Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask about the EHCP thresholds

70 replies

iwonderwhatisusedtobe · 07/04/2023 20:00

Looking for some insight on what a child's needs are to meet threshold to get an EHCP. I've read quite a bit about children who have managed to achieve good A-levels etc while on an EHCP either at mainstream or special school which is fantastic - as it should be. And I know that ECHPs can be given to support emotional needs as well as academic.

My DS has ASD, is doing poorly academically and is under CAMHs for his anxiety levels/mental health difficulties and yet I've been told by the school that they don't think he needs an EHCP. To be fair to the school they have made various adjustments for him and access to some interventions. But DS has a lot of anxiety and is not performing well academically. At the current rate I would image he will get a couple of 4s at gcse and the rest well below this. He masks however, so his attendance is good and the the fall out is at home after school.

I know the school is the best judge as they have the best measure of what need merits an EHCP. But it would be good to hear from others who are are in a similar situation and how they have been supported, or those whose child has an EHCP and understand better the difference in need, or any teachers. I really don't want to cause any offence with this question as I do fully appreciate that many children's needs will be far greater than my sons.

OP posts:
FloatingBean · 07/04/2023 21:33

On their website IPSEA has a model letter you can use to request an EHCNA. The thresholds are the same whether you apply or the school.

OT, SALT and MH therapies are likely to help. Assistive technology and specialist software beyond what the school can offer at a school SEN Support level and pre-teaching might be beneficial too.

Does DS already have a time out card and movement breaks if necessary? Does he use noise cancelling headphones or ear defenders if necessary? Would moving lessons 5 mins early help?

but parents have a greater rate of success in appeal.

The school can’t appeal. Only parents, or the young person, can appeal.

Abcdefgh1234 · 07/04/2023 21:30

Your son school its lazy IMO. Push them OP. I got 2 asd sons. Both brilliant, year 2 and nursery and both already got ehcp in place. My year 2 is very academically gifted. So very clever, only needs a little bit support on his social skill. My second DS still in nursery but very good and act like NT children, the only think he needs support is around eating. But their school are brilliant. Ehcp is long process, sometime school lazy to do it.

push the school to do ehcp. Its really worth it. Make everything easier for DS.

feellikeanalien · 07/04/2023 21:26

It's also important to remember that an EHCP can cover a child up to the age of 25. He may need different kinds of help when he is no longer in the school system and although it can be hard to get help when your son is a child, when he is classed as an adult it can be nearly impossible.

I would also echo another poster and look at the IPSEA website for help.

Littlebluebird123 · 07/04/2023 21:25

While it isn't a legal requirement for EP involvement, some LAs are overwhelmed and make this their standard. It ties the hands of SENCos.
It would be thrown out under appeal but parents have a greater rate of success in appeal.
Some SENCOs/schools are under the impression that EHCPs are to be awarded for children who are academically below average. In fact, it's to support their needs in education which may also be health related like in your case - mental health support.
The issue is lack of time, funding and support.

You can definitely apply yourself although I would urge you to inform the school of your intentions and ask for the relevant information as it makes your case stronger.

iwonderwhatisusedtobe · 07/04/2023 21:21

I didn't know I could apply for an EHCP myself - I will investigate further. Is it still viewed as positively as if the school apply? DS never causes any trouble at school and I can't help but feel this is partly why he isn't a priority for the school.

What sort of extra help could DS get that is different to what the school offer? He has been in a social skills group this year - though think it is due to end soon. And has had a short stint on help with maths. No other help with other lessons.

OP posts:
MummyJ12 · 07/04/2023 21:17

If a child needs an EHCP, school wants them to have it. It’s just that we are fighting a losing battle against a SEND system that is failing our children.

this just isn’t the case in all schools. Thank goodness for my DS’ psychiatrist who basically forced the school into making the application. Some SENCOs fail our children too.

FloatingBean · 07/04/2023 21:05

It might work differently in different schools/LAs etc, but in my school, if we apply for an EHCP we need to have had EP input.

The legal thresholds are set in law and apply equally to all LAs however much some LAs think they don’t and they can have their own unlawful policies. The only lawful threshold for the initial EHCNA request is a) has or may have SEN, and b) may need SEN provision to be made via an EHCP. Anything else, including requiring an EP assessment prior to the EHCNA request, is unlawful.

If a child needs an EHCP, school wants them to have it.

Unfortunately this isn’t always the case.

Nectarines · 07/04/2023 21:01

It might work differently in different schools/LAs etc, but in my school, if we apply for an EHCP we need to have had EP input. Without that, it will be rejected. The issue is, we have very limited EP hours and, even if we want to but more EP time, there’s none available due to lack of EPs, LA or private.

Combined with that, we are seeing more and more significant needs in mainstream. Children who we are just not equipped to educate. These children have to take priority for the little EP time we have as they need 1:1 to ensure the safety of themselves and others.

