Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Headoutofplace · 08/04/2023 05:27

I don't think euthanasia should be legalized in the way it has been in Canada and certainly shouldn't be an option just because someone's old but otherwise relatively healthy. But I do think there should be options opened up for more focus on pain relief and the option to prioritise pain relief over extending life (with solid safeguards and at the patient's request, not decided for the patient), so someone can decide they want DNR and maximum pain relief and if that ends their life then so be it. The idea should be that end of life/very ill patients should have control (with 2 doctors approving) over prioritising pain relief even if that threatens their life rather than focusing on euthanasia.

ProstituteHair · 08/04/2023 05:23

Well, it's a tricksy one, isn't it.

When the state becomes involved in the business of death I'd say that opens the door to state-legislated death. I'm more in favour of a legal fudge whereby it's accepted that certain drugs can be applied at the behest of the individual but it's not really the business of the state.

So it's accepted as a request in extremis and will not be prosecuted, but it's not on the statute books.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 05:22

GretaGood · 08/04/2023 05:13

write VERY clearly that you do not want antibiotics after a certain deterioration in your situation otherwise each time your condition deteriorates they (the docs/nurses) will pump you full so you lurch on in a deteriorated state until you eventually die of starvation and lack of fluids.
Hopefully the morphine syringe driver means You are oblivious of the hunger/ thirst pangs, the aching body and parched and shrivelled mouth but who knows.

Sadly yes this happens also looking like you have been in a concentration camp with the wasting. Dying unfortunately takes a long time for a lot of people. I'm thankful the Queen had a quick death I think she may had an advanced decision, she was up and about smiling a few days before. I hope mine is the same. Unfortunately yes the only choice we have is to refuse antibiotics and starve plus hope we get adequate pain relief in our overstretched health system. 😩

JacobsCrackersCheeseFogg · 08/04/2023 05:20

There are so many people in my family who would have taken advantage of VAD if given the opportunity. And it would have saved us a lot of heartache.

I saw an ad where a woman in Canada was too much in debt or bankrupt and she chose to die rather than get help for her problems. I think that's unethical. Canada's VAD laws are too lax.

But if a person is expected to have a protracted death from terminal illness then I'm in favour. I agree 2 doctors should agree before going ahead. I would want this if this was the case for me. I don't want my family to have memories of my decline, or be a burden on them.

GretaGood · 08/04/2023 05:17

Thing is - you might be aged and decrepit but you family around you aren’t, your nieces and nephews, cute grandchildren - who wants to leave DCs for a last time.

GretaGood · 08/04/2023 05:15

. Also a maximum age by which you have to check out by somwhere between 75 and 95.

I imagine this poster is 74 and struggling with her decision - not!

GoldenAye · 08/04/2023 05:14

Youdoyoubabe · 08/04/2023 02:51

I think we should have it. Also a maximum age by which you have to check out by somwhere between 75 and 95. Then the government and families can plan more easily financially. If you want to you could do something like 'buy' extra years. Or there could be like an annual lottery or draw where you can put your name in to get extra years. Something like that. I have often mulled on this during insomniac hours of the night.

Not just a grotesque idea, but a dystopian movie ('In Time') has actually been made on this premise. Well done you!

GretaGood · 08/04/2023 05:13

write VERY clearly that you do not want antibiotics after a certain deterioration in your situation otherwise each time your condition deteriorates they (the docs/nurses) will pump you full so you lurch on in a deteriorated state until you eventually die of starvation and lack of fluids.
Hopefully the morphine syringe driver means You are oblivious of the hunger/ thirst pangs, the aching body and parched and shrivelled mouth but who knows.

FullBloom · 08/04/2023 05:11

To people interested in this, I’d recommend a book called The Book about Getting Older by Dr Lucy Pollock. There’s a really good discussion of exactly how the current system works and what the options are for refusing treatment. Also a good discussion of euthanasia which she is very anti- I am pro but found it interesting to see the arguments against so well set out by an expert.

Ultimately I agree with PP that euthanasia will be normalised and legalised in response to the economic pressure of an ageing population. It’s coming, so we need to be thinking about how to make it work.

Missingthegore · 08/04/2023 05:07

FrumptyMumpty · 08/04/2023 04:39

It won’t happen in the UK whilst we have the NHS because it’ll be too easy to accuse the government of killing people to save money.

Plus, in theory, everyone has access to a pain free and dignified death.

Do I agree with it? I’m not sure. I agree with people’s right to die but the risk of expensive and time consuming relatives being emotionally blackmailed and brainwashed into it being the ‘decent’ thing to do terrifies me.

We have Medicare in Australia and more states and territories are legalising VAD.

If someone has less than 6 months to live and has the cognitive function they can chose to access VAD. They need 2 independent medical assessments. If a doctor doesn't agree with VAD they don't have to participate in the process but must refer the person to a doctor who will assess.
Catholic public hospitals must transfer a patient to a secular hospital if a patient is planning on accessing VAD as an inpatient.

It doesn't work for people with dementia sadly as they don't pass the cognitive assessment portion. 15 years in health I have seen the whole gambit of dementia from those pleasantly confused and directable to such violence that it is incredible difficult to place them in an appropriate facility and ex POW servicemen who are utter escape artists even breaking out through a 2nd floor window.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 04:58

Remaker · 08/04/2023 04:47

I find these discussions quite eye opening because so many posters seem to believe that long, drawn out, painful deaths are normal and the only solution is euthanasia.

I live in Australia and have experienced the deaths of my grandparents, father and many family friends. Some from cancer, some from dementia, some from other causes. None of them have experienced the horrors that are described in this thread. I also work for an organisation that specialises in dementia care. With the right, specialised care the majority of people with dementia can live happily and well. Yes, depending on the type of dementia some exhibit symptoms of distress. But is the solution really to kill them rather than care for them?

Regardless, I doubt it will ever be appropriate for people with dementia to access euthanasia as they do not have capacity to consent. And people can and do change their minds so committing to it in advance is fraught with risk. It also puts the burden of deciding that ‘it’s time’ onto another person which would be very tricky legally.

Surely improving care standards should be the first step before euthanasia?

If you work within dementia , you know the course of the disease the final stages. The wasting repeated respiratory infections from dysphagia , the becoming immobile , potential contractures and pressure sores. I agree care does need to be improved but personally I don't want people to give me build up drinks , thickened fluids , purees and repeated Antibiotics. It's not going to work and I will still decline then die. It's the nature of the disease . The only choice I have to prevent this is doing an advanced decision to refuse treatment which really is horrifying. Give me medication and some music on while I slip away. I'm not saying all people should believe/do the same but I absolutely don't want my life prolonged and that should be my right.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 04:49

FrumptyMumpty · 08/04/2023 04:39

It won’t happen in the UK whilst we have the NHS because it’ll be too easy to accuse the government of killing people to save money.

Plus, in theory, everyone has access to a pain free and dignified death.

Do I agree with it? I’m not sure. I agree with people’s right to die but the risk of expensive and time consuming relatives being emotionally blackmailed and brainwashed into it being the ‘decent’ thing to do terrifies me.

The NHS won't exist in 10 years the way things are going , the country is deep in shit. No a patient should only be the one who requests it , I think in one country you have to request on three separate occasions before they even discuss it. It should be part of the advanced care planning process. The fact is we have the drugs available to hasten death if needed but far too many people are being left in pain because of a fear of getting into trouble because of shipman opiates were tightened up.

I think they did it for my nan , she had bowel cancer died within a fortnight she asked to die at home , they put a syringe driver in and she died within a few hours of getting back home. Her death was very quick and I'm grateful. Most others aren't that quick.

Remaker · 08/04/2023 04:47

I find these discussions quite eye opening because so many posters seem to believe that long, drawn out, painful deaths are normal and the only solution is euthanasia.

I live in Australia and have experienced the deaths of my grandparents, father and many family friends. Some from cancer, some from dementia, some from other causes. None of them have experienced the horrors that are described in this thread. I also work for an organisation that specialises in dementia care. With the right, specialised care the majority of people with dementia can live happily and well. Yes, depending on the type of dementia some exhibit symptoms of distress. But is the solution really to kill them rather than care for them?

Regardless, I doubt it will ever be appropriate for people with dementia to access euthanasia as they do not have capacity to consent. And people can and do change their minds so committing to it in advance is fraught with risk. It also puts the burden of deciding that ‘it’s time’ onto another person which would be very tricky legally.

Surely improving care standards should be the first step before euthanasia?

HoppingPavlova · 08/04/2023 04:45

Absolutely should be legalised with right safeguards. I’m sick of people saying that more $/resource should be put into palliative care as though it’s a golden wand. There are some end of life scenarios that are just horrific and no amount of money or resource can take that away. We don’t let animals go on with some conditions where their pain and discomfort can’t be alleviated and there will be no quality of life moving forward, as it is inhumane, yet corresponding people are just meant to suck it up because some people believe this horrendous suffering is the way to go? Fucking hell.

IncompleteSenten · 08/04/2023 04:44

I do.

I'm life limited and would love to be in control.

My grandad died at home of cancer. Nobody who saw him go through that would think it was important that he did.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 04:43

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 03:59

@4plusthehound

Housing First is great, they've never got further than terrible shelters and very limited housing. (Compare to Singapore or Finland).

Legalisation is great. Canada have legalised but not dealt with the youth MH fallout and other drugs. See Portugal.

Euthanasia is important. They've rolled it out without proper health supports first.

I won't touch trans issues but same.

Now they are trying things like safe use, legalised small quantities of hard drugs etc. All without the things that made that work in places like Switzerland.

Good ideas, terrible execution.

They think that you can half-arse things that work in other places without the parts that MAKE them work. Look all right-on and progressive, while having a massive homelessness, MH and health issue.

I don't agree with Canada's legalisation but why would the UK have to be like that? Are people saying we should have to have long drawn out painful deaths because of what might possibly happen?

We have a situation where people who have incurable conditions are having to kill themselves sooner than they would otherwise like because no one is allowed to help them. I guess I will have to go to a dealer for fentanyl then if it's not legal by then.

BensonStabler · 08/04/2023 04:39

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 03:15

That sounds like a dystopian nightmare.

I know, right?!

WTAF 😱

FrumptyMumpty · 08/04/2023 04:39

It won’t happen in the UK whilst we have the NHS because it’ll be too easy to accuse the government of killing people to save money.

Plus, in theory, everyone has access to a pain free and dignified death.

Do I agree with it? I’m not sure. I agree with people’s right to die but the risk of expensive and time consuming relatives being emotionally blackmailed and brainwashed into it being the ‘decent’ thing to do terrifies me.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 04:38

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 03:35

No. There is not a way to do what you're saying. And people are not animals!!

It's a massive slippery slope. I have heard of people being convinced that euthanasia is the best thing for them when they are mentally unwell.

I hope it's never legalised in the UK and I don't think it will be.

It's being legalised in a lot of countries, USA is more religious than the UK and they have legalised it in a few states. It's coming because the government won't be able to afford to care for an aging population and not enough workers to pay the bill. It's best we talk about it now and what safeguards Vs when the government bring it in and do what they like.

It doesn't have to be a slippery slope.

nicetoseetgesunsout · 08/04/2023 03:59

@Jux
I hope that you do get your wish 💐

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/04/2023 03:59

@4plusthehound

Housing First is great, they've never got further than terrible shelters and very limited housing. (Compare to Singapore or Finland).

Legalisation is great. Canada have legalised but not dealt with the youth MH fallout and other drugs. See Portugal.

Euthanasia is important. They've rolled it out without proper health supports first.

I won't touch trans issues but same.

Now they are trying things like safe use, legalised small quantities of hard drugs etc. All without the things that made that work in places like Switzerland.

Good ideas, terrible execution.

They think that you can half-arse things that work in other places without the parts that MAKE them work. Look all right-on and progressive, while having a massive homelessness, MH and health issue.

temperedolive · 08/04/2023 03:57

I'd love a link to a source of this, as I searched Le Monde and couldn't find it. The most recent numbers I found on a Google search say euthanasia accounts for 3 3% of Canadian deaths on 2022, which is a very different figure than the OP cited and seems quite reasonable, really.

Jux · 08/04/2023 03:46

I want it legalised in UK, oh yes. I want to be able to die with dignity at some point, possibly quite soon (5-10 years) so that I don't have to suffer the indignities which will be forced upon me by ms. As I become increasingly unable to do things for myself, to remember new stuff, get more confused as my brain gets more and more damaged, unable to even manage the loo myself, can't be trusted on my mobility scooter - not to mention the ever-present pain which will only increase, and everything else which WILL happen to me....

Yes, let me die at a time of my choosing when the pain of just being alive and awake is greater than the pleasure, when I can still appreciate a warm sunny day, the loveliness of plants, the amazing thing that is the human body; when I can still thank my husband for what he does for me and look at my beautiful daughter and know exactly who she is.

Don't make my death harder than my life. Please.

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 03:39

Bottom line- if I want to end my life in a dignified way who the fuck else's business is that ?

Because it's not just about you.

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 03:35

herlightmaterials · 08/04/2023 00:53

But we really do need a way of making it possible for people to not die in agony. We wouldn't put a beloved pet through the suffering we subject ourselves and our family to. It's obscene.

No. There is not a way to do what you're saying. And people are not animals!!

It's a massive slippery slope. I have heard of people being convinced that euthanasia is the best thing for them when they are mentally unwell.

I hope it's never legalised in the UK and I don't think it will be.