Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Absolutely fuming Inlaws idea of when lunchtime is

185 replies

indianMIL · 07/04/2023 15:20

I don’t get along with Inlaws. They have never made me feel part of the family. SIL don’t bother and every time I’ve tried to get close they make it clear “I’m not family”. We’re Indians so on the many weddings and celebrations they pretend to like me which I never understood and naively took each wedding / party as a sign they did really want to be close but I misread it that they were pretending, now I know they pretend to like me at function so I do the same.

I don’t talk to them. I made the obligatory visit where she pushes me aside to get to DH and kids and ignores me. Sorry for all the background here is the AIBU:

DH has today off and we hardly see him as he travels with work and works in the city when he is in UK so we rarely have family time. I was excited about this weekend. His mother was supposed to come at lunch to see our new house so I spent entire day cleaning and guess what she’s still not here! It’s 3:15! I’m fuming as the weather is actually nice today and been raining all week. DH as usual doesn’t see my point of view. I’ve asked him to call them and he’s refusing as they will get upset as in the culture “sons house, their house etc,” plus MIL will do her usual fake dramas of crying and saying she didn’t realise she needs an appointment to see her family.

im really pissed off. He said I should say something to them when they arrive if I’m so upset (he’s not remotely upset or annoyed that they’re not here yet) I know and he knows I won’t because it will erupt and my kids don’t need to have their holiday ruined. Bloody bitch.

OP posts:
Mari9999 · 08/04/2023 20:56

@Nanaof1
OP and her MIL are both adults. They have the right to manage their relationship as adults. There is absolutely no reason to involve the children in their differences.
These children probably love both their mother and their grandmother. They should not be used as pawns in the acrimony existing between these 2 adult women.

When these children are older , they will form their own opinion about the relationship that exist between mom and grandmother, and it will be informed by what they know of mom and grandmother. At this early stage, the only thing that they need to know is that both mom and grandmother love them.

If mom steps out for a bit, there is absolutely no reason why the children should be taken from the home unless the mom functions on a theory of " my enemy is by default their enemy. " The OP has in no way suggested that her MIL is unkind or abusive to the children. It is also likely that at a young age these children are too self absorbed to pay much if any attention to the way that mom and grandmother interact. OP is not teaching her children about kindness by taking the kids away from their grandparents if the grandparents are perceived by the children as people that they love.

Nanaof1 · 08/04/2023 20:50

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:42

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there. There’s a huge difference between his behaviour and mine - I would genuinely like them if they didn’t make me feel awkward. My family is warm and welcoming to him but he’s always off with them and acts like his parents just silent and cold.

So, your "DH" is anything but dear. Got it. I do not understand why you let anyone treat you like this. Your children watch this and grow up to act just like your DH/ILs and you. You perpetuate a culture within a culture that thinks demeaning the wife/mother of the ILs is acceptable. It's not the culture as a whole, it's some of the people within that culture doing what they want, treating others like crap and then having the "it's our culture" excuse.
The fact that you are with a man who treats you and your side of the family like this is very telling. If he isn't willing to work on it and work on treating you as a person with immense value to the world, then you need to think about what lessons you want your children to learn.

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 08/04/2023 20:39

*is

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 08/04/2023 20:39

Antigonads · 07/04/2023 16:51

Isn’t this just part of what we refer to as Asian timekeeping?

In my heritage, my culture is English, this 8s referred to as 'soon come'.

Nanaof1 · 08/04/2023 20:34

Mari9999 · 07/04/2023 23:53

Why should OP need to take the children out? The grandparents likely want to see their grandchildren and the children likely enjoy seeing their grandparents.

It is the OP and the grandmother who seemingly do not enjoy each other's presence and company. Well it may not be well received, but the OP can find reasons to be absent for some of the visits. The MIl.will.probably express indignation over her absence, but she was going to be offended by something anyway.

Because, on a nice day, where the OP wants to spend time with HER DC, the children should not be forced to miss out because some over-entitled harridan is going to show up at some point to see what havoc she can wreak on the household. I don't really care if it's "the culture", making her children abide by it only makes this cultural tradition go on when it needs to be put into the nearest dumpster.
OP: If you lay yourself at the feet of your MIL/ILs; don't be shocked when they use you as a doormat. You cannot change how they act, that's up to them. But, you can change how you are treated by the way you act. Undervaluing yourself will only teach others (like your DC/DH) to undervalue you and perpetuate a culture that would be better for everyone if eased into the 21st century.

stacyvaron · 08/04/2023 20:27

Take the kids to the park and leave a note on the door for her tocome join you.

MMosheDaddysGirl4ever · 08/04/2023 20:24

Girl I feel your pain. Things were fine then they weren’t. Thought my “H” was backing me up and he wasn’t. Fast forward thru some yrs and I decide enough and reached out to the sil. I thought things were cool but my mil would make comments thru text with underlying meanings. The last straw was when I texted bout a party for my son and my mil responded to my sil not realizing I’d see it. It took a couple hrs to respond cuz I was gonna go off something fierce. My Dad passed a couple yrs ago n he was my world. They didn’t bother reaching out while my Dad was sick and when he died. I got a pathetic “sorry for ur loss sending hugs” from my sil and that was it. Not once did they call n ask if anything was needed, checked on the kids, absolutely nothing. I had enough n ended up responding in the text to them n bought my H into it…..my meaning was all there in a “nice” way pointing out the kids n I are still tryna pick up the pieces n H can’t jump in and help me, he didn’t when it was all happening n said just that n said I was sorry for thinking H was letting them know shit n thinkn he’d step up for once n that 1 time in over 15yrs, I didn’t say anything cuz I thought H did……I haven’t responded to anything from them, I no longer bother with seeing how they all are, nothing. I’ve had 1 party since n put it in a group along w/ my fam n friends, the ones that been there for us. Of course mil responds saying surgeries are coming up and blah blah……what is messed up is they NEVER tell me what is going on whether it’s bout my sils kids or my in laws health shit, absolutely nothing. I do it once n the world is ending. That told me what I already knew “they talked behind my back”. They are nothing but dramatic, liars, and fake. I happier now without bothering with them. It’s sad since my 14yr old has fallen into their “poor us” trap and my 9yr old never hears from them or anything. The 22yr old Can care less now. They’ve never made an effort to visit us, even after I had my 2 with the H. They come to parties n that’s it. They actually haven’t been to a party in over 2yrs too. I had to step away. It’s not healthy mentally and when you go thru something major like I did n they not there, it really messes u up. I heard from my mil once when my dad was sick n it was all bout how my H is worried. I’m sorry hun but u don’t know ur son, he hasn’t done a thing to help me, he just watches when I crumble, it’s pathetic. Sometimes u have to do what best for urself in these situations. I tried letting it go but I can’t anymore, it’s not fair. It’s not fair to you or your children either. At the end of the day, it’s their loss, not yours.

1234S · 08/04/2023 20:24

Grow some and say something when she turns up

i am indian this is so typical

newnamethanks · 08/04/2023 20:10

Could be worse. My old manager's FIL died and, cultural responsibility she said, MIL promptly moved in with her son and family. For good. She was really p'-d off as they had to fill in their swimming pool to build a granny flat. They didn't get on, last I heard she'd been living there for 15 years "every day is hell".

Astorminateacup · 08/04/2023 19:35

Your husband does not sound very nice to be honest...

Happyvalleyfan · 08/04/2023 19:05

Rise above it and mirror good behaviour for them. Ignore their passive behaviour. They’ll know full well they are misbehaving - even though for their own reasons may not be able/ have the inclination to change. Don’t think Indian families are unique in this.

Chat away like you you’re close and ignore the looks like water off a ducks back.

Make a point to speak to speak to his parents when they ring- or even ring them for a laugh. Then when your parents ring- make DH say hello to them- it’ll too mortifying for him to ignore. If he does ignore - have a conversation with him about how this has upset you. Involve him directly in conversation when they visit.

If they’re late for lunch - tell DH you’re feeding kids lunch at a reasonable hour and then may take them out for a play . He can telephone you if they arrive prior your return.

rainingsnoring · 08/04/2023 19:03

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:42

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there. There’s a huge difference between his behaviour and mine - I would genuinely like them if they didn’t make me feel awkward. My family is warm and welcoming to him but he’s always off with them and acts like his parents just silent and cold.

This is the problem. You are worried to a nasty mummy's boy who doesn't respect you and doesn't care about your feelings or your family.

Stop expecting the in laws to like you because they won't change. You need to change your response to them. Be out, be busy, stop cleaning the house. Your 'DH' can do it.

Shitsandwiches · 08/04/2023 18:59

Reminds me of my exH and exMIL. Ex being the operative word.

Rude to your family when they're nothing but nice to him and then expecting you to tolerate his family's clear rudeness to you. Disgusting.

You sound rightly frustrated and upset because you're being disrespected and unsupported - not melodramatic at all OP.

I'm not sure, by the sounds of it, that this will ever change. (Nor would it for his next wife/your MIL's next DIL if that were to happen)

Good luck Flowers

Solonge · 08/04/2023 18:52

I feel for you! But next time be prepared. Buffet lunch, covered, they can help themselves and you plan a day out with the kids. The other thing that works is to smirk back, when they speak to you. Dont start conversations, its pointless.

however what is truly unacceptable is your husbands rudeness to your family! He sounds very arrogant and you need to speak to him about his attitude. If you have the kind of marriage where he works and considers himself king of the castle, whilst you are seen as the kittle housewife…you need to bring him back to earth and understand he is living in a country where men and women are equal, well, mostly and you are not accepting this arrangement.

Bellabeemarie · 08/04/2023 18:51

Sounds like your H has the same issues your MIL has.... apple doesn't fall far from the tree and all that 🤔

He accepts his mother's actions because his actions are the same.

I wouldn't be bothered about upsetting him or his mother and would make myself unavailable when she visits from now on.... and definitely no pretending everything is OK for a audience and she's a bitch every other times! Most definitely not she can keep the same two-faced attitude she's has and roll with it 🫣

Honestly it's very disrespectful how they both treat you, you deserve better than that don't put up with it 🩷

Whatsocurringmervin · 08/04/2023 18:41

I can see why you would feel so upset, it looks like it’s a long and painful past for you with this family. Sending love to you.

I know Indian culture can be very, very dismissive of daughter in laws. The fact your DH shows no sign of support must make it feel further alienating too.

it’s amazing how much can be brushed off when your partner and you can give each other the look “oh jeez, these people” and have an in joke to chat about how crazy and rude they were later on. Or better yet, to stand up to them in the moment and make sure you are included and valued as part of the family.

you deserve consideration and thoughtfulness in any relationship, family or otherwise x

RYANCONWAY602 · 08/04/2023 18:34

That's awful. Hope you have a good weekend anyway. I'm a single man, but f me, that's not nice at all. Bless you. X

L3ThirtySeven · 08/04/2023 18:31

I would be livid at MIL as well. In no culture is 3:15 lunch time.
I’m also furious your DH won’t call them..at the very least he could call with excuse to ensure they are ok because they should have been at yours ages ago and what if they were in a car accident, or one was sick and had to go to the hospital? He can play the loving son act to the nth degree. It doesn’t have to be a call that goes “what the fuck, why aren’t you here? You know how my wife is”

ScruffyGrape · 08/04/2023 18:30

I wouldn't leave DH at home alone, leave him with the kids and you go and have a day to yourself. Not ideal as you want to spend time as a family. But there is nothing worse than waiting on someone to come around and scupper your plans. We no longer do it, we give them a courteous amount of time for lateness then bugger off out if we have something to do. Obviously you can't do this because of your husbands culture. So go and have a day to yourself. See how miffed he gets, being stuck in house waiting in his parents then!

violetrain1 · 08/04/2023 18:30

My husband is from a similar ish culture (Afghanistan)

I solved this problem by making sure when they never turned up at the correct time to be out.

Every time they turned up without warning (I was on the way out to an important appointment)

Now they call to ask if we will be in!
And turn up 15 mins early to arranged lunches!

TreehousePine · 08/04/2023 18:29

Indian time (ime):

12pm Breakfast
4pm Lunch
6pm Tea
10pm Dinner

You're welcome. 😉

YouSeenMyMarbles · 08/04/2023 18:27

I think because you dont get on its excabated the issue. You'll always have frustrating times when you have a realationship with someone who you know doesnt like you.

I see three options:

  1. Put up with frustrating situations for the rest of your life
  2. Learn to not give a crap, and accept
  3. Or have a face to face convo, just the two of you, and resolve the conflict. Try to learn what she wants, teach her what you want, and see if you can accomodate her wants. Then have time together - just you two, no kids, and active work on building and bonding. This might be hard for you to accept, but it might make your life easier in the long run

xx

MariesKnickKnacks · 08/04/2023 18:19

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:42

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there. There’s a huge difference between his behaviour and mine - I would genuinely like them if they didn’t make me feel awkward. My family is warm and welcoming to him but he’s always off with them and acts like his parents just silent and cold.

This sums up the man you're married to. This is his personality.

He's not going to change, so you can either remain in that situation for the rest of your life or ditch him.

I know what I'd do.

startingagain13 · 08/04/2023 18:00

I sympathise, I have in laws problems too which causing problems in my marriage. I think my MIL and SIL do a lot of pretending to like me too. It's very hurtful as I fell for it. Essentially I'm not blood.

Alipops1967 · 08/04/2023 17:53

Your husband sounds like a mummies boy , I walked out of my relationship for more or less the same problem...... Interfering Mothers of men

Swipe left for the next trending thread