Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing dilemmas & rejecting offer

116 replies

worldcupfan · 07/04/2023 14:00

Hello everyone,

I have posted about this before and I'm going to ask MHQ to remove the thread after as it is very identifying. But I am having second thoughts of accepting a council flat offer and I'm worried about the repercussions if I accept. In any case, I will have to let the council know my decision by next week.

To give a background. My 12 year old DS and I currently live in a very very small 1 bed private accommodation due to fleeing DV many many moons ago. We have been on the council list for approx.10 years. We have a direct offer (because another person friend it down) for a council property. It is like a terrace flat (?) it has three floors. I've been going back and forth with my decision but I think I am going to decline. Here are my reasons;

  1. The flat just has stairs. There's no landing ( apart from the hallway) as soon as you go up the stairs, you go straight into a room. The walls going up to to the stairs are quite narrow- almost like a claustrophobic feel. (however, the rooms are big). But the bathroom is all the way downstairs and is very small.

2.After you accept a property, you have 4 weeks to move in. There is no flooring, or anything, the property is very bare and in need of repairs . I am concerned about the costs, considering that DS is Autistic and has horrendous meltdowns and flooring and soundproofing is my concern. For example, if I wanted to have carpet to reduce noise, where do I put this? In the landing, living room, stairs and the bedrooms? What about laminate as I cannot afford to put carpet and sound proofing in every room.

  1. I am worried about the security of the housing. For example, the bedrooms are un the top floor and the front door is three floors down. I am currently going through the court process as DS's dad is requesting access to see his DS. I am worried about my ex founding out where we live. DS travels to some places on his own (school and to the local shops). If DS's dad has access, I'm worried that his dad may follow him home and would find out where we live- or worse DS will tell him (as he looks up to his dad and doesn't try to defy him).

Therefore, I'm at loss with security measures. I have never lived in a flat like this before and worry this is compromising with my safety (whereas if you are in a communal flat with others, there's a secure communal door and a range of flats). If DS dad knew where we live, he would not be able to guess which flat we live on.

  1. In my heart. I think the flat would just be too much for me to handle alone. I am used to live in a flat with rooms all in one level.

Please let me know if I'm going the right thing. It's so easy for my friends and family to say "take it take it" but not really taking my situation into concern.

OP posts:
BurntOutGirl · 07/04/2023 15:55

Could you do a floor plan so we can see what is in each floor?

Where is the kitchen and lounge? Is there a dining room?

Just thinking that you could alter the room usage around

martinisforeveryone · 07/04/2023 15:47

worldcupfan · 07/04/2023 15:16

They are all just telling me to take it, that I have been waiting such a long time and that DS is getting older. Yes I sleep on the sofa and DS has my room. The lack of space is a very big issue but at the same time, I don't want to move into a property where I would be worst off.

I don't mean this meanly or aggressively, but from reading what you've written, I'm not sure the council is ever going to be a in a position to offer you something you'd be wholly satisfied with.

Personally, I'd feel more secure not having to share a front door and corridors with any number of unknown people who could hang around being a nuisance, or who could buzz strangers into the building. Your own front door means you get to decide and provide the security measures with big bolts top and bottom, a door chain, a ring doorbell etc. which you can install easily or over time if necessary.

The flooring is going to be the same issue wherever the council could locate you, so that's nothing to decide by.

You'll spend next to no time on the narrow staircase or in the small bathroom, but if your living and bedrooms are a good size then that's very important, especially as your son grows.

If you take it you can look out for a swap, if you decline, you may be stuck in cramped and unaffordable private rental. I wouldn't look a gift horse in the mouth if I were you.

ShimmeringShirts · 07/04/2023 15:45

There’s been quite a lot of threads lately about single mums with one son of varying ages being offered a flat by the council and them wanting to turn it down because of reasons that aren’t really reasons.

Take the flat OP, or continue living where you are for another undefined amount of time. Only you are in control of your future, no one’s going to come along and rescue you.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/04/2023 15:45

worldcupfan · 07/04/2023 15:16

I am hoping the council will offer somewhere better but I don't know how long that will be or if we would find that all rounder flat.

That's why if you refuse a reasonable offer, they generally take you off the list altogether, as they've fulfilled their duty - because otherwise, everybody refuses until they get a nice house with a brand new kitchen and pretty garden in a nice area.

