Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why CCTV doesn't put people off doing wrong?

36 replies

girlfriend44 · 07/04/2023 15:06

We all know there are cameras everywhere today filming us and that CCTV is used in court etc.
Why are so many people still doing wrong when they know a clear image of them will be caught and given to the police.

Are people thick?
Even if I wanted to commit a crime I wouldn't I know that I'd be filmed. You have got to expect it today. Your even tracked in your car on camera what journeys you take etc.

Wayne Couzens who murdered Sarah Everard was caught by cameras.
Everything he did, hiring the car, his movements, her getting into the car was tracked?
He must have known?
How did he hope,and others too get away with it?

God why would you choose a life in prison, instead of getting some therapy and help?

.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SilverGlitterBaubles · 08/04/2023 15:32

The Boots where I live has very little stock on the make up shelves, even the basic ranges. I assumed that this was another supply changing issue but on asking a member of staff why they never had any stock out they said it was because the level of shoplifting was out of control and that even the half used testers are stolen. Apparently people don't care as they know police and stores don't have the capacity to prosecute. Staff are afraid to challenge them, especially if underage because they don't know how they might react and if they accuse someone they claim they are being victimised or discriminated against. How can we expect to have a law abiding society when even the most basic offences are not being investigated.

girlfriend44 · 08/04/2023 15:20

Anyone see this?

Paramedic gets caught in the act? worth it much for £60 now everyone knows?

https://www.itv.com/news/central/2023-04-07/paramedic-who-stole-money-from-elderly-woman-moments-after-she-died-avoids-jail

OP posts:
Hellocatshome · 08/04/2023 15:15

Because the criminals who get caught are not the intelligent criminals. The intelligent criminals are sat in their big houses with their big cars looking like normal respectable people while their minions go about doing their dirty work and getting locked up.

bythebanksof · 08/04/2023 15:03

I've not worked in SE England for many years, but CCTV has been critical in solving so many serious crimes. I do understand the civil liberties risks, but for me personally I'm all in favour of such systems (and more!) being used.

Some criminals are not forensically aware, but some are and these are classified as "experts", or you'll also see "organized" / "disorganized" classification. They've done research, they have practiced, completed trial runs, know the police process and tools, have a script they follow and sometimes refine and adjust based on what has happened, etc. Improvements in practice and tools now allows (in theory!) better "linkage" of cases based on what happened in the crime.

I'm not familiar with the WC case in detail, but it seems like he was going to do something like that, regardless of being caught? What is shocking for me is the lack of proper investigation of the prior reports about the man, and the tolerant attitude of his co-workers and organization. It is really appalling. I can't imagine the thoughts of the family, that something like this could have been avoided.

JudgeRinderonTinder · 07/04/2023 21:57

Despite it being 2023, a lot of CCTV isn’t worth the electricity as any images can’t be made out and are therefore completely worthless. Add to that that a lot are also dummy cameras or broken, and you can see why desperate criminals might take their chances.

A friend was sexually assaulted at night, and the CCTV in the area was of such poor quality it couldn’t be used.

In the depths of desperation and depravity a lot of people fail to stop and think about CCTV anyway.

AppelationStation · 07/04/2023 21:44

I don't think you have a very informed or imaginative understanding of how people end up on a path to committing crimes OP.

Aside from your Wayne Couzens of the world (thankfully comparitively rare and deranged enough that few could imagine what might lead to such hideous actions), criminals tend not to make rationally thought out decisions with sound risk assessment.

Strategies that assume they do, then being surprised when those strategies don't work, get us nowhere. See the last fifteen years of policy on anti-social behaviour.

girlfriend44 · 07/04/2023 21:02

That dosent make sense because everyone knows you start off small and then go on to bigger things.

If they investigated what they call low level crimes it might stop people escalating onto more.

Our paper locally reported a smashed car window today asking if anyone saw anything.

