Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Controversial Opinion - Simon and Garfunkle

158 replies

Magenta82 · 07/04/2023 07:49

I've long harboured this opinion and so far the people I've voiced it to have been split so I thought I would throw it out to you lovely ladies.

Paul Simon is a genius, his songs and music are amazing, however, pretty much every cover version is better than the original that was sung by Simon and Garfunkle.

So Mumsnet, AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
Ofcourseshecan · 14/05/2023 20:17

I don’t often say YABU, but really? The glorious soaring almost otherworldly voice of Art Garfunkel? He made those songs!

TheMarzipanDildo · 13/04/2023 18:48

Shocking opinion op

Dutch1e · 13/04/2023 18:30

LadyEloise1 · 07/04/2023 08:32

@So1invictus - they forgot to tell Dylan he couldn't sing.
😀
And I agree too that he was an amazing lyricist.

He got there on his own.... I remember reading an interview where he says "I can't sing and I'm not a great guitar player, I just needed something to carry the poetry." I completely agree even though I'm a huge fan of his!

Strugglingtodomybest · 13/04/2023 15:39
  1. The Tale Of The Mumsnetter who believed they were brothers called Art and Garth Funkel.
Oh bless, that's hilarious!

2. Also that one has brought up "Valerie" in a covers discussion, yes it was an amazing cover but no one ever shuts the fuck up about it 

IMO, shit song and I hate both versions (sorry Amy!).

I'm now listening to a First Aid Kit mix on YouTube. They're great, love their harmonies too.

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 11/04/2023 12:42

God I think that Disturbed cover is fucking dire, the singer sounds like the love child of Zack de la Rocha and Alfie Boe.

@Magenta82 I'm so pleased to find someone who also thinks the Johnny Cash cover is Hurt is just as good/better than the original!It's just so evocative and so meaningful. IIRC Trent Reznor said something like hearing JC was going to cover it was like hearing someone say they were going to fuck his girlfriend, but after he heard the track he realised they were meant to be together? I do love the original though, especially as the contrast to The Downward Spiral. Just amazing, especially hearing it for the first time.

Two things I am surprised not to read in this thread however:

  1. The Tale Of The Mumsnetter who believed they were brothers called Art and Garth Funkel.
  1. Also that one has brought up "Valerie" in a covers discussion, yes it was an amazing cover but no one ever shuts the fuck up about it 
dudsville · 11/04/2023 12:26

That Peyton Parrish version is so similar I guess I cuoldn't choose between them but what'sintereting about his voice is in the lower register he sounds like he's doing that Mongolian singing style where they somehow hold two notes together, forget what it's called.

EachandEveryone · 11/04/2023 12:21

Although I do have time for Everything but the Girls Only Living Boy in New York

dudsville · 11/04/2023 12:20

@Slitherie , my goodness, I dind't realise until now that I don't think i ever really understood that song until hearing that version just now.

Clawdy · 11/04/2023 12:11

Highlyflavouredgravy · 07/04/2023 08:05

You are quite, quite wrong .
So wrong in fact that it hurts my brain.

Me too. I saw them in concert years ago, and will never forget that night. Nobody ever sings their songs as wonderfully.

JustinOtherdad · 11/04/2023 12:05

The problem with a lot of S&G covers is that the artist is trying too hard to make something that sounds different without straying too far from the original. Disturbed's version of Sound of Silence is just one long gimmick on the crescendo. Yes he's got a great voice but the whole arrangement is simply about him getting louder and louder, and he tries to tweak the phrasing which just spoils the whole flow of the lyrics.

Similarly with Mumford and The Boxer, he alters the phrasing slightly which doesn't change it enough from the original it just spoils the lyrical flow. In fact I'd say it actually completely ruins all the emotion in the final verse. And his odd over-pronunciation of the 'la la la' parts - he sounds more like 'lar la lai' - makes them sound contrived.

First Aid Kit's America works so well because they stay true to the original musical phrasing and have the same natural harmony that S&G had.

Fraaahnces · 11/04/2023 12:02

Agree that they wrote stunning songs and amazing lyrics. They also didn’t have access to the technology we have today to record more impressive works. No autotune, no digital orchestration, no multitracks. Their voices weren’t magnificent, but they were authentic. The others were highly edited. The guy from disturbed is a baritone, S&G are both tenors. So many differences.

gogohmm · 11/04/2023 12:00

If you said Bob Dylan i would definitely agree, a better song writer than singer/performer

Annoyingwurringnoise · 11/04/2023 11:49

Nope, this must be a wind up, I don’t believe this is an opinion anybody can genuinely hold. YABVVVVU

DorritLittle · 11/04/2023 11:43

I like some of the covers mentioned a lot but totally disagree!

