Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.

459 replies

MrsMarkieParkie · 08/04/2023 00:48

I just read that 8% of deaths in Canada last year happened via euthanasia. This doesnt sit right with me. Also, as described in the article, the protocol seems mostly the same as the US death by lethal injection.
Do we want this in the UK?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
10
volleyballing · 21/04/2023 09:05

pointythings · 19/04/2023 20:07

Well, that hasn't happened in Switzerland, or the Netherlands, or Belgium, or Oregon, or Canada. So your post is basically scaremongering.

I’m not sure we will ever know if it does tbh. I’m not necessarily against MAID but, as a Canadian who has lived in the UK, I’d say the regulation is not sufficient compared to what those used to UK healthcare have come to expect.

There should be a separation between the assessor and the facilitator which is missing. Very little regulation is mandatory and in some areas assessor/ provider services are advertised online.

You can also keep trying multiple practitioners until you get your two assessors to sign you off without them having any record that you have previously been refused. Death certificates can record the cause of death as being the reason you sought MAID rather than MAID itself (at least in some areas). So, as I understand it, you could be recorded as dying of cancer when you had not received a terminal cancer diagnosis.

In most areas the death rates hover around about 3% or below of deaths but in a couple of areas they are much higher. Eg Vancouver Island is knocking at the door of 8%. There appears to be little discussion of why this is (just assumed older, affluent population) and a couple of doctors on the Island are very heavily involved in regulatory and training development and I can’t find being queried by the government.

The healthcare system is very different to the UK’s with a lot of individual clinics based outside of hospitals and many single practice family doctors, neurologists etc. I’m my experience there has been less involvement of social workers for vulnerable people. This has some disadvantages in terms of models of control and accountability.

LangClegsInSpace · 20/04/2023 23:57

I don't think Oregon has got this right. They give out the prescription and allow patients to hang onto it themselves to take at a time that they feel is right. Lots of people get the drugs but then don't take them.

At the time of reporting, ingestion status was unknown for 101 patients
prescribed DWDA medications in 2022.

Out of a total of 431 prescriptions in 2022. That's quite high.

More than 70% of ingestions in 2022 involved the drug combination DDMAPh, which consists of diazepam, digoxin, morphine sulfate, amitriptyline, and phenobarbital. The drug combination DDMA, consisting of diazepam, digoxin, morphine sulfate, and amitriptyline, accounted for 28% of ingestions.

These drugs have a street value.

The gap between prescriptions issued and deaths resulting appears to be getting wider year by year and it's not at all clear what is happening to unused prescriptions.

https://www.oregon.gov/oha/PH/PROVIDERPARTNERRESOURCES/EVALUATIONRESEARCH/DEATHWITHDIGNITYACT/Documents/year25.pdf

I don't think the UK would go for this model as we have very strict rules around controlled drugs. Any law passed here is likely to require the drugs to be dispensed only at the time of use and for a HCP to at least stay nearby (e.g. in the next room) if not directly supervising while the drugs are taken.

Euthanasie, dont legalise in UK.
pointythings · 19/04/2023 20:07

Irridescantshimmmer · 19/04/2023 19:44

No, we don't.

Just imagine.......the drug used to euthanize being available to wierdos and missfits on the black market.

All hell could break loose.

I'm about as religious as a fish driving a motorbike, so religion is not why I feel this way, it could be lethal in the wrong hands.

Well, that hasn't happened in Switzerland, or the Netherlands, or Belgium, or Oregon, or Canada. So your post is basically scaremongering.

Irridescantshimmmer · 19/04/2023 19:44

No, we don't.

Just imagine.......the drug used to euthanize being available to wierdos and missfits on the black market.

All hell could break loose.

I'm about as religious as a fish driving a motorbike, so religion is not why I feel this way, it could be lethal in the wrong hands.

AnyaMarx · 19/04/2023 19:37

Very crass and dismissive throwncrumbs

Each to their own . That's not a reason to deny someone a dignified death if that's their choice .

And let's face it - doesn't have to be your choice .

Throwncrumbs · 19/04/2023 19:23

SNWannabe · 08/04/2023 01:24

Do you see what people go through when they’re dying here in the Uk? Do you know how many days or weeks or even months it can take? Have you watched a loved one disappear day by day before your eyes? Or have you had your life savings drained through years of Funding care for a loved one?
Death “by injection” would be much like getting a GA and falling asleep- not painful, not scary, controlled and legislated.

Why wouldn’t anyone want to have that option at least???

Well you can volunteer to give the ‘death injection’ maybe you can practise on one of your elderly relatives.

AnyaMarx · 19/04/2023 19:15

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11975825/I-took-stroke-hit-mother-83-die-Dignitas-Switzerland-day-police-banged-door.html

This is a family friend, I knew Janet and I know the family . This shouldn't be this hard when someone has made their wishes so clear .

Mandys original article was in the times and a lazy journo took it to the mail and changed the names , however Mandy is a well respected journalist and often writes for the mail so I'm guessing she took her story back as hers .

It is food for thought .

GoldenAye · 13/04/2023 01:20

pointythings · 12/04/2023 17:24

@LangClegsInSpace I know that you are in favour of AD with safeguards. I know you want this to exist alongside excellent palliative care. On this we are in agreement.

But a lot of posters on here have shared how their loved ones have had to suffer because we don't have that legislation in place and I'm sorry, but you do come across as dismissive of their stories.

I find @LangClegsInSpace to be logical in what can be an emotive space.

pointythings · 12/04/2023 17:24

@LangClegsInSpace I know that you are in favour of AD with safeguards. I know you want this to exist alongside excellent palliative care. On this we are in agreement.

But a lot of posters on here have shared how their loved ones have had to suffer because we don't have that legislation in place and I'm sorry, but you do come across as dismissive of their stories.

LangClegsInSpace · 12/04/2023 17:01

pointythings · 12/04/2023 14:54

@LangClegsInSpace I absolutely can see the difference, but your description of the numbers provided as 'encouraging' when they clearly offer no hope for thousands of people every year is not great.

No, what is 'not great' is your bad faith take on my posts.

justteanbiscuits · 12/04/2023 16:18

I can't find the data for 2022 yet - it seems it hasn't been released yet. For 2021 is 3.3% of deaths.

I support it, with correct safeguards which do happen in Canada, whole heartedly.

NorthStarRising · 12/04/2023 15:50

I would like the same right to die as my dog.
That when the quality of my life has deteriorated to unbearable and I’m in continuous pain and distress, either me or those responsible for me can decide to let me be euthanised. Without fear of prosecution.
DIY can be inefficient, ineffective and sometimes impossible without help.

Felixss · 12/04/2023 15:00

Death isn't pretty for a lot of people here's some pallative care emergencies. Catastrophic bleeding hemorrhage, total obstructions , spinal cord compression , vena cava compression , hypercalcaemia , neutropenic sepsis and there's others. So people should be left alive until the natural with things like this knowing there's no cure it's cruel to be honest. I hope it's legal by the time I die.

pointythings · 12/04/2023 14:54

@LangClegsInSpace I absolutely can see the difference, but your description of the numbers provided as 'encouraging' when they clearly offer no hope for thousands of people every year is not great.

LangClegsInSpace · 12/04/2023 14:42

pointythings · 12/04/2023 09:26

@LangClegsInSpace those stats are NOT encouraging. Over 5000 people every years suffering unbearable unrelievable pain for 3 months? In whose world is that acceptable when a good laternative (if well regulated) is possible?

Where did I say it was 'acceptable'?

If we can reduce the number of people dying with unrelievable pain from 16,130 to 5298 simply by providing the best EoL care then that is encouraging because we could do that now.

'It's encouraging that we could tackle 3/4 of the problem now' =/= 'it's acceptable that 5K+ people per year would still experience no pain relief.'

Can you not see the difference?

AskMeMore · 12/04/2023 14:37

Palliative care needs to be provided well everywhere. Both my parents got excellent NHS care. But I have heard people talking about long delays in getting pain relief for example.

LangClegsInSpace · 12/04/2023 14:26

TrueScrumptious · 12/04/2023 08:59

How in earth do you see those stats as encouraging? Yes, of course the majority of people get effective palliative care. But what about the sizeable proportion that don’t? That’s the whole point.

