that. That was bad practice but legally an advanced decision overrides when you lack capacity. You wouldn't let someone who lacked capacity sign legal documents as it wouldn't be valid.

It's most likely I will develop dementia as I'm female, I'm terrified of being agitated and scared 24/7. I would rather die than live for years like that. I've seen so many who are confused and terrified it's horrible. Even with the drugs and behavioural therapies it doesn't seem to help some people.

Advance decisions are valid when you lack capacity but you can only use them to refuse consent for medical treatments that you don't want. You can't use them to insist on any active treatment.

There is a huge difference between refusing consent for treatment that might prolong your life and demanding treatment that will actively end your life.

Surely you can see that? The two are not equivalent, legally or ethically.

Felixss · 11/04/2023 19:51

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 19:11

A few posters here, including you, think that if someone signs an advance directive requesting euthanasia if they develop dementia then they should be held to that directive and euthanased even if showing extreme resistance and having to be held down to administer the drugs.

Here are your words:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4780333-euthanasie-dont-legalise-in-uk?page=15&reply=125336123

A woman was held down and killed when she did not want to die. You think holding her down and administering the drugs against her will was the right thing to do.

What safeguards would you put in place?

You seem very passionate about legalising assisted dying, have you worked out exactly what you are asking for? What you would like the law to say?

If advanced decisions aren't valid when you lack capacity what's the point in making one ? I'm horrified that something you have written down when sound of mind could be discarded. In late stage dementia I would not be the person I was because of the damage to the brain. She didn't know what was going to happen nor could she retain the information.

When she started to resist the doctor should have stopped , then come back another time and sedated properly instead of carrying on they should have been disciplined for that. That was bad practice but legally an advanced decision overrides when you lack capacity. You wouldn't let someone who lacked capacity sign legal documents as it wouldn't be valid.

It's most likely I will develop dementia as I'm female, I'm terrified of being agitated and scared 24/7. I would rather die than live for years like that. I've seen so many who are confused and terrified it's horrible. Even with the drugs and behavioural therapies it doesn't seem to help some people.

pointythings · 11/04/2023 19:33

@LangClegsInSpace I would argue passionately for the withdrawal of consent to be accepted and taken as the end point of the process in patients where capacity is impaired at the stage where euthanasia is to be carried out. I don't think anything else would be ethical.

Everydayshouldbe · 11/04/2023 19:20

pointythings · 11/04/2023 14:14

I am very happy for you.

Your mother's experience is not what happens to everyone. Palliative care does not provide sufficient or sufficiently effective pain relief for everyone.

I'm assuming this poster was putting forward her experience as a balance to the experiences elsewhere on the thread, eg the poster who said that as she had witnessed a death from cancer, she was all for euthanasia.

If one personal experience counts, so does the other.

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 19:11

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 11/04/2023 18:10

No one is calling for people who don't want to die, to die.

There will be a laws and safeguards. No one is setting out to intentionally cause someone else's death.

So yes, dial it down.

A few posters here, including you, think that if someone signs an advance directive requesting euthanasia if they develop dementia then they should be held to that directive and euthanased even if showing extreme resistance and having to be held down to administer the drugs.

Here are your words:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4780333-euthanasie-dont-legalise-in-uk?page=15&reply=125336123

A woman was held down and killed when she did not want to die. You think holding her down and administering the drugs against her will was the right thing to do.

What safeguards would you put in place?

You seem very passionate about legalising assisted dying, have you worked out exactly what you are asking for? What you would like the law to say?

TrueScrumptious · 11/04/2023 19:08

www.ohe.org/publications/unrelieved-pain-palliative-care-england

In summary:

378,427 people receive palliative care a year in England.

125,971 end-of-life patients receiving, or in need of, palliative care suffer from unrelieved pain.

16,130 patients experience no relief from their pain at all in the last three months of life.

Some suffer unnecessarily because of variations in the quality of care.

Even if unrelieved pain rates were the same as they are in hospices, there would still be 50,709 dying in some level of pain.

5,298 would still experience no pain relief at all in the last three months of life.

Unrelieved Pain in Palliative Care in England - OHE

In England, an estimated 378,427 people receive palliative care each year in a range of specialised and generalised services. Overall, the quality of palliative care in England and the wider UK is widely regarded as excellent. However, despite the gene...

https://www.ohe.org/publications/unrelieved-pain-palliative-care-england

MarshaBradyo · 11/04/2023 18:51

There is always something who will slip through the safeguards.

The trouble is if this is the case and people accept there will be some failings the result is severe. Ie death when not wanted

I get the arguments for but this seems very difficult

pointythings · 11/04/2023 18:44

@AskMeMore as has now been said many times on this thread, palliative care does not work for everyone. Please, please get that through your head and preferably into your heart.

This should not be a zero sum game. We need outstanding palliative care alongside the option of assisted dying so that people have a choice when palliative care fails them.

TrueScrumptious · 11/04/2023 18:43

AskMeMore · 11/04/2023 18:36

You can have well managed deaths with good painkillers. My parents both had this. We should be campaigning for everyone to have a good death.

But not everyone can, though. Because the painkillers don’t work on some people and some diseases. Even with the very best palliative care available. It’s very naive to think that. It’s great that your parents had pain-free deaths. But not everyone gets that - even with the best palliative cate available. I think it’s about a third of people don’t. I’ll have to look up the stats. They are very, very sobering. Yes, we should campaign for better palliative care, but that won’t solve the problem.

AskMeMore · 11/04/2023 18:36

You can have well managed deaths with good painkillers. My parents both had this. We should be campaigning for everyone to have a good death.

TrueScrumptious · 11/04/2023 18:12

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 17:48

@AskMeMore is right. Deliberately causing the death of someone who does not want to die is murder.

What would you call it?

Eh? But that’s not what it’s about. Why have you just invented that?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 11/04/2023 18:10

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 17:48

@AskMeMore is right. Deliberately causing the death of someone who does not want to die is murder.

What would you call it?

No one is calling for people who don't want to die, to die.

There will be a laws and safeguards. No one is setting out to intentionally cause someone else's death.

So yes, dial it down.

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 17:48

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 11/04/2023 16:44

Dial down the drama.

@AskMeMore is right. Deliberately causing the death of someone who does not want to die is murder.

What would you call it?

TrueScrumptious · 11/04/2023 17:36

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 17:18

Yes, it's frightening.

What’s frightening is having to endure a long and painful death, and knowing you are going to have to go through it, without any person or any medication to ease your suffering.

Badbudgeter · 11/04/2023 17:24

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 17:18

Yes, it's frightening.

I don't find it frightening. It's normally a consequence of witnessing a relative or beloved person die in a slow and awful manner which strips them of dignity. I wouldn't want that for myself if given the choice. I'd hope that my choice would be respected when I became too demented to care for myself.

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 17:18

DemiColon · 11/04/2023 10:20

The fact that so many people are ok with the idea of administering death to someone who no longer wants it, is pretty good evidence of why this kind of legislation is so dangerous and why safeguards in place are unlikely to remain.

Yes, it's frightening.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 11/04/2023 16:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BotterMon · 11/04/2023 16:49

I am pro human euthanasia. Belgium and The Netherlands seem to have got it right.

A lot of safeguards need to surround it however. I know far too many family members of vulnerable elderly people who can't wait to get their greedy mits on the money.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 11/04/2023 16:44

AskMeMore · 11/04/2023 14:01

So you do not care if people re murdered?

Dial down the drama.

Swipe left for the next trending thread