Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My new car is too bossy

219 replies

PolkaDotMankini · 06/04/2023 19:35

I got a new car a couple of weeks ago. It's pretty (if already muddy) but the bossiness is never-ending.

If I change lane on the motorway and there's a car next to the lane I'm going into, it flashes up hazard lights on the dashboard and wing mirror, beeps loudly and nudges the steering wheel away.

When I stop the car, it flashes up a reminder to check the back seats for people and belongings.

And the final straw: it sent me a text reminding me to lock it. I was sitting in it at the time, minding my own business in the car park Confused

AIBU to find this annoying? I particularly dislike it screeching and wrenching the wheel round when I'm changing lanes. It's dangerous!

OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 10/04/2023 18:54

I agree. I hate the temperature control on my car too. I have to press one button on the screen and then another button to actually change it. The volume is done by a little roller on the wheel so why can’t temperature be the same? I want a dial, with red and blue that I simply twist.

SinnerBoy · 10/04/2023 14:00

*Scepticalwotsits" · Yesterday 07:11

sorry I don’t want to have to go through three root menus just to turn the heating up or down, it’s dangerous

Yes, I don't even like fiddling with the radio, or the heating, as I often start to drive less straight. Mind you, I usually do an over the shoulder look, when changing lanes on dual carriageways and never veer then.

PolkaDotMankini · 10/04/2023 13:01

We're fully electric now and can't go back. I'm going to investigate turning off the panicking though.

OP posts:
catinboooots · 10/04/2023 12:54

Do yourself a favour and get rid. Treat yourself to a nice little 2003 Honda Jazz. No judgement or bossiness whatsoever.

JMSA · 10/04/2023 12:31

Ballyhoobird · 06/04/2023 19:56

Mine judges me and my driving. Scores me out of 100 at the end of every trip and gives patronising tips on how to improve. The kids are obsessed with my scores too.

Grin
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2023 12:29

These cars would not let you crash in that scenario if everything is switched on. They implement a total stop in the possibility of a crash.

They're not infallible, though. Even if they are working properly, do we really want a vehicle that thinks it's better to just stop in the middle of the road rather than let a human driver with eyes smoothly swerve around it, having checked that the way is clear to do so?!

NormaTheWife · 10/04/2023 10:52

We have everything and I love it. Yes the lane assist can be troubling on narrow country roads which are painted but it's minor overall. I don't have the handbag issue. Collision avoidance, lane keeping, run off road mitigation, cross traffic alert with auto break, blind spot info and surround view camera. It does make me wonder though why we also have auto dial to emergency systems when in an accident but I guess that for all we have others can still impact you.

NormaTheWife · 10/04/2023 10:45

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2023 09:55

A nagging, distracting beep because your handbag isn't wearing a seat belt is one thing; but a car actually taking over the steering wheel and removing the driver's autonomy is very concerning indeed.

Out of interest (and I think I can guess the answer), if the car did force you to crash into a broken-down vehicle or other obstacle, by overruling your autonomy as a driver when you were otherwise taking evasive safety action, would it be your insurance record that was affected?

It seems the worst of both worlds when a car will automatically take the autonomy from the human driver, but that driver will still be held responsible for the car's actions. At least if, in the future, you climb into a next-generation fully driverless car and let it do its stuff whilst you have a nice (planned, completely legal) nap in the back seat, and it crashes, nobody will blame you or hold you accountable for it.

These cars would not let you crash in that scenario if everything is switched on. They implement a total stop in the possibility of a crash.

Flev · 10/04/2023 10:42

Wow, I thought our Skoda was bad but reading some of these it's pretty good. It panics every time we reverse into our tight driveway and bings incessantly when it's cold outside. It does also have emergency brake assist but that's only triggered when we actually did need it and we're braking for ourselves, it just reacted slightly quicker than we did.

Bumblefuzz · 10/04/2023 10:42

I am on my 2nd from new Toyota, and I do love it, but it does have some fairly severe anxiety issues and is very judgemental.

ShiteInNiningArmour · 10/04/2023 10:38

@spidereggs complained to DH that our new car was absolutely useless in the snow. He disagreed, took it out, came back and agreed.

Best car I ever had the snow was a 1971 Morris Minor. It was bloody amazing. At the time I lived at the top of a really steep hill and first signs of snow everything was stuck at the bottom.
The mog became Winter ready with the addition of a breeze block for weight in the boot. It sailed past all the wheel spinning modern cars with all their bells and whistles and aside from the odd 4x4 was the only car that could get up there in winter.
I miss that car sometimes.

RudsyFarmer · 10/04/2023 10:10

For those thinking of getting a Mazda I wouldn’t. Cant stand the thing. It’s bossy but also the windscreen wipers are the most irritating design I’ve ever had. I know it seems like a small thing but it rains a lot in this country!!! The automated setting is absolute shite and moving the stick gives you either slow or fast. Where the fuck is the intermittent setting? Nowhere. Doesn’t exist 👹👹

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2023 10:08

I hate Lane Assist! If I need to deviate slightly over lane markings because of a cyclist for example, the steering wheel vibrates and pulls away! So dangerous. Just have to remember to turn it off EVERY TIME I GET IN THE CAR

What is the actual point of it? I can see how it could potentially bail out an incompetent, tired, drunk or stoned driver; but the obvious elephant in the room is that none of these people should be driving in the first place.

How does it help a competent, alert driver?

Who are these people who are spending their working lives developing useless and/or dangerous 'features' for vehicles that millions of drivers then have to sigh and mentally note to switch off every time they get in the car? It's like the equivalent of a chef routinely including a bonus dog poo 'sausage' in your bangers and mash by default, unless you 'simply' remember to tell the waiting staff that you don't want it (for whatever unfathomable reasons!!)!

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 10/04/2023 10:05

Ours doesn't have most of that, just the rear parking sensor which has a very strange idea of what behind me to beep at and sometimes spends the whole time I'm reversing beeping at imaginary obstacles and a forward sensory which flashes up a giant break sign, which causes me to slam on the break wondering what I possibly missed, as it turns out none of the time it's flashed at me did I actually need to break. All that adrenaline and whiplash for nothing. I do like the reversing camera, but the rest I could happily do without.

BCBird · 10/04/2023 09:59

Mine isn't whizz bang- basic Ford Fiesta but I remember when I used to be with Virgin tge Sat navs had attitude. Sounded thoroughly peed off when I made a mistake. Not good when 'turn around when possible' sounds so dismissive 🤣

RunningInTheFamily · 10/04/2023 09:58

I hate Lane Assist! If I need to deviate slightly over lane markings because of a cyclist for example, the steering wheel vibrates and pulls away! So dangerous. Just have to remember to turn it off EVERY TIME I GET IN THE CAR

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2023 09:55

A nagging, distracting beep because your handbag isn't wearing a seat belt is one thing; but a car actually taking over the steering wheel and removing the driver's autonomy is very concerning indeed.

Out of interest (and I think I can guess the answer), if the car did force you to crash into a broken-down vehicle or other obstacle, by overruling your autonomy as a driver when you were otherwise taking evasive safety action, would it be your insurance record that was affected?

It seems the worst of both worlds when a car will automatically take the autonomy from the human driver, but that driver will still be held responsible for the car's actions. At least if, in the future, you climb into a next-generation fully driverless car and let it do its stuff whilst you have a nice (planned, completely legal) nap in the back seat, and it crashes, nobody will blame you or hold you accountable for it.

Disgustipated · 10/04/2023 08:36

I drive a 22 yr old car. Basically go, stop and lights are the functions.

I moved a friends new car for her the other day as my Insurance allowed it, and she didn’t have it yet. I have no experience at all of newer cars, no idea of all this. So when it tried to steer me back into the lane, despite a broken down lorry, it nearly succeeded in killing me as I totally wasn’t expecting it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2023 08:30

I took it to the garage last week and it turned out the lane assist was on. So every time I swerved a pot hole it pulled me back into it.

I think it also doesn't help that some of these features are designed in Germany, within the proud context of excellent-by-default, well-maintained German roads. The UK's perpetually-neglected, pot-holed road infrastructure is very different indeed.

Incidentally, with all of this amazing driving technology, I want to know why we still have the same old jarring speed bumps that we have to suffer. I remember reading many years ago about an adaptive, reactive new design, whereby people travelling up to the limit would barely register the bump at all, whereas those exceeding the limit would find it very unpleasant, uncomfortable and possibly not good for their car's sustained integrity. Why has this never become reality? Speed bumps are meant to keep the traffic moving at an appropriate speed; not to force queues of congested vehicles to slow to a tenth of a MPH and still hear a horrible scraping sound on some of the nastier ones.

spidereggs · 10/04/2023 08:18

@PolkaDotMankini

I complained to DH that our new car was absolutely useless in the snow. He disagreed, took it out, came back and agreed.

We live up a valley in the middle of nowhere.

Single track roads everywhere.

The car never drove the same after he had been in it.

I took it to the garage last week and it turned out the lane assist was on. So every time I swerved a pot hole it pulled me back into it.

Lane assist is not required for country tracks.

Garage people had a good laugh and turned it off. Thank goodness

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/04/2023 07:58

The one I can’t get rid of is the warning about seatbelts not being out on if you’re put anything non-human on the back seats.

I think the main thing is the assumption that it is super-intelligent and that you, the driver, must be stupid.

Many of these tools are excellent, when you have the autonomy to choose to use/activate them or not to; but it's the constant overruling, on the basis that you yourself, as a human, cannot possibly know anything that the car hasn't been programmed to (try to) establish.

The balance of power always has to be heavily weighted towards the driver; and this is one of the things that concerns me about the prospect of fully driverless cars - when the time comes that humans simply are not allowed/able to override them. I don't care that, on average, tests may have shown them to kill fewer people than human drivers do, if that means that I or my loved ones become one of those statistics, when I could have prevented it, had I been allowed to step in.

emmathedilemma · 09/04/2023 16:47

YANBU I’ve got so many things deactivated on my car because I got sick of its anxiety attacks. The one I can’t get rid of is the warning about seatbelts not being out on if you’re put anything non-human on the back seats. Even the weight of a coat sets it off!

ShiteInNiningArmour · 09/04/2023 16:44

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/04/2023 14:48

Thanks, ShiteInNiningArmour

Yes, mine seems to need to be turned off for every trip; I agree you can get into the habit, but what kind of idiot designs an entirely unnecessary feature into a car that you then have to get into the habit to turn off every time?

It wouldn't be quite so bad if it always either worked or wouldn't, but when it finds that it can stop the engine but then needs me to restart it manually, all of a sudden, that's actually quite a dangerous, useless feature that they've unnecessarily introduced.

It makes me think of a toddler who is well able to get themselves into a fix without any help at all, but then shouts "Muuuuuuuuummmmeeeeee!!!!!" when they can't get themselves out of it! But this feature was planned, designed and signed off all along the line by actual adults?!

Ive never really done enough miles for any of mine to meet the battery conditions so I sympathise totally. Every now and then I'd put the battery on charge and it would kick in next trip if I forgot to turn it off. I've never liked it as a feature. I'm of the old school where starter motors were a thing you occasionally needed to replace and it always bothered me that the car could be continually starting in heavy traffic. Obviously modern starter motors deal with that easily, but it was still something that grated on me a bit.

My new one is full electric, so stop start is a feature I really don't miss.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/04/2023 14:48

Thanks, ShiteInNiningArmour

Yes, mine seems to need to be turned off for every trip; I agree you can get into the habit, but what kind of idiot designs an entirely unnecessary feature into a car that you then have to get into the habit to turn off every time?

It wouldn't be quite so bad if it always either worked or wouldn't, but when it finds that it can stop the engine but then needs me to restart it manually, all of a sudden, that's actually quite a dangerous, useless feature that they've unnecessarily introduced.

It makes me think of a toddler who is well able to get themselves into a fix without any help at all, but then shouts "Muuuuuuuuummmmeeeeee!!!!!" when they can't get themselves out of it! But this feature was planned, designed and signed off all along the line by actual adults?!

ShiteInNiningArmour · 09/04/2023 10:00

When people are saying that you can turn (most of) these off, does that mean that you can deactivate them permanently

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll I’ve had a few cars with the stop start feature and also really dislike it. Unfortunately the cars that have had this for me I’ve been unable to switch them off permanently, though you do get into the habit eventually.
They have all had a prominent ‘stop start’ or ‘eco’ button on the dash that can be pressed.