Yes, of course the majority of people get effective palliative care.

Reading threads about AD on MN (I've been on a few over the past several months) there is no 'of course' about it.

It would be very easy from these threads to get the impression that effective palliative care is rare and that the norm is for people to die in unmitigated agony. I never thought that was the case and I'm pleased the numbers show it's not.

But what about the sizeable proportion that don’t?

As I said, with the best care, we could reduce the number of patients experiencing only partial pain relief from 33% to 13% and the number of patients experiencing no pain relief from 4% to 1%.

Yes, I do find it encouraging to learn that we could massively reduce the amount of pain people are suffering without even having to wait for the law to change, simply by improving EoL care. Why don't you? Hmm

I have said nothing in my above post about whether I think AD should be legalised or not. If you read my previous posts you would know I am in favour with enough safeguards, one of which is good enough palliative care as an alternative.

Luckydip1 · 12/04/2023 13:06

It is awful for doctors who currently have to prolong the lives of patients who are in terrible pain and want to die.

countrygirl99 · 12/04/2023 12:46

AskMeMore · 11/04/2023 18:36

You can have well managed deaths with good painkillers. My parents both had this. We should be campaigning for everyone to have a good death.

None of the painkillers worked for my FIL. Either he was allergic/ had severe side effects or they didn't touch the sides of his pain. He was in constant agony once hos cancer spread to several bones but thankfully sepsis put an end to his suffering.
Ditto DHs uncle suffered copious vomiting and diarrhoea as a side effect of his pain relief drugs in the final stages of his cancer.
The good death you envisage isn't always possible.

KarmaStar · 12/04/2023 12:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GoldenAye · 12/04/2023 09:28

@ChardonnaysBeastlyCat

You had no Advance Decision. You had not expressed any wishes in advance,

No, I had no need to.

And I don't know, or want to know what your condition was, but it does not appear to have been terminal. You are highjacking a situation that was different to yours to make it all about your opinion.

I explained this. Did you read it?

So, yes, you were unwell, but why you felt someone might decide to finish your days on Earth is quite unclear.

I don't recall saying that I felt endangered in this way. What I did say is, because I couldn't communicate in any concrete way, I could not make my wishes known or advocate for myself as a patient or a person. If you haven't experienced this, it hard to explain the feeling of utter helplessness. I can imagine this is somewhat how patients reaching the end of life feel - particularly those with dementia.

I apologise if this makes you uncomfortable; just skip over my posts if so.

pointythings · 12/04/2023 09:27

*alternative (haven't had coffee yet).

pointythings · 12/04/2023 09:26

@LangClegsInSpace those stats are NOT encouraging. Over 5000 people every years suffering unbearable unrelievable pain for 3 months? In whose world is that acceptable when a good laternative (if well regulated) is possible?

TrueScrumptious · 12/04/2023 08:59

LangClegsInSpace · 11/04/2023 23:19

These stats are quite encouraging.

378,427 people receive palliative care a year in England.

The study itself says '378,427 people died in 2017 with palliative care needs' which is a useful clarification and allows this figure to be directly compared with the others given.

125,971 end-of-life patients receiving, or in need of, palliative care suffer from unrelieved pain.

This is around 33%.

16,130 patients experience no relief from their pain at all in the last three months of life.

This is around 4%

Even if unrelieved pain rates were the same as they are in hospices, there would still be 50,709 dying in some level of pain.

This is around 13%

5,298 would still experience no pain relief at all in the last three months of life.

This is around 1%

So the majority of patients experience effective palliative pain relief. With the best care, we could reduce the number of patients experiencing only partial pain relief from 33% to 13% and the number of patients experiencing no pain relief from 4% to 1%.

Regardless of what we do about assisted dying, we should do this.

How in earth do you see those stats as encouraging? Yes, of course the majority of people get effective palliative care. But what about the sizeable proportion that don’t? That’s the whole point.

MyopicBunny · 12/04/2023 08:15

And it was all fine GoldenAye, no one held you down, no one fed you benzos. You are still here to tell your tale.

What a nasty thing to say.