Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teaching unions aren’t actually particularly helpful to teachers?

59 replies

Easterrabbits · 07/04/2023 10:46

So I know I’m probably going to be deemed goady or purposefully provocative here and that’s not the intention, but I’d genuinely like to know about this.

I’ve been teaching a pretty long time now - since the early 2000s - and when I used to use the old TES forums, the same story with only slight variations would crop up again and again: someone would be bullied and unfairly targeted at school and the advice would always be to involve the Union. But then when the union was involved it would almost inevitably lead to a settlement agreement / agreed reference but often with the persons career prospects damaged or impacted as a result. I don’t think I ever heard of one story in nearly twenty years where a teacher was able to successfully fight threats of capability, and judging from a Facebook group I am a member of, this is still the case.

I am all for a pay rise (who wouldn’t be) but I am not confident at all the union are going to be able to successfully negotiate it, especially given questionable activities elsewhere - further details on this thread.

I can’t pretend to be an expert here. I just feel that after failing to successfully address bullying, seeming to support an end to exclusions, some mad behaviour with drag queens Hmm I don’t feel at all confident that they are going to be able to hold the government to account and get a decent and funded pay rise. I think public perception of teachers could be damaged as a result.

I guess in short I really don’t have a lot of faith or confidence in the unions generally. The NEU are good at blasting and trumpeting but don’t DO much and the NASUWT are more moderate but not necessarily particularly helpful if you do actually need their support.

I’ll prepare to be flamed now … [smile ]

Drag queen storytime should be allowed in schools for ‘inclusivity’, says teachers’ union | Mumsnet

Mumsnet makes parents' lives easier by pooling knowledge, advice and support on everything from conception to childbirth, from babies to teenagers.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4778755-drag-queen-storytime-should-be-allowed-in-schools-for-inclusivity-says-teachers-union

OP posts:
Easterrabbits · 07/04/2023 15:26

@rattymol it isn’t purely that, but when you’ve seen the same story over and over again, even allowing for recollections varying, patterns emerge.

Someone will be targeted, and you know, this might be totally fair, they might be completely incompetent. I don’t know. Either way, they are union members and post to say things like - the union weren’t interested, the union didn’t want to know, the union didn’t return my calls.

Unless there’s been a massive conspiracy taking place over nearly two decades, which isn’t plausible, it does seem to me that unions aren’t really providing a lot of support and that in turn makes me doubt that they are able to tackle the government. But I hope I’m wrong!

OP posts:
Marmaladesarnie · 07/04/2023 15:12

When I needed them 5 years ago (being put on a 10 week informal support plan at 34 weeks pregnant - after they didn’t follow any processes properly) the county union rep absolutely wiped the floor with school and it was all overturned.
I returned from maternity leave and have worked at the same school ever since, however in some ways I wish I had taken a settlement and left at that point because I’ve watched so many other colleagues bullied out for ridiculous reasons and I’m living on edge waiting for it to be me again!

Phineyj · 07/04/2023 14:52

I had poor experiences with ATL and NEU (who took over ATL) and switched to Edapt a few years back. I've been very satisfied with them - they have properly trained and paid legal staff.

Schools are very complex nowadays. You need to know people trying to help you are competent with the law.

With volunteer union reps, I think they are very variable. Some are excellent and others not so much.

CatOnTheChair · 07/04/2023 14:31

OK, so scrap the unions.
Loose any support they may offer. Loose the pay negotiation support. Loose the information.
Yes, they may be far from perfect, but they are a million times better than nothing.

FrippEnos · 07/04/2023 14:04

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 10:53

They certainly don't do much to help public perception of teachers and were actively harming it during covid lockdowns

Although the unions could do with some PR support, during covid it was the government, msm and groups like twats4themselves us4them, that put teachers in a bad light,

IceMagic · 07/04/2023 13:24

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 10:53

They certainly don't do much to help public perception of teachers and were actively harming it during covid lockdowns

It's the right wing press slagging off teachers that damaged public perception of them, not unions. The right wing press always try to distract attention from government failings by finding various scapegoats. Teachers are one of them

rattymol · 07/04/2023 13:22

I am wondering why you are posting a thread OP saying the unions are useless, simply based on some forum posts where you don't know the full facts?

LondonNQT · 07/04/2023 13:22

I’ve not seriously needed my Union yet (touch wood), however, if I were ever in a situation where a student made a false accusation against me I’d be very glad that I’d paid my subs.

timetorefresh · 07/04/2023 13:17

@HelpsHeal I and the other part time staff had part time contracts. We were bullied out of jobs. We were not made redundant. No proper process was followed. There was no reason for it other than the new head didn't like part time staff. It was after an ofsted inspection in which I got glowing feedback while the school was put in special measures. Why would I and my fellow part timers be targeted?

Easterrabbits · 07/04/2023 13:11

But they don’t @HelpsHeal , I’ve never once seen someone describe that happening.

@rattymol no idea, I mean, I’m specifically talking re teachers here.

