Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel hard done by.

207 replies

RabbitWarrren · 07/04/2023 09:07

DH is a part time teacher. Reduced his hours when I got a promotion. Our kids are 1 and 4. He is on holidays now. He takes them out for days etc to different parks, zoo, pub etc. I'm a bit jealous!

He doesn't do any of the kid or home admin or anything or much cleaning. I work v hard.

The kids ask for him now all the time. Especially the little one. I went back to work after 3 months to keep being able to afford all the costs.

Feel bit hard done by. AIBU? I really like my job. He says if I get another promotion he'll quit all together.

Am I unreasonable to say I don't want him to quit? I'm also worried because he can be a right grumpy arse sometimes and I think about splitting and if he quits his job I'm screwed!!

I guess this is just a modern set up. It's hard feeling disconnected from the kids.

OP posts:
PousseyNotMoira · 07/04/2023 14:15

Jojobalone · 07/04/2023 09:10

Is there anything stopping you from having a chat with him about how you work full time and do ALL kid and life admin?

who does housework and cooking?

This.

I read all these posts and these women seem to think they have zero agency, their husbands can do as they wish and they just…accept it. It’s baffling.

Goldenbear · 07/04/2023 14:10

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 14:07

@Tomkirkman

The 'advice' given depending on the sex of the op is stark.

If its ok for a woman to give up work and focus solely on looking after children and do no housework then its ok for men too.

Except that's not what is being said on this thread

If a man came on and said he didn't want his oh going part time or being a sahm because if they split, she'd get the kids he'd be torn to shreds

I've no interest in advising either sex but the difference is amazing

That is probably why the OP is losing respect for him, he sounds a lazy man.

Cakeandcardio · 07/04/2023 14:08

I'm also a PT teacher. On my two days off a week, I take dc to places like the park or the library or meet up with my dad etc but the bigger days out such as farm parks, cinema etc we only do as a family as they are good memories to have together. I do all organising and cooking of meals (often batch cook at the weekend) and I do all of the laundry and clean the bathroom and dusting. Husband changes beds and hoovers. We both keep of top of washing up and tidying etc. It seems balanced to me. I am super busy on my days off but we have a lot of time together as a family. I certainly think your life could be more balanced. Also, for us my DH isn't a higher earner - I actually earned more before I went PT. We don't have lots of cash but we get by fairly well by being organised. We just did this to have a balanced family life. Good luck. I think a big chat is needed!

Goldenbear · 07/04/2023 14:07

Most men don't want to be the primary care giver though especially at newborn stage

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 14:07

@Tomkirkman

The 'advice' given depending on the sex of the op is stark.

If its ok for a woman to give up work and focus solely on looking after children and do no housework then its ok for men too.

Except that's not what is being said on this thread

If a man came on and said he didn't want his oh going part time or being a sahm because if they split, she'd get the kids he'd be torn to shreds

I've no interest in advising either sex but the difference is amazing

KettrickenSmiled · 07/04/2023 14:03

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 10:16

Funny how no one ever advises men to worry about theory wives being the primary care giver in case they lose custody...

I can't speak for PP, but if your theoretical man posted about how his wife went part-time without consultation, but expected their husband to work full time AND take care of all the admin & childcare load, then threatened to give up work altogether, I'd be giving him exactly that advice.

Foreversearch · 07/04/2023 13:58

@RabbitWarrren you seriously need to consider working 4 days a week. Yes it’s tough but a) you get to spend an extra day with your DC b) financially the drop in salary is not as great as you think.

Every-time your DH mentions you getting a promotion immediately say say “I can’t wait to drop a day.”

You also need to look at how household tasks are distributed.

KettrickenSmiled · 07/04/2023 13:56

He is working too.

He is threatening to give up working @maddy68

KettrickenSmiled · 07/04/2023 13:55

Am I unreasonable to say I don't want him to quit? I'm also worried because he can be a right grumpy arse sometimes and I think about splitting and if he quits his job I'm screwed!!
What kind of number has he done on you over the years that you even need to ask?
He was unreasonable to reduce his hours, & thus the total family income, on a unilateral whim.
Any changes to work, especially those involving significant changes to money or time, should be discussed & mutually agreed.

