Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
4plusthehound · 08/04/2023 03:35

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 01:50

Canada has a habit of taking really good ideas and fucking them up really badly.

There is no need to follow their example. The UK can have decent ethics around it. Although I wouldn't put the Tories in charge of decent ethics in healthcare.

I am intrigued MrsTerryPrachett.

I thought they were supposed to relaxed and nice.

Can you give an example?

AnyaMarx · 08/04/2023 03:32

My friend went to Switzerland to dignitas. She had had a stroke and tried rehabilitation for 2 years- she could not function without 24 hour care . She could barely speak , but her mind was in tact . She needed help with every basic human function and she hated it .

Her family were subjected to a two year criminal investigation.

Absolutely ludicrous.

She made her choice and it cost thousands as the family had to charter a plane . Her daughter is a very famous journalist and she is now campaigning for others .

Bottom line- if I want to end my life in a dignified way who the fuck else's business is that ?

Tockomtele · 08/04/2023 03:26

I'd love to see an example of a country where it works with proper safeguards.

Children (who on default don't have capacity) are allowed to 'choose' euthanasia in some places.
Or people with mental health problems who can be suicidal as a symptom. Let's not forget about health inequalities and the lack of mental healthcare provisions.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 03:15

Youdoyoubabe · 08/04/2023 02:51

I think we should have it. Also a maximum age by which you have to check out by somwhere between 75 and 95. Then the government and families can plan more easily financially. If you want to you could do something like 'buy' extra years. Or there could be like an annual lottery or draw where you can put your name in to get extra years. Something like that. I have often mulled on this during insomniac hours of the night.

That sounds like a dystopian nightmare.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 03:10

lemmein · 08/04/2023 02:51

I don't see what's wrong with this though?

There isn't an endless pot of money; it makes little sense to me to spend ££ forcing somebody to endure a slow painful death when that money could be spent elsewhere.

I don't think there's anything wrong with it I'm pro patient requested euthanasia for terminal progressive condition.
The government won't legalise euthanasia to give us bodily autonomy and the right to a peaceful death, they will do it to save money. It's best we stop debating if it will be legalised, it's more a when. Society needs to start discussing the appropriate safeguards we want before the government do.

Youdoyoubabe · 08/04/2023 02:51

I think we should have it. Also a maximum age by which you have to check out by somwhere between 75 and 95. Then the government and families can plan more easily financially. If you want to you could do something like 'buy' extra years. Or there could be like an annual lottery or draw where you can put your name in to get extra years. Something like that. I have often mulled on this during insomniac hours of the night.

lemmein · 08/04/2023 02:51

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:06

The government will legalise it not because they want to give citizens bodily autonomy but because we have an aging population with increased comorbidities and it's very expensive to keep people alive with a lack of young adults paying taxes. The government will view it as a way to save money It's coming so it's best to prepare for how it will work with safeguards. I think it shouldn't be allowed for functional MH issues it should be for progressive terminal conditions.

I don't see what's wrong with this though?

There isn't an endless pot of money; it makes little sense to me to spend ££ forcing somebody to endure a slow painful death when that money could be spent elsewhere.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:44

AskMeMore · 08/04/2023 02:28

I sadly know all about dying. The Liverpool Pathway was forced on people prematurely. Reports of patients begging for water with one patient drinking water from a vase. Very different from the natural process of the body shutting down and patients n longer wanting to eat or drink.

The Liverpool care pathway was subject to hysteria by the media they now follow the gold standards framework which is similar. If someone is requesting food drink and they can process and swallow it of course they should have it. They should also be given regular mouth care to prevent a dry mouth.

Relatives quite often will try to feed because we associate feeding with love and helping them get better even if they are in the last days of life . They also can misunderstand the process of cachexia which is wasting so assume that the staff must be starving them. It's common to have wasting in terminal illness and being unable to swallow. It's also common to start withdrawing from the world , a syringe driver is a kindness for the person.

The media and misunderstanding was why it got a bad reputation. I'm sure some staff didn't use correctly but the LCP was designed to minimise pain and suffering.

nicetoseetgesunsout · 08/04/2023 02:39

Obviously my grandfather requested that his doctor / friend did this and asked my Nan, aunt and mum to agree. This was in the 60s. My nan sadly suffered with dementia and had two strokes. I wish we were able to let her go peacefully, as she wanted and had said so many times when she still had mental capacity.
Both of my parents (In their late 70s/80s) say often that if they end up like my nan, can I please suffocate them. I can't and I won't, but allowing them to have a dignified, painless death would be my preference.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 02:38

lemmein · 08/04/2023 02:26

I believe it's a personal decision and like abortion I would say if you don't agree with euthanasia, or assisted dying then don't request it - simple! Let others choose for themselves though.