Pouffeycat · 11/04/2023 11:40

HeddaGarbled · 07/04/2023 08:14

Nope. The harmony of the two voices is something special. And that Disturbed version turns the original into a ten-a-penny power ballad.

Exactly.

Their voices combined...
And sound of silence is a song of its time.
And should be respected as such.

WestwardHo1 · 11/04/2023 11:40

Oh that's been mentioned Blush

WestwardHo1 · 11/04/2023 11:39

Magenta82 · 07/04/2023 07:56

Disturbed version of sound of silence.
The Lemonhead's Mrs Robinson
Mudford and Sons the Boxer
Various versions of Bridge Over Troubled Waters
Hell I'd even go as far as to say the Suggs version of Cecelia is better...

I'd add Hazy Shade of Winter by the Bangles

mydogisthebest · 11/04/2023 11:32

EachandEveryone · 11/04/2023 00:03

I have The Graduate on now. What a soundtrack nothing compares to those two voices together. It cant be copied.

The Graduate is one of my favourite films. I skipped school to go and see it at the cinema and at the end stayed and watched it again as I loved it so much.

That film was my introduction to Simon and Garfunkel and I have loved their music ever since. Every single time I hear SOS I am back at that cinema as a 14 year old

EachandEveryone · 11/04/2023 00:03

I have The Graduate on now. What a soundtrack nothing compares to those two voices together. It cant be copied.

Enko · 09/04/2023 09:54

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 07/04/2023 15:06

Ironic, given they're both Jewish!

Thanks for whoever mentioned First Aid Kit. I hadn't heard them before and now want to hear more.

As the first person to mention Bob Dylan on this thread, I just want to clarify that there are some songs I can't imagine anybody performing better, notably all the songs on my favourite album, Blood on the Tracks, and especially Tangled up in Blue. I don't think a singer songwriter needs to have a fabulous voice to be a great performer. They need presence and musicality, and I agree with everybody who said there is an extra dimension when you listen to a song you know the lead singer wrote or co-wrote. Neil Young is a case in point, Leonard Cohen is another, so is Bob Dylan.

Paul Simon had a beautiful voice in his prime (he and Art are 82 now, no idea how they sound these days). It's very different from Art's but they were magical together.

Firstaid kit is really interesting if you look on you tube there are some short videos about how they grew up and came to form Firstaid kit.

I heard their America cover in a clothes shop. First thinking "Oh I'm not sure about this" then changed my.mind and asked who the artist was. Still listen to them now.

I do agree re Bob Dylan and Neil Young.

ByTheSea · 09/04/2023 08:04

Katherine1985 · 08/04/2023 20:38

Loved S&G since my teens and don’t think I know any of the covers mentioned here BUT a couple of years ago heard Kathy’s Song by Eva Cassidy and think it’s truly sublime

That's the one I think of when bringing to mind great S&G covers.

Katherine1985 · 08/04/2023 20:38

Loved S&G since my teens and don’t think I know any of the covers mentioned here BUT a couple of years ago heard Kathy’s Song by Eva Cassidy and think it’s truly sublime

Magenta82 · 08/04/2023 20:23

PurpleEmpress · 08/04/2023 20:10

I have spent a happy afternoon you tubing S&G videos and cover versions of songs. Agree about Nirvana and Man Who Sold The World incidentally. Thank you OP, I’ve had a lovely time. I finished by watching the programme about Bob Marley coming to the UK that was shown BBC4 last night, a most enjoyable few hours

I'm glad I inspired people to listen to some music the love at least!
I listened to the boxer and then left the amazon music algorithms to do their thing. I had a great music selection that made a long car journey much better.

OP posts:
PurpleEmpress · 08/04/2023 20:10

I have spent a happy afternoon you tubing S&G videos and cover versions of songs. Agree about Nirvana and Man Who Sold The World incidentally. Thank you OP, I’ve had a lovely time. I finished by watching the programme about Bob Marley coming to the UK that was shown BBC4 last night, a most enjoyable few hours