Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DSD doesn’t want to go to Russia (I don’t blame her)

281 replies

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 16:26

Hello,

Just wanted to see what others think about this situation.

DSD (11) has three passports - A European one from her dad (not British, an EU), an Australian one and a Russian one. My DH’s exW is Russian and is planning a trip to visit family in the Urals during the Summer holidays. DSD’s mum is now in the process of renewing their Russian passports as I guess they have both lapsed.

I suppose it’ll be a bit of a rigmarole to get there as they’ll have to fly via Turkey to get to Moscow. When they do get there I think they’d have to rely on cash (Rubles) as western bank cards won’t work and their British phones will probably have to be switched off in advance because when the Russian phone company detects a UK phone number on their network they are likely to become highly suspicious and track that phone (I work in telecoms, this isn’t unfounded paranoia they can do this so probably will).

Now that DSD is aware of the plan she’s voicing the fact that she’s feeling a bit nervous at the prospect of going. Honestly I don’t blame her. DH is also quite worried and would rather they don’t risk it, but doesn’t want to stop his DD from seeing her GPs and GGM who is 89 (I think). Overall DH wants what’s best for his DD so that would probably mean not going to a hostile country which is currently at odds with the west. He’s just needs to diplomatically approach his exW for the best outcome (no idea how he does that so I’ll leave it to him).

AIBU for being a bit nervous about seeing DSD go off to Russia?

Anyone else experienced this (unlikely but just checking)

Thanks!

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 06/04/2023 19:36

Like fuck would o be letting any child of mine go to Russia at the moment.

WilsonMilson · 06/04/2023 19:35

My instinct is to say hell no, absolutely no way. The UK govt website also suggests avoiding all travel to Russia at present. I think it’s your first priority to protect the safety of your dsd, not to think about her extended family’s feelings.

ittakes2 · 06/04/2023 19:32

The Australian government recommends not travelling to Russia and she has an Australian passport so might be interested in this:
Russia Travel Advice & Safety | Smartraveller

WakeMeUpInspring · 06/04/2023 19:30

Crazy idea and the mum is mad to take her. I'd be going to court to stop my child going.

JudgeRudy · 06/04/2023 19:29

Your SD is 11, plenty old enough to say she doesn't want to go. She may be rightly nervous about the political climate, but she might also have no wish to spend time with family she barely knows and will struggle to communicate with.
Are you able to accommodate her for the period her mum will be away? If it's not convenient atm I think you need to adjust your schedules. This will probably not go down well with her mum. This could really upset the status quo and your SD could even end up living with you. Be prepared.

BeautifulWar · 06/04/2023 19:28

Blimey, I'd be worried - relations with Russia are so fragile right now, it feels like anything could change at any moment.

pizzaHeart · 06/04/2023 19:26

Teado · 06/04/2023 18:09

I doubt that her great-grandmother would want the child to take a risk, big or small, on her account. It’s not something she needs on her conscience at the age of 90-odd if something untoward happened to your DSD.

I bet they don’t see the issue at all - they think differently. Older generation generally believes what is said on state TV. I wouldn’t trust their judgement and their intentions, not because they are bad people, because they are brainwashed.

gogohmm · 06/04/2023 19:21

Look at the advice for both Australian and the other nationality passport she holds, if both say do not travel then that should be sufficient for the courts to consider issuing a travel ban for her. If relatives want to see them, meeting up in turkey would be a good compromise. All that said I suspect that it would be pretty safe where you say they are going, just hide those other passports

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 19:20

@Duckingella

What about if when your DSD steps on that plane it's the last time you see her for a long time?;they might get into the country but what if they can't leave?

Pretty shit to be honest.

OP posts:
ToWhitToWhoo · 06/04/2023 19:17

YANBU at all to be nervous about it. Can't the trip be postponed until Russia is no longer at war (if ever)? Travel to some parts of Russia is strongly discouraged at the moment; and I would be nervous about a child going there at all, right now.

Duckingella · 06/04/2023 19:09

I can appreciate your DSD's mum wanting to see family but in the current political climate it's not exactly safe.

What about if when your DSD steps on that plane it's the last time you see her for a long time?;they might get into the country but what if they can't leave?

GraysPapaya · 06/04/2023 19:08

I’m never one for conspiracy theories or hysterics, but I would be very concerned. Putin has pretty much kidnapped thousands of kids who thought they were going on a camp. Never to return to Ukraine.
You’ve had some great advice of this thread. I just wanted to offer some support!