The only ways any offers are not counted as reasonable is if, for example, the LA Occupational Therapy Team or another professional states it is unsuitable for reasons such as it being incompatible with a disability such as being unable to go up stairs or get a wheelchair inside the front door (not being noisy - that's what underlay and carpet is for) or safety (ie, falling down outside steps or across the road from an ex's mother) - that kind of thing.

Unless you are on a band where you are specifically and explicitly stated to have x number of offers before removal and you're prepared to gamble on this to the extent that you could spend another ten years on the waiting list whilst offers are all made to people presenting as homeless, only to end up with somewhere worse in both location and quality - accept the offer.

Grimbelina · 07/04/2023 15:42

I actually think the flat sounds perfect for you... but that you are terribly anxious about the move (very probably reasonably considering your past and your DS's ASD).

Your current flat doesn't sound suitable at all though and this seems like a great opportunity. It will be difficult for a few weeks but then things will improve. You have to move at some point so just try and push through your anxiety, get as much support as you can IRL and here and get on with the next stage of your life (with more space etc.).

Try to be honest with yourself that this may well be anxiety rather than focusing on what you see as the problems (which are true for every move).

musicforthesoul · 07/04/2023 15:38

2 and 3 are issues anywhere, not specific to this flat. 1 and 4 are non issues and sound like you're making excuses not to move. It sounds more like fear of change than any actual problems with the place you've been offered.

If you turn it down I'd be really surprised if you get a better offer from the council. Depending on area you could easily be kicked off the list or go to the back of the queue for turning down a suitable property (and it is suitable, non of the reasons you've given would make it unsuitable in the eyes of the council). If you've already been on the list for 10 years that likely translates to this is your only offer.

I think you'd be mad not to take the flat tbh but obviously you're the one who has to live with the choice. Just make sure you make your choice on what's better between the new flat or staying overcrowded where you are permanently. Dont hold out for the idea of a perfect flat being offered because it likely won't happen.

glasshole · 07/04/2023 15:37

Good Lord, why aren't you snapping their hands off? The reasons you mention are not legitimate reasons AT ALL. If anything, being in an upstairs flat means that your ex could have more doors to get through to find you. And no matter where you live, he could follow you. You are much more likely to be looked upon favourably by the court if you are in suitable housing too. And as for noise I'm lost at this one. It's three floors. So make your kids room the one in the middle! Then it's only your living room/kitchen under bath and your bedroom above.

If you refuse this priest and they kick you off the list, what are you going to do then? You need to do right by your self and your son and move ASAP.

I ask this kindly, but do you think you could be intentionally self sabotaging on this? Most petite would be DELIGHTED in your shoes. If you move and hate it, you can apply for an exchange after a year. So take the property, spend the first week decorating it, the second carpeting it, and then move in. Because none of your arguments are valid.

Viviennemary · 07/04/2023 15:33

Ok I see. Difficult choice

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/04/2023 15:32

You won't be offered another flat.

Your ex could track you down wherever you are really, this is not a reason to turn down this property.

All council properties come without flooring - you'll only avoid this if you go for private rented which you have already said you can't do.

This is an opportunity for THE most secure AND CHEAP tenancy you will EVER have.

To not take it would be the height of stupidity.

romdowa · 07/04/2023 15:25

How could you be worse off with more space and a secure tenancy?if you want the perfect set up then you've to buy your own house. It's crazy how entitled some people on council lists are and I'm a council tenant myself and I thank my lucky stars every day that we have a secure roof over our heads.

beAsensible1 · 07/04/2023 15:25

the flat won't necessarily be "better" that they offer, it will be just what they think fits your criteria when other higher priority are already housed .

its a gamble

EarlofShrewsbury · 07/04/2023 15:22

Council properties don't usually include flooring, I know my council rip out any carpets or flooring when a tenant moves out before the next tenant moves in. I think it's to stop liability for pests (fleas bedbugs etc) or damage or whatever, so I wouldn't turn it down for that reason as the next property offered is likely to be the same.

Finding out where you live... is it a communal hallway? If he's hell bent on finding you by following wouldn't it be better to be in the flat? That way he might know the building you're in but not the specific unit.

I think you reasons for declining aren't really valid reasons. I would take it, it's going to be more suitable than what you are in now regardless.

VikingsandDragons · 07/04/2023 15:20

What authority area is it in? Most of them publish online their rules for what happens if you turn down a property, but for a lot of them they consider their obligation discharged and you'll be removed from the list so you won't be offered anything else.

memesndmoreme · 07/04/2023 15:20

worldcupfan · 07/04/2023 15:16

I am hoping the council will offer somewhere better but I don't know how long that will be or if we would find that all rounder flat.

