Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this doctor a bit rude to DH?

120 replies

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 15:51

Hi all,

When I was pregnant with DC2. My husband and I had a discussion and agreed that we would both get sterilised due to only wanting two children, finances, mental health etc we agreed it would be the best thing for our family. At first husband said he'd get the snip but I said I'd like to be sterilised as I wanted to take responsibility for my own reproductive health and knew I didn't want anymore kids but it would be great him getting the snip too because then we're double protected and it reduces the risk of an ectopic pregnancy.

So basically I got my tubes tied after my second baby during my c section - all good and husband said he'll book in for the snip. I completely forgot by that point but was like yeah okay.

He went to the doctors today and said it was more like an interrogation and the doctor were questioning him asking if I tricked him into it or was forcing him into it and if he knew he was essentially giving up his manhood?

I appreciate doctors need to make sure the patient is making the decision themselves etc but when I said I'd like to be sterilised there was no questioning like this and no one suggested I'd be giving up my womanhood.

It just seemed a bit odd and kinda rude to essentially blame me for it and say he was giving up his manhood.

Idk is this normal when a man asks for the snip?

OP posts:
TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:53

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 06/04/2023 18:50

I carried and gave birth to our three DC so DH agreed to have a vasectomy. It never crossed my mind to get sterilised as well. I can understand why your DH wants it but seems like you needn't have bothered, unless you're planning on leaving him at some point.

I just think everyone should be responsible for their reproductive health.

I'm allergic to condoms and have never found a contraceptive method agree with me and after hearing the horror stories about the coil I knew I didn't want anymore children so decided it was the best option for me.

OP posts:
ANiceBigCupOfTea · 06/04/2023 18:53

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:46

No one mentioned my husband when I asked about being sterilised.

At my booking appointment they just asked if I was being abused and I said no and that was the end of that.

Agree doctors have a duty of care but like said the wording felt odd but like said happy to be told I was unreasonable to think that.

The midwife who did my booking appointment was very specific with me, and gave me lots of things to do on with a list of behaviours even though I assured her I was fine. She was very senior so I guess she had seen some shit.
In terms of discussing you- sorry I missed that bit, and I agree that's unreasonable

Rosula · 06/04/2023 18:52

ilovesooty · 06/04/2023 16:07

If everyone insisted on both parties being sterilised on the NHS goodness knows how much money would be spent.

It's perfectly sensible. Suppose, God forbid, something happened to OP and her husband went into a relationship with someone else. Is he not allowed to take steps to ensure that that won't result in children?

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 06/04/2023 18:50

I carried and gave birth to our three DC so DH agreed to have a vasectomy. It never crossed my mind to get sterilised as well. I can understand why your DH wants it but seems like you needn't have bothered, unless you're planning on leaving him at some point.

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:46

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 06/04/2023 18:44

I dont think they were rude.
Its their duty of care as much as it is a midwifes duty of care during your booking in appointment to educate you about domestic violence and what it might look like.

No one mentioned my husband when I asked about being sterilised.

At my booking appointment they just asked if I was being abused and I said no and that was the end of that.

Agree doctors have a duty of care but like said the wording felt odd but like said happy to be told I was unreasonable to think that.

OP posts:
ANiceBigCupOfTea · 06/04/2023 18:44

I dont think they were rude.
Its their duty of care as much as it is a midwifes duty of care during your booking in appointment to educate you about domestic violence and what it might look like.

mauvish · 06/04/2023 18:44

Were you in the consultation, OP? Did you hear the doctor use those very words? Or is this what your husband has reported?

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:41

@Qazwsxefv

I'm sorry that was a bit snippy what I mean is when I decided to get sterilised I was told the risks of it and thought about the future and decided to go ahead with it. Why's that different for DH?

My hypothetical future was just as important as his.

This is something he wants to do, no one is forcing him to like I said I was a bit worried about an ectopic pregnancy but with the non latex condoms and statistics explained I feel a better about it and I'm not too fussed on that front.

This is something DH wants to do. He feels it's a benefit to him. He doesn't have to worry about future disabled children apart from the one (possibly two, hopefully not) we have and it takes a weight off his mind and that's his choice.

OP posts:
Datafan55 · 06/04/2023 18:41

Agree the doctor sounded both rude and misogynistic. They were free to point you to private care if necessary, but i like your being careful attitude.

