Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel embarrassed that we can’t afford to buy a property?

313 replies

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 12:51

Since me and DH have been together buying a property has never really been in our interest. We had money at the start but we wasn’t bothered as rent was fairly cheap back then and our priority really was just having fun and going on holidays.

Luckily our current property is HA and it is dirt cheap but we are now leaving and going into private rent. Our rent is now going to be 1k I never imagined spending that much on rent but it’s a beautiful home and it gives our kids the space they need to blossom.

FIL was gobsmacked about how much rent were going to be paying and said how it’s dead money. It’s obviously got into DH head and now he thinks we’re “failures”. Everyone in his family has brought their properties we are the only ones that haven’t.

AIBU to think we’re not failures? He said his family are probably laughing at us.

I don’t know how we would ever be able to buy a place in our area. Maybe if we moved up north!

OP posts:
CC4712 · 06/04/2023 15:45

Well you both chose travel, fun and to have continued to have more children over investing in property- even a 1 bed flat to start you off would have got you on the property ladder.

It was your choice though. I wouldn't call that a failure- just different planning/thinking to what many others might do. I'm not surprised your FIL has concerns- but you are adults and chose this path.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 06/04/2023 15:44

and said how it’s dead money.

I hate that inane phrase. Paying for shelter is not some waste of money, like buying food isn't a waste just because you don't still have the food once you've eaten it. Both are good uses of money and not wasted.

Lifeisnotfair4 · 06/04/2023 15:42

Is UC going to cover some of the rent? If it is then it’s different than if OP has to actually earn the difference in the rent increase. Non of our opinions are relevant until we know all the facts which OP does not wish to share so it seems as OP has not answered whether UC will be covering part of the rent and how much.

pilates · 06/04/2023 15:38

I wouldn’t say you’re failures just made some bad decisions.

Trinity65 · 06/04/2023 15:34

stairgates · 06/04/2023 15:05

I have only read your answers so forgive me if this has already been said but have you joined the facebook groups for people wanting to exchange? I think you can exchange HA properties as well as council but I may be wrong.

No you aren't wrong

I done a swap (9 Years this June 1st), We were both the same Housing Association though but not sure that matters as a friend swapped, some years ago now, from London to Suffolk without Issue.
In my case I downsized but wanted to be where I am now as it was and is so much more convinient here. I also used to rent privately not far from here and all my friends are here too. I came from a 3 bedroom maisonette to 2 bedroom house.
OP its a shame, as others have said, you cannot hold out a little longer in your safe, secure HA Home but you do you and best of Luck.

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 15:33

Yes agreed, this trope that everybody on the continent rents is no sense. Yes renting is generally more affordable, but no, in most countries it is not more common. If you compare the UK against the EU 27 we have the 5th highest proportion of renters out of 28 countries. I think people get confused because in some of those countries it's more common to rent until later (late 30s/ early 40s) to save up more then self-build, for example. But overall we don't have a particularly high rate of home ownership comparatively, it's a myth. It's valued by people in most countries because it's secure and stable, an inheritance for your children, and because you can then afford retirement when the mortgage is paid off.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 06/04/2023 15:32

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 15:22

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

Millions of families will never be able to afford a 4 bedroom house.

Surely there's a middle ground somewhere? What's wrong with a three bedroomed house?

Meandfour · 06/04/2023 15:32

You’ve made some bad choices but just ignore others opinions. There’s nothing you can really do about it now so you just need to grin and bear it and accept this rent is likely to be the norm for now.

Tidsleytiddy · 06/04/2023 15:30

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 06/04/2023 15:23

Well, in your own words, you prioritised "travel and having fun" over buying a house. I don't know why you think that makes you a failure. I presume you enjoyed travelling and having fun, after all.

But your choices now don't really make much sense to me. You had an HA property and chose to make yourselves overcrowded by having another baby - and now instead of staying put and saving hard for a mortgage, you're choosing to move out and make things 10x harder by spending 1k a month on rent?!

Personally, there's no way I would give up an HA property - you'll never get another and you may now find yourself stuck in private rental for life as rents are only going to keep increasing.

Yep

Dixiechickonhols · 06/04/2023 15:29

People don’t usually buy a 4 bed as a first home. Start small and work up. Obviously it’s trickier as you have children but you don’t need a 4 bed. I’d prioritise security over space.

purpledalmation · 06/04/2023 15:29

When my parents got married and decided as soon as possible to buy they scrimped and saved to get on the property ladder, and we lived off potatoes (seems like it!) but now they are retired and rent and mortgage free. They can enjoy their retirement, but we also enjoyed a reasonable standard of living once the initial period was over and wages caught up with the mortgage.

