Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Absolutely fuming Inlaws idea of when lunchtime is

185 replies

indianMIL · 07/04/2023 15:20

I don’t get along with Inlaws. They have never made me feel part of the family. SIL don’t bother and every time I’ve tried to get close they make it clear “I’m not family”. We’re Indians so on the many weddings and celebrations they pretend to like me which I never understood and naively took each wedding / party as a sign they did really want to be close but I misread it that they were pretending, now I know they pretend to like me at function so I do the same.

I don’t talk to them. I made the obligatory visit where she pushes me aside to get to DH and kids and ignores me. Sorry for all the background here is the AIBU:

DH has today off and we hardly see him as he travels with work and works in the city when he is in UK so we rarely have family time. I was excited about this weekend. His mother was supposed to come at lunch to see our new house so I spent entire day cleaning and guess what she’s still not here! It’s 3:15! I’m fuming as the weather is actually nice today and been raining all week. DH as usual doesn’t see my point of view. I’ve asked him to call them and he’s refusing as they will get upset as in the culture “sons house, their house etc,” plus MIL will do her usual fake dramas of crying and saying she didn’t realise she needs an appointment to see her family.

im really pissed off. He said I should say something to them when they arrive if I’m so upset (he’s not remotely upset or annoyed that they’re not here yet) I know and he knows I won’t because it will erupt and my kids don’t need to have their holiday ruined. Bloody bitch.

OP posts:
Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 04:39

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:42

The problem with not being there is that my DH will take it out on me for example when anyone from my family visits he will start being rude and obvious he doesn’t want them there. There’s a huge difference between his behaviour and mine - I would genuinely like them if they didn’t make me feel awkward. My family is warm and welcoming to him but he’s always off with them and acts like his parents just silent and cold.

So your DH is a rude twat as well, then?

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 04:37

Highdaysandholidays1 · 08/04/2023 09:27

No, everyone in a given culture doesn't find the same things rude, as we see hourly on mumsnet threads! But there are differences in time management in different nations and cultures broadly speaking, and not knowing that makes you seem a tiny bit narrow-minded. 12.30 for a 1pm lunch is not a thing in many cultures!

Then they should have politely declined!

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 04:34

Mari9999 · 07/04/2023 23:53

Why should OP need to take the children out? The grandparents likely want to see their grandchildren and the children likely enjoy seeing their grandparents.

It is the OP and the grandmother who seemingly do not enjoy each other's presence and company. Well it may not be well received, but the OP can find reasons to be absent for some of the visits. The MIl.will.probably express indignation over her absence, but she was going to be offended by something anyway.

There's quite a strong and important message to the kids by taking them out.

Lateness, especially deliberate, is bloody rude. It's not a nice trait. Teaching the kids that lateness is an absolute disregard of other people's time will set them up well in life and stop the circle.

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 04:30

Trinityloop · 07/04/2023 23:29

It's just a different culture. I'm my sister for example invited me for lunch and I turned up at 12.30 shed probably not be in, be still drying her hair etc.

When you give times, you don't expect people to turn up at them and it's almost considered rude if you do (its like turning up several hours early)

Some cultures if you said 12.00 for example would turn up around 12, others arrive early eg. For 12, others any time after 12.

Things like weddings etc are often several hours behind so its not seen as a reluctance or that people are arsing you around

Just because you are happy to mess people around this way, it doesn't make it acceptable.

Sortyourlifeout · 09/04/2023 04:13

Trinityloop · 07/04/2023 15:30

This is a cultural thing. I'm from a similar culture (judging from your description). Timings just don't work in the same way.

It's completely common to be several hours late to absolutely anything, regardless of importance. If I invited my family for lunch, they would arrive 4 ish probably.

It's bloody rude.

Magenta82 · 09/04/2023 04:01

Valeriekat · 09/04/2023 03:31

... And yet most restaurants stop serving at 2pm!

Interesting, I've just spent the last 10 minutes thinking of all the restaurants I go to, independent and chain, cheap and more expensive, cafes, pubs, and various restaurants, and the only one I can think of that does anything like that is a cheap and cheerful Chinese buffet that stops letting people in at 2pm.

I also had a scroll through the chat channel my team uses to announce when they are nipping of for lunch, there is the very occasional early day when someone will go at 12/1230 but I'd sat 80% are after 1.30.

I'm not trying to be argumentative, it could be selection bias or something, maybe I'm simply selecting the ones open later. But I wonder where you are and what kinds of places you go for lunch?

Zvifflemeyer · 09/04/2023 03:47

I would apply college rules to the situation. In universitys in the US, if the professor is more than 15 minutes late, you are free to leave and he cannot penalize you for missing class. Lunch is generally somewhere between 11 and 12:30. at 1245, you waited as long as you are obligated to as lunch is over. I CERTAINLY wouldnt have waited til 3 or 4 for her.

