Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
GettingStuffed · 08/04/2023 08:45

I've seen 3 members of my family die excruciatingly because they had terminal illnesses which not just affected them, but the whole family, as they clung to life awaiting the inevitable.

having seen the damage dementia causes I'd rather die than put my family through that.

Urghfedup · 08/04/2023 08:39

One of the many reasons I left nursing was the sudden fear of medics to prescribe palliative medication. One of my last shifts I had to listen to a dying man screaming out in pain for 8 hours. I rang everyone, from junior doctors to consultants, palliative care to management. No one was willing to prescribe more painkillers and I was already regularly giving morphine. If I close my eyes I can picture his face and hear those screams.
About 2 months after I left my neighbours dog got sick and was put down. He was peaceful and our neighbour was allowed to cuddle him.

AveragePerson5 · 08/04/2023 08:29

This is general - not just to you - but can we stop using the phrase "put to sleep"? This is a euphemism for pet euthanasia, not the potential death of a person close to you. Even mentioning how animals are dealt with - positively or negatively - while discussing human euthanasia is somewhat distasteful.

I understand what you’re saying but I chose that language deliberately to highlight that as a society we don’t let our pets suffer, but we do let people suffer.

That is the truth and it’s cruel and absurd and totally illogical.

Quveas · 08/04/2023 08:25

My dog has better end of life options than I do. That is ridiculous. Provided it is the clear wish and intention of the individual, I fully support assisted dying.

Pluvia · 08/04/2023 08:25

My mum died a lingering and upsetting death from colon cancer. I won't go into details but several times a week her body would develop fistulas out of which faecal matter would trickle all over her, the bed, the duvet, the linen... It was a horrible and for her a humiliating process. She wanted to die at home, thinking it would be quick. My sister and I nursed her for almost a year and she longed to die.

I want euthanasia introduced as soon as possible. I know there are far worse things than death.

Unsure33 · 08/04/2023 08:25

Jux · 08/04/2023 03:46

I want it legalised in UK, oh yes. I want to be able to die with dignity at some point, possibly quite soon (5-10 years) so that I don't have to suffer the indignities which will be forced upon me by ms. As I become increasingly unable to do things for myself, to remember new stuff, get more confused as my brain gets more and more damaged, unable to even manage the loo myself, can't be trusted on my mobility scooter - not to mention the ever-present pain which will only increase, and everything else which WILL happen to me....

Yes, let me die at a time of my choosing when the pain of just being alive and awake is greater than the pleasure, when I can still appreciate a warm sunny day, the loveliness of plants, the amazing thing that is the human body; when I can still thank my husband for what he does for me and look at my beautiful daughter and know exactly who she is.

Don't make my death harder than my life. Please.

I agree , as my mum had parkinsons and the last 6 months were awful . The worst bit was in the hospital where basically they said she was end of life but then treated her so badly not giving her any care at all , lack of food and water and just watching when she choked. We got her out asap and luckily gave her some dignity for the last part of her life . She was ready to go and to see her so scared at the end was just heartbreaking . I think actually I disagree with the poster who said the government will do it for money as there have been countless petitions to have a sensible discussion and so far nothing has happened. It has to be handled extremely carefully with lots of safeguards but for some I think it is a better way out .

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 08/04/2023 08:25

I don’t think we need to worry too much about following the Canadian way of doing things. They have some pretty bonkers ideas atm - here’s the school board endorsed woodwork teacher on insert -pronoun -here ‘s way to work .

We can probably work out a better system for ourselves on this one.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/04/2023 08:24

I’m the sort of person who rarely needs to see the GP, so it came as a shock recently to have to spend nearly 3 weeks in hospital (pneumonia and pleurisy) in sundry different wards, where I witnessed 2 elderly women with dementia, both evidently unable to get to the loo so both in incontinence pads, neither with a clue about anything.
I heard one being asked (very kindly) where she thought she was - ‘In my bedroom at home.’

