Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial Opinion - Simon and Garfunkle

158 replies

Magenta82 · 07/04/2023 07:49

I've long harboured this opinion and so far the people I've voiced it to have been split so I thought I would throw it out to you lovely ladies.

Paul Simon is a genius, his songs and music are amazing, however, pretty much every cover version is better than the original that was sung by Simon and Garfunkle.

So Mumsnet, AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
limitedperiodonly · 08/04/2023 17:51

I love Elvis Costello's version of How Much I Lied better than the Gram Parsons original not just because it's better, but because Almost Blue, the album it was on, was comprised of cover versions of country music I would never have listened to if he hadn't introduced me to it.

I went on to listen to more country music but this version is so simple and beautiful I always weep

Elvis Costello - How Much I've Lied (Gram Parsons)

From Almost Blue 1981

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q52Aen73vAE

LadyEloise1 · 08/04/2023 08:59

@JudgeJ ".....I have never and will never forgive that Madonna woman for ruining American Pie......"

"That Madonna woman"
Love it 😂😂😂

jcyclops · 07/04/2023 23:58

Paul Simon is definitely one of the greatest ever songwriters, but that doesn't mean his performances of those songs are the greatest versions. When I compare any cover version to the original, I imagine the cover artist wrote it and the writer is covering it, and see if it changes my thinking. Do this with several Simon & Garfunkel songs and their versions can sound like wishy-washy pared-down versions that are used commonly in modern adverts - which are often condemned on mumsnet.

I agree with posters above that the Bangles cover of Hazy Shade of Winter is far better than the original, and even Gerard Way's (of My Chemical Romance) compares well.

Some cover versions are infinitely superior to the original - a previous discussion on mumsnet discussed Badfinger's "Without You" and just about everyone agreed that most cover versions were better, especially Harry Nilsson's and Mariah Carey's.

Groutyonehereagain · 07/04/2023 23:15

I completely disagree, S & G are an absolute legend.

Summergarden · 07/04/2023 23:13

Maybe… I agree that Paul Simon is a genius, still listen to his best of album regularly.

However I find Bright Eyes to be one of the most emotionally moving songs ever. How much I’d still think that without having seen Watership Down though, I’m not sure…

i prefer Nirvana’s cover of the Man who Sold the World to Bowie’s original.

EachandEveryone · 07/04/2023 23:03

He was handsome. They are perfect together and I dont think any covers are a patch on what they created together. Ah, I wish I was a teen in those free and easy days. Although Central Park was terrifying in that era wasnt it?

EachandEveryone · 07/04/2023 22:33

Ive jus5 come to say this 😃

LyndaSnellsSniff · 07/04/2023 22:23

Concert in Central Park on Sky Arts on TV right now!

washinwashoutrepeat · 07/04/2023 20:52

YABU

BebbanburgIsMine · 07/04/2023 20:46

Simon and Garfunkel are brilliant.

I hate Disturbed's version of Sound of Silence, it's absolutely awful.

drpet49 · 07/04/2023 20:43

HeddaGarbled · 07/04/2023 08:14

Nope. The harmony of the two voices is something special. And that Disturbed version turns the original into a ten-a-penny power ballad.

This. I must the only person who didn’t like Disturbed’s version of sound of silence.

Starchipenterprise · 07/04/2023 20:36

I generally dislike cover versions, I prefer hearing the original artist. I really dislike that cover of SOS.

I have had time to explore Paul Simon's music recently. He's an amazing composer and singer. I consider Garfunkel to be the weaker link, but fab at melodies.

I really can't imagine, for example, a cover of Train in the Distance being sung without the intonation and meaning of the actual writer. PS's work is some of the best I have ever heard. One of the best first lines too in Graceland 'The Mississippi Delta was shining like a National Guitar' reflected by the crispness of the playing. Pure gold!

cheekaa · 07/04/2023 20:22

OP, if Bowie's version of America is anything to go by , I am totally in agreement with you.

NeelyOHara1 · 07/04/2023 20:09

I've wondered whether most of the super talented BeeGees songs would have been better if done by other artists.. The Al Green version of How Can You Mend, as an example?