Dachshund40 · 06/04/2023 19:07

I would be very concerned that the mum had plans to stay in Russia with your step daughter as well as all the other concerns voiced in this thread

Hhjfue · 06/04/2023 19:04

@SometimesMaybe do you know of anyone who has recently traveled there or even spoken to Iranian who do indeed go back and visit. In reality this situation is unlikely to change any time soon. Families will continue to travel and it is safe enough. I wouldn't recommend it if you are male or written on the subject of Russian security as I have but for regular people - mostly no one cares

NumberTheory · 06/04/2023 19:02

YourMagicSwirlingShip · 06/04/2023 17:40

I'm a dual national (not Russian though) and thought you could only get consular assistance if you travelled to one of your countries on the other passport, if that makes sense. So eg if you have a Polish and a UK passport, and you enter Poland on your Polish passport, the UK won't intervene if you get thrown in jail (but they would if you'd travelled on your UK passport.)

So if the worst happens and she couldn't leave, her other nationality's govt would only intervene if she had travelled in on that passport, not if she'd travelled on her Russian one.

Nightmare situation for you. Personally I'd be against letting her go.

Countries do not know what passport you enter another country on, so they cannot give or withhold assistance on that basis.

Most treaties and diplomatic norms do not place obligations on a host country to accommodate consular enquiries and requests in relation to someone who is a citizen of the host country. And right now, such norms could not be relied upon between Russia and a european government anyway.

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:59

@Panicmode1 how amazing! And you were there at a crazy time!! I was there 2009-2010.

I lived on Prospekt Tolbukhina (пр. Толбухина) above a Perekrestok (the supermarket).

I also worked with a really nice guy who studied Russian at Exeter sometime in the 90s, maybe slightly before you though.

OP posts:
SometimesMaybe · 06/04/2023 18:56

There is absolutely no way my DC would be going to Russia at the moment. For every story that of people that say “it’s fine” “I’ve been” - what about dual citizens in Iran who are locked up for show/trumped up charges? In a dictatorship It only takes someone with power to take offense or be pissed off with your step-daughter or her wider family and she’s in jail/prevented from leaving the country. Insanity to even consider it at the moment (especially as you say they have the opportunity to meet up in dubai).

JTro · 06/04/2023 18:54

As a dual citizen (UK and Russian) I can't see what is all this fuss about. My family (including kids, all with dual citizenship) were in Russia (Moscow and St Petersburg) this Christmas. Yes, the travel was long and expensive, but there were not a single problem with safety or the trip back to UK. Not a single one. Everyone on both border sides (actually triple sides, as we travelled through Turkey) were very nice. If her mum doesn't have russian bank account, she can exchange dollars and euros in the banks (not british pound though), also she can buy russian sim-card very easily at the airport and talk to youh DH by Whatsapp. Lots of British/Australian/USA expats are still living there without any problems, just check youtube for their videos. So please, calm down, your DSD will be absolutely fine and hopefully will remember her GGM

Museya15 · 06/04/2023 18:52

We used to go when it was USSR, it was hell to get passed airports etc with KGB all over the place but once through there it was fine apart from queuing for miles to get food on a daily basis.

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 18:52

@SuperDrooper I think it’s that she has indefinite leave to remain, definitely one of the two…

OP posts:
Panicmode1 · 06/04/2023 18:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I was Yaroslavl' too! (94-95) tho was at Uni of Exeter. How funny..

GingerScallop · 06/04/2023 18:47

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/04/2023 16:46

If I were your DH i would apply to the court to stop ex taking her to Russia and also to stop her renewing the Russian passport. I wouldn’t want my Dd to have any connection to Russia under any circumstances.

Sorry but child has genetic links to Russia. You cant bleach that out of her and can't brush a dictatorship into people of such a decent. Its Putin and his cronies that's are lunatics not all Russians.
OP you can advise your DH but ultimately this is something for him and his ex to sort out, putting the child's best interests at the heart of. Hopefully they will make an informed decision.

Hhjfue · 06/04/2023 18:43

Same as others who have traveled to Russia this year, honestly itnis a fair but its totally safe. Lots of Russians I know are going back for short trips, my parents will be going for their third this year. The reality is it's fine. Yes, it is conducting a war and yes relations with the West are bas and yes travel is annoying but it is safe. Thats not to minimize what they are doing in Ukraine or the nastiness of the regime and yes I am an expert on this. Would I recommend it, maybe not. Would I stop it, again no. I would not be going back but thats due to the nature of my work and public profile rather than Russia itself. However, it's fine for ordinary Russians.

SuperDrooper · 06/04/2023 18:42

Sorry

my phone is being weird!

SuperDrooper · 06/04/2023 18:42

What is DSD's UK immigration status? Hopefully indefinite leave to remain or EU settled status? If not, she won't be allowed to board the plane to come back to the UK.

If she used to rely on her EU passport to enter the UK she can no longer do this since Brexit.