OfCourseImNameChanging · 06/04/2023 18:40

Theunamedcat · 06/04/2023 18:28

Friend of mine has just had a complete hysterectomy discharged with no pain relief just take paracetamol it's not cutting it and of course Dr's are closed now until Tuesday glorious isn't it

This would never happen to a man after a vasectomy! I hope your friend can get some help.

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:32

Qazwsxefv · 06/04/2023 18:29

@TheJudgeandJury

This is why it is so complex and needs discussion. if you and DH split up (which hopefully never happens) and he starts a relationship with a new partner he may feel differently than he does now about having more children, the new partner may wish to use a coil, or he and his new partner may wish to explore pre implantation genetic diagnosis to ensure potential children are not affected. There are so many hypotheticals here.

It's DHs choice like it was mine to get sterilised.

I like how my DH can go off and meet someone else to have a baby but not me Grin it's absolutely ridiculous.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 06/04/2023 18:32

Did he really say "You're essentially giving up your manhood"? In those terms?

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:31

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 18:22

Okay say we spilt up then and DH goes on to father more children who have the gene that causes disability - is that not going to cost the NHS more?

Him fathering any children regardless of disability is going to cost the NHS a hell of a lot more than the cost of a sterilisation.

As would the cost of any future terminations or lifelong contraception for a new partner.

Ignore the people giving you grief for this.

You're right it's just annoying.

I see threads on here all the time usually when an op is pregnant and the man doesn't want anything to do with the baby they always say well if he didn't want a baby he shouldn't have had sex or taken responsibility and have a vasectomy.

My DH has made the decision to take his own reproductive health into his hands as he doesn't want to run the risk of passing the faulty gene onto anyone else (this is the main reason) and there's people saying he shouldn't be able to.

Should men not take responsibility for their sexual health? Is that what people are saying here? It's weird.

OP posts:
Qazwsxefv · 06/04/2023 18:29

@TheJudgeandJury

This is why it is so complex and needs discussion. if you and DH split up (which hopefully never happens) and he starts a relationship with a new partner he may feel differently than he does now about having more children, the new partner may wish to use a coil, or he and his new partner may wish to explore pre implantation genetic diagnosis to ensure potential children are not affected. There are so many hypotheticals here.

Theunamedcat · 06/04/2023 18:28

OfCourseImNameChanging · 06/04/2023 17:55

It must be so nice being a man and having the medical establishment care enough about your pain (or potential pain!) that they'll strongly counsel in this way. Women's pain, of course, doesn't matter at all.

Friend of mine has just had a complete hysterectomy discharged with no pain relief just take paracetamol it's not cutting it and of course Dr's are closed now until Tuesday glorious isn't it

GoodChat · 06/04/2023 18:22

Okay say we spilt up then and DH goes on to father more children who have the gene that causes disability - is that not going to cost the NHS more?

Him fathering any children regardless of disability is going to cost the NHS a hell of a lot more than the cost of a sterilisation.

As would the cost of any future terminations or lifelong contraception for a new partner.

Ignore the people giving you grief for this.

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:21

FlowersAndBonnets · 06/04/2023 18:13

It’s a totally unnecessary surgery. If you want it you should be paying for it yourselves.

Okay say we spilt up then and DH goes on to father more children who have the gene that causes disability - is that not going to cost the NHS more?

It's funded on the NHS, it's DHs body there's absolutely no reason he shouldn't have the procedure if that's what he wants.

It's his body and his choice.

OP posts:
TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:17

Are people on this thread just missing or ignoring the fact DH has a gene that had a 50% chance of causing disabilities in the children he has?

OP posts:
TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 18:15

Wishimaywishimight · 06/04/2023 18:11

@ThTheJudgeandJury Perhaps the doctor spoke of possible side / after effects and, even if your DH really wants to have the procedure, it might have made him have some doubts?

He doesn't seem to have any doubts and is waiting for the referral.

Again, this is not my decision it is DHs decision so if he came to me and said I don't want the snip then fine, he knows I'm not overly bothered. I was a bit apprehensive about an ectopic pregnancy but I knew that was a possible side effect from my procedure.

I would never make someone do something they don't want to do.

OP posts:
Qazwsxefv · 06/04/2023 18:14

@OfCourseImNameChanging

covered that a bit more in my second post

fully agree with you that the medical establishment does not take women’s pain seriously enough

that doesn’t change the fact that vasectomy isn’t really bringing any health benefits to the man but can have some health negatives.

Here the Op is already sterilised. The risk of unwanted fatherhood is small. Doing an operation on a healthy person (the man) to benefit the op by reducing her risk of ectopic pregnancy is always going to be more complex ethically than doing an operation on a person that will directly medically benefit them and so needs robust discussion.

FlowersAndBonnets · 06/04/2023 18:13

It’s a totally unnecessary surgery. If you want it you should be paying for it yourselves.

Wishimaywishimight · 06/04/2023 18:11

@ThTheJudgeandJury Perhaps the doctor spoke of possible side / after effects and, even if your DH really wants to have the procedure, it might have made him have some doubts?

Qazwsxefv · 06/04/2023 18:07

I’ve had a few men come and see me asking for a vasectomy. Quite often the consultation starts like this:

“the missus says I’ve gotta get the snip as she doesn’t want to get knocked up again and I don’t like faffing with condoms when we’re having a shag”

So I’ve got to

  1. check there not actually being forced into this by their wife as they have just stated (I know it’s just how men start generally start conversations with doctors - seriously it’s a trope - but I’ve got to actually check)
  2. check they know it’s irreversible on the nhs and that even though they say they won’t change their mind somehow get through to them that quite a few men do indeed change their minds
  3. check that they know there is a not inconsiderable chance of persistent permanent pain from a procedure that carries no medical benefit for them (female sterilisation has medical risks but also medical benefits for the women herself)
  4. check they are aware that some men do indeed suffer mental health consequences post vasectomy based around them no longer potentially being able to father children (I think it’s about 1%)
  5. check they are eligible on the nhs (which does involve asking about the current contraception used in the current relationship)

all in 10 minutes and using language that the patient understands.

If the consultation starts with the patient talking about “the missus” and “shagging” I’m not going to get very far with language like “coercion” and “irreversible post operative complications” and “emotional distress at the lack of the potential father role”. I hope wouldn’t ever say “giving up your manhood” as that just sounds crass but that might be what some people would take from the discussion around the mental health consequences. It would be a very different consultation in tone from one where the man comes in and says

“my wife and I don’t want any more children. We have discussed things and looked at multiple contraceptive options and feel that me getting a vasectomy is the best thing”

but I would still be covering the same ground. Seems to me the GP in this situation employed the wrong tone/set of words but got the right result. When you only have 10 minutes you have to make a guess of the patients education level and preferred level of formality in speech in the opening sentences and sometimes you get it wrong

OfCourseImNameChanging · 06/04/2023 17:55

Qazwsxefv · 06/04/2023 17:25

3-6% men seek vasectomy reversal for reasons like starting a new relationship or if a child dies. Persistent Post vasectomy pain is a real risk - around 2% and can severely affect men’s lives.

Therefore men should be strongly counselled both about how they would feel if they started a new relationship or if something happened to one of their existing children and that they have thought through the emotional consequences of vasectomy. They also need to be warned it may cause debilitating pain. Also as men don’t tend to decide to get a vasectomy without discussing with their partner it should be standard to check that they are not being coerced. None of these things are particularly easy to ask a patient without causing offence but need to be done in a way that the patient actually understands the risks and consequences - sounds like your partners GP didn’t manage to do that…maybe tried to take a more casual “blokey” approach to build rapport but missed the mark.

good news is he has been referred tho so hopefully it was just the GP trying to be thorough in checking consent but not getting the right tone.

It must be so nice being a man and having the medical establishment care enough about your pain (or potential pain!) that they'll strongly counsel in this way. Women's pain, of course, doesn't matter at all.

TheJudgeandJury · 06/04/2023 17:54

MrsDoylesDoily · 06/04/2023 17:51

I'll ask him what was said exactly. I know it was a older more traditional doctor.

You should probably have done that before starting the thread.

I was only saying that to appease the masses but I did ask if he was paraphrasing and he said no that's what the GP said to him.

I don't have any reason to doubt DH as I've had bad experiences with GPs before.

However the doctor has made the referral and that's all that matters really just thought his manner was a bit rude.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread