Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist people bring their own food to a family picnic?

239 replies

moosmum21 · 06/04/2023 11:53

The extended family wants a picnic tomorrow, although half of the guest list is tentative. No one is willing to help buy or prepare anything for the picnic, so my MIL suggested that I prepare it, and we all split the bill equally.

Conscious that everyone is time and cash poor and not wanting to waste lots of food if half don’t show up, I suggested that we all prepare packed lunches for ourselves, which was met with a complaint: "That’s not a picnic; that’s a meal deal in a park”.
I know that if I were to prepare a picnic and split the cost of the ingredients equally amongst all the attendees as suggested, there would be bill shock and squabbling.
I could prepare the picnic and sink the cost, wholly or by charging a modest contribution fee. I enjoy cooking (no one else in the family does!), and we are moderately well off compared to the rest of the family – it’s not a huge imposition. But I don’t want to set up the expectation that I’ll just cater and pay for every barbecue, picnic, holiday, and party. I’m also still apparently holding a grudge over the Christmas cake incident (a family member stopped by when I was making a Christmas cake for my family, told me that she hoped I was making her one, and then insisted I’d have to make cakes for other family members, so they didn’t feel left out. She neglected to mention that no one in the family likes Christmas cake, so most of it was wasted!) AIBU to stick firm with the suggestion that we bring our own food? Or should I let go of the grudge, prepare a lovely picnic, and sink the cost so we can all have a peaceful day out?

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 06/04/2023 12:21

Yeah, absolutely not! They're trying to get a free, zero effort meal.

I'd just ignore MIL's suggestion and reply 'Looks like we've got two options, either everyone agrees to bring a dish for a picnic, or we go out to eat somewhere.'

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 12:21

I'd text back "happy with MIL's walk and bite to eat idea, or each family bringing their own picnic, just let me know what you decide!"

TicTac80 · 06/04/2023 12:20

I agree with the others. If you don't want to do it (and I bloody wouldn't!), say no and make it very clear! Also, you can't cater for x number of people if you don't know who/how many are coming. Just say no. Whenever I've been on picnics, each family group/friend always brings their own food. It's much easier, there's no "bill shock", and people know their family likes/dislikes, so less chance of faff or food wastage.

Lakeyloo · 06/04/2023 12:20

Stick firm ! Personally I would rather take my own anyway

HelpsHeal · 06/04/2023 12:20

In every gathering like this I've ever been to either everyone brings a picnic for their imeadiate family or everyone brings something to share.

If there's an organiser, they might make suggestions on what each person brings so you don't end up with loads of sausage rolls etc.

No you can't do it for everyone.

FatFucker · 06/04/2023 12:19

SILS can do one! CFs both of them!!

Ktime · 06/04/2023 12:18

Why are you even entertaining this?

Why can't everyone make a dish to contribute to a pot luck e.g. potato salad, pasta salad, etc if they don't want a meal deal?

KirstenBlest · 06/04/2023 12:17

ShirleyPhallus · 06/04/2023 12:12

I’d ask everyone to bring something - cold meat, hummous, bread, cheese, pastries, strawberries etc etc

trust that not everyone will bring the same but you could assign people items if you wanted

This is what we do. It's shared between everyone attending.
It's unfair to expect one person to do it all.

You need to learn that little No word, @moosmum21

pippinsleftleg · 06/04/2023 12:17

so your in laws think you’re tha family slave?

That would be a big fat no from me!

TheaBrandt · 06/04/2023 12:17

Weird - are you their maid?

Cherrysherbet · 06/04/2023 12:16

We have an extended family picnic each summer and everyone brings for their own immediate family. Then sometimes we’ll bring things to pass round as well, like chocolate etc…

No way would I want to cater for everyone, or expect anyone else to.

moosmum21 · 06/04/2023 12:13

Crikeyalmightey · 06/04/2023 12:01

Who's idea was the picnic? Has someone else come up with it and volunteered you as the caterer?

