Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

DSD doesn’t want to go to Russia (I don’t blame her)

281 replies

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 16:26

Hello,

Just wanted to see what others think about this situation.

DSD (11) has three passports - A European one from her dad (not British, an EU), an Australian one and a Russian one. My DH’s exW is Russian and is planning a trip to visit family in the Urals during the Summer holidays. DSD’s mum is now in the process of renewing their Russian passports as I guess they have both lapsed.

I suppose it’ll be a bit of a rigmarole to get there as they’ll have to fly via Turkey to get to Moscow. When they do get there I think they’d have to rely on cash (Rubles) as western bank cards won’t work and their British phones will probably have to be switched off in advance because when the Russian phone company detects a UK phone number on their network they are likely to become highly suspicious and track that phone (I work in telecoms, this isn’t unfounded paranoia they can do this so probably will).

Now that DSD is aware of the plan she’s voicing the fact that she’s feeling a bit nervous at the prospect of going. Honestly I don’t blame her. DH is also quite worried and would rather they don’t risk it, but doesn’t want to stop his DD from seeing her GPs and GGM who is 89 (I think). Overall DH wants what’s best for his DD so that would probably mean not going to a hostile country which is currently at odds with the west. He’s just needs to diplomatically approach his exW for the best outcome (no idea how he does that so I’ll leave it to him).

AIBU for being a bit nervous about seeing DSD go off to Russia?

Anyone else experienced this (unlikely but just checking)

Thanks!

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/04/2023 21:03

GingerScallop · 06/04/2023 18:47

Sorry but child has genetic links to Russia. You cant bleach that out of her and can't brush a dictatorship into people of such a decent. Its Putin and his cronies that's are lunatics not all Russians.
OP you can advise your DH but ultimately this is something for him and his ex to sort out, putting the child's best interests at the heart of. Hopefully they will make an informed decision.

The dictatorship and the war are happening now though. I’m not holding against her something that has happened, I’m saying it would be dangerous for her to go there, especially with Russian nationality. As a later pp says, it might mean she doesn’t get consular assistance from her dad’s country if anything happens.

I also wouldn’t want my Dd to be in a position where other countries viewed or treated her as Russian.

SophieIsHereToday · 06/04/2023 21:00

Nimbostratus100 · 06/04/2023 16:29

It is a frightening situation, and I would be worried too. My experience of family members visiting Russia was before the war, but it was difficult even then, and there was not a good outcome. My relatives on UK passports came back, but their travelling companion on a Russian passport still hasn't.

What happened to them? Were they arrested?

TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/04/2023 20:38

I'd echo what @SummerBump23 said on page 1. We're a mixed household and I am on a lot of very active discussion groups with Russian (and Russian-speaking) mums in London, so inevitably there's a lot of discussion about this. Broadly women and children are travelling in and out without issue and in significant numbers, of course taking into account the longer journey via Turkey etc. No incidents at all. No men travelling for the obvious reason.

That doesn't mean

that it's morally a good idea to do so
that things won't change for the worse overnight,

but with family there and the war basically kicking off as soon as covid restrictions went away, you can see why families carefully try to balance risks as best they can.

CheshireCat1 · 06/04/2023 20:35

We’ve been over to Russia on holidays and had some fantastic times but at the present time and in the foreseeable future we won’t be going again. I’d advise against it, I think there’s too many risks attached.

FlyRobinFly · 06/04/2023 20:32

Givemes · 06/04/2023 20:20

Doesn't she have a mother and a farther to “think for her safety”???
Really think it is not your business OP.

God forbid OP cares about her husband's child who she undoubtedly has a bond with! She's not gone in all guns blazing ffs, she's seeking advice on an internet forum presumably to discuss with her husband who seems in 2 minds, that's what a marriage is.

JTro · 06/04/2023 20:31

FlyRobinFly · 06/04/2023 20:14

I think this is actually a personal child arrangements dispute rather than a political one. I think we need an idea of the mother's perspective on Russia personally, is it just a matter of wanting to see her relatives and then she'll be keen to get her DD back to her life in the UK, or is she a risk of missing it and wanting to go back? Russians are not one homogenous group, for every Russian that wants the USSR back and worships Putin, there's another that has left the country out of disgrace for it and would rather die than go back, and then everything in between.

DSD isn't at risk of being detained by Putin the moment she crosses the border or used as a political pawn. I think those with sway in Russia have more on their to-do-lists than kidnapping some random Russian/Australian/Another Country nationality child who grew up in the UK.

Whether I'd be willing to let her go or not all depends of my perception of her mother. Her mother is a Russian citizen, I'm sure she knows what she's doing and DSD will be perfectly safe with her. That is of course, providing the mother does genuinely just want to go back for a visit and isn't blagging you.

Exactly! Instead of thinking how horrible and dangerous trip to Russia will be (it will not!), I would focus on her mum position - would she come back (have a job/house/partner/other chikdren here) or she is planning to stay here (no more ties with UK)

Givemes · 06/04/2023 20:21

Why would they detain a half Russian as political pawn anyway.. 😂

Givemes · 06/04/2023 20:20

Doesn't she have a mother and a farther to “think for her safety”???
Really think it is not your business OP.

Newnamenewname109870 · 06/04/2023 20:20

I’m qurie surprised about exW wanting to take this risk. Is she not worried at all? She needs to go by herself. How old is the child?

FlyRobinFly · 06/04/2023 20:16

Also if DD doesn't want to go anyway then it is all a mute point, if her mum is trying to force her DH needs to put his foot down and speak up for his child, Russia or not.

FlyRobinFly · 06/04/2023 20:14

I think this is actually a personal child arrangements dispute rather than a political one. I think we need an idea of the mother's perspective on Russia personally, is it just a matter of wanting to see her relatives and then she'll be keen to get her DD back to her life in the UK, or is she a risk of missing it and wanting to go back? Russians are not one homogenous group, for every Russian that wants the USSR back and worships Putin, there's another that has left the country out of disgrace for it and would rather die than go back, and then everything in between.

DSD isn't at risk of being detained by Putin the moment she crosses the border or used as a political pawn. I think those with sway in Russia have more on their to-do-lists than kidnapping some random Russian/Australian/Another Country nationality child who grew up in the UK.

Whether I'd be willing to let her go or not all depends of my perception of her mother. Her mother is a Russian citizen, I'm sure she knows what she's doing and DSD will be perfectly safe with her. That is of course, providing the mother does genuinely just want to go back for a visit and isn't blagging you.

Justalittlebitduckling · 06/04/2023 20:11

They are holding US and British nationals on spurious charges to make prisoner swaps.
No f’king way.

JudgeRudy · 06/04/2023 20:05

Yes, apologies, I see that now (I'd not read the whole thread). A war is good enough reason. This trip sounds more about your SDs mum saying 'goodbye' to her grandma. She can do that without SD. Looks like they'll be other opportunities to see the family on neutral ground. As I said, be prepared to take your step daughter in...particularly if mum gets her return 'delayed'....😕

JTro · 06/04/2023 20:05

Just some British/ Australians/Americans citizens living in Russia currently and doing their videos from "GULAG". Just try and watch them, instead of mainstream media.
Wandering Emma https://www.youtube.com/@WanderingEmma/videos
Travelling with Russell https://www.youtube.com/@TravellingwithRussell/videos
Expat Americanhttps://www.youtube.com/@expatamerican3234
and lots of others.....

All of them are well and doing good. Please stop scaremongering! your DSD will be absollutely fine, if that was the purpose of your original post, of course.

Before you continue to YouTube

https://www.youtube.com/@WanderingEmma/videos

Stravaig · 06/04/2023 20:01

I've heard anecdotally of various children who used to live primarily with one parent in Russia who now live primarily with their other parent in various European countries. So some parents have evidently prioritised getting their child out of Russia even thought it meant sacrificing living with them.

If this trip does go ahead, please ensure all of DSD's devices and social media are scrubbed clean. Just in case she is detained and checked. Just because most people are fine, doesn't mean everyone will be. If DSD speaks fluent Russian and can pass as Russian that's probably a plus ... but then her fluency in English and her Dad's language might seem suspicious. Who knows which way paranoia could lean.

Why risk it?

War is unpredictable, and things can dramatically worsen from one moment to the next. It may look like a calculated risk, probably okay for DSD ... and then a bomb strays into Russia, or a nuclear facility is breached, and all hell breaks loose.

There is also the ethical dilemma about whether it's okay to help anyone in Russia approximate a normal life while Russia is the blatant aggressor. Your DSD may be feeling shaky about more than safety.

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 20:00

Thanks @AgrathaChristie - yes I think they do do they a lot. Maybe for the mum know it’s not the same as seeing her in person, which is what she really wants

OP posts:
WestwardHo1 · 06/04/2023 20:00

I would be extremely concerned. Russia is a deeply fucked up country. Terrible things are happening to people who do or say the wrong things. There's a piece on the BBC today about a young girl who lived with her father, and she drew an anti war picture at school. Her father is now in prison and she's been sent to live with her estranged mother who she hasn't seen for seven years.

Can you DP do anything to stop this crazy plan?

AgrathaChristie · 06/04/2023 19:58

As a grandparent I wouldn’t want any of my dgc put at risk by visiting me.
Is it possible to use FaceTime, WhatsApp, Skype so the dgp can see her ? I really wouldn’t take the risk of sending her to Russia.

cloudgo · 06/04/2023 19:54

At most get the child to insist she doesn't want to go.

One risk that may seem more salient to the Mum is also the hostile UK border policy. DSD is not British and has no British parents. Though the children who have lived in the UK all their lives, but are turned away upon returning from holiday are usually not white and don't have Eurocentric passports – but she doesn't have to know that.

cloudgo · 06/04/2023 19:53

WakeMeUpInspring · 06/04/2023 19:30

Crazy idea and the mum is mad to take her. I'd be going to court to stop my child going.

I don't think she's mad, and I don't think anyone has to go to court just yet.

Life is probably completely normal in many parts of Russia. OP's child is also probably safe as a dual national, unless they suddenly decide to cause a diplomatic incident, but children are rarely targeted in those. I would still not let my child go, but I wouldn't be going all OTT straight away, just persuade calmly.

It's not the same at all, but I'm from a very safe East Asian country, and my parents freak out every time they see all the chaos and violence and crime and stuff in the UK (or Western Europe) on the news. They think I'm mental to bring my child here in times like these. All my family friends back home ask about my safety in the UK as well.

Likewise, people from my country regularly travel to China (I'm not from there) yet my British DP is convinced the Chinese government will kidnap and torture him or something if he goes. I think he's flattering himself.

Blueblell · 06/04/2023 19:51

If your DH wants to be diplomatic then she should give practical reasons as to why it is not a good idea at the moment. Talk to dsd’s mother about postponing until next year - things could be better then (or worse of course)

I would raise things such as the difficulty with communication whilst she is away ect. One thing I would consider is air transport. Russia is having trouble servicing planes and it is likely flying is not as safe as it normally would be.

I would also remind that dual nationals are not always able to get consular assistance when in a country fir which they hold citizenship. This is a time where there is an increased chance of actually needing consular assistance.

JTro · 06/04/2023 19:51

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 19:50

Thanks @JudgeRudy

but she might also have no wish to spend time with family she barely knows and will struggle to communicate with.

Actually, she’s a really confident Russian speaker and she’s super tight with her ‘Baba’ and ‘Dede’ (her GM and GD). Even close with her GGM she hasn’t seen as much. And she has cousins she gets on really well with. Before the war she went to Russia most years. She’d be cool with it, were it not for the bloody war!

Actually it's "Deda", not "Dede"

OperationUnicorn · 06/04/2023 19:50

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 16:47

Oh sorry everyone - yes we are UK based. London specifically.

We've got Russian friends who needed to see relatives back home. They had major concerns about getting back into the UK, so I don't think your concerns are unreasonable. Their compromise was meeting the relatives in Turkey, but given the age you've mentioned maybe the grandparents are unable to fly?

CatherineEarnshawsGhost · 06/04/2023 19:50

Thanks @JudgeRudy

but she might also have no wish to spend time with family she barely knows and will struggle to communicate with.

Actually, she’s a really confident Russian speaker and she’s super tight with her ‘Baba’ and ‘Dede’ (her GM and GD). Even close with her GGM she hasn’t seen as much. And she has cousins she gets on really well with. Before the war she went to Russia most years. She’d be cool with it, were it not for the bloody war!

OP posts:
Amispringy · 06/04/2023 19:50

Teado · 06/04/2023 18:09

I doubt that her great-grandmother would want the child to take a risk, big or small, on her account. It’s not something she needs on her conscience at the age of 90-odd if something untoward happened to your DSD.

I'm not sure they the average Russian would see an issue

They're the victims. It's all Russophobia