Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel embarrassed that we can’t afford to buy a property?

313 replies

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 12:51

Since me and DH have been together buying a property has never really been in our interest. We had money at the start but we wasn’t bothered as rent was fairly cheap back then and our priority really was just having fun and going on holidays.

Luckily our current property is HA and it is dirt cheap but we are now leaving and going into private rent. Our rent is now going to be 1k I never imagined spending that much on rent but it’s a beautiful home and it gives our kids the space they need to blossom.

FIL was gobsmacked about how much rent were going to be paying and said how it’s dead money. It’s obviously got into DH head and now he thinks we’re “failures”. Everyone in his family has brought their properties we are the only ones that haven’t.

AIBU to think we’re not failures? He said his family are probably laughing at us.

I don’t know how we would ever be able to buy a place in our area. Maybe if we moved up north!

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 06/04/2023 16:37

There’s paying for shelter and renting a beautiful big home for £££. I’d definitely think dead money in the latter case.
Personally I’d opt to stay in cheaper and secure rental and save difference and look at buying a 2 or 3 bed.
Renting a big 4 bed house is a luxury choice not an essential.
Your choice though.

Whammyyammy · 06/04/2023 16:36

We had very cheap rent for years (£150pm military housing) and also enjoyed a fun lifestyle of multiple holidays etc so see where the op is coming from .

But we ownerd a flat (with mortgage)which we rented out for many years, for fear of being in a situation like this

oneleggedspider · 06/04/2023 16:29

I think everyone's being a bit harsh. No one meets their partner for the first time and immediately pools their savings to buy a property together. Presumably you were quite young, so having £30k in savings at a young age obviously shows the ability to save and be sensible with money. You enjoyed some holidays etc, its not a crime! But I would try and stick to a savings plan now, even if you do move into private rent, and look at buying somewhere in the next 5 years if you can, even if it means relocating. I wouldn't look at renting as a long term option unless you have a solid pension plan and/ or are likely to inherit a lot from said FIL and your parents 😉

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 06/04/2023 16:28

I just worry you're making this decision for the short term benefits of more space, without thinking about the long term problems of higher rent, future rent increases and having much less security.

From your story, it seems a bit of a pattern. I'd have a really really big think about this decision, as you may not get back into HA again.

I definitely wouldn't look down on somebody for renting. Paying for shelter isn't "dead money", just like paying for food isn't. But I would wonder why on earth somebody would choose to move from HA to private renting esp at the moment.

Thisgirlcan21 · 06/04/2023 16:27

I wouldn’t leave the ha property. I would save the money you are going to spend on the extra rent towards a mortgage. Rental properties are often sold by landlords without much notice. I have owned and rented. There is pros and cons to both options. There does seem to be people that look down on those who rent even privately. It’s no one else’s business but yours.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/04/2023 16:27

Have you priced business storage? HA rent and business storage (which will be a business expense) may be lots cheaper than £1000 a month rent.

Kailee · 06/04/2023 16:22

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 15:22

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

Reading your updates has been very strange. You appear to have a complete lack of forward planning, or maybe you're being disingenuous. No one buys a 4 bed house as their first home, but you could have used the £30k as a deposit for a 2/3 bed property and built up equity from there. Instead you had 3 DC in a tiny flat. What did you think was going to happen? I genuinely wonder what your plan was, or did you just assume everything would just work out somehow?

I really hope your business takes off and provides you with the kind of lifestyle you want.

Wintersgirl · 06/04/2023 16:20

You're not a failure OP, you provided a roof over your childrens head since they were born, you love tham and they're well fed. Can you stick it at out the HA house for say six months? And then save like mad during that time, if you move to the private rent you'll even be furher away from home ownership...

MysteryBelle · 06/04/2023 16:20

First of all, if his family are laughing at you and your dh, then they do not deserve to be trusted with your financial situation. From now on, neither of you should give them any personal information. It’s not their business whether you rent or buy or anything else. When they demand to know details, simply don’t give them.

Now, it is true that buying a house has advantages because you’re not ‘throwing your money away’ as you would renting, there will be nothing to show for it later when you rent. So it is important that you keep that in mind. It will be even harder to save for a deposit for a house when you’re paying so much in rent now.

However, you love the new place, so enjoy that for a while. But try to save what you can and in time buy a small home, then keep saving until you can get a house that you really love. That’s my advice but do what you think is best for your family. Take the good part of the advice from other people and ignore the disdain or lectures!

ChilliHeelerFanClub · 06/04/2023 16:20

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 15:22

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

I mean, personally I would be moving from the area if it meant your money would be enough for a deposit. More security for your kids, a greater chance at increasing your investment. But if you don’t want to move and are happy renting, then it doesn’t matter what anyone else (including your FIL) thinks.

sjxoxo · 06/04/2023 16:18

You aren’t failures! Buying isn’t the be all and end all. Equally it wasn’t good financial planning to spend on holidays when your rent was cheap- most people I know who have bought without parental or inheritance help have forgone extras for a long time (years) to be able to buy somewhere. Could you relocate? I would seriously consider it if you aren’t happy renting. x

Floralnomad · 06/04/2023 16:10

For us buying a house was an absolute must so we prioritised that early on and have been mortgage free for many years . I think you are mad to move from a HA cheap house to renting on the open market , I would have stayed put and done as much saving as poss to try and buy a 3 bed . It’s nice for all the kids to have their own bedrooms but a 3 bed and sharing is imo better than a rented 4 bed .

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 06/04/2023 16:09

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 15:50

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

So have you looked at how much more you'd need to top up the £30k, to get to the amount you need as a deposit for, say, a 3 bedroom with significantly more space? How much more would you need to save, and how long would that take if you stay in the HA property?

