Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial Opinion - Simon and Garfunkle

158 replies

Magenta82 · 07/04/2023 07:49

I've long harboured this opinion and so far the people I've voiced it to have been split so I thought I would throw it out to you lovely ladies.

Paul Simon is a genius, his songs and music are amazing, however, pretty much every cover version is better than the original that was sung by Simon and Garfunkle.

So Mumsnet, AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/04/2023 11:46

BrokenWing · 07/04/2023 09:19

Just watched this (twice). Simply outstanding 👏🏼

So have l. The clarity, harmony and just the sweetness of the voices in amazing.

That is the best version.

NooNakedJacuzziness · 07/04/2023 11:45

Nirvana's version over Lulu's?? Madness!*

*not really

JudgeJ · 07/04/2023 11:43

I have never and will never forgive that Madonna woman for ruining American Pie!
Some of the versions of S and G songs are simply different, not necessarily better. I listened to Elvis Presley and the London Philharmonic singing Bridge Over Troubled Water and it's wonderful but not necessarily better than the original.

limitedperiodonly · 07/04/2023 11:23

I prefer Sting's version of Little Wing to Jimi Hendrix's original. I'm troubled by that, but there it is.

Giggorata · 07/04/2023 11:13

Most of the songs are sublime, and most of the covers are interesting, some are superb. But better? No, not to me.
It does depend what mood I'm in, whether I can listen to the Disturbed's version and enjoy it, likewise some of the other covers, but for me, there is a special merit in hearing the songs performed the way I first heard them all those years ago.

Another very important factor for me is hearing the songs performed by their writers. Whether they can sing well or not. It adds a certain something.
This goes for Bob Dylan and many others. Simon and Garfunkel are, of course, wonderful.
There is one exception to this, and that is With a Little Help from My Friends, sung by Joe Cocker.

NoSquirrels · 07/04/2023 11:11

I'll also risk controversy by saying I prefer Nirvana's version of The Man Who Sold The World

Me too. And Johnny Cash’s Bird on a Wire over Leonard Cohen.

ExplodingMittens · 07/04/2023 11:11

Slitherie · 07/04/2023 07:52

YANBU

The Sound Of Silence by Disturbed is an absolute masterpiece … I listen to it all the time and when I hear the original it sounds like a karaoke version … no emotion or feeling in it at all

💯

Seashor · 07/04/2023 11:09

I was 16, in Spain for the summer with my friend staying with my Spanish relatives. There were two boys our age in the next door apartment. We all had an incredible summer listening to Simon and Garfunkel on the beach morning, noon and night. For me, no other artist can sing their songs like they did.

comeondover · 07/04/2023 10:56

Another vote for the Disturbed version of The Sound of Silence. It's great to turn up loud and bellow along to, and if I need a cry somehow this helps.

I'll also risk controversy by saying I prefer Nirvana's version of The Man Who Sold The World, and Natalie Merchant's Space Odyssey, to the Bowie originals.

BestIsWest · 07/04/2023 10:55

DH likes the Disturbed version, I don’t. But I love the First Aid Kit version of America. It’s not better than the original though.

LadyLyndon · 07/04/2023 10:34

Edie Brickell’s version of Hard Rain’s Gonna Fall (Dylan) is a masterpiece. She is also married to Paul Simon.

Iwantthepenthouse · 07/04/2023 10:28

I'm so pleased I'm not the only one who cannot stand that Disturbed cover. People went nuts over it and kept telling me to listen again, it's amazing etc etc

Dreadful.

OP, you are so so wrong about Art Garfunkel.

And covering Mrs Robinson was a terrible mistake for The Lemonheads.

Iwasafool · 07/04/2023 10:24

BrokenWing · 07/04/2023 08:34

Never heard the cover version from Disturbed before........ not keen, don't get the emotions in it at all, feels shouty for the sake of shouting, too try hard. Personally think S&G version delivers the essence of the song much more powerfully.

Yes, this sums it up.

RoseslnTheHospital · 07/04/2023 10:17

HarlanPepper · 07/04/2023 09:21

I love Simon and Garfunkel and I've got a deep emotional attachment to their music. So I don't agree in general, BUT I've always loved that Lemonheads Mrs Robinson cover.

This is me too. I love Simon and Garfunkel's Mrs Robinson but the Lemonheads cover was right in my 90s teenage years and I also have a fondness for it. Its "as good" as the original!

The Disturbed version of Sound of Silence is interesting and powerful, but not better than S&G's original.

And finally, Garfunkel is not the weak link in the duo. It's their different voices in harmony that makes the sound unique. Paul Simon on his own is a great songwriter and singer but together they were just sublime.

RaininSummer · 07/04/2023 10:13

Disagree entirely and don't like the Disturbia version.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 07/04/2023 10:11

Glad I’m not the only one who doesn’t get why The Sound Of Silence by Disturbed is good. Original is way better.

HoppingPavlova · 07/04/2023 10:10

Absolutely love S&G. I’m in camp Disturbed though for SoS, love it and can’t go back to S&G’s now. Can’t think of any other covers I believe are better though.

bellinisurge · 07/04/2023 10:09

Really don't like them. Too many "young people's Mass" at school where S&G were the soundtrack.

MrsMariaReynolds · 07/04/2023 10:08

Nope. gavel bang I'm not having it.

I fail to see what's so "great" about the Disturbed version of Sound of Silence, apart from it being a bit more gritty and modern. S&G's songs are 60+ years old now. Perhaps it's not greatness you're hearing in the remakes, but newness.

Enko · 07/04/2023 09:58

CoalCraft · 07/04/2023 08:01

Definitely agree re. Bob Dylan. Simon and Garfunkel I'm on the fence. Most of the time I think the original and the cover are both good.

I agree with this.

I also think many of S and G covers are soo different it makes you stop and listen.

I really love firstaid kits version of America but I also love the original version.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 07/04/2023 09:55

I don’t like the Pentinax version or Peyton Parish. Too overproduced.

l like Disturbed though.

NotSorry · 07/04/2023 09:53

HeddaGarbled · 07/04/2023 08:14

Nope. The harmony of the two voices is something special. And that Disturbed version turns the original into a ten-a-penny power ballad.

Thought it was just me! The Disturbed version is awful - the song is called the “sound of silence” and the singer shouts most of the way through it

ODFOx · 07/04/2023 09:49

YABU !!!!

BestIsWest · 07/04/2023 09:49

No, I think you’re wrong. I don’t mind some of the other versions but they are not better. Bob Dylan though.

TheyAreMinerals · 07/04/2023 09:46

Also Graceland wasn't S and G. It was just Paul Simon.