Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
VestaTilley · 08/04/2023 07:52

I do not want it. It is monstrous; fraught with risk and opens the floodgates to bump off your relatives with impunity. There could never be enough safeguards. People would ask for it so as not to be a burden- even when they didn’t want to go. It’s awful.

A leading campaigner for euthanasia in the late 20th century was a writer called Beverley Nichols. He wanted it when he was very, very ill. Guess what? He recovered.

Badbudgeter · 08/04/2023 07:48

MarshaBradyo · 08/04/2023 07:43

I think this is part of what stops parties looking at it.

The tories not keen on being seen as the party happier to do it and labour it’s not really their bag.

It’d interesting to see what proportion of electorate are for it.

There are lots of studies that show the majority of the population are in favour of euthanasia for people suffering a terminal illness. I found this one contrasting with MP's opinions interesting. I think MP's are concerned it'll be what they are remembered for. Maggie Thatcher: milk snatcher type thing but as a granny killer

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/health/articles-reports/2021/08/04/three-quarters-britons-support-doctor-assisted-sui

Three quarters of Britons support doctor-assisted suicide. Just one in three MPs say the same | YouGov

The public and MPs are also out of step when it comes to allowing assisted suicide for non-terminally ill patients suffering from painful incurable diseases

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/health/articles-reports/2021/08/04/three-quarters-britons-support-doctor-assisted-sui

idontlikementhols · 08/04/2023 07:48

YABU. If I was terminally I'll and had mental capacity I'd want to be able to decide to die peacefully at a time of my choosing. I don't want to suffer agony and indignity until my body finally gives up.

IfuWannaBmyLover · 08/04/2023 07:47

I always agreed with euthanasia for people who are suffering with no way out but the way Canada is applying it concerns me immensely.

Vulnerable people being offered it, pressured into it, talks of (or it actually happening to) it being offered to minors, expanding to mental illness. Nope, don’t agree.

MarshaBradyo · 08/04/2023 07:43

Tiredalwaystired · 08/04/2023 07:24

I think that at some point the Tory party in particular will look again at this.

We have a care crisis in this country.

With a VERY cold view on this, there are financial benefits to the country for allowing euthanasia. And that will be what swings it ultimately, not any ethical reason. I think that’s the chilling truth. It will be sold to us as humanitarian progressiveness though.

I think this is part of what stops parties looking at it.

The tories not keen on being seen as the party happier to do it and labour it’s not really their bag.

It’d interesting to see what proportion of electorate are for it.

daretodenim · 08/04/2023 07:43

nltimes.nl/2023/04/05/one-20-deaths-netherlands-last-year-euthanasia

5.1% of deaths in The Netherlands last year was due to euthanasia, up from 4.9% the previous year. There's a general upward trend. Most were people in old age. A very tiny amount - very tiny - were due to mental health (sorry, read what that figure was a few days ago but I can't find it now).

I'm not entirely sure of the Dutch protocol but I do know that the way the Canadians go about it is shocking. I've heard a few others who looked into that system say similar. I think there was even a programme recently with Pru Leith and her son looking at all the different systems. One was pro and one was anti euthanasia, but the one thing they agreed on was that the Canadian system was bad.

Badbudgeter · 08/04/2023 07:42

I want euthanasia. For me it's a personal decision often the women in my family tend to live long lives 90's but the last decade of that is spent in a dementia home. It's a horrid existance (to me) that I don't want to go through and I don't want my children to go through. I've seen people die slowly of cancer and that is awful aswell. Body stops really being able to process food/ water and it can take weeks of hardcore painkillers that aren't always effective whillst people whither away sucking on the odd ice chip.

It's fair to say you don't want Euthanasia and I had a great Aunt who lived in the Netherlands (till 94) and didn't wanted to be euthanised, she spent much of the last ten years in increasing pain but it was her choice and her mind remained sharp which was a blessing.

It's a personal choice and yes there should be safeguards. However a few extreme examples should not be the basis on which are the laws are made. There's a reason for the saying "Hard cases make bad laws" The previous case law on euthanasia/ assisted suicide in the UK is emotive and painful to listen to, does anyone remember Diane Pretty? She had MND and wanted to control the time of her death and have it agreed her husband could help her commit suicide without fear of prosecution as she didn't want to be ventilated / choke/ drown in her own saliva.

By not introducing euthanasia/ PAS we are condemning people in many cases to drawn out deaths which we wouldn't let a dog suffer.

https://www.dignityindying.org.uk/why-we-need-change/personal-stories/

Personal stories - Dignity in Dying

Telling personal stories can be extremely powerful. Each one is a painful reminder that our current law is broken and needs to change.

https://www.dignityindying.org.uk/why-we-need-change/personal-stories

GretaGood · 08/04/2023 07:41

Once you have dementia you can't choose to go as you don't have capacity.

Also if you do decide to go whilst you have capacity there are various methods of suicide (and no doubt many more on the internet) which you can choose to use.

Expecting some poor doctor to bump you off because you wrote something years ago is not fair on the doc. I wouldn't kill someone when they can be sedated with morphine. Sadly it is the time they take to die using this method which is the problem.

palelavender · 08/04/2023 07:40

I was with my father in his final illness with renal failure. He had Alzheimer's. He was frightened and in pain. It was utterly horrible and pointless. I got the morphine pumped up but he lingered on. He was nearly 90. If I could have chosen for him to die a week earlier I would have made that choice.

ShimmeringShirts · 08/04/2023 07:38

I do want it here. There is a heavy prevalence of Parkinson’s and dementia in my family on both maternal and paternal side. I’d rather choose how and when I was to die than put my family through watching and caring for me in my slow decent to death.

Intergalacticcatharsis · 08/04/2023 07:34

https://www.politico.eu/article/france-doctors-europe-too-far-too-old-too-few/

There is a shortage of doctors too, which might only get worse. It isn’t just an ageing population that is the issue.

Let’s say someone in terminal stage cancer. If they don’t want to live through the agony of the last 4-6 weeks (which can also be a big cost) then why should they not be able to die with dignity to avoid that huge pain and suffering?

The issue is if poor people were refused treatment for Stage 4 cancer due to cost… but we are very far away from that.

Properly legalised with adequate checks I think we do need euthanasia. However, again, not every doctor will want to do the lethal injection.

Obviously I am against it for people with depression who think they want to die. That is a very tricky area. Perhaps it needs to be limited to deteriorating physical health only?

AuntieMarys · 08/04/2023 07:34

I'm a member of Dignity in Dying and fully support my right to die when I feel it is time.

boboshmobo · 08/04/2023 07:30

Have you had a family member with dementia ?

I absolutely think it should be legalised for this and maybe other illness as well

Of course humans can't be trusted but I don't want to live like my nan , mum and aunt have and are being vile to the family I love ..

AveragePerson5 · 08/04/2023 07:26

Yes I definitely want this in the UK.

The last few weeks of life of certain family members have been absolute hell and suffering. Not everyone’s pain can be managed as well as you think. For various reasons. Not to mention the double incontinence or worse and other indignities and mental distress that occurs as well as the pain.

We absolutely should allow some people to be euthanised/ put to sleep if that’s what they want and they are going to die shortly anyway. We don’t let animals suffer and you don’t realise how much many people suffer a horrific last few months, weeks or days until you’ve seen it with your own eyes.