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/04/2023 03:34

It doesn’t sound as if your husband likes you very much either op. Please don’t throw your life away on a man and his family, who treat you like an annoyance. These days, you have options.

Valeriekat · 09/04/2023 03:31

Magenta82 · 08/04/2023 21:03

Just north of London, around 2 usually. If I was booking a table at a restaurant it would be at 2pm. If I was cooking at home I would aim for around 2 to serve it. Big occasions, Christmas etc I would probably aim for a bit later.

... And yet most restaurants stop serving at 2pm!

rangagirl · 09/04/2023 03:27

@newnamethanks

My cousin is married to an Indian man, so she knows that the ‘culture’ is that they will move in and she will care for them when they retire.

She got married knowing that, though. She agreed to that condition, so as ridiculous as most of us think it is it is for grown adults to expect their son’s wife to baby them in old age, that’s what she has agreed to - but at least she knew. She wasn’t blindsided years later.

They seem nice, though. They like her and they get along. So when they move in, it might not be such a nightmare for her as it is for some other people - if the in laws are not rude and entitled and treat you like absolute dirt, then your life of living with them might not be so bad.

I couldn’t even imagine. But now that I KNOW that about Indian culture, I won’t ever consider dating an Indian man who expects me to do that - because I don’t have any desire to.

T1Dmama · 09/04/2023 02:54

Zipadeebooyah · 07/04/2023 17:10

Culture is completely irrelevant. She knows she's mucking you about, and you're letting her.

I hope you did as PPs suggested and went out for the rest of the day either with or without your children.

You need to start doing that going forward. Set an exact time ("lunch will be on the table at 12, see you then) and if she doesn't show you simply start eating and go about your day as normal. If she's late just repeat that you told her lunch was at 1 and she should have phoned to say she was running late.

You need to start biting back. Keep it polite and matter of fact. She'll fucking hate it but you'll put an end to her mucking about with your head.

To be honest I'd cut all communication. She's made it clear she doesn't like you. Let your husband do all the communicating, planning, arranging, cooking etc from now on. Sometimes you might be around, other times you might be out doing other things. Don't revolve your life around her. Just crack on doing your own thing. She's his mother.

This.
min future let him do the cleaning and cooking for his mother ..
Tell him you’re not doing it anymore because she treats you like shit.

BasqueMass · 09/04/2023 02:00

Mari9999 · 08/04/2023 20:56

@Nanaof1
OP and her MIL are both adults. They have the right to manage their relationship as adults. There is absolutely no reason to involve the children in their differences.
These children probably love both their mother and their grandmother. They should not be used as pawns in the acrimony existing between these 2 adult women.

When these children are older , they will form their own opinion about the relationship that exist between mom and grandmother, and it will be informed by what they know of mom and grandmother. At this early stage, the only thing that they need to know is that both mom and grandmother love them.

If mom steps out for a bit, there is absolutely no reason why the children should be taken from the home unless the mom functions on a theory of " my enemy is by default their enemy. " The OP has in no way suggested that her MIL is unkind or abusive to the children. It is also likely that at a young age these children are too self absorbed to pay much if any attention to the way that mom and grandmother interact. OP is not teaching her children about kindness by taking the kids away from their grandparents if the grandparents are perceived by the children as people that they love.

You are woefully naive.

Kids model themselves on the adults around them. It’s already clear that the father has absorbed his parents’ bad behaviour, and now here’s an opportunity for another generation to be ruined by it.

notjaneausten · 08/04/2023 23:57

If people want to live her, and millions do, wouldn't they want our 'culture' too

rangagirl · 08/04/2023 23:55

@Vgt6y357

I agree. It really pisses me off when people make plans and then just don’t turn up. So I won’t wait around - screw them.

I had a friend call once to ask to come and pick up something he’d loaned me. Actually made a specific plan. An hour after he was supposed to arrive, I just left the house to go to the pool purely because I was pissed off at being expected to sit around all day!

He texted a couple of hours later, wondering why I wasn’t home… uh, did you really expect me to be? You called this morning and said you were coming by at X time. You didn’t make the plan 6 months ago and forget the exact time!

Gemcat1 · 08/04/2023 22:48

Tell your inlaws that you will be serving lunch to your kids at 1pm and, afterwards, you will be taking them out to enjoy the sunshine. It is usual in Indian families for the parents to be the head of the family and expect their children to fall into line. Explain to your DH how you feel and that you are no longer going to fall into their line. He is standing back because he doesn't want to upset his parents but doesn't seem to care that you are upset. My DH didn't even notice how badly his family treated me until I put my foot down after an unpleasant incident which caused extreme distress. I didn't stop him seeing his family but it was under my terms. My sons wanted nothing to do with them and only said hello before going out. His father died when he was young and the poison came from MIL. Once she died I refused to have any further contact with his family and my sons feel the same. You have to be careful because your DH's behaviour will affect your DCs at some point.