OP posts:
HelpsHeal · 07/04/2023 13:09

Easterrabbits · 07/04/2023 12:55

But you can behave ‘properly’ and also unfairly. So for example, you can observe a teacher and say the lesson was poor and that the teacher needs support with eg behaviour management without acknowledging that it’s a dreadful class across the school.

Obviously, it isn’t the case that only competent teachers are targeted for capability and bullying. But the system isn’t designed so that you can win it, whether you are competent or not.

The union would investigate that though, if the teacher told them they were being treated differently to others having the same problems with the same classes.

rattymol · 07/04/2023 13:06

Isn't that the same as poor performance proceedings everywhere? The in built assumption that if you can't do a good job it's your at fault not the design of the job.

Easterrabbits · 07/04/2023 12:55

But you can behave ‘properly’ and also unfairly. So for example, you can observe a teacher and say the lesson was poor and that the teacher needs support with eg behaviour management without acknowledging that it’s a dreadful class across the school.

Obviously, it isn’t the case that only competent teachers are targeted for capability and bullying. But the system isn’t designed so that you can win it, whether you are competent or not.

OP posts:
twelly · 07/04/2023 12:49

I think the unions are very good on an individual basis and can be very supportive, however, on a national basis and with regard to public perception of teachers I think the teaching unions are a disaster.

TheHoover · 07/04/2023 12:47

The problem with capability cases is that most times the staff member tries to obfuscate the capability by claiming bullying or other unfair treatment. So often managers giving non-positive feedback is all it takes for a complaint of bullying to be made. Sometimes the manager may be clumsy and even cruel in the way they deliver the feedback but none of this means that the employee doesn’t still needs to improve.
If employees showed enough of an improvement then they wouldn’t be sacked. But if they just argue bullying (and don’t improve) then really the only option. is compromise or a dismissal.

ilovesooty · 07/04/2023 12:46

maddy68 · 07/04/2023 11:18

If it wasn't for union support I wouldn't be here now.

Same here.

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 07/04/2023 12:45

My BIL was bullied and if it weren't for the union, his life would have been a living hell.

He did leave, with his reputation fully in tact and a big fat pay off by way of an apology.

I also work for a union that supports a lot of teaching support staff and we do a lot for them, so YABU 😛

HelpsHeal · 07/04/2023 12:41

timetorefresh · 07/04/2023 12:36

I had the union in when my old school announced they didn't want part time teachers any more and then started targeting us all. Regional rep came to see me and told me that he had more workload from that school than all the others combined. He told me the best thing I could do was leave. I did, but I really think they should have been done for constructive dismissal as it kept happening to people after I left. The SLT there was poisonous and i would leave my current school if any of them arrived there.

But the school can make operational decisions and provided they follow due process, what is it you think the unions should have done?

timetorefresh · 07/04/2023 12:36

I had the union in when my old school announced they didn't want part time teachers any more and then started targeting us all. Regional rep came to see me and told me that he had more workload from that school than all the others combined. He told me the best thing I could do was leave. I did, but I really think they should have been done for constructive dismissal as it kept happening to people after I left. The SLT there was poisonous and i would leave my current school if any of them arrived there.

maddy68 · 07/04/2023 12:36

HelpsHeal · 07/04/2023 12:29

I've been the employer in HR disputes involving teachers and their unions.

I find the reps to be very reasonable and professional. Where a school has behaved properly, they will tell their member that, even when it's not what they want to hear.

When a school has dealt with things badly they basically set out to deliver what their member wants. In most cases that will be to leave with a pay off, but they also work towards a resolution when that's what the member wants.

This is my experience too.

I was a head teacher but previous a union rep.

I saw both sides.

If a school has acted fairly there is nothing a union can do.

HelpsHeal · 07/04/2023 12:29

I've been the employer in HR disputes involving teachers and their unions.

I find the reps to be very reasonable and professional. Where a school has behaved properly, they will tell their member that, even when it's not what they want to hear.

When a school has dealt with things badly they basically set out to deliver what their member wants. In most cases that will be to leave with a pay off, but they also work towards a resolution when that's what the member wants.

rattymol · 07/04/2023 12:24

Surely you need to know the details? Did the teachers want to stay in the same school or did they decide in the end a payout was better?
I would not want to return to an employer that had bullied me and tried to sack me if I could get a good payout. Working somewhere like that destroys your confidence.

Easterrabbits · 07/04/2023 12:06

I think we all know there might be some cases where capability was an issue but the point is it doesn’t really seem to matter. Even in cases where pretty blatant discrimination or bullying was taking place, the unions didn’t seem able to take much if any action.

OP posts:
rattymol · 07/04/2023 12:03

I hate to say it, but all those cases you have read about may have teachers who do have capability issues and a payout was the best outcome any union could have negotiated.

Easterrabbits · 07/04/2023 12:01

So sorry to hear that @DarlingG , I think for a lot of people they feel so alone when there’s no support forthcoming. My ‘event’ if you like was over ten years ago but it made me feel so scared and isolated.

OP posts: