Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:12

WandaWonder · 08/04/2023 02:08

If it can be proven it is 100% of the persons decision with no pressure from anyone I don't think any of us can have an opinion

So you want to be left dying slowly in pain when you know the medics do have a way of quickly easing your suffering?

I have a problem with other people refusing but it's about bodily autonomy, my cat has more chance of a painless death than I do. I'm not religious I don't believe in God so what has it got to do with anyone else how I wish to die ?

Fleetwoodmac23 · 08/04/2023 02:11

Yes people need to be able to die with dignity
We allow it for animals wii can’t speak why not humans

WandaWonder · 08/04/2023 02:08

If it can be proven it is 100% of the persons decision with no pressure from anyone I don't think any of us can have an opinion

Mariposista · 08/04/2023 02:06

I watched my beloved gran die last Wednesday, at home, after several days of absolute agony, no dignity, horrible pain and discomfort despite the wonderful EOL nurses and carers' best efforts. I will never forget it, or how she looked at us, unable to communicate but just pleading 'help me', and we couldn't do anything else. She was the person we loved the most in the world but it was a blessing when she did finally go, as watching that was worse than any sadness we are feeling now.
I just said that I hope the law has changed when it is my turn to go - as many have said here, you wouldn't let a dog suffer like that.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:06

The government will legalise it not because they want to give citizens bodily autonomy but because we have an aging population with increased comorbidities and it's very expensive to keep people alive with a lack of young adults paying taxes. The government will view it as a way to save money It's coming so it's best to prepare for how it will work with safeguards. I think it shouldn't be allowed for functional MH issues it should be for progressive terminal conditions.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 02:04

Felixss · 08/04/2023 01:53

Harold Shipman fucked everything up in regards to palliative care prescribing . People say it's cruel to leave animals in agony we do it to humans day in day out. It's more the choice is taken away away from us who don't want a long drawn out death.

I'm not scared of death anymore there's worse things being lay in bed stuck in the foetal position limbs fixed , incontinent loss of speech , no interest in food. I'm shocked how long it can take to die with the medical advances but a low quality of life.

It's really sad people are having to pay 10k to travel to a foreign country and do assisted suicide before they feel ready because of the laws.

Shipman was a complete maniac. Murdering women for their money..Didn't that rogue also falsify the victim's wills in his favour?..Sickening.

A pharmacy locally said Shipman caused a lot of things to change around prescribing of opiates/opioids.

It was a sharp eyed pharmacist who noticed Shipman was getting through large quantities of opiates {if I recall correctly}

TheVeganCheeseTax · 08/04/2023 02:04

I want it. I want control of my death. Death can be brutal for the individual, and for the family and friends that can only watch on helpless. It doesn’t need to be that way and it’s crazy that we can’t choose.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 08/04/2023 02:01

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 01:55

A lot of Canadians struggle to find a GP. And even more find it hard to access MH and addiction support. 1/4 of a million people experience homelessness each year.

I have no faith that mentally ill people who are living in poverty won't be 'assisted' to die. Rather than providing decent healthcare.

You're probably right in your last paragraph, but with a failing NHS, people living longer and with no pension, I don't think there's going to be any chance to provide better health care in the future in most cases.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:01

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 01:51

A friend works with people with Dementia,In a Private nursing home {well regarded locally}..She had to undergo training to work there, and to her utter surprise, loves it.

she says she ''Spends most of the day laughing, with the staff and residents''..

However..the home is extremely expensive.

It clearly has a good level of care, and vets staff thoroughly so residents are assisted properly.

Erm I'm not sure where your friend has worked. Dementia is a massive variable disease so people are content , some people are definitely not some will yell "Help , Help " "I'm scared" "Mummy" "When am I going to die?"."I want to go to bed" all day all night , some refuse food and seem to have withdrawn from the world There's only so much calming medications you can give. I'm not scared of dying I'm scared of being afraid and terrified.

I don't want a slow decline , I want to be pain free and content. I don't cope well with when Im in pain. I want company and comforting that's not going to happen with the care home ratios, it would be in my best interests if I'm unhappy and declining to let me go. It's really about bodily autonomy we should get more of a choice.

If people want to be alive that's fine but people should be able to choose if they don't want their life to be extended. Right now all you can do is refuse life sustaining treatment, starve dehydrate to death. Isn't an injection much more humane for the people who want it?

ScattyHattie · 08/04/2023 01:59

My dogs have always passed in seconds & very peacefully with euthanasia injection so I'd definitely opt for that over a natural death which is often prolonged and would be deemed inhumane for animals. Not sure I'd necessarily say terminal Illness only either as I think it's very individual what they'd deem a poor quality of life rather than necessarily a medical view.

I read an article about leathal injection given prisoners not being like that but it seems mainly as difficult to employ experienced medics and pharma don't really want to be involved when it's executions rather than euthanasia which should be the individuals choice.

Of course there needs to be measures in place to avoid pressure being put on vulnerable people or like with COVID when Do Not Resusitate were added without consent on disabled peoples records. I'd also not like to see it develop into a world where only the wealthy can afford to live a long life and rest having to opt for euthanasia when no longer deemed functional & able to pay your way, given we already live in fairly ableist society.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 01:55

Noicant · 08/04/2023 01:50

I think Canada are expanding it to include mental illness. I find that a bit concerning. But people should have the right to end their lives in dignity if they wish as lomg as they are carefully screened.

A lot of Canadians struggle to find a GP. And even more find it hard to access MH and addiction support. 1/4 of a million people experience homelessness each year.