Mombie · 08/04/2023 22:27

I am from the same culture and although sadly this kind of stuff was expected in the past, it really isnt the norm for many British Indian families now. I feel terrible for the generations of Indian women who have had to live like this in the past. Nowadays we have choices, freedom and voices to stop this control and manipulation being passed off as culture. Think about the culture you will be passing down to your own children.

You sound incredibly frustrated and unhappy with your DH and his family. The first step is going to be thinking about your relationship with your DH. How does he help and support you? Is he even on your team?

Mari9999 · 08/04/2023 21:56

@Redebs
If you are correct and there is going to be nasty comments no matter what she does, then why prevent the children from seeing their grandparents. That action will only stop the children from having a happy encounter with their grandparents and won't improve the OP's situation in any way.

Redebs · 08/04/2023 21:24

Mari9999 · 08/04/2023 20:56

@Nanaof1
OP and her MIL are both adults. They have the right to manage their relationship as adults. There is absolutely no reason to involve the children in their differences.
These children probably love both their mother and their grandmother. They should not be used as pawns in the acrimony existing between these 2 adult women.

When these children are older , they will form their own opinion about the relationship that exist between mom and grandmother, and it will be informed by what they know of mom and grandmother. At this early stage, the only thing that they need to know is that both mom and grandmother love them.

If mom steps out for a bit, there is absolutely no reason why the children should be taken from the home unless the mom functions on a theory of " my enemy is by default their enemy. " The OP has in no way suggested that her MIL is unkind or abusive to the children. It is also likely that at a young age these children are too self absorbed to pay much if any attention to the way that mom and grandmother interact. OP is not teaching her children about kindness by taking the kids away from their grandparents if the grandparents are perceived by the children as people that they love.

I'm sure if she went out without the children there would be a lot of nastiness about her 'neglecting her duties'

Blip · 08/04/2023 21:18

Next time, invite them for lunch at a specific time: 12/1/2pm
Eat at this time whether they are there or not. Afterwards go out to the park with the DC, leave DH at home if he prefers.
PIL can have cold or reheated food on their own or with DH.

They will soon learn.

Noicant · 08/04/2023 21:10

It’s your husband, he doesn’t do anything and your MIL sees that as a green light. He’s perpetuating the idea that you need to sit there and take it or he’ll punish you afterwards. Your husband is a giant twat. I’m Indian, no this is not normal, most of the couples I know in my family eyeroll each other over this kind of thing. My in-laws are genuinely lovely thank god but I know DH would tackle it head on of there was a problem from his side of the family. We’ve both done it for each other before. You are supposed to be a team but he’s letting the side down here. Does he think he’s done you a favour by marrying you? Do you even like each other? Because I can’t see how you could like him very much.

Magenta82 · 08/04/2023 21:03

Just north of London, around 2 usually. If I was booking a table at a restaurant it would be at 2pm. If I was cooking at home I would aim for around 2 to serve it. Big occasions, Christmas etc I would probably aim for a bit later.

niugboo · 08/04/2023 21:01

indianMIL · 08/04/2023 09:45

To the person who said I’m being melodramatic and it was only 3:15! Well you obviously don’t have young kids whose bedtime is at 7:30.l, and yes I stick to bedtimes at holidays too. Due to the fact I spent the day cleaning and making sure there was enough food that meant I only had 4.15 hours with my kids.

Only you didn’t only have 4 hours with the kids. You could have spent time with them before in laws arrived rather than raging.

TomeTome · 08/04/2023 20:59

Magenta82 · 08/04/2023 20:56

Is it?!
I have lived in England all my life (over 40 years) and have been eating at the wrong time apparently.

That’s interesting, which part of the country do you come from and what time do you eat lunch?

Shine05 · 08/04/2023 20:59

It definitely isn't a cultural thing and sad to see many replies calling out a certain culture on this.
it is just the two people not liking each other. The guest is late for lunch. The host never bothered to check on them, is there a problem or something? nor did the guest bothered to inform. In normal circumstances one of the two would happen.

Magenta82 · 08/04/2023 20:56

TomeTome · 08/04/2023 07:58

How odd. Lunch in the UK is traditionally served at 1pm, turning up after 12:30 is shockingly rude it’s usually “12 for 1” so you have time for a drink first. Preschoolers lunch might be at 12.

Is it?!
I have lived in England all my life (over 40 years) and have been eating at the wrong time apparently.

Swipe left for the next trending thread