Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel embarrassed that we can’t afford to buy a property?

313 replies

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 12:51

Since me and DH have been together buying a property has never really been in our interest. We had money at the start but we wasn’t bothered as rent was fairly cheap back then and our priority really was just having fun and going on holidays.

Luckily our current property is HA and it is dirt cheap but we are now leaving and going into private rent. Our rent is now going to be 1k I never imagined spending that much on rent but it’s a beautiful home and it gives our kids the space they need to blossom.

FIL was gobsmacked about how much rent were going to be paying and said how it’s dead money. It’s obviously got into DH head and now he thinks we’re “failures”. Everyone in his family has brought their properties we are the only ones that haven’t.

AIBU to think we’re not failures? He said his family are probably laughing at us.

I don’t know how we would ever be able to buy a place in our area. Maybe if we moved up north!

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 07/04/2023 18:48

Is it too late to stay in the HA property?

What's the business exactly? Selling stuff is what all businesses do. Is it location-based in any way?

Zoejj77 · 07/04/2023 18:43

Why did you leave HA most people would love that cheap rent. We private rent and are trapped.

Laisydaisy · 07/04/2023 18:42

It can take years to get a swop with another HA property and there aren’t any guarantees you would get what you need anyway. Making a decision in favour of your health and happiness now seems like a good move to me. You will all benefit. Maybe if you can’t afford to buy a house yet you could buy a little flat on a Buy To Let Mortgage and rent it out. That might bring in some extra to help against the rent you pay and, if it’s a good investment, you could sell when you want to buy a house and it might help with growing your deposit. Maybe you could even buy it through your new business… I don’t know much about that but a good mortgage advisor could tell you.
Enjoy your new place! Hope the new business grows well.

Bullshot · 07/04/2023 18:41

OP what do you want to happen? If I were you I would stay in the HA property for another year or so and save like crazy. See if you can raise more towards a deposit and aim to buy something - it can be a 3 bedroom with 3 kids. I had to share a room as a child/teenager.

But if you don't want to do this then that's your choice.

I am in my 50s and guess was from the fortunate generation that was able to buy properties more easily. Don't get me wrong, it was still a scary amount to tie myself in to paying for 25 years on a basic salary but it was ingrained into me that I should buy and not rent. I still have a mortgage now but on a larger house- if I hadn't got my foot on the ladder then this wouldn't have happened. My younger sibling is still in rental and is also struggling to save for a deposit due to high rents, high cost of living and not as high wages. I really do feel for this generation as it's going to be so much harder.

Overall it's up to you to decide. Ignore your FIL - he could give you a deposit - that would be nicer of him than to mock you for renting.

Good luck!

summerin69 · 07/04/2023 18:37

Not failures at all. It’s only this country among just a few that places such importance on owning a home. Many people in Europe and in the major US cities rent. Here also, we see owning a home as an investment to make money off when we sell. It’s this that has driven property prices and rentals through the roof. A home should be just that - a home. I know a lot of people who own property who are stressed to the limits because of mortgage repayments. At least when you rent you can leave whenever you want and go somewhere cheaper. Plus you don’t have to fork out for home repairs, appliances breaking down etc. not failures at all.

Vetiver · 07/04/2023 18:28

If it makes you feel any better £1k a month rent seems really cheap round here at the moment (everything has shot up in the last few years) so it seems like a sensible move to get the space you want

Stanex · 07/04/2023 18:18

There are always choices in life, some one gets wrong, some right and others are more nuanced. The fact of the matter is that a house-owner has more control over their destiny acquired by some financial sacrifices in the first instance, and carries some risk in terms of the fact that a house is a wasting asset that requires expenditure to maintain and/or improve it, that is otherwise the responsibility of the landlord. It is the land that is valuable, not the house, something not generally well-understood. As a rule-of-thumb, though the proportion varies across the country, the house is worth a third-to-a-quarter of the value of a property. The rent-or-buy argument has run "forever" and in general in the long term buying is the better option, not least of which because it forces a form of saving that will not be equalled by the renter. But there is an issue of timing. Those who bought in 1988 were often regretting it by 1992 and there is a possibility that interest rate rises will cause price falls now, more noticeable in the first-time buyer market. So far this is not particularly noticeable where compared to the late eighties where most mortgages were variable, now most are fixed-period so the full impact or a rate increase is not immediate. You chose to spend now rather than save for later. There is a balance to be struck, but where saving is deferred expenditure and generally rewarded by way of long-term property market gains or growth of market investments in an ISA, SIPP or other pension by way of compounding, some initial conservatism in spending is likely to result in a greater standard of living on a whole-life basis. So in that sense your FIL is right. You will be paying rent years after a mortgage would have been paid off, unless you change tack. Key in this seems to be to contain expenditure now, staying with the low cost HA option and start the serious saving to get a house of your own. Not doing this is simply kicking the can down the road, and overall, your standard of living on a whole life basis will be lower. Maybe the holidays and "fun" were worth effectively mortgaging your future - that is for you to judge! But life is a marathon, not a sprint for most of us.

DemonSpawn · 07/04/2023 18:14

If renting for a long time you need to also save/invest for your future.

I always considered rental price to equate to the interest on a mortgage, so if renting you should at least save/invest what would be the capital part of the mortgage.

I’ve just checked a few of properties where I live and this premise still works.
One example is a house for rent at £650 a month and the equivalent house to buy is £140k - putting the figures into a mortgage calculator gives a mortgage interest of approximately £650 leaving the renter £200 a month to save/invest.

Of course renters don’t pay for any maintenance so should be able to save even more than this in reality.

Lou202211 · 07/04/2023 18:14

AIBU- That when visitors come to your home they should take their shoes off 😬 i just find it awkward when you invite guests around and they just trampoline in with shoes on in the house 🙈

JudgeRudy · 07/04/2023 18:10

No, you're not a failure. If your children are happy and thriving and you have a good relationship you are a winner. Add in good health and a fulfilling job and you've hit the jackpot.
In a couple of years time even 'old timers' will understand the financial challenge of home ownership and not be so judgement. I'm sick of Boomers saying how they worked hard for what they had and saved up. My dad was a bricklayer. My mum was a SAH parent until we were in out teens then worked part time in a job she left at the door. We had 2 cars, a nice home and regular holidays and hobbies. Seems apparently that I can't afford to buy a home because I have a smart phone and a takeaway.
Owning a home is good in some ways but seems to me the biggest benefit is when you're dead!

HamptonCaught · 07/04/2023 18:06

You’ve said yourself you had years of “dirt cheap” rent in a HA property. That was the time to save a deposit to buy, not to squander it on holidays, etc.

Also laughing at the idea of £1k rent pm being a lot. Welcome to the real world!

Some people are just wired to live in the moment and never think about or plan for the future and imo, they are failures.

drpet49 · 07/04/2023 17:57

Rowthe · 06/04/2023 13:34

YABU.

Initially it seems you prioritised holiday and days out.

Then you've lost a stable roof over your kids head, again for lifestyle reasons. It probably would have been better to stay for a little longer in the HA property and saved hard.

You arent failures, but you are in an unstable financial situation and at risk from future cost of living increases, especially if rents keep increasing.

It's up to if you want to try and get a safety net in place for yourself,.but it will require sacrifices.

This. You chose to prioritise holidays and having a good time and now it has come back to haunt you.

restingbitchface30 · 07/04/2023 17:57

save for a 5% deposit. No way would I pay £1000 rent when a mortgage could be that or even less. You don’t have to buy anything too swanky and may have to move a little for somewhere cheaper. But you are essentially throwing that money away.

mrsbyers · 07/04/2023 17:55

Is the benefits cap over £1,000 for private rental ? ie if you both lost your jobs or became unwell would the government keep you housed ? That would be my initial concern about switching

bellabasset · 07/04/2023 17:54

Rents where I live are high as there's very few houses up for rent and the demand has increased rents. It's a shame so many families are in this situation. But you seem to have thought it all through and having space for your family is important.

AllOfThemWitches · 07/04/2023 09:43

IWasFunBeforeMum · 06/04/2023 20:03

I hate the stigma that anywhere "up north" is cheap!!

Agreed. Looking at you, York!

MiniCooperLover · 07/04/2023 09:42

I think you're absolutely mad to leave a HA for private rental.

Rafferty10 · 07/04/2023 09:26

None of us can have it all, sacrifices have to be made and living for the now is fine but then don't complain when you struggle later.

FourTeaFallOut · Yesterday 19:44
This whole system is fucked, and skewed in a way to keep the poor and the lower classes poor.

This is silly, If you have 30 K in your 20s you are NOT poor and have choices millions would love to have.

IWasFunBeforeMum · 06/04/2023 20:03

I hate the stigma that anywhere "up north" is cheap!!

Newmumatlast · 06/04/2023 20:00

FourTeaFallOut · 06/04/2023 19:44

This whole system is fucked, and skewed in a way to keep the poor and the lower classes poor

Well, tbf, the system didn't make her blow a house deposit on holidays.

Yes noone who has 30k savings is poor so she at the very least wasn't poor then

WhatToDo2023 · 06/04/2023 19:44

Some of the responses here are so harsh. We all make choices, and travelling made you happy at the time. Every period in life has its ups and downs, you don't need to be embarrassed, that's crazy talk! You will be fine and I can’t see that your FIL shamed you in any way.

FourTeaFallOut · 06/04/2023 19:44

This whole system is fucked, and skewed in a way to keep the poor and the lower classes poor

Well, tbf, the system didn't make her blow a house deposit on holidays.

CallintheClownies · 06/04/2023 19:38

If your business is 'selling stuff' why can't you move somewhere cheaper? There is usually a market for most things across the country.

You said you needed storage space for the goods you sell.

Is this now your sole income or are you both working in other jobs as well?

Have you got a business plan? Investment, sales, profit and loss, 5 year projection of what you will earn?

If you are serious about setting up a business as a means of income and you want to buy a house at some point, you both need to see a good financial advisor and get some advice.

BitchBrigade · 06/04/2023 19:33

This is a stark reality by the way from my childhood, where my parents bought a house for 90k and we never moved or even considered it. That house sold for £295k and was most recently on the market for £325k.

This whole system is fucked, and skewed in a way to keep the poor and the lower classes poor.

caringcarer · 06/04/2023 19:33

My son moved to Hull, taking a £8.5k pay cut so he could buy a property. He bought a 2 bed terrace but his mortgage is only about £300 pcm on a 5 year fix. You could buy a nice 3-4 bed property there for under £700 pcm.