OP posts:
taxguru · 07/04/2023 19:11

The police only trawl through CCTV for the worst offences, i.e. murder and rape, etc. They're not interested in everything else. Even if you send them cctv footage of minor crimes, they don't bother taking action, make no effort to identify offenders, etc. Criminals know that no-one in authority cares about relatively minor crimes, so CCTV isn't a disincentive to them.

happinessischocolate · 07/04/2023 19:08

The police shared a picture of a guy in TKMaxx stealing and asked for people to contact them if they knew who he was. It was a very clear cctv photo of him and the police had raided his flat several weeks previously, you'd think they'd have been able to identify him. Lots of comments online about oh look who it is and someone even tagged him, but he never got a visit from the police about it.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 07/04/2023 18:52

Not thick no. Most are just aware that the police don't give a flying fuck about 99% of crimes, that the chances of getting caught are slim and that the chances of actually being charged/found guilty are even slimmer.

In Wayne Couzens case I wouldn't be surprised if he half expected them to cover for him again tbh.

Dbank · 07/04/2023 18:47

I think cameras are a deterrent for some people, but some really don't seem to care, or even bother looking.

For example

Porch Pirate

After several locals suspecting packages were being stolen from their doorsteps, I left a "bait" package out to see what happens..

https://youtu.be/y8B9MqlPRzU

category12 · 07/04/2023 18:38

girlfriend44 · 07/04/2023 17:39

Being a policeman though he would know about CCTV so I'm not sure about the he didn't think he would get caught mantra.
They even got the reg of the hire car he hired on film.

Probably more like as people have said. His urge was too strong and he didn't care.

He'd also got away with tons of dodgy to criminal behaviour before, like the indecent exposure and his reputation as "the rapist".

I think it's likely he thought he was untouchable/invincible and would get away with whatever he did.

Imridiculous · 07/04/2023 18:32

clearly the CCTV camera rattled them a little. So they thought they'd put it out of action by spraying it with something. This meant they had to come up within a couple of yards of the camera to do it

We had an incident where the person came right up to the camera to rip it off. A full close up of their face was visible. Why they thought the image of them doing this would be destroyed with the camera is beyond me.

1offnamechange · 07/04/2023 18:26

having watched a lot of cctv for my job

a lot of the time it's not pointing in the direction, cameras don't work, don't cover a key area, footage has been deleted before can be stored, or is of very poor quality.

Also cctv alone doesn't magically come with a ID tag - unless someone watches it who happens to know the person doing the crime then its not of much use to identify someone. So it's helpful if you have a suspicion of who did the crime, but not if you hope to identify the person solely from the cctv.

I believe Wayne Couzens was caught due to the car number plate being traced to him, and then was identifiable as the person on the cctv, rather than being recognised BY the CCTV.

SnowOnTheBeach1 · 07/04/2023 18:22

Most of the time you can't pick out anything further than the colour of their jacket, most CCTV is so grainy and low quality that its not really worth anything.

Neededanewuserhandle · 07/04/2023 18:12

Sorry that should read Police don't give a fuck. (They genuinely don't)

Neededanewuserhandle · 07/04/2023 18:11

The illegal street racers recreating The Fast and the Furious around here don't give a fuck and the perpetrators know that.

Mendholeai · 07/04/2023 18:06

Cctv is good for cars not so much for human. Grainy black and white pictures often aren’t helpful.
much more helpful are phone records.

It’s like the Wild West out there at the moment, burglaries not investigated, rapes not prosecuted etc. I am guessing that is probably why. People gambling with their futures for short term gain.

dottypotter · 07/04/2023 17:59

Sparklesocks · 07/04/2023 17:49

Some people wear hoods/masks etc so they’re not easily identifiable even if caught on camera. When my neighbour got broken into to they caught the guys on the ring camera but both had balaclavas on so didn’t really give them any clues on their identity. They wore gloves too so no fingerprints.

Sometimes I think people are arrogant - they might have gotten away with smaller crimes previously so believe they’re untouchable, or like others have suggested they take the risk even if they know the full weight of it because the thrill/result is worth taking that chance.

