Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult disability payment allowance?

83 replies

KittyKatMcNairn · 07/04/2023 11:52

Hi folks, im writing here to see if anyone has been in the same boat as me.

I am 37 years old with a history of anxiety and depression. I have been on and off antidepressants a lot of my life.

My husband has to deal with all my finances as I physically stress and struggle with anything money related. My social anxiety is horrendous. I thought after having a baby I would be better but nope - my husband has to come places with me unless it’s a familiar place I know. Social gatherings I now take beta blockers for as I come out in a rash over my neck, chest and face as I am so anxious. he has to remind me to take medication otherwise I just don’t take it, he cooks for me as I struggle to read recipes and if he is out to work I go to sleep so I don’t have to cook.

Before my husband done anything for me, my parents done all this. I can’t drive as the thought scares me, I only leave my house if I’m with husband and baby. I can’t read maps unless it’s voiced on my phone.

i applied for ADP (I’m aware this is the equivalent for PIP). They called to book a face to face appointment. What are the chances of winning this? anything to prepare for for the appointment? Any help appreciated thanks 😊

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lovelyjubbbly · 16/06/2023 16:19

How long did peoples letter take to arrive after a decision was made? And to receive back pay?

caringcarer · 11/04/2023 03:18

@Irritateandunreasonable, I was advised by practice nurse to write down what I could do on a good day and a bad day. Then how often I had good and bad days and any triggers. I think you need to be honest. Also if help if you have evidence from specialists. Eg report from Psychologist on how how you did on CBT and what medication you are on.

70sDuvet · 11/04/2023 01:53

I was only commenting using my experience vs my mums. We have the same.e genetic disorder.

She also had had admissions due to her MH which I have not, and is obviously older and has some significant osteoarthritis.

I take all meds suggested by my consultants and have tried everything to become "healthier" which is futile but I've done it..

Mum hasn't engaged with the pointless and tedious physiotherapy (I've had multiple 8 week courses with OAPs gaining strength after a hip replacement- I dont have a hip replacement)
I'm not sure if it's a physical issue or her MH holding her back, but she is convinced medication makes her worse and even paracetamol doesn't agree with her (this does make me skeptical)

I on the other had take 30 tablets and injections a day in order to live some sort of life.
I get high rate care and mobility. Mum gets low rate care only, and I think due to her non compliance she is in a much worse state than me and during physical tests would very much struggle to do them at all.

So in my small pool of 2 with the same disease, compliance with Drs, taking meds and treatments offered and showing a history of drs letters showing you've tried xyz to no benefit DOES help back up what you have written on the form.

FatGirlSwim · 09/04/2023 01:12

I generally try to comment on pip threads with the correct info but there are always know it alls who don’t know the law, and there’s a particular idiot on this thread who somehow thinks it’s impossible to be a welfare rights lawyer… but I literally do tribunals every day, and the law is the law.

OP, mumsnet isn’t a great place for benefits advice even though there is a wealth of experience here, mainly because of arseholes who confuse the picture with half baked notions. So definitely get clear advice and support to fill the form in. Wording the answers to reflect the descriptors and with knowledge of case law so there’s no wiggle room if it’s appealed makes all the difference.

FatGirlSwim · 09/04/2023 01:07

I agree op that misinformation and conflicting info here is unhelpful to you. CAB can advise and there are also specialist welfare advocacy services like the one I work for, where you can be sure you’re getting the correct advice.

FatGirlSwim · 09/04/2023 01:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Would you like to see a CV? 🤷‍♀️

LizzyLovesTea · 08/04/2023 17:15

For PIP, I was given the advice to answer ‘no, but’ instead of ’yes, but’ in questions where the answer is complicated. Eg if asked can I cook a meal , instead of’yes, but only once a week, and I need somebody helping me and I would need to rest for two hours afterwards', you might say the same info but begin your answer with no, on the majority of days I’m not well enough to cook. And then give the true details about the challenges on days when you do cook, and what happens on days when you don't cook. Apparently with pip assessors this helps to make sure they don’t make mistakes in assessing you as more capable than you are. Hopefully the Scottish assessors would be better!

Also ask for breaks if you need to and explain if you find it difficult eg if you’re feeling anxious or upset at a particular point, or if talking is hard. You might be able to take a support person with you too.

Mrsjayy · 08/04/2023 16:52

I agree get proper advice visit CAB they can help with form filling and whatnot your husband can do it on your behalf if you find it difficult. I think the conflicting replies isn't helpful.

Kaffiene · 08/04/2023 16:38

OP please get help from a local support worker who has experience with ADP. So much mis information and scare mongering on this thread. I would suggest your husband contact your local carer centre. They will be able to help with your ADP application, check for any other supports you may be entitled to and that you are all well supported as a whole family.

Mrsjayy · 08/04/2023 16:23

SouthCountryGirl · 07/04/2023 13:29

This is fraud. They want to know how you are most of the time.

This isn't fraud at all, with these forms you always fill in your worst days because "good days: can be few and far between.

Op nobody can say if you will be successful there is no magic answer just be honest and be prepared to appeal if your application is refused.

itwasmeeee · 08/04/2023 16:18

You really need a good amount of backup in the form of Consultants letters, hospital reports and GP letters or referrals. To show that you have been engaging in trying to improve your health- even though with Covid its been nearly impossible.

No you don't. You need these things to prove your disability. There is nothing at all on the PIP application that talking about showing how you have tried to improve your health.

Also to be successful I believe you need to be medicated for your mental and/or physical health issues and show this by attaching a list of all medications and even go back to show if you have tried different types of meds.

Nope: you do not need to be on medication to have a successful PIP application.

70sDuvet · 08/04/2023 15:21

You really need a good amount of backup in the form of Consultants letters, hospital reports and GP letters or referrals. To show that you have been engaging in trying to improve your health- even though with Covid its been nearly impossible.

Then while filling in the paperwork refer to the appropriate letter.
I.e. "my anxiety is debilitating as agreed with Dr X in y letter dated x/x/x (attached as appendix 5)
Then staple copies of letters to the form.
Go into much more detail than the box allows, i type mine, or get help to - and then staple the pages to the form. Put your name and national insurance number on every piece of paper you send in.

Also to be successful I believe you need to be medicated for your mental and/or physical health issues and show this by attaching a list of all medications and even go back to show if you have tried different types of meds.
(This is based on the fact my DM suffers badly with her MH but believes the meds make her worse, she has never been successful in getting points for MH issues, even after being in a MH hospital for a few months - if she won't medicate they see it at not trying, and I can see their point, but also hers as the meds she has tried have made her more unwell. But it's just a def NO from PIP)

ArianahX · 08/04/2023 15:19

I struggle with day to day tasks because of negative symptoms of Schizoaffective disorder but can only get the low mobility rate of PIP (due to having photosensitive epilepsy)... I put in a lot of evidence too. But didn't try going to appeal. This was nearly 4 years ago.
Now I've had to reapply for my PIP claim as it's due for renewal & I've been waiting over a year for assessment as they're so behind!
I do need the money as I struggle to work only part time.

@SouthCountryGirl write about how you are normally in each section with evidence if you have it. I had a local charity to help me fill my form in. For some of my examples i need help with my finances from my sister, I struggle to shower regularly due to various reasons (not getting into it here) & I struggle to cook. Also travel is hard for me as I have the epilepsy.

Irritateandunreasonable · 08/04/2023 14:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Babyroobs · 08/04/2023 11:43

I supported someone at a PIP appeal recently. The panel really questioned her as to why she had not been to her GP for her chronic condition for over 10 years and had refused surgery that may have helped 10 years ago !

FatGirlSwim · 08/04/2023 09:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

pompomdaisy · 08/04/2023 08:54

@SouthCountryGirl have you actually seen a pip form? The questions are phrased so you have to answer how you are on both your best and worst day. They then make the assessment.

RoobarbandCustud · 08/04/2023 08:46

Life sounds really hard for you. I know this post is about your PIP claim but have you ever had help to get relief from your anxiety and to find ways of living better with it? Some antidepressants have a good effect on anxiety. Have you ever had therapy? Are you able to look after the baby at all on your own? Occupational Therapy may help you to function day to day better. You can find ways of preparing food that don't involve reading a recipe if this make you anxious. Also you can reduce the admin around finances etc by using direct debits etc. I hope you

lsanny · 08/04/2023 08:34

I'm not suggesting the criteria are different btw. I'm suggesting the idea that people who don't take medication will be viewed as not helping themselves and disallowed is against the law. No matter what people opinion are.

lsanny · 08/04/2023 08:30

Fair point about medication. I don't know anyone who has completely refused medication to assist with their condition.

ADHD is good example, same with depression, anxiety and several physical pain conditions.

Trez1510 · 08/04/2023 08:23

lsanny · 08/04/2023 05:28

People are not obliged to accept treatment in this country. Taking medication is still optional and has little bearing on a decision regarding benefits
.

You say you have assisted quite a few but then you go on to mention DWP so I assume you mean you have assisted PIP not ADP which is what OP is talking about.

Fair point about medication. I don't know anyone who has completely refused medication to assist with their condition. However as another poster notes, those circumstances will see you being refused initially. Of course if you have mental and, sometimes, financial resources you can request a mandatory reconsideration (which will most likely result in the same outcome) prior to submitting an appeal. So it's true medication is not compulsory but is a substantial element of the decision making process. The difference in ADP is in respect of how applicants are handled.

The assessment criteria remains the same which means if your narrative differs wildly from your diagnosis/recommended treatment you will still face the mandatory reconsideration and appeal route to establish your claim.

lsanny · 08/04/2023 08:03

It is true that DWP will deny many applications for these reasons. But case law doesn’t support that and we always win on appeal when these are the reasons given.

Because legally it's a choice whether or not to medicate. The refusal to take medication doesn't eliminate disability so it's no surprise appeals are won.

Irritateandunreasonable · 08/04/2023 07:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Irritateandunreasonable · 08/04/2023 07:53

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/04/2023 00:31

Not at all. Mental health professionals would caution against it.

  1. They absolutely wouldn’t be saying that after someone had a baby.
  1. That’s a very broad assumption considering anxiety and depression is so widely varied - no they wouldn’t caution against it for everyone.
FatGirlSwim · 08/04/2023 07:33

lsanny · 08/04/2023 05:28

People are not obliged to accept treatment in this country. Taking medication is still optional and has little bearing on a decision regarding benefits
.

You say you have assisted quite a few but then you go on to mention DWP so I assume you mean you have assisted PIP not ADP which is what OP is talking about.

It is true that DWP will deny many applications for these reasons. But case law doesn’t support that and we always win on appeal when these are the reasons given.

I have no experience of the Scottish disability payments. However, colleagues do and I’m told that the criteria are extremely similar to PIP.