Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Absolutely fuming Inlaws idea of when lunchtime is

185 replies

indianMIL · 07/04/2023 15:20

I don’t get along with Inlaws. They have never made me feel part of the family. SIL don’t bother and every time I’ve tried to get close they make it clear “I’m not family”. We’re Indians so on the many weddings and celebrations they pretend to like me which I never understood and naively took each wedding / party as a sign they did really want to be close but I misread it that they were pretending, now I know they pretend to like me at function so I do the same.

I don’t talk to them. I made the obligatory visit where she pushes me aside to get to DH and kids and ignores me. Sorry for all the background here is the AIBU:

DH has today off and we hardly see him as he travels with work and works in the city when he is in UK so we rarely have family time. I was excited about this weekend. His mother was supposed to come at lunch to see our new house so I spent entire day cleaning and guess what she’s still not here! It’s 3:15! I’m fuming as the weather is actually nice today and been raining all week. DH as usual doesn’t see my point of view. I’ve asked him to call them and he’s refusing as they will get upset as in the culture “sons house, their house etc,” plus MIL will do her usual fake dramas of crying and saying she didn’t realise she needs an appointment to see her family.

im really pissed off. He said I should say something to them when they arrive if I’m so upset (he’s not remotely upset or annoyed that they’re not here yet) I know and he knows I won’t because it will erupt and my kids don’t need to have their holiday ruined. Bloody bitch.

OP posts:
Mari9999 · 08/04/2023 14:57

OP, it does seem a bit dramatic to say that you only had 4.15 hours with kids that you live with and see every day.
You don't seem understanding or accepting of the fact that your husband might experience your family in exactly the same way that you experience his family. What you experience as warm and welcoming in your family he may experience as overreaching and intrusive. It is all a matter of individual differences and individual perceptions. You may both be correct in describing the way that you experience each other's family. Some one else might have a totally different experience and response to both families.

UsingChangeofName · 08/04/2023 13:40

Anoisagusaris · 07/04/2023 23:57

12.30 would be ridiculously early for a social lunch…..unless all invitees are 2.

also, just being pedantic, but how did you spend the entire cleaning when you were posting mid-afternoon?

Not in my world.
I am in the UK and 12.30 / 1pm is a very normal time to eat lunch. Hmm

But, even if I were invited to something at a time I thought unusual, I understand that it is up to the host to decide, and that I can accept and go for that time, or decline if for some reason I was so inflexible I couldn't change my routine.

Not that I can understand how anyone needs to "spend the whole day cleaning". That must be a choice that the OP has decided to make. I've never "spent the whole day cleaning" in my life.

Although, OP, from your post on the last page, this is clearly much more than about your PiL's manner - this is about how rude your dh is.

Anywherebuthere · 08/04/2023 12:14

Catwithbigfeet · 08/04/2023 12:06

After reading all that, what stands out is not your relationship with the in laws but your relationship with your dh

He doesn’t sound like a supportive partner and sounds as passive aggressive as his family.

Why are you still with him ?

This.

The main problem in this is the 'DH'.

The 'DH' has no respect for her and is enabling the in-law behaviour.

Catwithbigfeet · 08/04/2023 12:06

After reading all that, what stands out is not your relationship with the in laws but your relationship with your dh

He doesn’t sound like a supportive partner and sounds as passive aggressive as his family.

Why are you still with him ?

declutteringmymind · 08/04/2023 11:58

@indianMIL

For your your sake you need to stop making a massive deal about this. Take a deep breath, learn from the experience. Especially look at how other family members deal with this kind of behaviour and watch and learn. Also just keep quiet and get on with what you want to do. Don't let her ruin today as well as yesterday. Fill your life with those who are your type of people. She will then become insignificant.

Take it from someone who has been through these exact same situations.

Thundercats77 · 08/04/2023 11:51

OP you should have fed the kids and then taken them out. DH could stay at home and inform you when they finally rock up and then you can (in no rush) when you are ready, go home. Going forward do this in the future. Give specific times of when you will be expecting them next time. And if they are more than 30 mins late with no call to say they are running late, go and do your own thing. I am of Indian heritage too and find this quite unacceptable. If they aren't pleasant to you don't converse with them.

SkyandSurf · 08/04/2023 10:51

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:42

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there. There’s a huge difference between his behaviour and mine - I would genuinely like them if they didn’t make me feel awkward. My family is warm and welcoming to him but he’s always off with them and acts like his parents just silent and cold.

Ah so you're also married to a dick.

That's your real problem

Jagoda · 08/04/2023 09:59

DH problem as is so often the case.

You don’t have to live like this you know ❤️

AgentJohnson · 08/04/2023 09:57

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there.

Ahh, so this is a not so dear H problem, you are married to a twat.

When he’s rude to your family, he’s only embarrassing himself. By toeing the line and keeping up appearances in front of his and your family, the only winner is your twat of a H and his dysfunctional relationship with his family.

Rant away but only you can change this and I don’t mean persuading your H and PIL to act like grown ups but by making it clear that you won’t be bullied or manipulated into silently being their version of a dutiful DIL.

diddl · 08/04/2023 09:47

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:42

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there. There’s a huge difference between his behaviour and mine - I would genuinely like them if they didn’t make me feel awkward. My family is warm and welcoming to him but he’s always off with them and acts like his parents just silent and cold.

