Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel embarrassed that we can’t afford to buy a property?

313 replies

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 12:51

Since me and DH have been together buying a property has never really been in our interest. We had money at the start but we wasn’t bothered as rent was fairly cheap back then and our priority really was just having fun and going on holidays.

Luckily our current property is HA and it is dirt cheap but we are now leaving and going into private rent. Our rent is now going to be 1k I never imagined spending that much on rent but it’s a beautiful home and it gives our kids the space they need to blossom.

FIL was gobsmacked about how much rent were going to be paying and said how it’s dead money. It’s obviously got into DH head and now he thinks we’re “failures”. Everyone in his family has brought their properties we are the only ones that haven’t.

AIBU to think we’re not failures? He said his family are probably laughing at us.

I don’t know how we would ever be able to buy a place in our area. Maybe if we moved up north!

OP posts:
BitchBrigade · 06/04/2023 19:30

I have moved 17 times over the last 20 years OP. Two of those were through my absolutely own choice - the first one when I moved city and the most recent one to a larger house with a bit more guaranteed stability) and the rest were as follows, in no particular order:

  • Landlords selling ( one died and their kids took over and sold for their inheritance money, others retired, one pulled the rug after giving it all the big talk of not looking to sell for 5 years at LEAST and others just plain sold up).
  • Flat mates moving out times x 3
  • Rent raised well beyond my means at the time x 2
  • Landlord deciding to renovate/move back in x 1
  • Roof caving in with water pissing in all winter and landlord doing fuck all x 1
  • Chronic mould issue that made us all acutely unwell/hospitalised and landlord doing fuck all x 1
  • Divorce when DH decided to leave me (couldn't afford house on own) x 1

I would have murdered for an HA house or the opportunity to pay cheap as shit rent so I could save and have ANY kind of stability. I have never paid less than £625 and that was for a shit bedsit. Even now with our landlady being incredibly sweet and promising years long rental, I have been burnt before.

There is ZERO stability in private rentals and they are at least 50 x overpriced for what they are, What were you thinking????

weddingdaydancet · 06/04/2023 19:26

Annon1234 · 06/04/2023 18:56

I feel like there’s so many judgey people on here. I for one can say 10 years ago when I met my husband, I wasn’t thinking about saving for a house and where my child that didn’t exist yet were going to live. We were the same we had the holidays, weekends away and nights out. Now we are early 30s and saving for a home. Wether people buy a house in their 20s or 40s they’ve still bought a home, no better or no worse. And shock horror if someone never choice to buy a house, that’s fine too because it’s their choice. Renting is not Failing, it’s reality for a lot of people.

But you’re not the op. Who already had a child and they had 30 grand in savings. Which went on holidays and fun. Now they’ve have another two kids, are over crowded and going to give up a secure low cost tenancy to a private rental 4 bed house, a private rental today that costs a grand and they will be lucky if their rent is less than 1400 in two years. That’s if the company who owns them doesn’t decide to divest.

the rental market has shrunk 30 percent. With landlords selling up. Many folks are finding with the increases and shortages they are being priced out. Housing association properties are like hens teeth. Folks waiting years or in bed and breakfast hostel type accommodation, or forced to move out the region.

so it’s not about what you did In your child free twenties. It’s about the op and her circumstances now.

CallintheClownies · 06/04/2023 19:20

I keep reading your first post and more things come to mind.

If the house you are going to rent now will be £1K and will be for 5 people, (3-beds?) you must surely live somewhere cheap already!

In my area, you can't even rent a 1-bed flat for £1K!

A 3-bed house would be closer to £2K a month in the grottiest part of the town.

You mention moving north, but you must be in a cheap area already.

CallintheClownies · 06/04/2023 19:16

We have savings but not enough for a big deposit.

So how much would you need and how to get there?

Starting a business presumably means you are investing in it and giving up more secure work (or not?)

How can you risk the savings you have on a business that is not guaranteed to succeed?

What is Plan B?

retrosteamband · 06/04/2023 19:14

I mean to a certain extent could be some money mismanagement. It depends on location/the size of the property I suppose but many people would be shocked at someone paying £1k in rent as that could easily match their mortgage payments. I pay similar in rent and everyone is shocked. I’m young & live in a trendy city centre apartment with all amenities. For me, the high cost is worth it for the independence. Whereas others might be more comfortable being elsewhere and saving up. I’m not able to save much with my bills.

CallintheClownies · 06/04/2023 19:13

@Foreveraskingquestions Maybe think ahead?

My very elderly aunt has £12Kpa as her sole income (state pension and half her late H's occupational pension.)

Her council tax is £2K pa (even as a single occupant), her utilities are around £3Kpa at the moment. That's not leaving much for everything else, including major stuff like boiler repairs, new washing machine if it goes bust, but at least she has some savings that will be enough as a top-up.

