Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't parents held responsible for their children's criminal offences?

168 replies

Nat6999 · 06/04/2023 20:01

news.sky.com/story/boy-12-arrested-on-suspicion-of-murder-after-woman-hit-by-car-in-sheffield-12851331

Last night in the nearby area to me a 60 year old woman was killed by a 12 year old who was trying to steal her car. It is a lovely area where it happened, my brother lives round the corner, as you can imagine it has been a massive shock to residents.

A 12 year old boy has been charged with murder, he ran her over with the car as she tried to stop him taking the car, it happened at 7.30pm & she died at the scene. Why aren't parents held responsible for their son's actions? He was armed with a knife as well. If my son had been involved with crime at that age I would have known, he wasn't allowed out unless I knew where he was & who he was with, is it that some parents just don't care?

OP posts:
CrotchetyCrocheting · 07/04/2023 10:22

I don't know. I have a 13 year old and a 16 year old and when they say they are going up town with their mates I just have to trust that they aren't going around steal cars and running people over. I can't keep them locked up and they need to become independent at some stage. Obviously, I don't believe they would ever do that but how would I know for sure, how could anyone?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/04/2023 10:15

OneInEight · 07/04/2023 10:11

Personally I blame the grandparents. Because if the parents are shit it can only be because they in their turn had shit parents.

What about the great-great grandparents though? I think they’re the key.

I mean, if mine had had less than 14 kids maybe they’d have been better parents and then the knock on effect to how my gr-grandparents parented my grandparents would be better?

OneInEight · 07/04/2023 10:11

Personally I blame the grandparents. Because if the parents are shit it can only be because they in their turn had shit parents.

IsolatedWilderness · 07/04/2023 10:08

Zipps · 07/04/2023 10:06

Yabvu.
I doubt very much few parents even bad ones, say to their dc go out and steal a car/murder someone or any other serious crime.
I know the parents of 3 brothers, one is an accountant, one a sports coach and the other a thief with a drug habit and who has never worked. They all had very similar opportunities and I saw them grow up with very loving parents, who are now turning themselves inside out trying to work out what they did wrong even though they tried everything to help him. Nothing is the answer.

Plenty of families where all the children do well - then there is the one child who doesn't. Some people just can't be reached, no matter how much love and effort you give it. That's always heartbreaking.

Zipps · 07/04/2023 10:06

Yabvu.
I doubt very much few parents even bad ones, say to their dc go out and steal a car/murder someone or any other serious crime.
I know the parents of 3 brothers, one is an accountant, one a sports coach and the other a thief with a drug habit and who has never worked. They all had very similar opportunities and I saw them grow up with very loving parents, who are now turning themselves inside out trying to work out what they did wrong even though they tried everything to help him. Nothing is the answer.

IsolatedWilderness · 07/04/2023 10:04

Naunet · 07/04/2023 09:59

But again, you could say the same from dogs, could be a rescue with an unknown background, could go to doggy darecare or a pet sitter.

And sorry, but stealing a car and running a woman over is not a “mistake” for god sake. It’s a act of violence he knew was wrong. Let’s not minimise, even if you disagree with me on the point about dog owners.

Yes, that's very true about dogs. It's always very sad when improper socialisation results in poor outcomes. Though if we're comparing to kids from adverse backgrounds, some of the best kids I've known have come from what would be considered hard starts. Not that we can really compare dogs and children, which was my point.

I certainly won't minimise what this boy has done. It is violence and wrong feels like too weak a word. I don't blame the parents though. I would expect to find it far more complex than that. It's not that the parents might not have a role, small or large. Just there is no guarantee they did. I never jump to blaming the parents without all the facts.

user1494050295 · 07/04/2023 10:02

Thinking of the case in the US where the 6 year old shot his teacher, the parents should be held accountable for allowing the child access to a loaded gun. And he has needs which they knew about so even more accountable

Naunet · 07/04/2023 10:01

Oops, so many typos!

Naunet · 07/04/2023 09:59

IsolatedWilderness · 07/04/2023 09:54

I have two dogs and plenty of children. The dogs are easy.

So your kids are never going to be exposed to other influences than yourself? Never make a mistake or decision they regret? Never make a mistake because they were naive about a situation? Are you going to shadow them their whole life?

But again, you could say the same from dogs, could be a rescue with an unknown background, could go to doggy darecare or a pet sitter.

And sorry, but stealing a car and running a woman over is not a “mistake” for god sake. It’s a act of violence he knew was wrong. Let’s not minimise, even if you disagree with me on the point about dog owners.

IsolatedWilderness · 07/04/2023 09:54

Naunet · 07/04/2023 09:48

Dogs are not as simple as that at all, it takes a second to bite someone and equally, children are meant to be more intellegent, rational and have a better understanding of human ideas around right and wrong than dogs do. If were meant to be responsible for an animal that can’t even speak/understand English, parents should be responsible for their children that can.

I have two dogs and plenty of children. The dogs are easy.

So your kids are never going to be exposed to other influences than yourself? Never make a mistake or decision they regret? Never make a mistake because they were naive about a situation? Are you going to shadow them their whole life?

WoodenFloorboards · 07/04/2023 09:52

ButterCrackers · 07/04/2023 07:47

The care givers should be held responsible. Correct parenting enables a child to know right from wrong.

I'm not sure how you're going to hold the caregiver responsible if she's dead.

Naunet · 07/04/2023 09:48

IsolatedWilderness · 07/04/2023 09:33

Dogs are easy. You make sure they are fenced in, on lead when out, behind barriers. Kids make choices, get exposed to other ideas, and have free will. Dogs don't. If I contained my kids the way I contain my dogs, sure, they couldn't put a foot wrong. They wouldn't be very able to manage in the world once they were released at 18 though as they'd not have been given the chance to grow in it. Unfortunately that freedom sometimes leads to them finding a wrong path, no matter how conscientious the parent.

Dogs are not as simple as that at all, it takes a second to bite someone and equally, children are meant to be more intellegent, rational and have a better understanding of human ideas around right and wrong than dogs do. If were meant to be responsible for an animal that can’t even speak/understand English, parents should be responsible for their children that can.

MrsSkylerWhite · 07/04/2023 09:45

My mother, my brother and I were subject to the worst DV until I was 10, my brother going on 12, when my mother finally managed to break us free and we spent nearly a year moving from relative to relative so he couldn’t find us. This was in the early 70s. She worked tirelessly, late hours, to provide us with a home. When we settled, my brutalised brother took over where my father left off and made our lives hell. No-one in authority wanted to know or help. He stabbed someone when he was 14 and was taken into borstal.
Was that the fault of my traumatised mother, working herself to exhaustion to keep a roof over our heads?

Sorry but unless you know the particular circumstances in every case, you can’t make such a sweeping statement.

DangerNoodles · 07/04/2023 09:39

Plenty of people with abusive parents grow up to be decent members of society. By OP's logic do the parents deserve credit for how thier child turned out?

IsolatedWilderness · 07/04/2023 09:33

Naunet · 07/04/2023 09:25

That’s so, so awful. I kind of agree OP. If I had a dog and it bit someone, I’d be held accountable. I don’t see why it should be any different for parents when their feral kids do something awful like this.

Dogs are easy. You make sure they are fenced in, on lead when out, behind barriers. Kids make choices, get exposed to other ideas, and have free will. Dogs don't. If I contained my kids the way I contain my dogs, sure, they couldn't put a foot wrong. They wouldn't be very able to manage in the world once they were released at 18 though as they'd not have been given the chance to grow in it. Unfortunately that freedom sometimes leads to them finding a wrong path, no matter how conscientious the parent.

Naunet · 07/04/2023 09:25

That’s so, so awful. I kind of agree OP. If I had a dog and it bit someone, I’d be held accountable. I don’t see why it should be any different for parents when their feral kids do something awful like this.

IsolatedWilderness · 07/04/2023 09:12

None of mine are criminal, thankfully, but I'm not going to blame the parents. These things are always very complex. No, I'm not going to take responsibility for my children's choices. I've known plenty of teens to lie to their parents about where they are and who they are with. The parents are oblivious. My children have some different values than I raised them with in some areas. Nothing wrong with that, but it shows our children don't always pick up on parent values for whatever reason.

Easterfunbun · 07/04/2023 09:02

@BramleyAppleHotCrossBun

But your child’s narcissism does come from one parent? So technically the root cause of it was a dickhead parent who was also devoid in empathy. Depending on what you think in regards to personality disorders, you’re not born with them. They’re very much shaped by the child’s environment, particularly in the early years. Doesn’t matter if you then “parented the fuck out of them”, which by the way comes across as very overbearing and it’s no wonder your child thinks the universe revolves around them.