If a child needs an EHCP, school wants them to have it. It’s just that we are fighting a losing battle against a SEND system that is failing our children.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 07/04/2023 20:39

Don't listen to school they are trying to save money 🤷‍♀️
Apply yourself there's lots of help on here (sen section) and don't let them fob you off.

elliejjtiny · 07/04/2023 20:39

It's so confusing. My son has moderate learning difficulties and was awarded an ehcp in year 3. I had asked for one repeatedly since before reception and the school always said he didn't need one and all parents at that school who applied anyway after the school said the child didn't need one didn't get the ehcp. So we waited until the school said it was time. We got one with no problems and the ed psych said he should have had one years before.

iwonderwhatisusedtobe · 07/04/2023 20:34

The school has said DS is 'meeting expectations' as basically STATS etc are all very low and he is following that trajectory through secondary (though is doing much better in a couple of subjects that interest him). And of course it could just be that DS isn't that able - some children aren't and that is fine. How can I argue/prove that he could do better if he was better supported, less anxious - I'm sure it is the case but of course could just be a biased parent? Or at least argue it is important to explore why he isn't doing better - I feel he has been written off a bit tbh.

OP posts:
blueshoes · 07/04/2023 20:27

As with things of this nature, do it yourself and be prepared to advocate fight all the way. I wish you all the best. You are doing it for your ds so I know you won't give up.

FloatingBean · 07/04/2023 20:24

Sadly many schools tell parents their DC doesn’t need or won’t get an EHCP but the parents go on to successfully apply themselves, although they may have to appeal.

The initial threshold you need to focus on is that for an EHCNA. It is relatively low - a) has or may have SEN, and b) may need SEN provision to be made via an EHCP (s.36(8) CAFA 2014). Anything else is unlawful.

The test for whether an EHCP is issued is in s.37(1) CAFA 2014 - “Where, in the light of an EHC needs assessment, it is necessary for special educational provision to be made for a child or young person in accordance with an EHC plan”.

Be careful with SENDIASS, some are good but too many repeat the LA’s unlawful policies.

MummyJ12 · 07/04/2023 20:22

Have you asked the CAMHS practitioner as to their thoughts? The LA will ask for their input should you be successful at panel for your DS to be assessed.
We were in exactly the same position. DS’ school were extremely reluctant to support an RSA telling me that we wouldn’t be successful, he doesn’t present in school as he does at home blah blah blah. However, DS’ psychiatrist got involved and insisted that the process should be started and it was put in a letter following an appointment. We were successful and we are coming up to the second panel date in a couple of weeks where it’s expected that he’ll get the EHCP.
If he has a my support plan and he is still struggling then I would absolutely go for it. If school won’t support, get in touch with SENDIASS.
It is well known that LAs aren’t giving the go ahead nearly as much as they used to or should so you’ll need a strong case. Submit a timeline and all of your CAMHS letters as well as asking for a support letter from CAMHS.
Good luck.

imip · 07/04/2023 20:22

Google ‘ ipsea parental request’ and you will find info on how to apply yourself. While the legal threshold is low, your LA is likely to refuse. However, you could say that without a proper assessment, you are unable to fully understand your son’s barriers to learning. Therefore a statutory assessment is necessary. School are trying to help, however they are not clinical psychologists, OTs or other such professionals and they need to come in to help. It sounds like an EP would be helpful. If he is struggling in certain areas, is it because he has troubles with inference or some other language problems? Is the sensory environment a stressor? Are you able to evidence that he is able to academically perform well but something g is holding him back?

school should be able to bring in some some professional als, eg, SALT, autism outreach or EP who might be able to provide advice, though this can be so very hard to secure.

clocktock · 07/04/2023 20:18

Apply yourself.

For years I was told my dd wouldn't get an ehcp as the school felt they met her needs.

I applied myself and got one with no problems.

I just don't think they want the hassle etc

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 07/04/2023 20:15

I'd echo the fact that schools aren't the best judge. Apply yourself.

Namechange828492 · 07/04/2023 20:15

My DS has an EHCP And ime it's a total gamble and depends on if the people writing the reports know "how" to do it. ds attended a private SS for a year (which turned out to be not right for him) so before he transitioned to MS the school got their in house people to write the reports in a way the council couldn't argue with. I don't think generally schools know how to apply so it can't be argued with which is sad but true.

PurpleBugz · 07/04/2023 20:12

To add..

To have an EHCP needs assessment you just have to show 'may have SEN'. Then the LA assess and see if EHCP is needed. It's a very low threshold for assessment. You can appeal if they say no to assessment. As is likely they say no to most. Most appeals win because to get assessment it's a very low threshold

PurpleBugz · 07/04/2023 20:10

In my experience schools are not best to judge parents are. School didn't want the extra work in my sons case.

I found some helpful groups on Facebook to find out about EHCPs.

The main thing i would say is parents can apply themselves you don't have to rely on school. In my experience schools don't have/give the time to apply properly. My sons school applied and it was turned down but I then applied myself and he got amoung other things a full time 1-2-1 in the EHCP