Your husband is just plain nasty.

Perhaps you should think about leaving.

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:45

To the person who said I’m being melodramatic and it was only 3:15! Well you obviously don’t have young kids whose bedtime is at 7:30.l, and yes I stick to bedtimes at holidays too. Due to the fact I spent the day cleaning and making sure there was enough food that meant I only had 4.15 hours with my kids.

OP posts:
AgentJohnson · 08/04/2023 09:43

This is who they are and they aren’t going to change and this is who your H is and he isn’t going to change either. Prioritising people who treat you like an option is never going to end well.

If you want to keep your sanity, you need to accept that this is who these people are (H included). Next time, given them until 14:00 and go out with your children. Your H can stay home and enjoy the awkward exchanges.

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:42

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there. There’s a huge difference between his behaviour and mine - I would genuinely like them if they didn’t make me feel awkward. My family is warm and welcoming to him but he’s always off with them and acts like his parents just silent and cold.

OP posts:
TomeTome · 08/04/2023 09:39

Highdaysandholidays1 · 08/04/2023 09:27

No, everyone in a given culture doesn't find the same things rude, as we see hourly on mumsnet threads! But there are differences in time management in different nations and cultures broadly speaking, and not knowing that makes you seem a tiny bit narrow-minded. 12.30 for a 1pm lunch is not a thing in many cultures!

Which is why I expressly said it was the norm in the UK not in a particular culture. @indianMIL s in laws are not behaving like this to enhance her status or enjoyment and should be adapting to HER expectations in her home. They are attempting to undermine her and they know it.

maddening · 08/04/2023 09:38

If dh doesn't chat follow his lead imo, let the silence hang.

gotmychristmasmiracle · 08/04/2023 09:35

I wouldn't worry about oh family, it's up to husband to manage. At least you missed an awkward afternoon of politeness. So did they even turned up in the end ?

Highdaysandholidays1 · 08/04/2023 09:27

No, everyone in a given culture doesn't find the same things rude, as we see hourly on mumsnet threads! But there are differences in time management in different nations and cultures broadly speaking, and not knowing that makes you seem a tiny bit narrow-minded. 12.30 for a 1pm lunch is not a thing in many cultures!

Kanaloa · 08/04/2023 09:25

Trinityloop · 07/04/2023 23:29

It's just a different culture. I'm my sister for example invited me for lunch and I turned up at 12.30 shed probably not be in, be still drying her hair etc.

When you give times, you don't expect people to turn up at them and it's almost considered rude if you do (its like turning up several hours early)

Some cultures if you said 12.00 for example would turn up around 12, others arrive early eg. For 12, others any time after 12.

Things like weddings etc are often several hours behind so its not seen as a reluctance or that people are arsing you around

But again, this is obviously not just a ‘cultural’ thing because op (from the same culture) finds it rude. So clearly they are not all in agreement that their culture finds this acceptable behaviour.

padsi1975 · 08/04/2023 09:16

Op, hold your nerve and DO NOT chit chat. Stay silent unless spoken to. Let your dh and family to it, not your problem. My dh has a family member I don't like and if he visits I go out. If my dh wants to see him, he knows he will have to visit and take kids without me. It caused a bit of annoyance at first but my dh now knows its pointless pushing it as he knows my position and that's that. You head off out somewhere, leave dh and kids to it. It's your dh family, you don't get on. Don't stop him or kids seeing them but you can minimise your involvement. Good luck.

Sodd · 08/04/2023 09:14

Personally I’d have everything ready, take the kids out and tell the parents to text once they have arrived at your house. You’ll then return to the house yourself.

TomeTome · 08/04/2023 09:11

It's a social code, not rudeness.
breaking social codes or expected manners IS rude. That’s what “rude” means aka “ill-mannered”.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 08/04/2023 09:05

I also agree it's fine to set the time in your own home and proceed on, I'm more understanding when abroad as the whole set up is designed for people to come late e.g. food served in small plates over several hours, no-one sits down to dinner and eats it all in 20 min and needs it to be hot, meals last many hours and people often pop in and out.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 08/04/2023 09:04

Time is elastic in many cultures, my husband's for one (not Indian, eastern Europe). Everyone understands the parameters and being quite late is completely expected. It's problematic in the UK and when he returns home for that reason, because we are used to being on time. It's a social code, not rudeness.

TomeTome · 08/04/2023 07:58

Anoisagusaris · 07/04/2023 23:57

12.30 would be ridiculously early for a social lunch…..unless all invitees are 2.

also, just being pedantic, but how did you spend the entire cleaning when you were posting mid-afternoon?

How odd. Lunch in the UK is traditionally served at 1pm, turning up after 12:30 is shockingly rude it’s usually “12 for 1” so you have time for a drink first. Preschoolers lunch might be at 12.

Anoisagusaris · 07/04/2023 23:57

12.30 would be ridiculously early for a social lunch…..unless all invitees are 2.

also, just being pedantic, but how did you spend the entire cleaning when you were posting mid-afternoon?