He says if I get another promotion he'll quit all together.
He's lining you up to be his cash cow, & if you allow him to get away with that, not only will you end up skint & resentful, you will be trapped, because he could then divorce you, claim he is the agreed SAHP, demand Resident Parent status & rinse you for at LEAST half the assets, & CMS for years.
You could fight that, but it would be costly & you'd have a significant chance of losing.

Talk to a lawyer - SECRETLY. Get a concrete picture of what any split & asset division would look like currently. Take informed & detailed advice on how it would look should your H choose to quit work before you can get a divorce rolling.
Watch him closely.
If he keeps talking about his entitlement to have you provide for him so that he can enjoy a life of comparative leisure & get to enjoy it with the DC while you cannot - divorce the fucker.

This may strike you as extreme OP - but I had a near-decent H once who turned himself into a wilful cocklodger. Cost me 2 beloved homes & a significant lump sum - & there were no dependent DC involved, Please watch your back, & get legal advice on how to best protect your own interests here.

Goldenbear · 07/04/2023 13:53

It sounds like you don't find this very attractive as a set up maybe some unconscious bias there about men providing or at least accommodating your DC seeing their mother for days our occasionally.

beAsensible1 · 07/04/2023 13:47

RemoteControlDoobry · 07/04/2023 12:17

That’s because mothers are more attached to their children than fathers. How many mothers abandon their children compared to fathers? There’s an evolutionary reason for this because of course women can only have a limited number of children. To split a child from its mother is devastating for both.

i think its more due to the actually physical requirements to abandonment with women and societal stigma.

deadbeat men rent stigmatised enough if at all. yesterday there was thread where a bunch of mums said they wouldn't stop their young sons from abandoning the teenage girl he got pregnant.

L3ThirtySeven · 07/04/2023 13:45

It’s great if you both want your DH to be a SAHD, but it’s not great he is sort of gradually backing you into it. I think the two of you need to have an honest conversation about what you both want for the children and yourselves.

Many couples have a SAHP, but other couples have it so they both work PT as it is hard to be the sole breadwinner or to be the primary caregiver. There are sacrifices from both sides.

If he is going to be a SAHD, then he should have the child benefit in his name and you need to plan to keep up private pension so he doesn’t suffer the parent penalty (usually affects mothers who stay home with DC). He should also think how to keep his skills current so that he can return to teaching when they are school age.

So instead of things just happening- get together and plan what you want to do as parents.

Tomkirkman · 07/04/2023 13:45

It’s really hard what to suggest.

Absolutely tell him you do not want to be a one income household. A sahp set up only ever works if both people want it. If you don’t, tell him that and if he doesn’t accept it you may as well split now as you can not force him to not hand his notice in.

It’s also difficult to say about the division of labour. It is true a female teacher posting that she worked part time, would get sympathy from MN if the male partner was telling them they don’t do enough housework or admin. Especially, when one child is only one. Teachers often work more than their official hours.

Also, it’s really not unusual when a marriage is going down the drain for the working partner to decide they are being taken advantage of and the sahp does nothing. Men the world over have said this about their sahm wives during divorce. I can’t see why it would be any different the other way round. When marriages are in the final stages, both sides often feel badly done to and claim the other never does enough.

He could be not doing enough. Op could be just feeling badly done to and so (subconsciously) framing her life as worse than his. No one here knows.

And it is entirely natural that he would stand more of a chance of having the kids more if they split. That’s why women, get majority custody more often than men. Because they have been the main care giver before the split. Admin and cleaning doesn’t usually come into it.

As for the ‘why doesn’t anyone warn men they will see their kids less if their wife is a sahp and they split’, since MN is mainly frequented by women we can’t answer that. Why not go ask men why they don’t point that out when their friends, or people posting on advice forums mention it? Why would it be MNs or women’s responsibility to make sure men know the really obvious consequences of decisions they make?

I mean it could be that a lot of time, men (usually) simply aren’t fussed about having the majority custody. Or they do know but think the benefits outweigh the risks. It’s still not women’s jobs to make sure men know what will happen if their marriage splits.

It’s not even women’s jobs to tell other women. And we don’t, unless someone is specifically asking for advice. Like the female op here is.

If you think men need more education in this area. Work with men to provide it.

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 13:42

@IWineAndDontDine

Nah.