YellowGreenBlue · 08/04/2023 07:26

I support euthanasia. I don't know anything about the Canadian system, but if it is flawed that doesn't mean we shouldn't do it - just that we should use a different blueprint.

https://www.dignityindying.org.uk/

Dignity in Dying - Join the campaign

Dying people are taking their own lives here and abroad. The current law offers them no protection or support. Join us and help change the law.

https://www.dignityindying.org.uk/

SBAM · 08/04/2023 07:24

Youdoyoubabe · 08/04/2023 02:51

I think we should have it. Also a maximum age by which you have to check out by somwhere between 75 and 95. Then the government and families can plan more easily financially. If you want to you could do something like 'buy' extra years. Or there could be like an annual lottery or draw where you can put your name in to get extra years. Something like that. I have often mulled on this during insomniac hours of the night.

Who decides on the maximum age?
My 3 remaining grandparents are in their late 70s, still in very good health and after retirement have been volunteering with local organisations. They have children, grandchildren and great grandchildren.
Would they get a pass because they’re providing some
use to the community or do you think my grandparents shouldn’t have got to meet their 3 youngest great grandchildren?

Tiredalwaystired · 08/04/2023 07:24

I think that at some point the Tory party in particular will look again at this.

We have a care crisis in this country.

With a VERY cold view on this, there are financial benefits to the country for allowing euthanasia. And that will be what swings it ultimately, not any ethical reason. I think that’s the chilling truth. It will be sold to us as humanitarian progressiveness though.

Tockomtele · 08/04/2023 07:24

I wonder how many doctors, nurses and other healthcare workers give up their jobs when they'll be asked to assist in someone's dying.

And there's also a trend to slowly widen the legislation to allow more and more groups to be included.

Nobody addressed my point about whether children have capacity in this, especially if they have mental health problems. Very dangerous trend.
I see the same safeguarding issues as I see around the whole 'you can chose to be whatever gender you want to be' trend.

DurhamDurham · 08/04/2023 07:19

Or have you had your life savings drained through years of Funding care for a loved one

And this is why we would need to proceed with extreme caution, relatives who would rather hang on to their inheritance than spend it on the care needs of the person they love.

BecauseTheOnlyWayIsUp · 08/04/2023 07:05

Yes I do think we should have it. I watched my grandma die in agony. She begged me to help her. I will live with it forever that she was in so so much pain and I could do nothing but sit there.

teezletangler · 08/04/2023 06:49

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia

It was 3.3% in 2021, not 8%

https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/230213/dq230213c-eng.htm

NeedToChangeName · 08/04/2023 06:48

Felixss · 08/04/2023 02:06

The government will legalise it not because they want to give citizens bodily autonomy but because we have an aging population with increased comorbidities and it's very expensive to keep people alive with a lack of young adults paying taxes. The government will view it as a way to save money It's coming so it's best to prepare for how it will work with safeguards. I think it shouldn't be allowed for functional MH issues it should be for progressive terminal conditions.

This

And it terrifies me

I think people are extremely naive if they believe assisted suicide would be used in rare cases, with patients giving informed consent

We've all seen how this government treats vulnerable and disadvantaged people

KrasiTime · 08/04/2023 06:31

I wouldn’t put an animal through what my dad went through. Watching someone you love suffer is the worst thing. It’s cruel & inhumane. Palliative could make him comfortable & as pain free as possible but it wasn’t really enough. That is not what I want for myself.

LlynTegid · 08/04/2023 06:11

I think legalising euthanasia will lead to a slippery slope. Very different from stopping life extending treatment in my opinion.

ProstituteHair · 08/04/2023 05:41

I think the phrase 'I don't want to be a burden' is extremely harmful when applied to state-legislated death.

Who gets to chose?

I speak as one who is radically pro-abortion. I absolutely believe in self-determination. That up to the moment of birth the mother should have absolute control over what happens to her body with regards the foetus.

Once a person is born they become an individual and then, and only then, does their ownership begin.

And once it does, it's not the business of the state.

There's a social contract by which we live politically and which we get to vote on but it doesn't presume that anyone other than the individual has ownership of their life.

It's why I opted out of presumed consent with organ donation. Not because I'm intrinsically against organ donation, but because I am against presumed consent. For any matter.

And death is a big matter.