Chickenkeev · 07/04/2023 19:56

Garfunkel's voice soars. He hasn't been able to sing for a long time whereas PS can still sing. But Garfunkel in his day was magnificent.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 07/04/2023 19:53

YABU - I like the Lemonheads' Mrs Robinson but S&G are still better. Their voices and production are of their time and can't be improved on.

As for that Disturbed version of Sound of Silence?! I went to listen to it because of the Mumsnet raves but it is embarrassing. Singing like you have constipation does not make it sound emotionally meaningful.

Chickenkeev · 07/04/2023 19:52

RattlewhenIwalk · 07/04/2023 08:01

Together they are S&G and their sound is unique (I'm a fan...)

Paul Simon's own material is great but different and I love that too. Without Art Garfunkel their S&G isn't quite the same, a little bit lacking - he really does contribute something individual.

So, yes, OP, you are BU!

Agree with this!

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/04/2023 19:45

Ooooh thems fightin' words...

Love Simon and Garfunkel. They are awesome.

Cover versions... I think their songs are good to cover as theres a lot of scope to play around with them, and they're solid songs to start with, you'd need to go some to fuck it up...

Disturbeds Sound of Silence... once you get past the 'loud and shouty'... it lacks depth and range, it is just loud. The original had subtlety and power that for all Disturbeds volume and rage, they just cannot capture. The more I hear it, the less I like it and prefer the original.

PurpleEmpress · 07/04/2023 15:53

If you like S&G it’s worth seeing the tribute show The Simon and Garfunkel Story. The two men playing S&G are really good, obviously not as good as the real thing but a good evenings entertainment

Want2beme · 07/04/2023 15:36

YADBU. You cannot beat S&G at their own music. Mumford and Sons version doesn't touch the original.

Simon and Garfunkel take me back to when I first discovered DMs record collection. Nostalgia 😊

PuppyMonkey · 07/04/2023 15:17

It’s a hard no for the Disturbed version for me. Ditto the other mediocre cover versions.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 07/04/2023 15:06

bellinisurge · 07/04/2023 10:09

Really don't like them. Too many "young people's Mass" at school where S&G were the soundtrack.

Ironic, given they're both Jewish!

Thanks for whoever mentioned First Aid Kit. I hadn't heard them before and now want to hear more.

As the first person to mention Bob Dylan on this thread, I just want to clarify that there are some songs I can't imagine anybody performing better, notably all the songs on my favourite album, Blood on the Tracks, and especially Tangled up in Blue. I don't think a singer songwriter needs to have a fabulous voice to be a great performer. They need presence and musicality, and I agree with everybody who said there is an extra dimension when you listen to a song you know the lead singer wrote or co-wrote. Neil Young is a case in point, Leonard Cohen is another, so is Bob Dylan.

Paul Simon had a beautiful voice in his prime (he and Art are 82 now, no idea how they sound these days). It's very different from Art's but they were magical together.

Strugglingtodomybest · 07/04/2023 12:53

comeondover · 07/04/2023 10:56

Another vote for the Disturbed version of The Sound of Silence. It's great to turn up loud and bellow along to, and if I need a cry somehow this helps.

I'll also risk controversy by saying I prefer Nirvana's version of The Man Who Sold The World, and Natalie Merchant's Space Odyssey, to the Bowie originals.

I agree with the Nirvana cover, I absolutely love it.

JudgeJ · 07/04/2023 11:50

izzy2076 · 07/04/2023 08:44

'Toss me a cigarette I think there's one in my raincoat..

Kathy I'm lost I said though I knew she was sleeping....I'm empty and aching and I don't know why...'

These lines are so powerful in their simplicity and could never be sung by anyone else. YABU!

On our first US trip we landed at Newark airport and drove up to Connecticutt, the children started counting 1, 2, 3 etc, when I asked what they were doing they sang Counting the cars on the New Jersey turnpike!

JudgeJ · 07/04/2023 11:47

friskybivalves · 07/04/2023 09:31

Ohhh the live Central Park version of Bridge over Troubled Water is just...sublime. and The Boxer is another favourite. Wish I'd ever seen them play.

I have that wonderful concert on the Sky box as a 'keep' , I'd never heard the extra verse of The Boxer before, the thing that slightly detracts is the obvious poor relationship between them. An old friend used to talk about seeing Paul Simon in the UK before he hit the big time, would have been around the time he wrote Homeward Bound.