I am no spring chicken so the experience has made me utterly dread anything like this sort of demented, incontinent old age - give me the lethal jab any day. And if it had been legal I’d have wanted it for my poor mother, who had approx 15 years of Alzheimer’s - from her very early 80s until she died at 97. And I can’t say that any of those years was anything like ‘happy’.

Never mind my own feelings, the thought of being a worry and a burden to dds appals me.

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 08/04/2023 08:22

herlightmaterials · 08/04/2023 00:52

We want it but we need to use Canada as a cautionary tale. Their ethics committees seems to care about who they can bump off on the basis that it would be cheaper and they apply moral pressure to people by telling them how much they're costing - unbelievable. I would have thought the ethics was ensuring nobody felt under pressure to choose death, not making a song and dance about wasting resources.

I believe people should have the choice, we don't let animals suffer, but this post above is what we would end up with. Especially on here;

Aibu to not want to euthanise? I love my family.

Yes you are, you are going to die anyway, save the taxpayer the hospital bill and end it now.

🤔

Lamelie · 08/04/2023 08:22

JackiePlace · 08/04/2023 01:02

I don't believe this. I am Canadian with a life limiting illness and have been assessed for MAiD. There was no pressure and no mention of money.

Was the assessment at your instigation?
Flowers

GoldenAye · 08/04/2023 08:21

AveragePerson5 · 08/04/2023 07:26

Yes I definitely want this in the UK.

The last few weeks of life of certain family members have been absolute hell and suffering. Not everyone’s pain can be managed as well as you think. For various reasons. Not to mention the double incontinence or worse and other indignities and mental distress that occurs as well as the pain.

We absolutely should allow some people to be euthanised/ put to sleep if that’s what they want and they are going to die shortly anyway. We don’t let animals suffer and you don’t realise how much many people suffer a horrific last few months, weeks or days until you’ve seen it with your own eyes.

This is general - not just to you - but can we stop using the phrase "put to sleep"? This is a euphemism for pet euthanasia, not the potential death of a person close to you. Even mentioning how animals are dealt with - positively or negatively - while discussing human euthanasia is somewhat distasteful.

HairyToity · 08/04/2023 08:20

I am hugely favour euthanasia, it would save a lot of suffering.

eleanorwish · 08/04/2023 08:19

Here's an article I found

nationalpost.com/news/canadian-veterans-assisted-suicide

Showerpowerer · 08/04/2023 08:15

If I got anything like my family members I would be on a plane to Switzerland. Being locked in your own body with it failing is horrible. Knowing that your breath is due to your muscles not working anymore and suffocating to death whilr your brain is still completely with it.

AveragePerson5 · 08/04/2023 08:15

I wouldn't kill someone when they can be sedated with morphine.

Not everyone can be sedated with morphine.
Some people can react very badly to it (delirium, confusion) and can’t be given it or similar.

More commonly, the pain is so great the amount needed to relieve it would also push the person into unconsciousness and death and doctors won’t do it.

Sometimes the syringe driver won’t stay in because the person is thrashing around or ripping it out in confusion and it’s dangerous.

The idea that everyone can just spend their last months or weeks in some unconscious pain free morphine induced cocoon is a total myth. Many of us have seen that’s not the case at all for a very sizeable minority. I feel like the public has been lulled into a false sense of security about this probably as some sort of kindness but it’s not the case. You don’t realise it until someone you’re close to is in that position.

Atreus · 08/04/2023 08:14

I have first hand experience of this...I lived in Switzerland a few years ago and my amazing mum who was diagnosed with MND travelled from the U.K. out to Zurich to end her life by assisted suicide at Dignitas. I attended the clinic with her and was with her when she died. In the face of a cruel and brutal disease, she got the peaceful death that she so desired, at the time of her choosing. It was a privilege to share this with her.