You will be kicked off the list or at best be put to the bottom. Your son will have grown up and moved out. Take it

ChickenBurgers · 07/04/2023 15:20

Take the flat. One bed flat with a teenager is less than ideal. If there are repairs that need doing (not cosmetic repairs, like things that can’t be left) point these out to the council and get them on it before you move in.

You’ll have to save for carpets or an alternative option if the budget allows it is carpetright does finance where you pay monthly. I’m sure other companies do too. The majority of council places don’t have flooring laid before you move in so it’s pretty standard. Your council may have additional funding you can access to help with DIY bits.

in regards to the DV, I would contact your local domestic abuse service. For example where I am, ours is WORTH services and see if you can be assigned an IDVA to support with your worries.

An appropriately sized property with a secure tenancy and reasonable rent is surely better than living in cramped conditions? You’ve waited 10 years for this, take the flat. If you still hate it in a year you can explore swaps/mutual exchange.

RandomMess · 07/04/2023 15:19

Realistically what they offer you next could be worse.

worldcupfan · 07/04/2023 15:19

Viviennemary · 07/04/2023 15:15

It is really difficult to say whether this is a good move or not without seeing the flat. Not sure how it is classified as a flat if it's on 3 levels. And if its on three levels you wont be above or below anybody. You will have to decide if its better than where you are living now or not. I agree you sound scared of change which is perfectly understandable.,

It's a house which they have split into two flats.

OP posts:
worldcupfan · 07/04/2023 15:16

RandomMess · 07/04/2023 15:02

So do you envisage staying on your 1 bed forever or do you think/hope the next council offering will be better?

It sounds like your anxiety is running away with your fears.

Once in the council property you could apply for an exchange?

I am hoping the council will offer somewhere better but I don't know how long that will be or if we would find that all rounder flat.

OP posts:
worldcupfan · 07/04/2023 15:16

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 07/04/2023 15:01

I think OP is just very worried I can imagine how that feels. Do you have friends or family who could have a look with you? Take some pictures? I would feel exactly the same as you OP. So if you stayed in the 1 bed how would it work? I take it your child has the bedroom and you gave a sofa bed? Are you happy there aside from the lack of space?

They are all just telling me to take it, that I have been waiting such a long time and that DS is getting older. Yes I sleep on the sofa and DS has my room. The lack of space is a very big issue but at the same time, I don't want to move into a property where I would be worst off.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 07/04/2023 15:15

It is really difficult to say whether this is a good move or not without seeing the flat. Not sure how it is classified as a flat if it's on 3 levels. And if its on three levels you wont be above or below anybody. You will have to decide if its better than where you are living now or not. I agree you sound scared of change which is perfectly understandable.,

Tiredalwaystired · 07/04/2023 15:11

IKEA rugs are very very reasonable and could be a medium term problem to the flooring issues. Or even Facebook marketplace.

I agree that your current set up is unsustainable for you both and you should take this flat.

I can understand your worries though, but I think this is a better option as you’re unlikely to offered anything else x

memesndmoreme · 07/04/2023 15:11

If you refuse you will be kicked off the list. All council properties come without carpets. You can't allow ur son to keep living in a 1 bedroom flat.

emmathedilemma · 07/04/2023 15:07

I live in a split level flat with my own front door and I wouldn't trade it to go back to living with a communal stair well and shared front door where neighbours leave stuff clogging up the stairs, they're poorly maintained, smell of whatever your neighbours are cooking for dinner, and the noise echoes every time some one talks in the hall or slams their front door. It's bliss having your own front door! That said, my bathroom is on the same level as my bedrooms but i've lived in a terraced house that had the bathroom downstairs at the back of the kitchen and we managed fine.
Laminate floor is no cheaper than carpet. Get yourself along to one of the big carpet retailers this weekend, there's bound to be a bank holiday weekend offer on and they should easily be able to fit within 4 weeks if you buy something that's in stock.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 07/04/2023 15:03

ScattyHattie · 07/04/2023 14:54

As PP you can look to swap properties & council area after become an assured tenancy which was only a year.

That sounds like an isea OP you could check that out on Tuesday maybe find out your options? If you only had a year or so in it you might feel able to cope?

RandomMess · 07/04/2023 15:02

So do you envisage staying on your 1 bed forever or do you think/hope the next council offering will be better?

It sounds like your anxiety is running away with your fears.

Once in the council property you could apply for an exchange?