Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DSD doesn’t want to go to Russia (I don’t blame her)

281 replies

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 16:26

Hello,

Just wanted to see what others think about this situation.

DSD (11) has three passports - A European one from her dad (not British, an EU), an Australian one and a Russian one. My DH’s exW is Russian and is planning a trip to visit family in the Urals during the Summer holidays. DSD’s mum is now in the process of renewing their Russian passports as I guess they have both lapsed.

I suppose it’ll be a bit of a rigmarole to get there as they’ll have to fly via Turkey to get to Moscow. When they do get there I think they’d have to rely on cash (Rubles) as western bank cards won’t work and their British phones will probably have to be switched off in advance because when the Russian phone company detects a UK phone number on their network they are likely to become highly suspicious and track that phone (I work in telecoms, this isn’t unfounded paranoia they can do this so probably will).

Now that DSD is aware of the plan she’s voicing the fact that she’s feeling a bit nervous at the prospect of going. Honestly I don’t blame her. DH is also quite worried and would rather they don’t risk it, but doesn’t want to stop his DD from seeing her GPs and GGM who is 89 (I think). Overall DH wants what’s best for his DD so that would probably mean not going to a hostile country which is currently at odds with the west. He’s just needs to diplomatically approach his exW for the best outcome (no idea how he does that so I’ll leave it to him).

AIBU for being a bit nervous about seeing DSD go off to Russia?

Anyone else experienced this (unlikely but just checking)

Thanks!

OP posts:
amylou8 · 06/04/2023 18:36

Russians are still travelling to Turkey for holidays, we had a whole hotel full of them growling at us there recently (might have been the blue and yellow beach towel 😁). I don't think she'd have any trouble travelling back to Turkey on her Russian passport. That said I wouldn't want to go there at the moment, or anytime in the foreseeable future and no way would I want my child being taken there either.

PigletJohn · 06/04/2023 18:34

Not the same thing, but I remember a lad (born abroad, parent moved when he was an infant, had dual nationality) who visited Turkey to see family and was conscripted into the army.

Bit awkward as he didn't speak Turkish.

As a Turkish national this was correct.

At the time we had a friendly and co-operative government and they let him off.

The current Russian government is not friendly and co-operative.

Hullabalooza · 06/04/2023 18:30

I know of a case in my town, through mutual friends, where a child of about 7 was taken back to Russia by her dad after he picked her up from school and left the country. The mother is obviously distraught, but other than heavily controlled phone calls she hasn’t seen the child for 4 years and there is nothing that can be done as their whereabouts isn’t exactly known and the child has Russian citizenship. The father had it seems always been very reasonable in parenting matters, but rumour has it the wider family in Russia put lots of pressure on and he left. Even if the mum seems reasonable there is a chance she could be influenced.

HelpsHeal · 06/04/2023 18:29

candieland · 06/04/2023 18:17

Wouldn't it make more sense for the husband to just talk to his own ex wife before going to court to sue her into submission..... And I also don't think the child's mother is going to force her to go if she's completely unwilling. Are people assuming the ex wife is completely insane just because she's Russian or something?

Of course it would. My question was in response to suggestions that the courts could block it. A question becuase I don't know if they can of neither child nor parents are British

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:29

Thanks @candieland

Are people assuming the ex wife is completely insane just because she's Russian or something?

Oh sorry, that isn’t the impression I was trying to get across. I think for her it’s the emotion that could be guiding the decision as she wants to see her frail GM and wants her DD to see her GGM one last time. I get it must be a difficult situation for her, and unfair that her ridiculous government have made it so difficult for their citizens to have a normal family life, while making life intolerable for Ukrainians and destroying their country also. It’s awful.

OP posts:
Jibo · 06/04/2023 18:28

I don't blame DSD either but I think she'll be safe. The main risk is that DSD's dad would not be able to get her back if her mum decides to keep her there. DN's best friend at boarding school has a Russian friend with dual Russian/EU nationality who goes back there a lot in the holidays to see her dad in Moscow. Apart from the difficulty of getting there (no direct flights any more) she has been fine.

I don't think there is much to be done, I would suggest that you reassure DSD and keep things amicable with her mother.

Prescottdanni123 · 06/04/2023 18:28

@candieland

Going to court should be a last resort, but if it all ends up boiling down to a choice between going to court or letting the child go to Russia, I know which option I'd be going for.

Zeborah · 06/04/2023 18:26

It’s always best to follow FCDO published advice. This is also what travel insurance companies adhere to.

Prescottdanni123 · 06/04/2023 18:26

I would definitely not allow this to happen. I agree with others suggesting applying to the courts to prevent her being taken there. They may not be able to stop the passport being renewed, but if there is a safeguarding risk to the child, they can confiscate it.

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:22

@Teado that’s my assessment too.

