Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel embarrassed that we can’t afford to buy a property?

313 replies

Foreveraskingquestions · 06/04/2023 12:51

Since me and DH have been together buying a property has never really been in our interest. We had money at the start but we wasn’t bothered as rent was fairly cheap back then and our priority really was just having fun and going on holidays.

Luckily our current property is HA and it is dirt cheap but we are now leaving and going into private rent. Our rent is now going to be 1k I never imagined spending that much on rent but it’s a beautiful home and it gives our kids the space they need to blossom.

FIL was gobsmacked about how much rent were going to be paying and said how it’s dead money. It’s obviously got into DH head and now he thinks we’re “failures”. Everyone in his family has brought their properties we are the only ones that haven’t.

AIBU to think we’re not failures? He said his family are probably laughing at us.

I don’t know how we would ever be able to buy a place in our area. Maybe if we moved up north!

OP posts:
Kaiserchief · 08/04/2023 21:42

If you’re both able to work, you can rent somewhere privately or buy…

Skinnermarink · 08/04/2023 20:55

Check2223334 · 08/04/2023 20:25

You will also get rehoused if your overcrowded.

Only if there are any available properties in your area, someone is looking to downsize and switch with you or if you don’t mind totally uprooting everyone to a random part of the country.

I don’t live in HA but I thought the above was quite well known.

Check2223334 · 08/04/2023 20:25

You will also get rehoused if your overcrowded.

Check2223334 · 08/04/2023 20:23

your crazy leaving HA , you know you get a discount in buying them after a certain amount of years ? £1000 pm is insane . You could have saved staying with HA.

Densol57 · 08/04/2023 19:53

I have read your post OP over several days and saw your updates

To answer your headline question generally - No, no one should be embarrassed that they cannot afford to buy a property, but with shared ownership its far more easier.

To answer your question pertaining to you - Yes with your opportunities wasted and money spent on fun when you was already a mum you should be a bit embarrassed. To give up a HA tenancy that gains “ acquired rights “ …. Google it …. Yes be highly ashamed as a mum - sorry

Boojabooj · 08/04/2023 15:15

GasPanic · 08/04/2023 11:47

Ever heard of negative equity ?

It can and does happen.

Round my way it's taken over 15 years for prices to recover from their 2007 high. Many, especially flats are still being sold below the top of the market price.

You take your chances.

I certainly agree that there's more nuance to renting vs buying, but not just in the way you stated.
Insurance, maintenance etc.. you don't get all that for free as a renter. You're paying for it as part of your rent. And when mortgage rates go up, presumably the rent will too if you rent from a BTL landlord.
Negative equity is a concern, but it's only relevant at 2 points - when you sell, or remortgage.
A more pressing concern is stability of tenure.
I don't see my house as a 'major investment', its my biggest asset yes but as long as I eventually pay off the mortgage what happens after isn't my most major concern. Having moved several times in the last few years, and spent enough time in shite properties the security of my own, small home is immeasurable.

Unlike the older generation I wouldn't advise people to buy ASAP, as you stated properties like flats are dropping in value in places without a big rental market for those places - where DP is from for example nobody really goes for work and young people don't rent a flat, they stay home and save. Young people are more likely to move out of these places for work, and it will then become a burden.

But I do think, unless people are planning to move around they should be aiming to buy. Or obtain a secure tenancy.

Sugarfree23 · 08/04/2023 14:45

@GasPanic have you seen the thread about the woman considering buying a property for her Dad in his mid 70s because his landlord wants to sell up?

Op is absolutely mad to give up a secure tenancy.

Sugarfree23 · 08/04/2023 14:30

@GasPanic negative equity means the house is currently worth less than you paid. And it really only becomes an issue if you need to sell.
But long term houses go up in price.

AllOfThemWitches · 08/04/2023 14:03

sabbii · 08/04/2023 13:30

Defo failure on the basis you had the opportunity and the funds to buy a property. If you never had even chance that would some comfort.

Lol what a prick.

sabbii · 08/04/2023 13:30

Defo failure on the basis you had the opportunity and the funds to buy a property. If you never had even chance that would some comfort.

workinprog · 08/04/2023 13:23

Where is your area @GasPanic ?

HistoryFanatic · 08/04/2023 13:17

No offence but you don't sound very bright OP!

ConsuelaHammock · 08/04/2023 12:30

You had 30k but you spent it on holidays and now you’re claiming UC to help pay your rent ? I’d be embarrassed about that tbh. You’ve gone backwards. Stay where you are and save up for a house. Rents are only going to get higher.

GasPanic · 08/04/2023 11:47

AlwaysGinPlease · 08/04/2023 09:24

@GasPanic ever heard of equity?

Renting is throwing your money at someone else never to be seen again. Renting is never going to be as cost effective five as owning. When you retire you still have to pay rent. When the mortgage is paid that's it!

Ever heard of negative equity ?

It can and does happen.

Round my way it's taken over 15 years for prices to recover from their 2007 high. Many, especially flats are still being sold below the top of the market price.

You take your chances.