Or, what desposits would be needed for shared ownership properties in the area?

The OP has spent the £30k on holidays and treats it seems

theemmadilemma · 06/04/2023 16:09

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 15:00

@Clementine2377 that’s very kind of you to say, thank you.

when I met DH we had about 30K in savings all together. I already had a son and lived at my mums. I didn’t think I’d ever have any more kids to be honest. We just travelled and had fun never thought about buying a house together.

I know we will buy a house eventually but it won’t be for another 5+ years unless the market crashes!

You chose your prority and it was travel and freedom rather than property and security.

No reason to be embarrassed, but it it is true that had you bought when you could you'd be in a very different position than you are now.

YankeeDad · 06/04/2023 16:09

@Foreveraskingquestions having money or owning a house does not mean people are great people, and conversely, not having money and not owning a house certainly does not mean people are rubbish. In fact, people who have money seem more likely to be jerks than people who do not have money. I say this as somebody who has enough money, and tries not to be a jerk.

So you are being entirely reasonable to think you are "not failures."

However, that does not help you to get housing security or to cover expenses. Having gone through a period of prioritising enjoyable life experiences at the expense of saving, which is not necessarily a bad idea since nobody knows how much life we have got left, you might now decide it is worth going through a period of saving more and spending less, in order to achieve more economic security for your children.

Do you have any credit card or other debt, especially high interest rate debt? If so then the first priority for use of savings should be to pay that off, as otherwise it will grow.

pizzayumm · 06/04/2023 16:08

You’re not failures at all, however the reason everyone wants to buy is mortgage is generally lower than rent, plus no rent (or mortgage) to pay when retired.

If your FIL is so shocked I think he should have emphasised the advantages of buying to his son much earlier on. From when I was age 22 my Dad was telling me to buy. I bought at 25. I didn’t appreciate the reasons why then but I do now I’m older.

I think a lot of it is how you’re brought up so if it’s not been drilled into you both by parents to buy that’s really not your fault.

ellie09 · 06/04/2023 16:06

I made the same bad decisions.

My mum came into money when I was 18. She decided to buy a couple of homes and rent one out to me for cheaper.

That young, and living with my boyfriend at the time, we were the only ones out of our friends who had a house. We went out still, we hosted house parties, we had 2/3 holidays a year. We had fun.

Then the baby came when I was 23, then my marriage fell apart.. And it was only then I stepped back and thought what a mess I had made with my priorities.

While my friends were still living at home, they were saving like mad, and now all my friends bar 1 now owns their own home.

I do blame my mum at times for literally handing me the keys at 18 instead of talking to me about saving, or leaving it until maybe 21 to give me the keys. However, I know she meant well.

Easterfunbun · 06/04/2023 16:06

You’re mad for moving even with limited space. A landlord can just uproot you whenever they see fit and that’s got to be worse for your MH? The lack of security will take its toll in the end. Don’t do it. Stay in the HA house.

Sammyandtheboocas · 06/04/2023 16:04

I think it's a Mumsnet thing to demand that people should live in abject poverty and misery for 10 years + just so they can say they own their own home.

Many couples and families now just cannot afford the deposit for a property. People that scold others for not living in a box room in parents eating porridge for every meal to save , often paid a 5% or even 0% deposit for their first property, or had the deposit gifted to them.

Be happy with your choices, life is for living not for wasting in poverty and misery in your youngest and most exciting period of your life.

If you never own a home, who gives a toss?

Wintersgirl · 06/04/2023 15:58

workinprog · 06/04/2023 13:37

Your father in law probably bought a property when it was much cheaper and doesn't realise how much mortgages are for new buyers these days. Obviously it's still cheaper than renting in most cases but not much cheaper at all.

Exactly this, my parents (late seventies) seem to think you can buy a detached cottage with 3 acres of land in the South Downs National park for less than £450,000...bonkers

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 15:50

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

So have you looked at how much more you'd need to top up the £30k, to get to the amount you need as a deposit for, say, a 3 bedroom with significantly more space? How much more would you need to save, and how long would that take if you stay in the HA property?

Or, what desposits would be needed for shared ownership properties in the area?

IhearyouClemFandango · 06/04/2023 15:47

GasPanic · 06/04/2023 14:27

Well you decided to prioritise holidays over housing for your family.

You decided to have 3 kids, and bringing up three kids and housing them is expensive.

A lot of people would question whether you have made good life choices.

But ultimately I wouldn't care who thought I was a failure or success. It's only what I think of myself that counts.

This tbh. Your choices have a massive part to play here.

QueefQueen80s · 06/04/2023 15:47

Most people I know have had deposits from parents, it wouldn't have been possible otherwise. you are not a failure.

NoGoodUsernamee · 06/04/2023 15:46

It really doesn’t matter. People who own their houses certainly do look down on renters IMO but if you’re proving a warm, clean home with enough space for you all it really doesn’t matter. You say you’re going to be in a position to buy at some point anyway, some people never will be… they’re certainly not failures. Don’t waste enough thought on it, life is short.

TwoManyKids · 06/04/2023 15:46

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 15:00

@Clementine2377 that’s very kind of you to say, thank you.

when I met DH we had about 30K in savings all together. I already had a son and lived at my mums. I didn’t think I’d ever have any more kids to be honest. We just travelled and had fun never thought about buying a house together.

I know we will buy a house eventually but it won’t be for another 5+ years unless the market crashes!

Well done on saving that much as a single parent! To me that is something yo be very proud of!