Problem is, and take this for what is as it comes from a biased source (my DH), but DSD’s GPs aren’t the most reasonable or with it people from what I’ve heard. GM is a complete narcissist who thinks the world and everyone in it should bend to her will, while the GD is on a completely different planet to everyone else (so maybe not his fault). If they have any sway over whether this plan goes ahead I’d be concerned 😟

OP posts:
Peachy2005 · 06/04/2023 18:19

If DSD doesn’t want to go, her Dad should support her and that should be the end of it. Her mum can choose to take the risk for herself but your DH should put his foot down. DSD will no doubt feel pressured by her mum to go, so your DH should take any legal steps needed to stop her being taken out of the country, if it comes to that.

candieland · 06/04/2023 18:17

HelpsHeal · 06/04/2023 16:58

FCO isn't relevant if she's not a British citizen and neither are her parents? It wouldn't be the British consular they'd look to for help anyway.

Could the British courts prevent a child who isn't British being taken abroad?

Wouldn't it make more sense for the husband to just talk to his own ex wife before going to court to sue her into submission..... And I also don't think the child's mother is going to force her to go if she's completely unwilling. Are people assuming the ex wife is completely insane just because she's Russian or something?

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:16

@Dahliass I get you, but there is tension, suspicion and paranoia on both sides which can have serious consequences

Even when I was studying Russian and living there in the 00s, I remember MI6 and the FSB keeping a v close eye on each other to a comical degree (spy cameras disguised as rocks, secret spy holes surreptitiously drilled into the walls of the British consulate in Moscow etc.) which we all thought was hilarious. I don’t find it so funny any more….

OP posts:
Teado · 06/04/2023 18:09

I doubt that her great-grandmother would want the child to take a risk, big or small, on her account. It’s not something she needs on her conscience at the age of 90-odd if something untoward happened to your DSD.

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:08

@Nimbostratus100 I understand, I’m so sorry. That must be terrible for the person in question, their friends and loved ones including you.

wishing you well xx

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 18:06

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:04

@Nimbostratus100

My relatives on UK passports came back, but their travelling companion on a Russian passport still hasn't.

Shoot, that is worrying. I’m so sorry. Can you share any more details about the whys and wherefores? Don’t worry if not, you don’t have if it’s delicate / traumatic etc. thanks for your insight.

sorry, I dont really want to say any more than that about what happened- we dont think they are "safe and well" though. This was an adult, not a child.

YoDood · 06/04/2023 18:06

Also could she even get travel insurance?

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:04

@Nimbostratus100

My relatives on UK passports came back, but their travelling companion on a Russian passport still hasn't.

Shoot, that is worrying. I’m so sorry. Can you share any more details about the whys and wherefores? Don’t worry if not, you don’t have if it’s delicate / traumatic etc. thanks for your insight.

OP posts:
StressedToTheMaxxx · 06/04/2023 18:03

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 16:29

It is a frightening situation, and I would be worried too. My experience of family members visiting Russia was before the war, but it was difficult even then, and there was not a good outcome. My relatives on UK passports came back, but their travelling companion on a Russian passport still hasn't.

Do you mean that the person that hasn't returned has been held in Russia against their will?

Dahliass · 06/04/2023 18:03

HelpsHeal · 06/04/2023 16:49

I might be inclined to report this as a safeguarding concern. I'm not sure what they could do but I know schools get involved when it's suspected travel is being arranged for FGM or forced marriage. Not the same but still a significant risk to the child.

There's no war within Russia , DSD holds russian nationality and can travel on her Russian passport. The risk is towards foreigners not russian citizens. They are females so no risk of being conscripted. I think assess the situation is DSD in anyway close to relatives is there a possibility she may never see them again ?

endofthelinefinally · 06/04/2023 18:02

I have got 3 friends/neighbours who are Russian citizens with dual nationality. None of them will set foot in Russia. One of the younger ones has met up with their parents in Turkey once in the last 2 years. It is hard for all of them, but they consider it to be too dangerous to visit.

Viviennemary · 06/04/2023 17:57

Not surprised I wouldnt go anywhere near Russia at the present time. Better safe than sorry.

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 17:52

Thanks for your responses everyone - my feelings align with what almost everyone else is expressing so it just confirms that my fears are not an over reaction. Same for her dad.

So for people asking if her GPs can come to the UK or if they can all meet up in a neutral country like Dubai or Turkey, they can and they do! Her GPs came over to the UK on a tourist visa not that long ago and for a chunk of time (not sure how they swung it, but they did) and have no problem moving around and through borders etc. (going via Turkey etc) In fact, I was just chatting to DSD a few minutes ago and there’s even a plan to meet up in Dubai before the summer holidays anyway so it’s not even about going to see them as they can do this safely and so it’s low risk. I think it’s that DSD’s mum really wants to see her GM (DSD’s GGM) as there’s the feeling she’s not long for this world.

So in my estimation, this trip is a complete folly.

OP posts:
Wtfishappeningnow · 06/04/2023 17:50

Not a good idea to go at all

kittensinthekitchen · 06/04/2023 17:45

Nope, no chance in hell would I be allowing her to go if I was your husband.