It's called being on holiday for a reason

Inthesamesinkingboat · 07/04/2023 13:37

This reminds me of the other thread on here at the moment where OPs cocklodging partner does nothing and she pays for everything. I think this is that situation a few years down the line.

be very careful OP that he doesn’t manoeuvre himself into a position where you will end up funding him in the future. Personally if you get more money from work through a promotion I just wouldn’t mention it if it is going to tip him into cutting his hours further.

as soon as your littlest can go to nursery I would insist on him going back to work in order to pay for a cleaner and additional help if he isn’t going to do those jobs himself. He has a choice as far as I see it, he can either keep the house at an acceptable standard or he can work and you can pay for someone else to do it.

SittingNextToIt · 07/04/2023 13:36

Casilero · 07/04/2023 09:36

God don't let him quit! Wouldn't that make him primary carer iff you split up? Not a lawyer by the way. I wouldn't do it anyway

Imagine someone saying that to a dad as advice.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 07/04/2023 13:28

Werehalfwaythere · 07/04/2023 10:17

Really? I think you're being sexist. The set up of higher earner / SAHP is pretty common for families with young children. It doesn't mean people are being screwed over; it means the family benefits from being raised by a parent.

SAHP needs to step up with the housework though.

I agree totally with billy1966. If DH is deemed primary carer in a divorce/custody dispute, the OP would face an extremely tough, expensive battle for custody. Potentially losing the house too (primary residence) and paying child support.

When a couple makes a considered joint decision for one of them to be a SAHP it can work brilliantly. But they each need to bring something of value to the table - one provides financially, the other does the majority of the childcare and housework.

When one parent is unilaterally deciding to be a SAHP but isn't contributing enough value in other ways (the mental as well as physical load of sorting out the house and kids!) it's a recipe for resentment and eventual marital breakdown. And then we're back to the primary carer/custody issue...

IWineAndDontDine · 07/04/2023 13:27

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 13:25

@IWineAndDontDine

In your opinion

Not in mine.

Being off on holiday with your kids isn't working

😂

Kids maybe, toddlers? Yes it is

Cherryblossoms85 · 07/04/2023 13:26

@BessieSurtees yes and no. He has different priorities, so he'll do endless DIY, washing, kids activities, homework, but he won't cook or clean. This is partly because I have much greater desire to cook healthy food from scratch and he views that as unnecessary when he can just stick beige food in the oven. It's frustrating because I enjoy cooking, but wouldn't do it if I could rely on him not taking the easy, unhealthy route every day because he doesn't "have time"...tbh though it's more that I wanted to stay at home and only took the new job because he banged on about how great I was

CantBeArsedOrAsked · 07/04/2023 13:26

If you're suffering in silence and acting as if everything is fine he probably thinks you're quite happy with the arrangement.
Is there a reason why you haven't spoken to him about this?

briancormorant · 07/04/2023 13:26

This is bollocks OP. You are being worked over.
When DW & I did our role swap back in the 90s. We exchanged most jobs and tasks, I learnt the mundane everyday cooking and house work, the laundry and the ironing.
Exceptions: She did the sewing and I did DIY and the car.
If I could adapt anyone can. Get tough OP. Think like a man. State the redlines clearly and keep to them.

AgrathaChristie · 07/04/2023 13:26

You can jiggle days round all you like, you drop and day, he adds a day, but it doesn’t take away from him deciding how he’ll lead his life without any discussion with you.

FWIW my ex h did this and had to work more hours, pay more bills while he sat on his arse at home. It didn’t end well.

Botw1 · 07/04/2023 13:25

@IWineAndDontDine

In your opinion

Not in mine.

Being off on holiday with your kids isn't working

AnnaMagnani · 07/04/2023 13:25

It's absolutely not a modern set up.

  1. He is making unilateral decisions 'I'll give up work if you get a promotion' instead of both being a team
  2. He isn't doing any household chores, life admin despite being the more at home parent. He's getting to be a Disney Dad while still having you to provide all admin services + sex.

Time to start getting rid of some chores on to him and evening things out. He might not think being a SAHP is so much fun when he is regularly cleaning the loo.

BessieSurtees · 07/04/2023 13:21

@Cherryblossoms85 but does he support you in your work so if he is at home is he doing childcare, housework, cooking, life admin. Do you work and then relax, does he enable and compliment you?

OP's DH doesn't appear to share the load.