I have no faith that mentally ill people who are living in poverty won't be 'assisted' to die. Rather than providing decent healthcare.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 01:53

This reply has been deleted

Mentions method of assisted dying.

Harold Shipman fucked everything up in regards to palliative care prescribing . People say it's cruel to leave animals in agony we do it to humans day in day out. It's more the choice is taken away away from us who don't want a long drawn out death.

I'm not scared of death anymore there's worse things being lay in bed stuck in the foetal position limbs fixed , incontinent loss of speech , no interest in food. I'm shocked how long it can take to die with the medical advances but a low quality of life.

It's really sad people are having to pay 10k to travel to a foreign country and do assisted suicide before they feel ready because of the laws.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 01:51

Req · 08/04/2023 01:45

I work with people with dementia. They all want to live, the people I know. This is clear from the way their survival instincts kick in daily. Before they had dementia, they may well have been horrified at how the condition would develop in themselves and say they wanted to be euthanized at a certain point. But, the person they are now has the right to live, however uncomfortable it may be for other people to experience the manifestations of their symptoms. Euthanasia without a robust process of informed consent is murder. I'm sure no one could argue for that.

I support the rights of people to end their lives if they are capacitous. We need to ensure we are crystal clear on what that means and how it looks in practice.

A friend works with people with Dementia,In a Private nursing home {well regarded locally}..She had to undergo training to work there, and to her utter surprise, loves it.

she says she ''Spends most of the day laughing, with the staff and residents''..

However..the home is extremely expensive.

It clearly has a good level of care, and vets staff thoroughly so residents are assisted properly.

Noicant · 08/04/2023 01:50

I think Canada are expanding it to include mental illness. I find that a bit concerning. But people should have the right to end their lives in dignity if they wish as lomg as they are carefully screened.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 01:50

Canada has a habit of taking really good ideas and fucking them up really badly.

There is no need to follow their example. The UK can have decent ethics around it. Although I wouldn't put the Tories in charge of decent ethics in healthcare.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 01:47

Worked as a HCP for years watching people slowly decline they become immobile lose weight in pain, doubly incontinent, and dysphagia. It can take years as well. I'm not actually scared of dying anymore I'm scared to be in pain and have a really slow decline. I want bodily autonomy and I want mercy , l want a quick death for which we have the ability to do.

If I'm already dying a slow painful death why draw it out ?

LightDrizzle · 08/04/2023 01:45

This reply has been deleted

Mentions method of assisted dying.

Req · 08/04/2023 01:45

I work with people with dementia. They all want to live, the people I know. This is clear from the way their survival instincts kick in daily. Before they had dementia, they may well have been horrified at how the condition would develop in themselves and say they wanted to be euthanized at a certain point. But, the person they are now has the right to live, however uncomfortable it may be for other people to experience the manifestations of their symptoms. Euthanasia without a robust process of informed consent is murder. I'm sure no one could argue for that.

I support the rights of people to end their lives if they are capacitous. We need to ensure we are crystal clear on what that means and how it looks in practice.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 01:40

Doingtheboxerbeat · 08/04/2023 00:53

Yes I do absolutely want this. I am looking at a bleak old age and I can't afford the £10,000 to go to Switzerland. I know this sounds grim but life can be for many.

£10,000??

Yikes!

When my beloved pet was Euthanised at home, the drug {which is the same as used for humans, most likely} was just £4.
The vet's visit was £60.

£10,000...Someone is making a monstrous profit out of euthanasia.

magicthree · 08/04/2023 01:39

Surely the UK can make its own rules and doesn't have to blindly follow Canada? It's legal where I live (fairly recent) but seems to be working okay.

Nat6999 · 08/04/2023 01:39

We need voluntary euthanasia, I watched my dad die from renal failure & would have done anything to end his suffering. I have multiple chronic health conditions & am nearly in a wheelchair, I don't want ds to have to be responsible for caring for me in the future, he already cares for me sometimes as well as his dad. I want to go when I want & in my own home, not in a hospital.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 01:36

HermioneWeasley · 08/04/2023 01:26

Canada doesn’t seem to have any safeguards at all for this. Euthanasia with proper safeguards is entirely proper and necessary

Completely agree...One cannot have greedy relatives forcing euthanasia drugs onto their aged relatives just because the replies want the inheritance!

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 01:34

I'd want a peaceful Euthanasia for myself if I became so affected by Dementia {That's the one most people fear} that I couldn't recognise my own son.. and had trauma with it..

A lovely woman locally had Dementia that caused her to rant and rave in a very upsetting manner, as if she was locked into an eternal ''Bad Trip''..That is absolutely awful.
Poor woman no way needed to suffer like that.

However...One needs to give informed consent.

If one is so far gone with dementia..can one do that?

Animals aren't allowed to suffer if they are terminally ill.

A kindly vet can come to the animal's house or field and end their life before symptoms become distressing for the animal.

HermioneWeasley · 08/04/2023 01:26

Canada doesn’t seem to have any safeguards at all for this. Euthanasia with proper safeguards is entirely proper and necessary

SNWannabe · 08/04/2023 01:24

Do you see what people go through when they’re dying here in the Uk? Do you know how many days or weeks or even months it can take? Have you watched a loved one disappear day by day before your eyes? Or have you had your life savings drained through years of Funding care for a loved one?
Death “by injection” would be much like getting a GA and falling asleep- not painful, not scary, controlled and legislated.

Why wouldn’t anyone want to have that option at least???