Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
magicthree · 08/04/2023 23:51

I feel that TV is to blame to a point. Death is not someone lucid, talking to relatives, then passing away with a smile on their face moments later. Active dying can take days, and then it is things like terminal agitation, secretions (the death rattle), all odd patterns of breathing, things like suddenly sitting up etc.

While that is unpleasant for the person sitting with the dying relative/friend, the person who is dying is unaware of those things happening, it is peaceful enough for them. I recently sat with my DF for several days as he was dying and I didn't find it so terrible, although admittedly I wasn't there when he actually died, but I found the whole thing far less stressful than I had imagined it to be. It was in fact a lot easier than what happened before, when he was delirious and thought everyone was his mother.

XenoBitch · 08/04/2023 23:03

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/04/2023 17:45

I think a lot of education needs to be given people about dying we shy away from it then people are shocked that it can be a horrible process

I couldn't agree more, Felixss; we're notoriously bad at this in the UK and so many seem to regard death as as failure, when actually it's a natural process and something none of us will escape

That said, natural doesn't always mean pleasant and certainly not pain free, and that's where the euthanasia debate comes in

I feel that TV is to blame to a point. Death is not someone lucid, talking to relatives, then passing away with a smile on their face moments later. Active dying can take days, and then it is things like terminal agitation, secretions (the death rattle), all odd patterns of breathing, things like suddenly sitting up etc.

Greenfairydust · 08/04/2023 22:52

I never understand why we accept that putting beloved pets to sleep when they become too sick to have any quality of life is the best thing to do yet we expect people to be kept alive at all cost when it is obvious they are in pain/have no wish to live anymore...

I don't see why you think your opinion should prevent people to choose a dignified exit.

I certainly would not want to live once I lose my independence/develop dementia or if I a terminal illness drag things on past the point where my quality of life is gone.

It is perfectly feasible to put enough safeguards in place to make euthanasia a choice for those who want it.

But that means going beyond the usual knee-jerk arguments about religious nonsense and the idea that life must be preserved at all cost.

EuphemiaLives · 08/04/2023 22:47

This subject is very close to my heart. In December 2021 my father ended my mother's life and then attempted to take his own. He survived and is now in prison in Cyprus and we are in the midst of a murder trial. My mum had terminal blood cancer, she couldn't take any more pain and wanted to go on her own terms. My parents were desperate and my whole family has been plunged into a nightmare.

As a society, we have to do better. Yes, there need to be safeguards in place but we need to give people the option to die with dignity on their own terms.

PurpleBrocadePeacock · 08/04/2023 22:33

Some stats from the Canada report:

  • 80% were on a palliative care pathway
  • ~2/3 cancer was the main medical cause followed by cardiovascular disease
  • Alzheimers/dementia not represented (I am assuming my low because unable to give consent. Family members cannot give consent on behalf of another.)
Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.
Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.
Powerof321 · 08/04/2023 18:17

I’d like the option!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/04/2023 17:45

I think a lot of education needs to be given people about dying we shy away from it then people are shocked that it can be a horrible process

I couldn't agree more, Felixss; we're notoriously bad at this in the UK and so many seem to regard death as as failure, when actually it's a natural process and something none of us will escape

That said, natural doesn't always mean pleasant and certainly not pain free, and that's where the euthanasia debate comes in

Teenangels · 08/04/2023 17:42

I watched my Mum, die from Dementia less than 5 weeks ago.

It was a death I would not wish on my worst enemy, she had no hope of recovery and she died without eating or drinking for 2 weeks, she was thirsty but as she could not swallow we could not even wet her lips.

In this country we should give the person and family the right in the last few weeks to decide that they be given an injection.

I will never get over what I witnessed.

Tealsofa · 08/04/2023 17:36

herlightmaterials · 08/04/2023 00:53

But we really do need a way of making it possible for people to not die in agony. We wouldn't put a beloved pet through the suffering we subject ourselves and our family to. It's obscene.

you'd be (rightly) locked up for treating animals the way we treat older/in pain people - its a fiucking disgrace

Tumbleweed101 · 08/04/2023 17:33

I agree with the right to death but it would have to be a very solid policy. Signed by the person and NoK while the person was aware enough decide.

We had to make a very similar decision when my mum was end of life. Choose more invasive treatment or let her sleep comfortably with morphine to take away the distress of struggling to breathe (end stage COPD). Knowing she had chosen a DNR when she was in hospital the year before and made it clear to all of us that was what she wanted made it easier for us to decide on the morphine and no more treatment (which would have only prolonged not cured). It was a hard decision for us but we knew she was struggling and ready to go when it reached that point.

I think people reach a point in prolonged illness especially where they know the fight is over and its just a waiting game to the end. Those are the people euthanasia would most benefit.

MyDarlingClementine · 08/04/2023 17:23

@oakleaffy.
Someone is either terminally ill with no chance of recovery or not.or very elderly and I'll.

Forcing people to live on every single moment in pure agony is dispicable and a stain on humanity.

Felixss · 08/04/2023 17:19

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 16:22

I've watched many people die and unfortunately I haven't seen that many good deaths. The best seem to be sudden very quick. I'm not scared of dying I'm scared of being unable to tell people I'm in pain and it being very drawn out.

I admit that having not been in your place, I haven't seen the impact of these situations. And I'm sure you're right.

Don't people in final stages of life get offered morphine etc to make them comfortable? That was the case with my grandmother who died and I'm fairly sure she was not in pain but this was a long time ago.

Erm no it isn't drugs wear off some drugs don't react well in some people. It's obviously hard for some patients to verbalise their pain we do use assessment tools but I'm sure it doesn't catch all. We also are only allowed to give so much controlled drugs as after shipman there's a lot more hesitancy around prescribing large dosages. If someone has a high tolerance it can be a very large doses and it may hasten death. Some relatives also complain the patient is sedated and not talking. I think a lot of education needs to be given people about dying we shy away from it then people are shocked that it can be a horrible process.

pointythings · 08/04/2023 17:17

@Jonei I do have severe reservations about introducing it under the current administration, yes.

Jonei · 08/04/2023 16:57

I don't want it here. I don't think it's likely to be safeguarded properly.

Shininghope · 08/04/2023 16:53

This is very helpful. Thank you.

pointythings · 08/04/2023 16:28

@MyopicBunny many people think that it is possible to keep everyone pain free and comfortable in EOL situations. It isn't. Sometimes the painkillers are not enough, and that happens more often than you'd think. Add to that the fact that many people also really struggle with the complete loss of dignity and you end up with a situation where the suffering is prolonged and unbearable. That was where my grandmother was at - the dose of medication she needed to take away the pain was a lethal dose. Fortunately she was legally allowed to have it.

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 16:22

I've watched many people die and unfortunately I haven't seen that many good deaths. The best seem to be sudden very quick. I'm not scared of dying I'm scared of being unable to tell people I'm in pain and it being very drawn out.

I admit that having not been in your place, I haven't seen the impact of these situations. And I'm sure you're right.

Don't people in final stages of life get offered morphine etc to make them comfortable? That was the case with my grandmother who died and I'm fairly sure she was not in pain but this was a long time ago.

maddy68 · 08/04/2023 16:06

The country I live in it is legal. And I support it.

I would have loved that option for my dad instead of drawing out his suffering

Felixss · 08/04/2023 15:56

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 14:23

What nonsense. Can you not see how simplistic this is? Some people are vulnerable and are specifically vulnerable to abusers telling them that they would be better off dead.

Can you not appreciate that at all?

If someone is already dying is a greedy relative really going to push for it to happen even more quickly? The medical staff wouldn't allow it. Yes there are risks I propose it becomes a part of advanced care planning while the patient has capacity . A doctor isn't allowed to mention it until the patient asks on separate occasions , it should then be independently validated. Medical staff should not be allowed to mention it as an option it should be all patient led.

I've watched many people die and unfortunately I haven't seen that many good deaths. The best seem to be sudden very quick. I'm not scared of dying I'm scared of being unable to tell people I'm in pain and it being very drawn out.

londonrach · 08/04/2023 15:50

Op have you had a family member in severe pain who will die in the worse pain ever and nothing can help in the next few days. My proud and beautiful gran brain tumor made her last days alive hell. Yabu. Under strick control this is needed in the UK. Urgently. Vvvv Strick control. Doctors (not just one, a team including nurses) and family working together to make terminal I'll patients last few days bearable.

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 15:40

Unless you think that hordes of vulnerable people are being bumped off wholesale over there and it's a total free for all?

With this government in power? Anything's possible...

@DameKatyDenisesClagnuts will you stop trying to force me to admit I'm a religious nut? It's tiresome and lazy. Of course I support rights to abortion - I'm not some crazy, right wing loon.

Death is irreversible though isn't it.

DameKatyDenisesClagnuts · 08/04/2023 15:36

@MyopicBunny in the US states where it is legal, the individual has to have a terminal diagnosis with a prognosis of less than six months. Due to the general difficulty in predicting how close to death a person is unless it is quite close, in reality most of those people will be weeks or days away from dying. For me, that's a reasonable safeguard for most cases but there are also other criteria. I'm presuming you are not anti-abortion just in case there is coercion?

pointythings · 08/04/2023 15:34

@MyopicBunny you safeguard it in the same way that those countries which have legalised it the right way have done. Look at the Dutch and Belgian models, not the Canadian one. Unless you think that hordes of vulnerable people are being bumped off wholesale over there and it's a total free for all?

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 15:31

I'm still waiting to hear how it would be 'safeguarded'

I'm also slightly offended by the notion that if you don't believe legalising euthanasia is a good thing, you must be a religious nut Hmm

MyopicBunny · 08/04/2023 15:28

No it's not. I am making the point that people can be coerced to do things they don't want, especially if vulnerable. And nobody can safeguard it.

This applies to people being forced to keep a pregnancy, too - so you've illustrated my point.

There is absolutely no way to safeguard anything absolutely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread