Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't parents held responsible for their children's criminal offences?

168 replies

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 20:01

news.sky.com/story/boy-12-arrested-on-suspicion-of-murder-after-woman-hit-by-car-in-sheffield-12851331

Last night in the nearby area to me a 60 year old woman was killed by a 12 year old who was trying to steal her car. It is a lovely area where it happened, my brother lives round the corner, as you can imagine it has been a massive shock to residents.

A 12 year old boy has been charged with murder, he ran her over with the car as she tried to stop him taking the car, it happened at 7.30pm & she died at the scene. Why aren't parents held responsible for their son's actions? He was armed with a knife as well. If my son had been involved with crime at that age I would have known, he wasn't allowed out unless I knew where he was & who he was with, is it that some parents just don't care?

OP posts:
MintJulia · 07/04/2023 08:34

If my son had been involved with crime at that age I would have known, he wasn't allowed out unless I knew where he was & who he was with, is it that some parents just don't care?

A 12yo boy who has full mental capacity and had been in the UK's school system for 7 years knows he shouldn't take a car. He knows he shouldn't drive a car at another human. He may not have realised he would kill the poor lady but he knew what he was doing was wrong. At 12 he is responsible for his actions. His parents may have been guilty of poor parenting, but by 12, the boy has free will and made his own decisions.

Now hopefully, he will be raised in a secure environment where he will be physically unable to run wild, for at least 6 years until adulthood, to get sorted.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/04/2023 08:34

ButterCrackers · 07/04/2023 07:47

The care givers should be held responsible. Correct parenting enables a child to know right from wrong.

How long should someone have to be a “care giver” for before they’re legally responsible?

My grandparents for example. Took my siblings and I from our abusive parents and gave us a proper home. I was 7. My siblings were 12, 13 and 15.

The 13yo was involved in an incident at 15. Grandparents should have been held responsible or not?

and at what point do foster caters have to be legally responsible for the children they’re trying to help? Because I imagine that would have a considerable impact on the already low numbers

Easterfunbun · 07/04/2023 08:32

I think crimes like these signal more than a “going off the rails”.

Disgustipated · 07/04/2023 08:31

I grew up somewhere parents were accountable, with things like fines for anti-social behaviour or theft. I think it could rise to community service or jail.
However there were pretty much no consequences for however you chose to manage a child, bar extreme injury or neglect.
I can’t see how you could work it within the western parenting model

Easterfunbun · 07/04/2023 08:30

@BananaBlue

I don’t know any well raised kids who kill people at aged 12. The fact people are just normalising that describing it as behavioural is worrying.

There’s a different to bad behaviour and psychopathic behaviour completely devoid of empathy or any sort of conscience, which is well developed in 12 year olds who have been raised to know a very simple right from wrong.

BananaBlue · 07/04/2023 08:24

I think some people need to blame the parents because the alternative is to imagine that your own (well bought up) child is capable of such a heinous crime.

Gives a feeling of superiority.

MintJulia · 07/04/2023 08:24

BlusteryLake · 06/04/2023 20:11

To me that gets complicated if you are trying to apportion blame to parents. Are you blaming the one who is actually doing some form of parental support as opposed to the one who buggered off when the child was a baby?

This.

I've raised my ds. His df has barely spent any time with him, and has certainly not contributed to his moral or ethical values.

If my ds went off the rails would it be my fault for being responsible 24/7 while working full time and providing for us, or his df's fault for being completely irresponsible?

monkeysmum21 · 07/04/2023 08:15

Seriously, OP?

This is the kind of thoughts that comes from the guts not from the brain. You need to blame someone, you need to punish someone, but doesn’t look like you are looking for a solution in society.

Butchyrestingface · 07/04/2023 08:08

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 22:00

Bettyboop3 if my ds had murdered someone I would feel responsible, it is a parent's responsibility to teach their children right from wrong. If my child was a minor I would expect to be punished for their crime.

Why would you expect to be punished for their crime?

What country do you live in that this would be a reasonable expectation? It can't be the UK because no parent here would reasonably expected to be held responsible for their offspring's criminal behaviour.

phlebasconsidered · 07/04/2023 07:58

I teach in a pupil referral unit. Although some of the students there are products of their upbringing, some have lovely, desperate,very distressed parents at their wits end who have done all the parenting, all the lines drawn, grabbed all the help they can and still can't help their child.

Sometimes children's behaviour isn't just as a result of parents not laying down the law. It's not that simplistic. A good example of this is county lines- you would not believe how many "nice" kids fall prey to that.

Weallgottachangesometime · 07/04/2023 07:58

ButterCrackers · 07/04/2023 07:47

The care givers should be held responsible. Correct parenting enables a child to know right from wrong.

Ok. What do you think will happen if foster carers had to take legal responsibility if the children in their care commit crimes?

There is already a shortage of good foster carers, especially those willing to care for older children with difficult behaviour and significant needs. So when people refuse to foster older children with complex needs, because they don’t want to end up in prison if that child commits a crime, who is going to care for those children?

what crime would the foster parents be charged with?
What happens to other children in the parent/carers care if they go to prison?

ofasphodel · 07/04/2023 07:52

Are you the same OP who posted about the neighbour's cat shitting in your garden? It's spooky if not, because this is the exact same nonsensical logic.

ButterCrackers · 07/04/2023 07:47

Weallgottachangesometime · 07/04/2023 07:43

Surely thought, with teenagers, the only way you could guarantee your child was not doing anything illegal would be to supervise them at all times. It’s hat realistic for a 12 year old +?

Also this child was in care and not in the care of his parents.

The care givers should be held responsible. Correct parenting enables a child to know right from wrong.

Weallgottachangesometime · 07/04/2023 07:43

ButterCrackers · 07/04/2023 07:37

The parents should be held responsible and so should the child. If this happened parents would try to parent correctly and not have their kid on the street with a knife and stealing and in this case killing someone. There are no excuses for having your child out and committing crime.

Surely thought, with teenagers, the only way you could guarantee your child was not doing anything illegal would be to supervise them at all times. It’s hat realistic for a 12 year old +?

Also this child was in care and not in the care of his parents.

ButterCrackers · 07/04/2023 07:37

The parents should be held responsible and so should the child. If this happened parents would try to parent correctly and not have their kid on the street with a knife and stealing and in this case killing someone. There are no excuses for having your child out and committing crime.

SnackSizeRaisin · 07/04/2023 06:51

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 23:52

BettyBoop3 agreed there needs to be reform in policing, Social Services, Children's Services & Education as too many families & children fall through the net. Too many children miss out on education after being excluded while waiting for places in PRU, maybe secondary schools each having their own PRU on site or groups of schools sharing a unit would work. Children need good role models to help them develop healthy relationships & behaviour & guide them on the right path. There is a need to bring back youth services & youth clubs that were cut & the clubs closed. There used to be an amazing youth club that covered the area this lady was killed in, the staff were dedicated to working for the young people who went there & kept many from going off the rails & out of trouble. They also were someone who wasn't a parent to listen to the young person's problems & not judge but give advice, they cared about every one of the members. It also kept them off the streets, involved in activities & helped them develop interests like sports, arts, music, car maintenance & dance. The young people were involved with running the club, they ran the coffee bar, were dj's, helped maintain the building ding painting, decorating & repairs. That is one thing that is needed to keep youth crime down.

Yes to all the above. Not to punishing parents. The Tory government is responsible for this crime. If they hadn't repeatedly cut the budgets for all of the above services there's a decent chance the outcome for this child would have been different.
As said upthread, a disproportionate number of criminals were either brought up in care or had abusive parents. It's prevention we need more of, not harsh punishments that ultimately do more harm.

Avarua2 · 07/04/2023 00:06

Ooooo

remember that film, We Have to Talk about Kevin.

My god. Eye-opening.

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 23:52

BettyBoop3 agreed there needs to be reform in policing, Social Services, Children's Services & Education as too many families & children fall through the net. Too many children miss out on education after being excluded while waiting for places in PRU, maybe secondary schools each having their own PRU on site or groups of schools sharing a unit would work. Children need good role models to help them develop healthy relationships & behaviour & guide them on the right path. There is a need to bring back youth services & youth clubs that were cut & the clubs closed. There used to be an amazing youth club that covered the area this lady was killed in, the staff were dedicated to working for the young people who went there & kept many from going off the rails & out of trouble. They also were someone who wasn't a parent to listen to the young person's problems & not judge but give advice, they cared about every one of the members. It also kept them off the streets, involved in activities & helped them develop interests like sports, arts, music, car maintenance & dance. The young people were involved with running the club, they ran the coffee bar, were dj's, helped maintain the building ding painting, decorating & repairs. That is one thing that is needed to keep youth crime down.

OP posts:
TeaAndTattoos · 06/04/2023 22:57

Not everything can be blamed on the parents even kids from great backgrounds can form friendships with the wrong people and kids need to take responsibility for their own actions. People scream about people taking responsibility for their own actions and then you want the parents blaming for their 12 year old running a lady over.

CharlotteDoyle · 06/04/2023 22:46

Sorry OP but the notion that a person should be criminally responsible for the independent acts of someone else is not only unworkable (for some many reasons) but also contrary to the fundamental principles of fairness and individual accountability.

That said, it would be natural to question the upbringing and experiences of a young child who goes on to intentionally commit a serious violent crime. IMO these families probably need more support, not more criminal convictions.

Elvis1956 · 06/04/2023 22:40

MakiSushi · 06/04/2023 20:07

I think it's really unfair to cast aspersions on the parents in these circumstances.

Of course parents have to raise their children to hold strong moral values etc. What happened was absolutely horrific but the child was 12 - in Scotland children are held responsible for criminal activity from the age of 10. Factors will be a play beyond the child's upbringing (peer pressure, substance abuse etc).

Blaming the parents is just shifting blame - not actually solving any problems.

Fuck right off. If the parents had been parents then perhaps....I grew up in a rough intact very rough working class area. The worst criminals from my age group were the ones who parents didn't give a shit.
Yes some good people had kids who were naughty. But the rapists,murderers, burglars I knew all had shit parents

Bettyboop3 · 06/04/2023 22:38

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 22:19

BettyBoop3 no it wasn't her fault but after she found out she made damn sure I never did it again, she made school put me on permanent report so I had to get it signed every lesson.

And what if you were bigger than her, violent and she was scared of you? Would you still think that's all on her that she couldn't physically get you into school? What if she had spent years begging for help from gp, camhs, police, cab & nobody would help? Even though she had 2 children good as gold, going into school every day? Still sonething she must be doing wrong?

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 06/04/2023 22:34

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 22:19

BettyBoop3 no it wasn't her fault but after she found out she made damn sure I never did it again, she made school put me on permanent report so I had to get it signed every lesson.

Key point AFTER. What about before? What if you had killed someone or did something illegal, should your mother have gone to jail for it?

Bettyboop3 · 06/04/2023 22:32

FrumptyMumpty · 06/04/2023 21:31

I believe that if a child is in possession of something illegal that the parent should be held responsible for that in itself.

Cigarettes, alcohol, energy drinks, weapons, drugs, etc

I don’t think for their actions though. Everyone is capable of making a bad a split second decision with massive consequences for other people. Kids probably more so as they scientifically lack the ability to process such information with speed and total consideration.

Does that include drugs runners, radicalisation? All the parents fault?

matis · 06/04/2023 22:26

Very many wealthy children or children from farming families are driving at 12.

They aren't criminals or likely to become criminals just because they've learnt to drive cars and other vehicles early.