Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel embarrassed that we can’t afford to buy a property?

313 replies

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 12:51

Since me and DH have been together buying a property has never really been in our interest. We had money at the start but we wasn’t bothered as rent was fairly cheap back then and our priority really was just having fun and going on holidays.

Luckily our current property is HA and it is dirt cheap but we are now leaving and going into private rent. Our rent is now going to be 1k I never imagined spending that much on rent but it’s a beautiful home and it gives our kids the space they need to blossom.

FIL was gobsmacked about how much rent were going to be paying and said how it’s dead money. It’s obviously got into DH head and now he thinks we’re “failures”. Everyone in his family has brought their properties we are the only ones that haven’t.

AIBU to think we’re not failures? He said his family are probably laughing at us.

I don’t know how we would ever be able to buy a place in our area. Maybe if we moved up north!

OP posts:
kittensinthekitchen · 06/04/2023 17:49

Can't vote as your title question doesn't tie with the question at the end of your OP

begoneday · 06/04/2023 17:47

You are most definitely not failures. House ownership is not as obsessed over in other countries like it is here , and I say that as a home owner. I’m also sure family members are not laughing at you but rather crying at their mortgage increase.

skyeisthelimit · 06/04/2023 17:47

You're not a failure, you just made different life choices to FIL. As you say yourself, you chose to travel and have fun. As I keep telling DD, you can't spend it twice.

You had different priorities to FIL, so he should respect that, ( but at the same time, you can't complain about your life now in rented accommodation. )

I don't think anyone should judge others as not everyone wants to buy a house and lots of people rent for different reasons.

NaturalBae · 06/04/2023 17:44

*3-way swap

weddingdaydancet · 06/04/2023 17:44

I’m wondering if you’re live for now people. The spending your savings on fun stuff, moving to a four bed rental, giving up a secure HA tenancy, having 3 kids in a small two bed new build, these are all ultimately decisions you are both making.

there are so many options to help to buy now, to get families on the property ladder, and as painful as your living situation is now I think folks just want to make sure you’ve both examined all those options and don’t, as said, come to regret this decision very quickly if you see your rent sky rocket.

NaturalBae · 06/04/2023 17:43

You’d be mad to give up a HA Property to pay rent within the private sector!
Social housing is like gold dust and you wouldn’t be allocated another HA or Council property in this day and age.

Stay put and save up a for a deposit. It would surely be cheaper to pay for storage for your business stock.

I can’t believe that private rents are only just recently a shock to you. I would advise you both to brush up on your financial literacy/planning. Read up on how mortgages work/the process, Solicitor’s fees, Stamp Duty, insurance, etc. Also consider Shared Ownership schemes via your HA or other HAs.

Have you looked into doing a 3-way sway via mutual exchange?
Or considered moving out of the area for more options?

Itakecreaminmycoffee · 06/04/2023 17:42

Struggling to understand why you think you get a 3-4 bed home up north for less than £1k per month anyway? Unless it was a shithole in the arse end of nowhere??

My dd lives in south Manchester and is paying that for a tiny 1 bed flat. Up north is not the utopia of cheap housing that some southerners seem to think.

Blondeshavemorefun · 06/04/2023 17:27

Failure no but mad yes

To give up a ha properly is insane imo

You may be crowded at the moment with baby in your room (many will say why have another child is was in a small 2 bed new build)

But assume in a year or so you will be moved into a 3 bed house and space /life will be better

Renting privately is a huge risk as ll can decide to sell (happened to my friend) and she has struggled to find a new house in their budget near school

You would be better to stay in ha and save

Tho you say you have savings but uc won't pay if have savings over £16k

TeaForMeandThee · 06/04/2023 17:26

I went to uni and then took a gap year in my early 20s, I met my husband at uni. Once we got to around mid 20s we said right time to save a deposit and sacrificed holidays abroad for 5 years in order to save (also saved for our wedding too). We bought our house aged 31. We prioritised buying a house when many people around us were prioritising holidays, we had a really good deposit saved and will have the house paid off by about aged 45 with overpaying. You were living in the now, we were living in the future and forward planning, if you'd have done the same you'd own your own home too. I'm sure I'd have been jealous of all the lovely things you were doing whilst we were scrimping. You aren't a failure, you clearly just aren't very switched on when it comes to finances and planning for the future.

CallintheClownies · 06/04/2023 17:18

Maybe start thinking about 20-30 years ahead.
The state pension is low enough now, but in future it may be lower.

£12K pa rent couldn't be paid out of the current state pension, if that is someone's only income.

Do you contribute to a private or work pension?

Many elderly people in rented houses struggle hugely trying to cover current rent on an income of around £9K if they have no occupational pensions to top that up.

You still have time to start saving for a deposit and really need to think further ahead.

This isn't about being embarrassed, it's about being asked to move from a private rental in your 60s, 70s or 80s, and not being able to afford anything (unless you qualified for council housing.)

sybil40 · 06/04/2023 17:17

We bought our house about 3 years after we were married but because of low income and starting a family it was bloody hard going. It took a long time 20+ yrs before we felt good about it.

So please do not feel a failure. You are still in the marriage, that must be scored as a win. Just look around Mumsnet at some of the sorry tales.
Hold your head high OP, Good Luck and a Happy Easter to you and the family.

PapadamPreach · 06/04/2023 17:16

There is so much judgement on this thread. Who prioritises buying a house together in the early days of a relationship?

I don’t think anyone is saying that.