And CCTV isn’t always reliable - images can be grainy, there might not be audio or it’s not clear even if there is, camera can be facing the wrong way, no current tape or live feed connected etc. Some people even use decoy cameras. The criminals might know all this and think it’s worth a try in case it all aligns in their favour.

Also it depends on the crime, unfortunately. The police don’t always have the resources to investigate especially if it’s considered ‘minor’ in the big scheme of things so CCTV might be overlooked. Sarah Everard’s case received widespread media attention and concern from the public. Lots of people go missing who don’t get anywhere near the same level of attention or interest, which the perpetrators might be counting on.

You would think today the cctv would be excellent and also with audio sound.

Nevertheless it does help in solving crimes and people do get caught. Some images of people in our local paper recently have been very clear. It is in the daytime though admittedly.

Crimeismymiddlename · 07/04/2023 17:59

They cover faces and know that even if it is clear it is them that committed the crime no one will do anything to them.
People also forget how many cameras are about, it’s not clear now what is, and what is not a cctv.

Sparklesocks · 07/04/2023 17:49

Some people wear hoods/masks etc so they’re not easily identifiable even if caught on camera. When my neighbour got broken into to they caught the guys on the ring camera but both had balaclavas on so didn’t really give them any clues on their identity. They wore gloves too so no fingerprints.

Sometimes I think people are arrogant - they might have gotten away with smaller crimes previously so believe they’re untouchable, or like others have suggested they take the risk even if they know the full weight of it because the thrill/result is worth taking that chance.

And CCTV isn’t always reliable - images can be grainy, there might not be audio or it’s not clear even if there is, camera can be facing the wrong way, no current tape or live feed connected etc. Some people even use decoy cameras. The criminals might know all this and think it’s worth a try in case it all aligns in their favour.

Also it depends on the crime, unfortunately. The police don’t always have the resources to investigate especially if it’s considered ‘minor’ in the big scheme of things so CCTV might be overlooked. Sarah Everard’s case received widespread media attention and concern from the public. Lots of people go missing who don’t get anywhere near the same level of attention or interest, which the perpetrators might be counting on.

Apocalypticdays · 07/04/2023 17:43

Well the boy racers on dirt bikes causing havoc in my neighbourhood wear balaclavas and the police (if there were any) aren't allowed to chase them so basically they can do whatever the fuck they like with no consequences, other than possible death of course, or more likely causing a death.

girlfriend44 · 07/04/2023 17:39

Blossomandbee · 07/04/2023 17:30

Criminals like Wayne Couzens often start off, like he did, with smaller crimes that go unpunished. This gives them the idea that they're untouchable and clever enough to get away with it and so move onto worse crimes. Plus he was also in a position of power with his job which clearly went to his head. People who commit crimes like his also don't think like normal human beings.
As for cctv and the like, the images my local police puts out on appeals for witnesses is usually such poor quality that the person is unrecognisable.
Our door camera caught very clearly the scumbags that stole our neighbours car and the police weren't remotely interested.

Being a policeman though he would know about CCTV so I'm not sure about the he didn't think he would get caught mantra.
They even got the reg of the hire car he hired on film.

Probably more like as people have said. His urge was too strong and he didn't care.

OP posts:
Blossomandbee · 07/04/2023 17:30

Criminals like Wayne Couzens often start off, like he did, with smaller crimes that go unpunished. This gives them the idea that they're untouchable and clever enough to get away with it and so move onto worse crimes. Plus he was also in a position of power with his job which clearly went to his head. People who commit crimes like his also don't think like normal human beings.
As for cctv and the like, the images my local police puts out on appeals for witnesses is usually such poor quality that the person is unrecognisable.
Our door camera caught very clearly the scumbags that stole our neighbours car and the police weren't remotely interested.

DojaPhat · 07/04/2023 16:57

Because it doesn't make a difference. If you're speeding or wrongly parked you'll get a picture of your car in 4k quality. If you're the subject of a mugging in a central/main train station you'll be lucky to get even the most grainy image of anything and that will be after months of hassle.