I would include mental illness in that too - nobody should have the right to tell others they must continue living in a constant hell, mental pain can be every bit as consuming and life-limiting as physical pain.

Besides, banning things doesn't stop them from happening, people still end their lives but with risky methods which can have grave consequences if the suicide isn't completed.I know somebody who attempted to hang himself in his 20s and has been in a care home ever since with severe brain damage. What an horrific life society has made him endure without his consent Sad

That is tragic.

A train driver I knew had to quit working as a train driver after a Suicide incident.

It caused the driver extreme guilt and made him ill, as he would see it over and over in his mind's eye.

It is a difficult topic, and tricky to know how to make it legally watertight and humane.

People have survived suicide attempts and been ''So thankful to have been given another chance to rebuild their lives'' {Quoted from a Survivor}

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 02:30

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:20

I work in a specialist complex care unit it's basically 5 star funded by the NHS. So it's nothing to do with carers/nurses most patients are on a 1:1 ratio. it's the best place I've worked it's the nature of the disease that it's uncertain. I've worked with some people who are content with dementia and some who are really not. It's a roll of a dice of what impact it has. If I was suffering and afraid I would want it to be quick.

Quite possibly my friend hasn't yet seen people who are really distressed yet, because she is new at the job.

Our neighbour with ''Bad trip'' type dementia, poor woman was wearing about ten layers of clothing on a sweltering hot day, and had locked herself out of her house, and was begging and pleading to be let back in.

I tried to help her, {We did get her in eventually} but she said ''Who are you! Go away!'' while banging on her windows and shouting at invisible people inside the house, and in cars parked outside.

She had been a friendly and mild mannered person before developing Dementia.
It was very distressing to witness, but must have been far, far worse for the poor Neighbour.

AskMeMore · 08/04/2023 02:28

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:22

Well the public have no idea about the dying process. They seem to think the dying can eat and drink normally they can't. If you force food and drink on someone actively dying with no swallow reflex they can choke to death causing even more distress.

I sadly know all about dying. The Liverpool Pathway was forced on people prematurely. Reports of patients begging for water with one patient drinking water from a vase. Very different from the natural process of the body shutting down and patients n longer wanting to eat or drink.

lemmein · 08/04/2023 02:26

I believe it's a personal decision and like abortion I would say if you don't agree with euthanasia, or assisted dying then don't request it - simple! Let others choose for themselves though.

I would include mental illness in that too - nobody should have the right to tell others they must continue living in a constant hell, mental pain can be every bit as consuming and life-limiting as physical pain.

Besides, banning things doesn't stop them from happening, people still end their lives but with risky methods which can have grave consequences if the suicide isn't completed.I know somebody who attempted to hang himself in his 20s and has been in a care home ever since with severe brain damage. What an horrific life society has made him endure without his consent Sad

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:25

WandaWonder · 08/04/2023 02:16

Huh? If the person dying is making thr decision for themselves with no pressure from anyone else no one should have an opinion

Not sure how many other ways I can say it is up to person dying only to decide

I worded it wrong people should be free to decline . I'm not religious I don't believe in God so religious people should have no say in the way I die. I think euthanasia should be opt in only , it should only be the patient that requests and they should be allowed to request as part of advanced care planning. A doctor shouldn't be allowed to mention it.

user1477391263 · 08/04/2023 02:25

There is a place for assisted dying. To be honest, however, that place is probably not Canada, which now has a track record when it comes to falling down really stupid rabbit holes and failing to do proper safeguarding on this kind of thing (see also, trans).

WhyCantYourPartnerDoIt · 08/04/2023 02:22

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 01:19

Le Monde, article in French

That’s not how you cite things! Link please?

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:22

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 02:21

The thing is..If someone was to supply you a drug to end your life, they could be potentially charged your murder.

Well the law needs to change and it will.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:22

AskMeMore · 08/04/2023 02:15

It would be another Liverpool Pathway disaster. Introduced for the right reasons, but would quickly lead to many scandals.

Well the public have no idea about the dying process. They seem to think the dying can eat and drink normally they can't. If you force food and drink on someone actively dying with no swallow reflex they can choke to death causing even more distress.

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 02:21

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:12

So you want to be left dying slowly in pain when you know the medics do have a way of quickly easing your suffering?

I have a problem with other people refusing but it's about bodily autonomy, my cat has more chance of a painless death than I do. I'm not religious I don't believe in God so what has it got to do with anyone else how I wish to die ?

The thing is..If someone was to supply you a drug to end your life, they could be potentially charged your murder.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:20

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 02:14

Obviously I won't mention the place where she works, but it has changed her views about Dementia. With enough trained staff who want to be there..it does seem to make a real difference.

She has worked there for about 18 months.

I completely agree with you, the thought of Dementia terrifies me..I'd rather euthanasia.

Seems care homes vary a lot.

I work in a specialist complex care unit it's basically 5 star funded by the NHS. So it's nothing to do with carers/nurses most patients are on a 1:1 ratio. it's the best place I've worked it's the nature of the disease that it's uncertain. I've worked with some people who are content with dementia and some who are really not. It's a roll of a dice of what impact it has. If I was suffering and afraid I would want it to be quick.

nicetoseetgesunsout · 08/04/2023 02:16

Absolutely want it here. My grandfather was humanely put to sleep by his doctor who was also a great friend. This happened after discussion with my grandmother, my sister and aunt. He was in a lot of pain and suffering from an illness from which he would never recover and there isn't any remedy.
When my grandmother, his wife, was very ill, my mum and my aunt (her two daughters) both said that they wished that they could do for her as happened to grandad. Sadly, Doctor had passed by then. We all had to watch my beloved Nan die an awful death. She couldn't walk, talk, eat and didn't even recognise us.
Surely it would have better for her to be put to sleep than just survive for another year, laying in a hospital bed, not understanding where she was.
I definitely think so.

WandaWonder · 08/04/2023 02:16

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:12

So you want to be left dying slowly in pain when you know the medics do have a way of quickly easing your suffering?

I have a problem with other people refusing but it's about bodily autonomy, my cat has more chance of a painless death than I do. I'm not religious I don't believe in God so what has it got to do with anyone else how I wish to die ?

Huh? If the person dying is making thr decision for themselves with no pressure from anyone else no one should have an opinion

Not sure how many other ways I can say it is up to person dying only to decide

AskMeMore · 08/04/2023 02:15

It would be another Liverpool Pathway disaster. Introduced for the right reasons, but would quickly lead to many scandals.

Wellillsayitifnooneelsewill · 08/04/2023 02:15

herlightmaterials · 08/04/2023 00:52

We want it but we need to use Canada as a cautionary tale. Their ethics committees seems to care about who they can bump off on the basis that it would be cheaper and they apply moral pressure to people by telling them how much they're costing - unbelievable. I would have thought the ethics was ensuring nobody felt under pressure to choose death, not making a song and dance about wasting resources.

I agree that ethically this is wrong.

For me it should be a choice made be and instigated by an individual either verbally or through a very specific pre-consent with specific criteria etc (such as medical conditions/criteria that must be met as per patients wishes) and that is regularly updated to a point where it can be said to be current (eg: if someone renews consent annually but then ends up 6months later in a condition where they wouldn’t want to live then that would be better than an agreement 20 years old and maybe forgotten about)

i also feel that euthanasia should only be mentioned as an option by drs if such an agreement exists/patient has said it’s their wish (unless it’s in the context of withdrawing medical life support for a patient that can’t recover these functions to survive in much the same way they already do). I find it shocking that Canada thinks it’s ethically ok to ask next of kin to consider it as an alternative to lifelong care/treatment

oakleaffy · 08/04/2023 02:14

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:01

Erm I'm not sure where your friend has worked. Dementia is a massive variable disease so people are content , some people are definitely not some will yell "Help , Help " "I'm scared" "Mummy" "When am I going to die?"."I want to go to bed" all day all night , some refuse food and seem to have withdrawn from the world There's only so much calming medications you can give. I'm not scared of dying I'm scared of being afraid and terrified.

I don't want a slow decline , I want to be pain free and content. I don't cope well with when Im in pain. I want company and comforting that's not going to happen with the care home ratios, it would be in my best interests if I'm unhappy and declining to let me go. It's really about bodily autonomy we should get more of a choice.

If people want to be alive that's fine but people should be able to choose if they don't want their life to be extended. Right now all you can do is refuse life sustaining treatment, starve dehydrate to death. Isn't an injection much more humane for the people who want it?

Obviously I won't mention the place where she works, but it has changed her views about Dementia. With enough trained staff who want to be there..it does seem to make a real difference.

She has worked there for about 18 months.

I completely agree with you, the thought of Dementia terrifies me..I'd rather euthanasia.

Seems care homes vary a lot.