Surely you can see that a single mum of one going on to have two more children when not in a position to sufficiently house them because she opted to spend money on “holidays and fun stuff” isn’t making great decisions?

misssunshine4040 · 06/04/2023 17:12

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 14:10

It’s not a decision we made lightly we have stayed here as long as we possibly can and I feel stupid for giving it up. But at what stage do you say enough is enough?

Tiny small box garden, small bedrooms baby DS is still sharing with us. No room to put anything we’re all so unhappy.

FIL bought his property in his 30s for 30K and sold it for 200k few years ago 😩

In all honesty I would still stay.
This is a hugely unstable time for renting privately.
You should be creative and think long term. Your new landlord could sell or die and their family sell.
You can have kids sharing, you can have your room in the living room. You have a garden albeit small.
It's a massive bonus and better than a lot have.

FeetupTvon · 06/04/2023 17:10

Keep the HA property.
You'd be mad to give that up.

User1438423 · 06/04/2023 17:08

No I don't judge people who rent, but I do think you are mad to give up the HA, have you looked up family assist mortgages? You don't need a deposit with one of those. Buckinghamshire building society do them I think. FIL can be your guarantor using his property as an asset if he feels so strongly.

Oigetoffmylawn · 06/04/2023 17:07

Not failures, you've just prioritised different things. No shame or failure in that but you can't lament those choices now!

ConstanceOcean · 06/04/2023 17:05

I don’t think you are failures but I think you were silly not to buy if you’ve been in a position to in the past.
Its common sense that renting is basically throwing your money away whilst buying us building up assets that you can sell if you ever need to.

However, what’s done is done.
There is no point in dwelling on what could have been.

I completely get how desperate you are to get out of your current situation.

Have you look into first time buyers mortgages?

They are on certain new builds and only require a 5% deposit.

If you are going to be spending £1k on rent anyway I’d use that money and put it away for a deposit instead.
It may mean staying in your current home for a few more months but at least you’ll see an end to your situation.

weddingdaydancet · 06/04/2023 17:03

Op, you’re saying some unusual stuff. Like you can’t afford a house for five years until the market crashes, or that you just can’t afford a 4 bed. That’s a big leap from a 2 bed council house, few could do that, a small three bed would be the next step up

and in a property owned by a company doesn’t mean that company won’t divest, but I’d say you’re possibly more secure, the down side is they will implement full market increases annually, no discussion. On average rents are 11 percent year on year. And it’s likely going to get worse. Can you afford this increase each year? So next year it’s 1100. The year after it’s 1250? The year after 1400?

people are just urging you to be very cautious here. As you’re going from a secure but inappropriate property, to an expensive and highly insecure appropriate one.

it’s another life decision you stand a high risk of regretting.

Whippetlovely · 06/04/2023 17:01

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 06/04/2023 15:23

Well, in your own words, you prioritised "travel and having fun" over buying a house. I don't know why you think that makes you a failure. I presume you enjoyed travelling and having fun, after all.

But your choices now don't really make much sense to me. You had an HA property and chose to make yourselves overcrowded by having another baby - and now instead of staying put and saving hard for a mortgage, you're choosing to move out and make things 10x harder by spending 1k a month on rent?!

Personally, there's no way I would give up an HA property - you'll never get another and you may now find yourself stuck in private rental for life as rents are only going to keep increasing.

Agree completely. Irresponsible to have kids and overcrowd when you don’t have the room for them. Living in HA with less than half the cost of private rent you should have saved thousands so no sympathy.

Mirabai · 06/04/2023 17:01

Sammyandtheboocas · 06/04/2023 16:04

I think it's a Mumsnet thing to demand that people should live in abject poverty and misery for 10 years + just so they can say they own their own home.

Many couples and families now just cannot afford the deposit for a property. People that scold others for not living in a box room in parents eating porridge for every meal to save , often paid a 5% or even 0% deposit for their first property, or had the deposit gifted to them.

Be happy with your choices, life is for living not for wasting in poverty and misery in your youngest and most exciting period of your life.

If you never own a home, who gives a toss?

But if you end up in poverty and misery - having to pay rent until you die? Surely life is for living when you’re older too?

It’s ok as long as you have 12k+ a year to blow on rent for the rest of your life.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 06/04/2023 17:00

workinprog · 06/04/2023 13:37

Your father in law probably bought a property when it was much cheaper and doesn't realise how much mortgages are for new buyers these days. Obviously it's still cheaper than renting in most cases but not much cheaper at all.

Did you even read her post or just jump to the default defense?

They lived in a cheaper HA property which would have allowed them save more but they choose to enjoy and live now rather than save.

I would have made different decisions as you can enjoy while also using the opportunity to save but it’s their choice so I wouldn’t call them failures, they just have to own their decision and live with it.

Popatop · 06/04/2023 16:52

Honestly now is not the time to leave a HA rental. The prices for rentals are going up monthly let alone 6 monthly and yearly. You will very very quickly notice your rents increasing or they will ask you to leave so they can charge a higher rent from the next tenants. Do NOT do it. You’ll regret it

KitKatKathy · 06/04/2023 16:49

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 15:22

Who said we are out of savings? We don’t have enough to buy a 4 bedroom house in our area. We still have savings!

Because savings an UC don't mix. If you are receiving UC, you can't have much in the way of savings and certainly not the 30,000 you originally entered the relationship with

crazyaboutcats · 06/04/2023 16:41

You are abosultly not failures for not buying no one is. But, and this is purely my opinion and possibly that of your in-laws is that you have or have had a lack of priority

Dguu6u · 06/04/2023 16:39

AlwaysGinPlease · 06/04/2023 15:23

Uncalled for.

It was the question OP asked so I gave the answer. Literally called for.