When will parents actually accept some fault for the way their kids turn out? It’s not rocket science.

BertieBotts · 07/04/2023 09:00

FrumptyMumpty · 06/04/2023 21:31

I believe that if a child is in possession of something illegal that the parent should be held responsible for that in itself.

Cigarettes, alcohol, energy drinks, weapons, drugs, etc

I don’t think for their actions though. Everyone is capable of making a bad a split second decision with massive consequences for other people. Kids probably more so as they scientifically lack the ability to process such information with speed and total consideration.

Who do you think is responsible for that now? It's not the child, as they are considered too young to be able to make a reasonable choice. The burden of responsibility/blame in that case applies to the adult who supplied a child with these things. That's why shopkeepers can get into such serious trouble if they are not checking ID.

It's not like the US where a 16 year old can get a criminal record from being found in posession of alcohol.

(I'm not sure how it works in the case of things like illegal weapons, drugs etc that no adult should have either).

MintJulia · 07/04/2023 08:52

Do we know this child has full mental capacity?

Yes, it's obviously a factor. There's a lot we don't know yet.

BramleyAppleHotCrossBun · 07/04/2023 08:44

BananaBlue · 07/04/2023 08:24

I think some people need to blame the parents because the alternative is to imagine that your own (well bought up) child is capable of such a heinous crime.

Gives a feeling of superiority.

This.

I have 4 DC, all of whom have been taught right and wrong. Three of them are good, honest, decent kids. One of them doesn’t give a flying fuck about right or wrong, they only care about themself and what they want. They are now an older teen, and no longer live with us. We have parented THE FUCK out of that child. It hasn’t made the blindest bit of difference. I’m utterly heartbroken that they’re just turning into a clone of their abusive, narcissistic father. But no amount of desperate parenting and screaming (metaphorically) to services for help has ever made a difference.

It’s not always a parenting problem.

BananaBlue · 07/04/2023 08:41

Do we know this child has full mental capacity?

Could have severe learning difficulties.

Could be a psychopath.

We really don’t know.

Changechangechanging · 07/04/2023 08:38

Clementineorsatsuma · 06/04/2023 20:33

Venables and Thompson came from opposite backgrounds. One set of parents were raising their son well, and trying to make sure he had a good life.
He still did what he did.

If I have them the right way round, isn’t Veneables the one with the better background who has gone on to receive additional convictions?

which suggests nature, not nurture.

The quality of parenting varies bit by far the majority of people go on to lead lives that are crime free. Parents can only do so much and are not responsible for their children’s actions.

Weallgottachangesometime · 07/04/2023 08:38

MintJulia · 07/04/2023 08:34

If my son had been involved with crime at that age I would have known, he wasn't allowed out unless I knew where he was & who he was with, is it that some parents just don't care?

A 12yo boy who has full mental capacity and had been in the UK's school system for 7 years knows he shouldn't take a car. He knows he shouldn't drive a car at another human. He may not have realised he would kill the poor lady but he knew what he was doing was wrong. At 12 he is responsible for his actions. His parents may have been guilty of poor parenting, but by 12, the boy has free will and made his own decisions.

Now hopefully, he will be raised in a secure environment where he will be physically unable to run wild, for at least 6 years until adulthood, to get sorted.

If you think 6 years in a youth custody with get him “sorted” you are delusional.

most end up with more trauma, more issues and come out and commit more crimes.

I suppose though after 6 years if he commits more crime the staff at the custody centre will be legally liable for him future crimes?

BananaBlue · 07/04/2023 08:36

I’m not sure anyone is normalising this or any other crime.

What people are saying is good upbringing doesn't always = non-criminal.

There are caring engaged parents tearing their hair out at their child’s behaviour.
There are parents getting their kids to help rob.

It’s a moot point in any case as

  1. the child was in care (maybe shit parents, maybe an orphan or ill parent),
  1. We don’t know if this was murder or manslaughter? was he trying to Nick the car and lost control? Did he purposefully put his foot down to hurt her?

What I do know is a poor lady has lost her life and I prefer to wait for more information before making assumptions.