SIL(1)'s idea, MIL volunteered me as the caterer. MIL would rather go for a walk in the park and then have a meal somewhere afterwards, SIL(1) doesn't want to spend money on dining out. SIL(2) made the "that's not a picnic" comment.

OP posts:
RosesInWater · 06/04/2023 12:13

Go to mcDonalds and everyone pays for their own. Sit on a bench in the park after and talk about how lovely the meal was.

ShirleyPhallus · 06/04/2023 12:12

I’d ask everyone to bring something - cold meat, hummous, bread, cheese, pastries, strawberries etc etc

trust that not everyone will bring the same but you could assign people items if you wanted

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 12:12

@Fridayfreddie yes I agree but everyone has to be willing to do that to make it work. Or you will be in my situation sharing one family's contribution among the 5,000. Or OP's situation expected to cater for everyone on her own!

MintJulia · 06/04/2023 12:11

You could tell your MIL to do it herself !

But seriously, ask each family to bring something to share. It makes it more interesting too, mixing up other people's food ideas. Just say there are e.g.12 mouths to feed ask each to choose to bring a savoury for twelve, a salad for twelve, a dessert for twelve etc.

Plus car rugs and a football/frisbee etc

CC4712 · 06/04/2023 12:10

Is it so MIL doesn't need to cook? Have you spoken to the rest of the family? They might prefer to bring their own food 'Sarah only eats plain cheese sandwiches', 'Billy won't drink that squash' etc etc

NO way would I be making for all- then trying to get the money back. Neither should you be paying for all- regardless of your financial situation. I love cooking, but no doubt someone in the group would have preferred something different to eat, plus some people wouldn't pay/keep forgetting etc. That would then leave you chasing for money- which I personally find embarrassing.

Each family just bring their own- and if you like, bring an additional dish each that everyone can share. End of.

CatOnTheChair · 06/04/2023 12:10

Can not family 1 bring sandwiches and fruit.
Family 2 quiche and crisps
Family 3 pasta salad and cake

So everyone brings a main and a pudding, but if one family doesn't show up, there is still a decent balance?

Xiaoxiong · 06/04/2023 12:09

@ColadhSamh has it - this also solves the problem of the tentative guest list.

What's MIL proposing about half the guest list being tentative?

We had a strange situation years ago where we went to a park picnic birthday party so I packed a pretty nice picnic for our family plus brought some grapes and strawberries to contribute. I had checked in advance, just bring your own food and picnic rug I was told. When we got there we were the only family to have brought any food or drinks at all, including the birthday family who had brought cake and nothing else! We ended up sharing our picnic for 4 around about 10 extra kids and adults. Very weird experience.

Fridayfreddie · 06/04/2023 12:07

We also have an extended family picnic tomorrow. Everyone will bring dishes to share, either homemade or shop-bought, it doesn’t matter and making or buying one or two things is hardly an imposition. We also share drinks.

Crikeyalmightey · 06/04/2023 12:05

What sofaNearYou said, but let MIL do the telling. Don't be her fall guy.

KezzaMucklowe · 06/04/2023 12:04

Oh gosh my in laws were a bit like this. Although not cheeky enough to demand one person does all the work.
They insisted on certain people bringing certain foods, this never worked out as we were all stuck with sandwiches one person wanted and most of us didn't like,
a squashed packet of sausage rolls and a bumper pack of wotsits.
There was always someone who didn't turn up, someone who forgot they were contributing and lots of disappointed people who wish they'd brought their own food.
A meal deal in the park is the way forward.

Wiltingredrose · 06/04/2023 12:03

Don’t over complicate things. Tell people to bring their own food plus something to share. If you prepare all the food you will end up resenting it. Don’t let them put it all on you!

aSofaNearYou · 06/04/2023 12:02

Your MIL sounds really cheeky and pushy. I would just say no thanks, you don't have time (or inclination if you're feeling confrontational) to make food for everyone. Happy to bring a dish if everyone else does, otherwise you'll just bring food for you.

KirstenBlest · 06/04/2023 12:02

A friend loves picnics and the usual arrangement is that everybody brings something to share.