Thistooshallpsss · 06/04/2023 15:29

Please don’t feel a failure everyone has to make decisions depending on so many factors and no one has a crystal ball. My grandfather scrimped to save for a mortgage in the 1930s the depression hit and he ended up posting the keys through the door of the building society and never became a home owner for the rest of his life.

NewLifter · 06/04/2023 15:29

I don't think anyone would say you are 'failures'. You sound like a happy family to me and are doing well in life? Sounds like it to me!

You have made your choices and you need to have confidence that they were the right choices for you and 'own' those decisions. Who cares what others think?

We did the opposite and saved hard and had a very frugal lifestyle to save to buy our house (we married and bought our first home when we were 21). That isn't what you wanted, neither of us were right or wrong, we just made different choices.

Renting does suck though, the lack of stability and cost are why we decided we didn't want to go down that road. Not to rub it in, but our mortgage is £430 a month, we genuinely couldn't afford to pay 1k a month.

theresnolimits · 06/04/2023 15:28

Can I just add that, as someone with Dutch family, the old ,’on the continent everyone rents’ is very outdated now. Because laws were so tight on rentals, they became almost impossible to get. Some people were on the housing list for 10-20 years.

There was a huge move to home ownership in the 80s and 90s and all my friends, cousins, nieces and nephews own. There are tax implications around paying off your mortgage but home ownership is common. In fact it’s around 65-70% - almost the same as it is here. France is almost identical, Spain is higher at about 75%. Germany is lower at about 50%.

All this suggests that most people feel home ownership is a priority - for good reason?

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 15:27

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

But why would that be the only option? Very few people would buy a 4 bedroom house for their first property. There must be houses for sale larger than the one you currently have that would be more realistically affordable to save a deposit for.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/04/2023 15:27

FIL hasn’t called you failures just expressed view £12,000 a year from net is a huge chunk to pay in rent. Which it is. Plus instability of private rental.
You obviously made decisions you did not to buy when you could. It was your choice. You presumably could have bought then but chose not to.
If I was FIL I’d think you were making a bad decision leaving an affordable HA house. Yes it’s small but it’s affordable and secure.

purplepencilcase · 06/04/2023 15:27

We live in a very strange world where worth is frequently judged by property ownership.

I know plenty of people who own massive properties but are miserable, unhappy or just horrible people.

Personally it means very little to me as long as you have a secure and happy home, that's all that matters isn't it?

Queenofscones · 06/04/2023 15:27

Tell me you're paying as much money as possible into your pensions, OP. Because how are you going to pay rent when you retire? Or are you expecting to inherit from your DH's family?

AlltheFs · 06/04/2023 15:25

How do you imagine your retirement will be? Will you be able to afford the rent then?

People that rent are absolutely not failures, it’s an equally valid way to live, but it does smack a little of poor planning and prioritising if you don’t have a retirement plan. We all make different choices though. I bought straight out of uni as couldn’t stand the thought of not having my own place-so I had no money or holidays. It’s all a choice.

I wouldn’t want to be at the mercy of private rental market on a pension though.

AlwaysGinPlease · 06/04/2023 15:23

Dguu6u · 06/04/2023 15:20

Yes, I think you should feel embarrassed that you chose to throw your money away on travel and 'fun', and now you're out of savings and can't afford a secure house for your kids. That wasn't very sensible.

Uncalled for.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 06/04/2023 15:23

Well, in your own words, you prioritised "travel and having fun" over buying a house. I don't know why you think that makes you a failure. I presume you enjoyed travelling and having fun, after all.

But your choices now don't really make much sense to me. You had an HA property and chose to make yourselves overcrowded by having another baby - and now instead of staying put and saving hard for a mortgage, you're choosing to move out and make things 10x harder by spending 1k a month on rent?!

Personally, there's no way I would give up an HA property - you'll never get another and you may now find yourself stuck in private rental for life as rents are only going to keep increasing.

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 15:22

Dguu6u · 06/04/2023 15:20

Yes, I think you should feel embarrassed that you chose to throw your money away on travel and 'fun', and now you're out of savings and can't afford a secure house for your kids. That wasn't very sensible.

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

OP posts:
DragonflyLady · 06/04/2023 15:20

Most definitely not failures. I’ve owned and am now in a HA home. I’ll not be able to buy again. This is the reality for very many.

Applesinmyhouse · 06/04/2023 15:20

Used to rent a one bed flat for £1100. And that was on the low side for the area (greater London). I’ve had one shitty landlord that was a complete nightmare but our last landlord was an absolute G. His ‘day’ job was a mortgage broker & he helped us buy our house.

Dguu6u · 06/04/2023 15:20

Yes, I think you should feel embarrassed that you chose to throw your money away on travel and 'fun', and now you're out of savings and can't afford a secure house for your kids. That wasn't very sensible.