You are running a business, so presumably you can do the maths?

What are you putting away in pensions for your old age?

All this living hand to mouth, buying non essentials may be fine in your 30s, but you will come a cropper in later life unless you are banking (literally) on an inheritance from parents.

Abyss23 · 06/04/2023 19:09

I agree @HazyDragon . With the terrible state of the private rental market in the UK I think priority number one for everyone should be trying to obtain a secure roof over their heads. Not everyone will be able to buy but those who could really should in most circumstances.

CallintheClownies · 06/04/2023 19:07

There is a family like the OP living in the same street as my parents. They rent the house. They have 1 child. They have holidays overseas (think Disney), the house looks like ToysRUs (when they existed), the buy everything under the sun for their kids and say they can't afford to buy a home.

They say they can't save the deposit.

Given the cheapness of homes in the area, they must be spending the deposit they'd need every year on non-essentials.

HazyDragon · 06/04/2023 19:04

I think that as you already had a child when you met your DH, secure housing should have been your no1 priority.

But you are in the lucky position of having a secure tenancy and I think you would be crazy to give that up.

I grew up in an overcrowded 2 bed council flat, I know how awful it is, but staying put and saving would definitely be the sensible thing to do.

Newmumatlast · 06/04/2023 19:01

skyfalldown · 06/04/2023 14:04

The UK is weird about home ownership. Plenty of families - particularly in Europe - don't own property and never will. Don't see why it even matters tbh, and it certainly isn't anyone else's business.

Its just cheaper even if you don't care about the asset - my last house would've rented for 1200 but my mortgage was 350 pm - but actually the benefit of equity in the asset cant be ignored at least while value is climbing. We made 160k on our last house so even with the interest it was worth it - bought just over 10 years ago.

Personally glad we didn't prioritise living for the now over owning. I wouldnt think someone who did was a failure. But those who earnt similar to me and had the ability to save a deposit like me when I bought but chose not to are definitely in a worse position than me now financially subject to inheritance or lottery wins. So I wouldnt think them financially astute. Plus actually we were able to holiday etc once we had gotten over the initial expense of saving then buying because our mortgage was so so much lower than rent. So actually we have been more able to live in the moment in the last decade overall compared with our friends who didn't buy.

Aposterhasnoname · 06/04/2023 19:00

Well personally I think you’re stark staring bonkers for spending the vast majority of your 30k savings, having a third child when you’re already overcrowded and then compounding the lot by giving up a HA house, but I’m sure you had your reasons, so you have to make the best of it. Would love to know how you plan on saving enough to buy a four bed house in five years while bringing up three kids and paying £1000 a month in rent though.

Annon1234 · 06/04/2023 18:56

I feel like there’s so many judgey people on here. I for one can say 10 years ago when I met my husband, I wasn’t thinking about saving for a house and where my child that didn’t exist yet were going to live. We were the same we had the holidays, weekends away and nights out. Now we are early 30s and saving for a home. Wether people buy a house in their 20s or 40s they’ve still bought a home, no better or no worse. And shock horror if someone never choice to buy a house, that’s fine too because it’s their choice. Renting is not Failing, it’s reality for a lot of people.

weddingdaydancet · 06/04/2023 18:49

thenightsky · 06/04/2023 18:37

Too many people don't realize that when you're retired, with little to no income you'll still have to pay rent. With a mortgage you'll have a home that is paid for , no monthly mortgage payment.

Me and DH have recently retired and the drop in income comes as a shock, even after doing the sums and bracing ourselves. We paid off the mortgage about 5 years ago, so the house is ours, but I hate to think how we'd cover rent on pensions.

That’s partly why there are so many elderly people in poverty, unable to heat their homes. It’s heartbreaking. Low pensions, high outgoings.

Summerbreeze111 · 06/04/2023 18:45

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 14:20

This is what we was holding out for but our council aren’t housing anyone unless they are homeless. We even had environmental health come out and assess us but that made no difference. I’ve been on homeswapper over a year and no interest at all, I think it’s because our house is so small.

Do you mind me asking what local authority this is?!

Veryxonfused · 06/04/2023 18:37

You’re not failures but choices have consequences, that’s just how it works

thenightsky · 06/04/2023 18:37

Too many people don't realize that when you're retired, with little to no income you'll still have to pay rent. With a mortgage you'll have a home that is paid for , no monthly mortgage payment.

Me and DH have recently retired and the drop in income comes as a shock, even after doing the sums and bracing ourselves. We paid off the mortgage about 5 years ago, so the house is ours, but I hate to think how we'd cover rent on pensions.

CallintheClownies · 06/04/2023 18:27

TickyTacky · 06/04/2023 17:50

We have no choice but to rent. We got our first rented flat at 19, got married and had a baby at 22, second at 23. It's been 11 years & we have a lovely home now. DH earns well & I'm at university but there's basically no chance we'll be able to save for a deposit while paying rent. My dad is 65 & has never owned, he never had the opportunity to.

But presumably you chose to have a child at 22 and 23? Many people wait 10 years , saving, and working f/t to get a deposit together. Most professional people now don't have a child till they are 30+.

My DH is 68- older than your dad. He bought his first home at 29, 6 years after leaving uni, in the south east UK.

Why did you dad not?

Rafferty10 · 06/04/2023 18:11

Well l wouldn't say you are a failure, but somewhat reckless yes.
To have 30K and blow it when you have the responsibility of a child seems pretty reckless to me, secure housing should be everyone's no 1 priority.

I waited years to have kids as did many of my professional friends to secure a home first. Most of us worked 2 jobs, didn't take holidays etc to achieve the first mortgage then everything else became relatively easy.

I agree with your FIL it is dead money and l think you were mad to give up the low rent of a HA property before you had saved enough to buy.

FlowersAndBonnets · 06/04/2023 18:03

Rowthe · 06/04/2023 13:34

YABU.

Initially it seems you prioritised holiday and days out.

Then you've lost a stable roof over your kids head, again for lifestyle reasons. It probably would have been better to stay for a little longer in the HA property and saved hard.

You arent failures, but you are in an unstable financial situation and at risk from future cost of living increases, especially if rents keep increasing.

It's up to if you want to try and get a safety net in place for yourself,.but it will require sacrifices.

This. You’ve spent your whole lives prioritising something else.

Beautiful3 · 06/04/2023 18:03

I'd buy the ha house, sit on it for the legal period before selling. I'd use that money to buy a property. Renting is dead money. My sister has lived in rented housing for years. She gave up a ha house for rented accommodation, because she wanted more space. She said it was manageable. But rent has shot up over the years. Rising rent and a house sale meant and she had to leave numerous house. She's now in a private, tiny 2 bed house, it's rent is four times what she paid for the larger original ha house. I'd stay where you are OP. 1,000 pound rent might be manageable this year, but when it keeps rising you may not be able to afford it and end up in a private tiny 2 bed house. What happens when the landlord sells up, you'll keep moving on. It's not a forever home, because it's rented.

mishmased · 06/04/2023 18:01

@Foreveraskingquestions now is the time to look forward. Have you moved yet? If no I'd request to stay put if possible and declutter as much as possible.
Make a decision looking at current savings and decide how much difference (approx) you need to add to your savings for a deposit.
Then I would (if you decide to stay) I would take the difference in your HA rent and your proposed rent and put into savings for the 12-18 months. Add this to whatever savings you have monthly towards the deposit.

How old are your kids? If they're under 6/7 I find it cheaper as at that age they're not big into things so very little extra spending and they're happy with trips to the park.

My friend rented a three bed apt from the an investment company that owned apts on her complex. Initial rent was €850, one day they received a letter saying that rent is going up to €1250. No consultation with tenants, pay up or get out. They scrimped between the three of them (husband, and brother no kids) and bought a doer upper. This was 8 years ago and I dread what the rent is now.

Life happens to us differently. We bought at age 33 with two young kids and went on to have a third. Our mortgage on a 4 bed semi excluding overpayments is around €1300, a similar sized house to rent is a minimum of €2900, 5 years ago it was €1800.
Please stay in your HA house if possible and best of luck.

Heronwatcher · 06/04/2023 18:00

Yes like others I agree, you need tp
be realistic about what you can buy. If you could afford the deposit for a decent sized 2 or 3 bed flat they buy that, improve it and move up the property ladder. Look for an upper maisonette with a loft to convert (into a further 1-2 beds) or a good sized 2 bed where you can (temporarily if necessary) divide a room. I know of literally no-one whose first house was a 4 bed detached.

3WildOnes · 06/04/2023 17:57

Personally I would stay where you are and save like mad for a deposit. I wouldn't give up a secure tenancy.

Terraria · 06/04/2023 17:54

Of course you are not a failure, you earn and provide for your family. I don't think your FIL have any idea of how much more we pay for our mortgage vs his time. However, I would consider buying a house if mortgage payment is about the same as rent so that it will likely to become an investment rather than running cost.

TickyTacky · 06/04/2023 17:50

We have no choice but to rent. We got our first rented flat at 19, got married and had a baby at 22, second at 23. It's been 11 years & we have a lovely home now. DH earns well & I'm at university but there's basically no chance we'll be able to save for a deposit while paying rent. My dad is 65 & has never owned, he never had the opportunity to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread