Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't parents held responsible for their children's criminal offences?

168 replies

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 20:01

news.sky.com/story/boy-12-arrested-on-suspicion-of-murder-after-woman-hit-by-car-in-sheffield-12851331

Last night in the nearby area to me a 60 year old woman was killed by a 12 year old who was trying to steal her car. It is a lovely area where it happened, my brother lives round the corner, as you can imagine it has been a massive shock to residents.

A 12 year old boy has been charged with murder, he ran her over with the car as she tried to stop him taking the car, it happened at 7.30pm & she died at the scene. Why aren't parents held responsible for their son's actions? He was armed with a knife as well. If my son had been involved with crime at that age I would have known, he wasn't allowed out unless I knew where he was & who he was with, is it that some parents just don't care?

OP posts:
Meandfour · 06/04/2023 21:40

@Nat6999 you mustn’t live too far from me. It’s absolutely horrific isn’t it and I completely agree- wtf has happened in this boys life for him to do this at 12?! The fact he could even drive a car…. It’s terrible.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/04/2023 21:36

I believe that if a child is in possession of something illegal that the parent should be held responsible for that in itself.

Cigarettes, alcohol, energy drinks, weapons, drugs, etc

How do you deal with parents not together with that? My ex and I had very different standards of what we’d accept from our girls. Would I be held responsible for something he allowed them to do even though I had no choice but to make them available to him as per the court order (hypothetic obviously as he didn’t bother his arse most of the time).

Then you have situations like my childhood. Technically by the time my brother went off the rails we were the responsibility of our grandparents, having been removed from our parents. However, he was 13 when we were taken. So if he got caught with a knife or drugs at 15 would it actually have been fair to hold them responsible?

It’s far too simplistic.

Mayorquimby2 · 06/04/2023 21:35

Because it would be fucking stupid

BramleyAppleHotCrossBun · 06/04/2023 21:33

It’s reported that this child was in care. Are the local authority going to be held responsible? Social workers?

I thought the concept of criminal responsibility was such that it assumes the human is responsible for their choices 🤷🏼‍♀️

FrumptyMumpty · 06/04/2023 21:31

I believe that if a child is in possession of something illegal that the parent should be held responsible for that in itself.

Cigarettes, alcohol, energy drinks, weapons, drugs, etc

I don’t think for their actions though. Everyone is capable of making a bad a split second decision with massive consequences for other people. Kids probably more so as they scientifically lack the ability to process such information with speed and total consideration.

RightWhereINeedToBe · 06/04/2023 21:31

Right, and what about the shitty parents of the shitty parents? People who were raised without love, care, boundaries, etc, don't know how to raise their own kids differently.

JamonEverybody · 06/04/2023 21:26

What a fucking stupid ignorant post.

Shame on you OP.

cptartapp · 06/04/2023 21:21

When you mean parents you mean mostly the mothers. Because in many such cases the fathers have long gone.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/04/2023 21:18

It’s not always as simple as shit parenting.

My paternal grandparents brought up four children. Two are/were thoroughly decent people. Brilliant parents, decent partners, good jobs, responsible and kind people. One is decent but a bit selfish. Nothing majorly bad, but a bit selfish with anyone other than their children. They are a good parent. Then there was my father. We were moved to live with sad grandparents when 7yo me told my teacher, in a very matter of fact way because it was normal for us, about my brother getting in trouble the night before and my father burning him with the iron as punishment.

It’s also now strongly suspected that my father was responsible for a few horrific nasty crimes against women going back to his teens.

It’s rarely as black and white as shit parenting imo.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 06/04/2023 21:16

It’d be expensive and of very little use once the crime has occurred.

Far better to spend money trying to intervene and support kids of useless or neglectful parents whilst they’re still young. At least then you’ve a chance of doing some good.

Regularsizedrudy · 06/04/2023 21:14

you only have to think about this for about 30 seconds to realise it’s fucking stupid and wouldn’t work. You sound dim.

Ted27 · 06/04/2023 21:08

@Whichnumbers

Could you state your source for that number
I think you are massively over stating it

OP posts:
Atealltheminieggs · 06/04/2023 21:04

It's too complicated. Yes they could be crap parents who don't care, but it's not always that simple.

Sometimes children from good families go off the rails. Yes they should have control over a 12 year old, but let's say the parents were working all the hours to pay the bills.

They might have other children to look after that aren't getting into trouble. What happens to them if you jail the parents?

They could have learning difficulties or disabilities and be doing their best.

I am playing devils advocate of course.

Goldbar · 06/04/2023 21:02

Because people, including children, have free will and autonomy in many respects. And although the actions of others may influence the choices we make, ultimately they are our choices and others cannot be held responsible for them.

neilyoungismyhero · 06/04/2023 21:02

Easterfunbun · 06/04/2023 20:13

Similar thing happened near me not long ago. A 14 year old killed an elderly lady during a burglary. As a mother of a 13 year old son who would NEVER in a million years commit such a heinous crime then you do have to wonder about the parenting or rather the lack of it? It absolutely is a factor. A massive one.

I'm guessing perhaps the parents of the 12 year old echoed your thoughts until yesterday.
Once our children are out of sight none of us know what they're getting up to. My children are adults with children of their own now but have since shared some of their antics back in the day- some of which I would not have approved of.
They were brought up in a good home, had all the opportunities going that we could afford, medium income family, were taught values and respect but still crossed the line at times it would seem.

JaffavsCookie · 06/04/2023 21:00

Totally naive of some posters to suggest always the parents fault. As a teacher of course i teach some kids with issues where the parents also have issues, but I have also taught many families where most of the kids are working hard and doing well and 1 is off the rails for some reason, almost certainly not related to the their parenting.

WheelsUp · 06/04/2023 20:54

I think a better strategy would be for youth offending and social care to work more closely and for more input in early intervention with these families.
By the time a child has committed a serious offence it’s already too late.

Absolutely. Investment in services like CAMHS, Social Services etc is a commitment that needs to be made to reduce the odds of incidents like this but children are not a priority as the case where the man got away with raping a 13 year old proves.

Hellocatshome · 06/04/2023 20:53

Despite the fact it is not a good idea and will never work if it was implemented parents would then be more likely to help their children conceal their crimes so that they didn't also get put on trial.

SunshineGeorgie · 06/04/2023 20:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yeah, right, do you have a link to all that??

Delia123 · 06/04/2023 20:51

Parents and any other person caring for a child can't be held directly responsible for the childs crimes because they didn't commit the crime. Parents can be held responsible if their child repeatedly gets into trouble or if they do not take reasonable steps to control their behaviour. They could be asked to attend a parenting programme (although most of these are pretty shit), asked to sign a Parenting Contract or be given a Parenting Order by a court. Social Services may become involved if your child is considered to be 'out of parental control'.

BertieBotts · 06/04/2023 20:49

What is it meant to achieve?

Is it supposed to be a warning to other parents - make sure your kids behave or end up in jail? Would that even work? Not sure. It must be a tiny minority of parents who actively cause delinquent behaviour in children, and of those, some of them might actively be choosing not to parent, but some of them will just be completely clueless/struggling heavily with multiple issues of their own, so not sure that it would be much of a deterrent, since someone with that many issues is unlikely to even notice much outside of their own immediate experience.

Is it meant to protect the parents' other children? Because sometimes parents who have one delinquent child have other children who behave perfectly normally, who are probably already suffering/struggling due to their sibling's behaviour. The impact upon them on being removed and taken into care because their parents have been prosecuted would be massive. That kind of trauma may well lead to the same kinds of behaviour that you're hoping to avoid in them in the first place.

If the parents do have other children that they are similarly failing then it might be helpful in that scenario - but again, if you're hoping to help those children not become delinquent themselves, then it might be worth looking at whether prosecuting the parents (and therefore removing the kids) is the best course of action, or whether that might be likely to cause more issues in the kids, or whether supporting the parents might be better for the children.

What about children who are not brought up by their parents? Or who are brought up by a single parent? What happens in that scenario?

I can see the thought process of the surface idea, but I think you have to go back a step - what's the situation now, what should it be, how to achieve that.

I assume you're saying

Situation now: Poor parenting is causing teenage crime
Situation should be: (More/most) parents should parent effectively, therefore preventing/reducing crime
Way to achieve: Punish parents whose children commit crimes

So I think if you're going there you've got to go back to the root of what the situation is now and examine that as a premise. Is it poor parenting which causes teenage crime? Is that the only cause? The main cause? Can we define/agree on what "poor parenting" consists of? Why might parents act in that way? What might help them parent differently?

purpleme12 · 06/04/2023 20:49

I can see how a child could have good parents but still do bad things.

Honeyroar · 06/04/2023 20:49

MrsR87 · 06/04/2023 20:30

Teacher here and it really isn’t as black
and white as you think it is.
You are suggesting that all young people who commit serious crimes come from homes where the parents don’t care/ don’t enforce boundaries/ break the law themselves etc. And whilst this will be the case for some it is so far from the truth for others.
Your argument always reminds me of the parents of two children, both came to our school. The first was a model student; self motivated, polite, helpful etc. They went on to study at an excellent university and are now a doctor. Their sibling was the total opposite; always in trouble, rude, aggressive, lazy etc. The parents would beg the school and other agencies for help. They tried so hard but the second child would frequently run away/ go missing etc. I can promise you that those parents could not have done anything more to try to get their child back on the straight and narrow but I saw in the papers a few years later that they had committed a serious crime and are now in prison. I would never expect those parents to take the blame for the actions of that child, that would be highly unfair.

Great to hear a teacher say this. That’s exactly what it was like with my brother and myself. My parents tried so hard for him.

Whichnumbers · 06/04/2023 20:47

The prison stats show that 90% of prisoners were brought up in care, therefore the government were their parents

I doubt the government wants to be held accountable

Swipe left for the next trending thread