For me there is a distinct difference between euthanasia (where a doctor or health care professional administers drugs that will result in death) and assisted dying (where the individual themselves takes the drugs that have been provided to them). I'm actually in agreement with both for life limiting illnesses as long as there are stringent and robust checks to ensure no coercion, but I do think assisted dying is maybe easier to rationalise and also provide a safe framework for. If anyone is interested, I did an AMA a few years back about the experience.

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 08/04/2023 08:11

For me it's quality of life and not quantity. I absolutely want this here.

Thoughtful2355 · 08/04/2023 08:09

i knew a girl who decided to be Euthanized

she had disabilitys since birth that meant she was unable to walk or do anything was in pain all the time, she also could hardly talk and now pretty much had nothing but a head and torso with a brain to think but no way to communicate. she was blind and deaf and had a colostromy bag.

She used to spend 24 hours a day in bed with carers coming in but she didnt have anyone else, no family etc and was on a million pills a day for the pain.

I often think about her and im happy she is now at rest. she was only 24 .. she could have had a loooong miserable life otherwise

EllisActon · 08/04/2023 08:06

I have capacity but after brain bleed little else and I pray every day for the release that is denied me...I just want to not be here

IfuWannaBmyLover · 08/04/2023 08:06

Headoutofplace · 08/04/2023 05:27

I don't think euthanasia should be legalized in the way it has been in Canada and certainly shouldn't be an option just because someone's old but otherwise relatively healthy. But I do think there should be options opened up for more focus on pain relief and the option to prioritise pain relief over extending life (with solid safeguards and at the patient's request, not decided for the patient), so someone can decide they want DNR and maximum pain relief and if that ends their life then so be it. The idea should be that end of life/very ill patients should have control (with 2 doctors approving) over prioritising pain relief even if that threatens their life rather than focusing on euthanasia.

I agree completely

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 08/04/2023 08:04

I would like it to be available. People should be able to be in control of their deaths. If they have a terminal illness, why should anyone have to suffer? It's a personal choice. If you don't like it, don't have one.

ZirihePevzig · 08/04/2023 08:03

8% of deaths happening via euthanasia doesn't sound unreasonable to me. You'd have to know roughly what proportion of deaths are in a situation where death is (a) going to be inevitable across a timescale of weeks or months and (b) either the actual death will be very unpleasant/painful or the last weeks/months very unpleasant or painful. Then multiply that by whatever fraction for what proportion of people will prefer to get it over with. I don't know what those 2 factors are but I could believe a resulting outcome of anything between 5% and 20%.

You do realise OP that precisely zero of those 8% would have been alive, well and living a fulfilling and positive life a year later if they hadn't taken that decision? They would all be dead anyway but having suffered a lot more and probably with some severely traumatic memories among the living who cared for them during that time.

Many final deaths are eventually asphyxiation when the lungs can't get oxygen into the body any more. For many people it's the unpredictable timescale that causes the most distress. I would much rather have a controlled, predictable injection than wait around for an unavoidable and unpleasant end to happen some time soon but in an uncontrollable way.

SoShallINever · 08/04/2023 08:01

It took my beloved mum 3 weeks to die in agony. We knew there was no way back and she was in so much pain. Absolutely appalling end for her.

I 100 percent support assisting dying, with appropriate safeguards.

MarshaBradyo · 08/04/2023 07:54

Badbudgeter · 08/04/2023 07:48

There are lots of studies that show the majority of the population are in favour of euthanasia for people suffering a terminal illness. I found this one contrasting with MP's opinions interesting. I think MP's are concerned it'll be what they are remembered for. Maggie Thatcher: milk snatcher type thing but as a granny killer

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/health/articles-reports/2021/08/04/three-quarters-britons-support-doctor-assisted-sui

Well this perfectly shows the issue well found. Yes I agree with you as an MP making the decision and the reputation from it is a tough one.

Okunevo · 08/04/2023 07:52

teezletangler · 08/04/2023 06:49

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia

It was 3.3% in 2021, not 8%

https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/230213/dq230213c-eng.htm

So it more than doubled in a year?