NewNovember · 08/04/2023 11:39

NaturalBae · 08/04/2023 01:00

Oh okay. Exactly which scheme is being extended in England?

currently there is right to acquire for HA properties essentially the same as RTB just a much smaller discount. The government is piloting RTB for HA properties with a view to extending the scheme across England.

unique78 · 08/04/2023 11:34

You're not faliures for renting. It's a bad idea moving from HA to private though, unless you get one of those wonderful LL that want you to stay long term. I get the cramped issue, we lived in a small house with zero storage (even the loft was practically unusable due to low cross beams). We were constantly tripping over stuff and our house looked like a junk shop, and with 2 DC it wasn't fun.

There's so much instability in private renting, although I can see why you want to, but the only way I would move out of a HA house is if the area/neighbours were horrendous. I would hang on in there for a larger house swap, or would try to organise my house into something more efficient (plenty of advice on the internet), and I would save, save, save for a 3 bed.

I know home ownership is out of the question for some, but if you can, you should, because at least then you can't be kicked out (barring calamities) and you can get your money back(ish) if you sell.

Pearfacebananapoop · 08/04/2023 10:05

@Mummyof3dc @drpet49 yep my thoughts exactly. People with £30k savings shouldn't be getting housing association houses.
You had the money OP. You spent it as you wished. Deal with it. Also you don't have to buy a 4 bed. Buy a 3 bed, save some more and do an extension.

Sugarfree23 · 08/04/2023 09:50

@GasPanic
Monthly costs
Renting = paying someone else's capital & their interest & profit.

Buying = paying your own capital & interest which will drop as your capital goes up. No profit

Maintenance.
Decorating is needed in both social housing and private.

Other Maintenance kitchens/ bathrooms/ windows and doors should have a design life of 25 years plus people change more often for fashion reasons.

Insurance
Building insurance is about £150 per year probably included within the rent payment.
Contents you need in regardless of ownership

On year one mortgage maybe the same as rent. But in year 10 the rent will have gone up while the mortgage is the same.

Owning is a long-term investment. Renting you are always paying for someone else's investment.

Buying eventually be minimal housing costs, Renting will always be a big bill.

AlwaysGinPlease · 08/04/2023 09:25

No idea where the five appeared from in my post 😂

AlwaysGinPlease · 08/04/2023 09:24

@GasPanic ever heard of equity?

Renting is throwing your money at someone else never to be seen again. Renting is never going to be as cost effective five as owning. When you retire you still have to pay rent. When the mortgage is paid that's it!

GasPanic · 08/04/2023 09:08

Sugarfree23 · 08/04/2023 07:10

Paying a mortgage is also a roof over your head.
But it's investing money at the same time. Money that you'll always have. Over a 25 year period your mortgage will stay the same even if cost of living and wages go up.

Private renting your effectively Paying someone else's mortgage.
Paying rent the rent will always go up, even if the landlords mortgage stays the same.

Getting a mortgage you are paying someone elses interest (ie the mortgage holder pays the savers interest).

The key issue is not whether your are paying something to someone else, but how you can fulfill your living requirements (which includes stuff like size of house and security of tenure) at the lowest cost.

A lot of time people do not factor into the expense of owning a house fully. They compare rent with mortgage payments. What they don't do is factor in maintenance costs, insurance costs of running a house etc which can be very expensive.

For me renting was always cheaper than paying a mortgage, but my personal circumstances were a bit different from most people. What tended to put me at a disadvantage more was house price increases over the period. These increases are unlikely to be huge (and may even be negative going forwards for the next few years), so we are at a stage now where renting looks even better value.

Mummyof3dc · 08/04/2023 09:03

@drpet49 Im
glad it’s not just me, this made me really quite cross!

drpet49 · 08/04/2023 08:57

Mummyof3dc · 07/04/2023 19:09

I’m sorry but why on earth did you take a HA house if you had 30k in savings and went on holidays and had fun. This absolutely makes my blood boil, there are people who have nothing who really need the HA! No wonder this country is in such a mess.
you should be ashamed.
welcome to the real world of having to pay proper rent like EVERYONE else

I agree. I don’t have any sympathy for the OP at all. Imagine squandering 30k on holidays and good times instead of buying a house when they already had a child.

Boysnana · 08/04/2023 08:53

Definitely not failures.. I see this quire a lot where people renting privately say they could buy properties for the same amount. The HA are your best bet IMHO as you are secured..
Scenario is private rent can sell up or increase prices.
Mortgage you are basically renting from the bank/building society until its paid off. If you were to have a period of not working you could have property re possesed. And are responsible for all your own repairs.
HA is secured tenancy and even if you have a period of not working then they will work with you to keep you in your property. Also their rent is regulated.

My opinion is stay in HA. Whatever you choose i hope it works out for you.

GreggsRoll · 08/04/2023 08:40

Kaiserchief · 08/04/2023 08:22

I prefer a fixed rate to variable; this may suit you better too.

We were on a fixed rate but it's expired and haven't yet been able to remortgage annoyingly